Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 19

Compliance

“Forty-one point eight pounds,” says Dr. Ellen Sato, to the court. “Up three tenths since the tenth. Heart rate eighty-eight. The murmur is unchanged, grade two, I would not call it progressing. The left hip remains stiff. His coat is better. His eyes are clear.” She looks over her half-glasses at the bench. “Your Honor, I have been examining animals for the state for twenty-six years, and I have never in that time been asked to certify that a dog is happy. I am going to say it anyway. He is.”

“Let the record show it,” says Judge Hatch.

It is Monday, nine twenty, in the Pronghorn County courthouse, where the clock on the wall above the bench still says ten past four, and has said so since March. The east wing has no heat. Everyone in the courtroom is wearing a coat. The judge is wearing two. Her black robe is zipped over a quilted vest, and a hot-water bottle is propped under the bench against her knees, visible only to those of us in the front row, which is a thing I will never mention to anyone.

Pickle lies in the center aisle on a folded saddle blanket, with his head on his paws. He has taken, over the course of ten days, a view of this room that I would describe as proprietary.

The gallery is smaller than the first time. The feed store has gone back to the feed store and the quilters to the quilts. But the room is not empty. Mr. Okafor from the co-op is here. Bev Tarkington is here, with a thermos. Ruthie’s father is at the back, with his cap in both hands. And in the third row, in a green coat, with a thermos of her own and a face of granite, sits the woman Margit Voss calls her housekeeper, who has attended every hearing as, I have been told, a witness who tells the truth in either direction.

Margit herself sits at the Foundation’s table, in a gray suit. Beside her is Nathaniel Cross, in a cardigan and half-glasses, and on his other side, with the air of a man who has had a very bad week and has not yet been told it is going to get worse, Preston Hale.

“Mr. Hale,” says the judge. “I understand you have a motion.”

Hale rises. He does not have the sleek shine of the seventh of November. He has the stiffness of a man who has found, in a drawer, a document with his own signature on it. “Your Honor. On behalf of the Brandt Family Foundation, I withdraw the petition for interim relief with prejudice. The Foundation has been reconsidering its position.”

“I thought it might.”

“And I am instructed to say,” says Hale, not looking at anyone, “that the Foundation will no longer be taking direction from its chief financial officer.”

There is a small, interesting sound in the gallery. Several hundred years of Montana ranch manners are being applied to the problem of not saying anything aloud.

“Noted,” says the judge, drily. “Mr. Garrity?”

A third man at a third table stands up. He is Dennis Pell’s attorney, a florid man in a silk tie. He raises a hand on which a large ring gleams.

“Your Honor, my client objects to the protective order in its entirety. It was drafted ex parte, after midnight, on what I can only describe as a telephone call from a veterinarian.”

“It was drafted at seven fifty-five this morning, Mr. Garrity, in this building, on the basis of a sworn statement by the sheriff, and signed at eight oh two. The call was at midnight. The signature was not.” She takes off her glasses. “Your client is on an ankle monitor on five hundred thousand dollars in cash bail, the source of which this court is going to want to hear about. If he has an objection to being forbidden from communicating with witnesses, directly or through intermediaries, I would like you to tell me which witness he intends to call.”

Garrity opens his mouth. He closes it.

“Denied,” says the judge. “Next.”

She is a small woman with a wide, plain face. When she smiles, which is not often, she looks like somebody’s grandmother at a church supper who has just found out who took the last pie. She does not smile now.

“Dr. Marrow. Please rise.”

I rise.

“I have before me the report of Dr. Sato, filed at nine this morning. I have a statement from the Rimrock laboratory. I have, on the table in front of me, a sealed envelope that I do not intend to open in public, which I am told contains evidence in a matter that is now under the sheriff’s supervision.” She looks at me, and I think, for a second, of Ray’s brisk voice saying, count your load.

“I find that the guardian is in compliance with the terms of the order of the tenth. I find that the animal is in good health, in the care of a competent veterinarian, who is, incidentally, the only person in this room who has not been paid to say so. The petition is dismissed. The guardianship stands.”

A sound goes round the room, not applause. It is lower than that, like a held breath being returned.

