Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 4

Chain of Custody

The controlled-substance log lives in the glove box of my truck, because a large-animal vet who carries ketamine to a ranch at two in the morning has to be able to prove where every milliliter went.

I hand it to Sheriff Pruitt in the parking lot behind Marrow Animal Clinic, under a sodium light that makes everyone look like a bad photograph of themselves. It is a green clothbound ledger with a coffee ring on the cover. He takes it with both hands, the way you take a casserole from a neighbor after a funeral.

“Doc,” he says. “I hate this.”

“I know, Dale.”

“Come look at your back door.”

Dale Pruitt is fifty-eight and shaped like a tired bear. He has been sheriff of Pronghorn County for sixteen years, and he has attended every one of my cow emergencies since I came back from school, usually in the passenger seat, drinking my coffee. He is friendly, and he is suspicious of money, and in this county those are not different traits.

The door has been jimmied with something flat. The frame is splintered at the strike plate in a clean white wound. Inside, the lab is untouched, the front desk is untouched, and the stuffed raccoon on the monitor is untouched, still wearing his stethoscope. The only thing that has been opened is the narrow steel cabinet on the pharmacy wall, whose lock I replaced two years ago with a nine-hundred-dollar model that I am still paying for.

It stands open. Its shelves are bare.

“Whoever it was knew exactly where to go,” says Pruitt. “Didn’t touch the cash drawer. Didn’t touch your computer. Went through the back, straight to the cabinet, and out. Deputy Amundsen says four minutes, tops.”

I stand in front of the empty shelf and do what I do. I count.

Three vials of ketamine, ten milliliters each, which is what was in the cabinet when I locked up on Monday night. Two of the opioid. A bottle of the euthanasia solution I hate keeping in the building and have no way to dispose of. A box of the sedatives for the horses. All of it gone, in a clean sweep, in four minutes.

Three vials.

And the book in the sheriff’s hands says four.

I feel the number turn over in my stomach like something drowned.

“Dale,” I say.

“Mm.”

“Before you read that.” My voice does a thing I do not like. “There’s a discrepancy.”

He lowers the ledger a half inch. He does not look at me. He looks at the empty cabinet, which is, I think, what a good man does when somebody he likes is about to say something he does not want to hear.

“Go ahead.”

“I came up one short on the monthly count. A ten-milliliter vial of ketamine. I think it went missing on the first of October, or the night before. I have not been able to account for it.”

“You report that?”

“No.”

“Did you write it down?”

I look at the floor. “I signed the October inventory on Friday. I wrote four.”

For a long second the only sound is the compressor on the vaccine refrigerator and Deputy Amundsen, in the exam room, photographing nothing.

“Josie,” says Dale Pruitt, which he has never once called me in a professional setting. “Why would you do that?”

I could tell him. I could tell him about a man in a camel coat who stood at my pharmacy cabinet at eight minutes to midnight on the first of October while I went to the back for a tube and a needle, and who had a perfectly steady hand.

I could tell him that I have no proof of any of it. I could tell him that I looked at the shelf on the sixth, and then on the tenth, and then on the thirty-first, and each time I thought: if I write three, they will ask why, and I will have to tell them who was here.

I could tell him I made an oath to a dying man.

“I thought I’d miscounted,” I say. “I thought it would turn up.”

“Uh huh.”

“I’m a good vet, Dale.”

“I know you are.” He rubs the back of his neck. “That’s why I’d like you to say something else, because that sounds like what a person would say if she was selling it.”

It is quiet in a way I have not heard in my own clinic. It is a quiet with a room in it.

“Where were you between five-thirty and seven-thirty this evening?” he says.

“At the ranch.”

“Anybody see you there?”

I think of a cold room, and a rack of glass vials, and a small white dome with a blue eye. I think of a card in the front of my scrubs. If I say the creamery, I say the vials. If I say the vials, I say everything, and I do not know yet who is on the other side of the camera.

“Ines Abara,” I say. “The housekeeper. I was in and out of the kitchen.”

“Between five-thirty and seven-thirty.”

“I took the dog for a walk.”

“Alone?”

I open my mouth.

“She wasn’t alone,” says a voice from the doorway.

I turn.

Cole Brandt stands in the back door of my clinic in his shirtsleeves, still with no coat, and behind him, in a bolo tie and a tweed jacket buttoned to the wrong hole, is Dub Teague. They have come in out of the cold. Cole has a faint shine of sweat at his hairline, in a room where I can see my own breath.

“Mr. Brandt,” says Pruitt.

