The knock came a third time.
It was exactly as loud as the first two. Three raps with a knuckle, evenly spaced, the way you knock when you've been raised to wait on a porch until somebody comes.
I stood in the kitchen in my socks with the phone still warm against my ear. The line had gone dead. The thin black thread of lake water had reached the leg of the table and stopped.
Moose was standing between me and the back door, stiff-legged, a low growl rolling out of his chest.
"Moose," I whispered. "Quiet."
He didn't quiet. But he didn't charge, either. That was the strange part. In the theater and on the beach, he had thrown himself at the dark like it owed him money. Now he held his ground and shook.
I got Danny's old baseball bat from the broom closet. It felt ridiculous. It felt better than nothing.
"Sadie?"
The voice came through the wood, small and cracked from the cold.
"I know you're there. I can see your shadow under the door." A breath that rattled. "Please don't hit me with the bat. It's the aluminum one. It hurts."
I looked at the bat.
When I was sixteen, I had broken a window with that bat, and Danny had told our mother a bird did it.
"Nobody knows that," I said, to the door.
"You do." A tiny laugh. "I do."
Footsteps on the stairs. Priya came down in an oversized Cubs T-shirt with a recorder already in her fist, red light blinking, her hair flattened on one side. She had slept in Danny's old room for four nights without once complaining about the posters.
She looked at the water. She looked at the dog. She looked at me.
"Is that her?" she mouthed.
I hadn't told her about the call. I hadn't had to. She'd heard the dog.
I put the chain on the back door and opened it as far as it would go.
There was a girl on my mother's porch.
She stood in the wedge of yellow light with her arms wrapped around herself, barefoot on the boards, and water ran off the hem of her nightgown and made a small pool at her toes. A gray flannel nightgown with a faded crescent moon on the pocket. I had worn it until it fell apart in the wash.
Sixteen years old. Her hair was plastered to her cheeks. Her lips were the color of a bruise.
She had my face.
Not a face like mine. Mine, from before. Before the careful eyebrows and the sleepless gray under the eyes. Before I learned how to look at the world like a liar I was about to catch.
"Hi," she said.
I tried to say hello. What came out was a sound like a hinge.
Behind me, Priya said very softly, "Oh, no. Oh, that is not okay."
"It's okay," said the girl. "That's what I always say. It's not a good line. I'm working on a better one."
"What are you?"
"The part the lake kept." She said it simply, like giving her address. "When Danny brought you back, the lake gave him your breath and your name and your whole body. It kept the part of you that follows. The part that walked in after Dad. They call it the deposit." She glanced down at her bare feet. "I think it's an accounting word."
"A deposit on what?"
"On the twelve years."
I held the edge of the door. The chain pulled tight between us, a few inches of brass and a six-inch crack of cold air.
"Prove it," I said. "I'm sorry. I'm a professional. I have to ask."
She smiled. It was the worst thing I've ever seen. It was so careful.
"Moose knows me," she said.
I turned.
The dog had stopped growling. His head hung low and his tail swept the wet floor once, twice, uncertain, as if he wasn't sure he was allowed. A thin whine came out of him, the sound he makes at the vet.
"He's been sleeping across your feet for four nights," said the girl. "He knows I smell like you. He just doesn't know which of us is the one he's supposed to guard." She looked at me with enormous patience. "Also, the bird never did it. You're welcome for the twelve years of keeping that secret."
I stopped being able to feel my hands.
Priya's recorder lowered an inch. "Sadie, we can't," she said. "Whatever this is."
"I know."
"She's been standing there the whole time," said the girl. "Every night. At 11:52. I stand on this porch and knock. Four thousand three hundred and eighty-three times, if you count the leap days." She wasn't complaining. She was just saying it. "Nobody ever answered. Nobody could hear me. Nobody remembered to listen."
"Why are you telling me this?"
"Because tonight you could." The girl lifted her eyes to mine. "Because everyone remembers now. The lake can't keep what's remembered, so everything it ever swallowed is loose. And the rules are changing, Sadie. I think all of us down there are about to start walking home."
Priya let out a breath. "Okay," she said. "Okay. Nope. I'm putting that on the record. Nope."
"Please let me in," said the girl.
The water on the floor crept an inch.
I stepped back, and the chain slid free of my fingers.
"I can't come in unless you ask," she added quickly, and she sounded apologetic about it. "That's a rule too. Somebody who remembers me has to say my name and say yes. That's the only way the door opens. So I'm sorry. I know it's weird, me standing here, all wet, asking you to ask."
"No," I said.
Her face did something small and terrible. Then it smoothed.
"That's okay," she said. "I'd say no, too."
"I'm not saying no to you."
"You are. A little."
"I'm saying no to the lake." My voice was shaking. I hated it. "I've known you for ten minutes and I've been lied to by that water for twelve years. I'm not letting anything in through that door until I know what it costs."
For a moment, I thought she'd cry. She didn't. She looked exactly like a girl who had spent a long time practicing not to.
"That's the smartest thing you've ever said to me," she said. "I'll wait on the step."
She sat. Right there, on the porch of the house we grew up in, drawing her bare knees up under the wet nightgown, her back to the door, facing the lake.
"I don't get cold anymore," she said over her shoulder. "I just stay cold. It's different."
Priya's hand found my sleeve. We stood in the kitchen with the bat and the dog and the water, and I noticed what I had been refusing to notice since I saw her face.
I had not cried. Not when I saw my father burn a pancake in a video. Not when Theo walked into a lake for me. Not once, in twelve years, in front of two hundred and twelve missing families.
She was sitting on the step with her shoulders shaking, and she was making no sound at all.
That's when the front door knocked.
Not a polite knock. A tired one. A man's knuckles, slow and heavy, the way you knock when you are very cold and very sure of your welcome.
"Jo?"
The voice came from the other side of the house, muffled and warm and ordinary.
"Jo, honey, it's cold out here. Let me in."
Upstairs, a bedroom door opened.
I heard slippers on the stairs, quick, light, a woman half running in the dark. I heard my mother's voice, wild and shaking and nineteen years old.
"Pat?"
By the time I got to the hall, she was already standing at the front door in her bathrobe, her hair loose, her face lit up like Christmas morning.
Her hand was on the latch.