“I will visit the clinic at one o’clock, as I said I would. It is not a punishment. It is an inspection. I have not been in a veterinary clinic since my husband’s retriever died, and I intend to be shown around.” The gavel comes down once, not hard. “We are adjourned.”

I sit down, and discover that my hands are shaking, and that Cole, beside me, has put one of his on top of both.

He does not look at me. He is looking at the phone that has just buzzed against his ribs.

I watch him read it. I watch his face go through three things, a flicker, a stillness, and a smoothing, like water that has been disturbed and put back. He takes his hand away and stands.

“Excuse me,” he says, to the room. “I must take this.”

I follow him out. The courthouse corridor is long, and green, and cold, with a bench along one wall and a rubber plant dying politely by the water fountain. He is standing at the far end under a window with his back to me and his phone against his ear.

“Yes,” he says. “Yes. I understand. I have the paper in front of me. Yes. Wednesday at five.” A pause. “Ms. Varga, I would like to say that I appreciate the courtesy. I would like to say, too, that I do not intend to use it.” He listens. “No. No, I do not think I will be asking for an extension. Thank you. Good morning.”

He lowers the phone. He does not turn around.

“It landed,” I say.

“It landed at nine twenty-six. The stock closed Friday under the line. Castellan has formally demanded the forty-one million, and has noted that Thanksgiving is not a banking day.” He puts the phone in his pocket. “I have thirty-four million, I think, if the man in Dallas wires on time. Seven to go.”

“Seven,” I say.

“Seven million dollars.” He turns. He is smiling, a small and terrible smile. “It is a very specific number, Josie. It is exactly as much as the clinic’s annual revenue is not.”

“Cole.”

“I am not going to be melodramatic. I am going to think.” He puts both hands in his pockets, and I see them shake in the cloth. “I would like to have one half hour in which no one asks me whether I have eaten.”

“Did you eat?” says a small voice at my elbow.

It is Marcy, the courtroom clerk, in her cardigan, with a roll of saltines in her hand. She holds it out to Cole with a perfectly straight face.

“It is for the dog,” she says. “But I think he will not mind.”

Cole takes a saltine. He looks at it. He eats it, with great gravity, in two bites. And then, to my astonishment, he laughs again, a short helpless breath of a laugh, and Marcy pats his arm and goes away.

At one o’clock, Judge Florence Hatch comes to my clinic in a pair of rubber boots.

She has come in her own car, a dented green sedan with a bumper sticker for the county fair, with Sheriff Pruitt behind her and Dr. Sato behind him and, in a long gray car at the rear, a court reporter with a steno machine on her knee. She gets out of the car and stands in the lot with her hands on her hips, looking at the building. It is a cinder-block box with a tin roof and a hand-painted sign that Tori redid in teal. She stands there for a long moment.

“It is smaller than I pictured,” says the judge.

“It is a clinic for large animals and small ones,” I say. “It has a lot of heart.”

“I should hope so. It has very little else.” She walks in.

I give her the tour. I do it badly, I think. I have never had to explain my life to someone with a gavel. We start in the waiting room, with its eight chairs and its corkboard full of lost-cat posters. We go to the exam rooms, to the surgery with its single table, to the kennel run where a beagle with an ear infection tells us both what it thinks of the situation. The judge examines the autoclave. She examines the X-ray machine, a model from before Tori was born. She stands for some time in front of a bulletin board that holds a crayon drawing of a dog and a woman and a calf, signed by Ruthie, and does not say anything.

On the exam table in the surgery lies a quilt. It arrived on Saturday, in a plastic bag, with a note: FOR THE TABLE. SO THEY’RE NOT COLD. THE QUILTERS OF SADDLE GAP. It is blue and gold, in a pattern of tiny stars. The judge puts her hand on it and stands there.

“The beagle,” she says, at last, “has a quilt.”

“He had one on Sunday. He says it was a lot.”

“I would think so.” She looks at me, over her glasses, and I see that her eyes are wet. “Dr. Marrow. I have sat on the bench for twenty-two years. I have walked into a number of institutions in that time, with my robe and my gavel, and I have been shown the fine rooms and the fine files. I have not very often been shown a quilt.”

“Your Honor.”

“I am only saying.” She turns away, brusquely. “Show me the drug room. I would like to see the log.”