“Sheriff. Dr. Marrow was with me.” He says it evenly, each word set down like a coin on a counter. “We were in the ranch library from about five o’clock. We were going over trust paperwork, the guardian’s duties and the schedule of examinations. I had Dub send the documents out at three. We were in the library the entire time, until you called.”

I do not move. I do not look at him. I put the whole weight of my attention on the dead black eye of the pharmacy cabinet.

The entire time.

It is a clean lie. It is the cleanest I have ever heard, and it has a thing in it that I do not want to look at, which is a door.

He is giving me a door. He saw the vials, and he saw the card, and he is standing in my back doorway with a lie so smooth it could be sold in a store, and I cannot walk through it without admitting to the room behind it. I cannot contradict it without telling Pruitt where I really was.

“That right, Dub?” says the sheriff.

Dub clears his throat. “I can swear I sent the documents out at three,” he says. “I cannot swear to the library. I wasn’t there.”

“Dr. Marrow?”

“Yes,” I say. “That’s right.”

My voice sounds like it belongs to somebody else.

Dale Pruitt looks at me, and at Cole, and at me again, and he gives the small nod of a man writing something down in a notebook he does not have to open.

“Okay,” he says. “Okay. I’m going to need statements from both of you tomorrow. The two of you.” He holds up the ledger. “And I’m keeping this.”

“Of course.”

“And Josie.” He is gentle. It is much worse. “I’d find a lawyer who isn’t Dub.”

He walks out to find the deputy. Dub stays where he is, looking at the cabinet, with an expression like a man who has found a cracked stone in the foundation of his own house.

“I’m trustee, Doctor,” he says to me, under his breath. “I cannot be your lawyer. It would be a conflict.”

“I know.”

“I would like to be.”

“I know that, too.”

He lays a dry hand on my sleeve and goes.

I find Tori in the exam room with Pickle on the table. She is kneeling beside him with both arms around his chest and her face hidden in his neck, and she is in a hooded sweatshirt and pajama pants with cartoon pizza on them, and when she looks up her eyes are red.

“I’m so sorry,” she says. “I’m so sorry, boss. I didn’t see anybody. I was in the barn.”

“It’s not your fault.”

“There was a pickup.” She wipes her nose on her wrist. “Behind the building. I saw it from the barn door around six. Dark, a crew cab. It pulled in back by the dumpster and I thought it was somebody dropping a horse off, and I was just done and tired, and I went home. I didn’t even think about it. I didn’t think.”

“What did it look like?”

“Like a truck.”

“Tori.”

“I’m trying,” she says miserably. “It was dark. I didn’t get a plate. I’m telling you I just thought it was a client.”

“Did you tell Dale?”

“I will. I’m going to.” She sniffles. “He looked so hungry, by the way. The dog. I gave him a scoop. Is that okay?”

“What?”

“A scoop of food. He was dragging. I know you said Ines feeds him, but she’s not here, and I just, I couldn’t watch him.” She looks up. “Was that all right?”

I am looking at Pickle. He is looking at me. His one eye is clear, and his tail is moving slow against the steel, and there is a steel bowl on the counter by the sink, licked clean.

I am so tired. I am so tired that I hear the question the way you hear a voice in the next room.

“It’s fine,” I say. “It’s fine. Thank you.”

“You’re sure?”

“A scoop,” I say. “It’s fine.”

I go out to the lot to breathe.

It is bitterly cold. The sodium light buzzes. Cole is leaning against the tailgate of my truck with his arms crossed over his chest, and he does not look up when I come out, and for some time neither of us says anything.

I get as far as the bumper.

“You lied to the sheriff,” I say.

“Yes.”

“For me.”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

“Noted,” says Cole, “that you didn’t thank me.”

“That is not an answer.”

“It’s an observation.” He pushes off the tailgate. His breath makes a small white cloud. “If you’re arrested, my father’s dog goes to the Foundation. If the Foundation gets the dog, my aunt gets the shares, and whoever is standing behind my aunt gets whatever she wants. I would prefer that none of that happen on a Tuesday.”

“That’s all.”

“That’s all I’m going to say in a parking lot.”

I look at him. It is as dark as it can be under a light. He is thirty-four years old and he has not worn a coat in twenty-six degrees, and he is shaking, a little, from head to foot, and I do not think it is entirely the cold. He has not looked at the watch. He has told me one thing and meant it, and I realize that I have been trying all night to find the hole in it.

“I need to go back,” I say. “To the creamery.”

He does not ask why.

“I know,” he says. “I brought bolt cutters.”

