Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 12

Burn the Pancakes

"Mom, wait."

I got between her and the door. She was shorter than me now, and she put both hands flat on my chest as if I were a piece of furniture she meant to move.

"That's your father."

"Maybe."

"Sadie Marie." She had never in her life used both names unless someone was in trouble. "That is my husband, and he is cold."

"Jo," said the voice on the porch. It was patient and warm, a little hoarse, my father's voice with the gravel in it. "Jo, I know it's late. Let me in."

From the back of the house, thin and desperate, a different voice cut through the dark.

"Mom! Mom, don't!"

My mother froze. I saw it travel over her face, the way a gust travels over a field.

"That's not him," the girl on the back step called. She had gotten to her feet. I could hear her bare soles slapping the boards as she ran around the side of the house toward the front. "Mom, please. It's not anyone."

"Who is that?" my mother whispered.

"That's the part of me they kept," I said. It was the first time I had said it out loud. "I'll explain. I swear. Give me ten minutes."

"Jo," said my father's voice. "It's freezing."

The girl's face appeared in the narrow window beside the door, pale and breathless, hair still dripping. She looked at my mother with an expression I can only call hunger.

"They're what's left over," she said through the glass. "When the lake chews on a forgotten thing, there are scraps. It makes them into shapes. They look like whoever you wish for, and they know everything the town ever forgot. They only know what's gone. They don't know what you kept."

"What do you mean, what I kept?"

"Ask him something you remember." Her voice cracked. "Something you've never told anyone. Never said out loud, never filmed. Something you still have, all of it, in your own head. He'll say whatever you want. Or he'll say nothing. That's how you know."

My mother looked at me. I looked at Priya, who stood at the bottom of the stairs with her recorder held high like a candle.

"She's right about the filming," Priya whispered. "The whole town saw him say 'Burn the pancakes.' Anyone can say that now."

I had a terrible thought. It was the kind I'd had a hundred times in a hundred interviews, when a witness's story turned out too perfect.

"Mom," I said. "Ask him."

She wet her lips. She stood at the door with her hand still on the latch, and her voice came out so quiet I almost didn't hear it.

"Pat. When you proposed to me. What was in your other pocket?"

There was a pause. It lasted a little too long.

"Whatever you want it to be, Jo," said the voice.

My mother closed her eyes.

"I want it to be the truth," she said.

"I want it to be the truth, Jo," said the voice, a half beat behind her.

Then, in my mother's own voice, soft and sweet and unmistakable: "Let me in."

Nobody moved.

The voice on the porch went on. "Let me in. Let me in. Let me in," a little faster each time, my mother's pitch, my mother's breath, as if a tape had caught on a tooth. Under the door, a thin dark wetness crept across the boards, and my mother took one step backward, then two.

"Say it to him," said the girl at the window. "Say no. Three times. They have to go if you tell them three times."

"No," my mother said.

"No," I said.

"No," said Priya.

The voice stopped like a radio cut off at the wall.

I heard the water go. A long, hollow trickling, like a bathtub emptying through a hole in the floor. I counted ten seconds. Then I opened the door.

The porch was empty. A wide stain of wet darkened the boards where a man might have stood, with one set of bootprints leading down the steps and away across the lawn, getting fainter, as if the grass had drunk them.

My mother sat down on the floor of the hall in her bathrobe and put her face in her hands.

I knelt in front of her. She didn't push me away. When she finally looked up, her eyes were red, and she wasn't angry. She was looking past me, at the window.

"Let her in," she said.

"Mom."

"She's mine, Sadie. She's my daughter. I carried her up that beach." Her voice broke. "I will not leave a child on a step in the cold. Not again."

"We don't know what it costs."

"I don't care what it costs."

"I do," said the girl at the window. She said it so gently that we both turned. "I'd like to know what it costs, too. Honest. Before anybody opens anything."

She looked at me.

"You could ask me something. To check."

I felt like a coward and a cop at once. I asked anyway. I asked the one thing I had kept in my head for nineteen years, because I had never found anyone I was willing to tell.

"When Dad's boat was found," I said. "The night after. What did I do at the dock?"

She didn't hesitate.

"You took your orange life jacket," she said. "The little one. You carried it down to the end of the dock when nobody was looking, and you dropped it in the water. So he'd have it."

I could hear Priya's recorder humming.

I had told no one. Not my mother, not Danny, not the therapist in Chicago I saw for exactly two sessions before I decided I was fine.

"That's her," my mother whispered.

"That's me," the girl said. She pressed her palm against the glass. "I'm so sorry. I'd like to say I'm sorry for a better reason. I just wanted you to know that I know."

I opened my mouth to say her name. I didn't have one for her. I had called her the girl. I had called her the part. But she was sixteen, and she was still, somehow, sixteen.

"Sixteen," I said.

She laughed, one breath of a laugh, surprised. "Okay," she said. "That works."

I put my hand on the cold window opposite her palm.

"Not tonight," I said. "I'm sorry. Not yet."

"I know," said Sixteen. "That's okay."

Then she sat down again on the porch outside the window with her back against the wall, and my mother sat down inside against the same wall, a few inches of wood and glass between them. They talked until the sky turned gray. I sat in the kitchen with the dog's head on my foot and listened to my mother tell a girl who looked like me about the summer she taught me to ride a bike, and the girl said "I remember," and I thought, she does, doesn't she, she remembers it better than I do.

At first light, the voice outside the window stopped in the middle of a sentence.

I went to look. The porch was empty. A small wet outline in the shape of a girl sitting with her knees drawn up was already drying in the dawn.

"Tomorrow," said my mother, to nobody. "Eleven fifty-two."

Up and down Larch Street, the porches were wet.

I walked out onto the lawn in my socks and saw it. Footprints on every step, every walk, every doormat. Some houses stood wide open, with figures moving in their kitchens. In one yard, a man in a Sunday suit from some earlier century sat on a porch swing holding hands with a woman in her bathrobe, neither of them saying a word.

A rusted red truck came up the street too fast and stopped crooked on the curb.

Theo got out. He looked terrible. His beard was frosted at the tips. His lips had a gray edge to them, and he was holding the truck door for balance.

"Sadie." His teeth were chattering. "I need to tell you something."

"Theo, sit down, you're—"

"Last night, somebody knocked at the marina." He swallowed. "I passed the test, I think. I asked him about the thing with the tackle box. He knew. I said yes."

"Who?"

Theo looked at me with brown, wet, shaking eyes.

"Danny's in my kitchen," he said. "He's making eggs. Sadie, he's breathing."

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!