The drug room is a closet. It is six feet by four, lined with steel shelves, and in the corner, bolted to the wall, with a keypad on its door and a brass plate that says RECORDS, is the safe.

“Controlled substances,” I say. “The log lives in there. The sheriff has already been through it. The vial that I reported missing was a ten-milliliter bottle of ketamine, lot number ending seven-seven-one-four, signed in on the twenty-eighth of October and never used. I reported it on the seventh. I want to be very clear for the court reporter.” I look at her. “Do you want me to open it?”

“I want the sheriff to watch you open it,” says Judge Hatch. “And I want Dr. Sato to count.”

I turn to the keypad. I punch in my code, six digits, with my back to them, which is a thing you learn. The lock clicks. I swing the door.

I do not see it at first. I see the log on the top shelf, green cloth, with a date stamped on the spine, and a rack of vials beneath it in their neat rows, each with a number, each with a tab. I see an empty slot. It has an empty slot, as it has had since the third of November, and a strip of masking tape with the date in my own handwriting.

I look again.

It is not empty.

In the slot, upright, its label to the front, where it was never, in the whole history of this clinic, put by anyone I trust, is a ten-milliliter vial with a gray rubber cap and a crimped aluminum seal. It is whole. The seal has not been broken. On the label, in the manufacturer’s blue print, I read the lot number without wanting to.

Seven-seven-one-four.

“Doctor,” says Judge Hatch.

“That wasn’t there Friday.”

“Do not touch it,” says Pruitt.

“I am not touching it.” I have my hands up in front of me. My voice is perfectly even, which is how I know how frightened I am. “Sheriff. That is the vial. The one that went missing. It was not in this safe on Friday afternoon, and I counted. I was in here with Tori. She will tell you. I looked at that slot and I put my finger on the tape.”

“It’s sealed,” says Dr. Sato, very quietly, over my shoulder. She has crouched, with a flashlight, a long way from the shelf. “It is unopened. The crimp is original. If it has been tampered with, I cannot see how.”

“That is not the point,” I say.

“No,” says the judge. “I see the point.”

Nobody moves.

“A woman reports a missing vial, and says so on the radio, and the county hears her.” The judge speaks in a flat, steady voice, to nobody. “And on the day the court inspects her clinic, the vial is found in her own safe, intact, in its place, after the whole county has heard her say it was stolen.” She turns her head, and her eyes are like two small gray stones. “Dr. Marrow. What do you say to me?”

“I say that someone put it there,” I say, “and that I would like the sheriff to find out who.”

“I am going to state for the record,” says Judge Hatch, to the court reporter, “that I find this the least persuasive piece of staging I have encountered in twenty-two years on the bench. I am aware that that is an observation and not a ruling.” She looks at Pruitt. “Sheriff, bag it. Photograph the shelf. I want the keypad’s entry log.”

“Yes, ma’am.”

“And, Dale. I would like to hear who has been in this room since Friday afternoon, in the order they went in.”

I give them the keypad’s log within the hour. It is a little gray box under the keypad that records, in a tiny font, each code entered, and Tori has to find the manual to read it. We stand around it in the drug room, the judge and the sheriff and the vet and the tech, like people at a christening.

Friday 4:52 p.m.: DR. MARROW. Friday 4:55 p.m.: TECH 1. That is Tori, and me, counting. Saturday 6:10 a.m.: TECH 1. Tori, feeding the kennel, as she does. And then, long after, on Sunday evening, at nine forty-one p.m., eleven minutes after the last of us had gone to the ranch and the road had been plowed:

TECH 3.

“Who is Tech 3?” says the judge.

“That’s the extra code,” says Tori. Her voice has gone high and flat. “It was for the temp we had, last spring. A student from Bozeman. She left in August, and I meant to delete it, and I swear, Dr. Marrow, I swear on Dolores, I meant to.”

“Where were you Sunday at nine forty-one?” says Pruitt.

“At my mom and dad’s. In the funnel-cake trailer. We do inventory on Sundays.” Her eyes are huge. “There were eleven people. And my mother, who will tell you in detail.”

“I am sure she will,” says Pruitt mildly. “Amundsen, call Mrs. Boyd.”

“The camera,” I say.

I do not know why I say it. I think I have been waiting. There is a small black dome in the corner of the clinic’s hallway that I have not thought about since the first week of November, when Pell’s man turned it off from Billings. Tori goes to the monitor. She runs the log. She does not need to say it.