It is eleven-forty when we reach the cottonwoods.

We go in two trucks, which seems important. I drive mine, with the dog beside me, who sleeps the whole way with his chin on the dashboard. Cole follows in his. At the edge of the windbreak we pull up beside each other and get out, and there is no talk. The wind has died. The pond shows a black skin of ice with a quarter moon in it.

Pickle goes ahead.

He knows the path. He does not look back. He crosses the plank, and the frozen grass crackles under his feet, and then he is at the steel door and he has stopped, and I see before I even get the flashlight up what is wrong.

There is a lock on the hasp.

It is not my lock. It is not the fist-sized padlock with the oiled shackle. This one is newer. Brass, bright, with a hard little shackle and a shine on it that the moon makes pale. It hangs where the old one hung and it does not budge.

“That’s not the one,” I say.

“No.”

“Cole. That’s not the one.”

“I see it.” He steps up beside me. In the flashlight his face is very white. He puts the bolt cutters to the shackle and leans, and it takes him two tries, and the brass gives with a flat crack like a branch breaking. The door opens on its gasket.

The room is dark.

I find the switch by memory. The light overhead blinks and hums. The compressor is running. The temperature chart is on the wall.

The rack is empty.

Fourteen slots in a straight line, stripped. Not a vial. Not a stopper. Not a label. Just a long gap of clean wood where the glass has been, and a faint ring of dust at the bottom of each slot, and, at the end, the little card. MARROW. 10/1. (IN HER KEEPING.)

I stand there with my hand over my mouth.

“Josie,” Cole says.

“They’re gone.”

“What was here?”

I do not answer. I do not look at him. I look at the corner of the ceiling, where a small white dome stares down with no light in it at all. The blue is gone. It is a dead eye.

Cole follows my gaze.

“That feed,” he says slowly. He takes out his phone and thumbs it awake and opens an app with a green icon, and the light of it throws his jaw into relief. He is quiet a moment. “The security desk logs it. There’s a gap. Ninety minutes. It dropped at six fifty-one this evening, and it came back at eight twenty-two.” He looks up. “Right after you left.”

“Right after we walked out.”

“Which is when Pruitt called you.” His mouth goes thin. “Somebody was waiting for the room to be empty.”

“Then somebody had a key,” I say, “in the ninety minutes after we left.”

“Three sets. My father’s, in the library safe. Mine, on my ring.” He lifts it, and I hear the brass chime. “And whatever you have.”

I do not take mine out. I do not have to. We both know what I have.

“I didn’t take them,” I say.

“I didn’t say that.”

“You were thinking it.”

“I was thinking,” says Cole, “that I do not know what was here.”

It is true. I know it is true, because he says it in the voice of a man who has been in my debt all night and does not like it. I look at him in the harsh hum of the light, with his shirt stuck to him and the gray in his cheeks and the faint fine shiver in his hands, and I have no more lies in me.

Pickle has gone to the far corner.

He sits in front of the steel freezer drawer under the table, the way he sat there before. The same pose. Back straight, nose to the seam. He does not look at me. He just waits.

“He keeps doing that,” Cole says.

“I know.”

“What is in it?”

“I don’t know.”

“You didn’t open it.”

“I didn’t have time.”

He kneels. It is a long, folding movement, and the dog does not move aside. He puts a hand on the drawer pull. It is a steel handle with a frost on it. He gives it a tug.

It does not want to open. It opens. A little rush of colder air spills out around his wrist.

Inside the drawer, on a bed of frost, there is a single glass vial.

He does not pick it up. He just looks at it. His hand has gone still on the steel, and for the first time since I came home, Colton Brandt looks his age. He looks, in fact, a good deal older.

Then he turns his head and looks up at me with a stranger’s eyes.

“You knew what was in this room,” he says.

I do not answer.

“You knew when I walked in,” he says. “You knew when I stood in that door, and you knew when you told me the dog brought you. You knew when you let me lie to the sheriff for you, and you stood there, and you let me, and you did not say one word about what I was lying to protect.” His voice does not rise. It never does.

“I don’t think you stole them. But I think you know what they were, and who would want them, and I think I have just been made a fool of in front of the county sheriff.”

“Cole.”

“Doctor,” he says, and it is a door closing. “One of us is going to have to tell the other the truth. And I think, since you were here first, that it is going to have to be me.”

He reaches into the drawer and lifts out the little glass vial and turns it in the light, and I read the label upside down.

It is written in the old man’s hand, in block capitals, and it does not say PICKLE.

It says COLE.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!