“It’s blank,” she says. “From nine thirty-eight to ten oh six. Twenty-eight minutes. And it comes back on all by itself.”

“The same trick,” says Cole, quietly. I did not know he was there. He has come in at the back and is standing in the door with the cold on his coat. “As at the ranch. A person with access to the cloud account, from outside.”

“Nobody is going to find that,” says Dr. Sato. “Not in a cloud.”

“No,” says Pruitt. “But somebody was standing outside this clinic on Sunday evening, watching the lights go out, for as long as it took us to leave. They knew when the road would open, and when we would all be gone. And they knew,” he says, and I see his face go grim, “which night the judge was coming.”

“They knew about the radio,” I say. “They wanted me to be a liar.”

“They wanted the Ledger to have a second headline,” says Cole. “They wanted that vial in the picture. VET LIED ABOUT MISSING DRUG.” He closes his eyes. “I am sorry. I should have thought of it.”

“You have been a little busy,” I say.

By the time the judge leaves, it is nearly four. She shakes my hand on the step, in the dying light, with her rubber boots in the gravel, and her hand is dry and hard and warm. “I do not think you took it, Doctor. I would like that on a record somewhere, and I will not put it in an order, because it is not evidence. Go home. Eat something.” A pause. “Is there anything else?”

“No, Your Honor.”

“There is always something else,” says the judge, and gets into her car.

At twenty past five, my phone rings.

I am in the truck, in the clinic lot, with the engine off and Pickle on the seat beside me and my forehead against the steering wheel. I have been in this position for some time. The sky is the color of a bruise. It has started to snow again, a few fine flakes drifting down through the dusk and settling on the hood, and I watch them without feeling them.

“Doctor Marrow,” says Dub Teague. “It is Monday.”

“I know it’s Monday.”

“I propose to read you the Clause. I regret that it is a long one. He appears to have enjoyed writing it.” There is a rustle of paper. “Clause Five.”

I sit up.

“On Thursday next, the long table in the great room of Cold Spring Ranch shall be set for twelve. The guardian shall invite those she is most inclined to leave out, and Margit Voss shall be among them. The dog shall be fed first, at the head of the table, in the chair of the old man. No person shall eat until he has. Should any person decline to sit, the guardian shall ask her why, and listen to the answer, and not argue.” He pauses, and reads on, and the dry voice thins. “There is a postscript. ‘Doctor. A table is the only court that has never needed a judge. Feed the dog first.’”

“Thursday,” I say.

“The twenty-seventh. I am advised that this is also an American holiday.”

“Dub, I have a margin call on Wednesday at five and a ledger in the county vault and a vial in an evidence bag. I have a man in a coat who is going to buy my clinic on the fifth of December and burn my father’s truck. I have to go to Great Falls. I have a goat.” I hear my voice go up. “He wants me to cook.”

“Ines will cook,” says Dub.

“He wants me to sit at a table with the woman who gave Pell the key.”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

“I should think,” says Dub, gently, “that you would have to ask her.” He clears his throat. “I should add, Doctor, as the trustee of this instrument, that Mrs. Voss has not declined. I took the liberty of informing her counsel at four o’clock. Mr. Cross telephoned me at five. He said, and I quote, ‘Tell the Doctor that Mrs. Voss will come, and that she will want to be asked.’”

I look out of the windshield. The snow is falling faster. Through it, across the lot, I see the lit window of the clinic, and in it the small bright shape of Tori, bent over a kennel, talking to a beagle.

I think of a vial in a slot. I think of a cough in a telephone. I think of an old man in a dark kitchen, telling a dog the whole story, because the dog would keep it.

“Dub,” I say. “How many chairs does the long table have?”

“Twelve, Doctor.”

“Who sat in the twelfth?”

There is a very long pause.

“I do not know,” says Dub, honestly. “In forty years, I never saw anyone sit in it.”

I start the engine. Beside me, Pickle lifts his head from the seat and looks at me with his dark old eyes, patient and expectant, like a man who has been sent a train ticket.

“Okay,” I say. “Okay. Okay.” I put the truck in gear. “Tell Cole to get the leaf out of the barn. We’re having people to dinner.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!