Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 41

An Item

Here is what nobody tells you about pulling a man out of a lake. It is not a rescue. It is an argument, and the other side is patient.

The water came up Elias Harmon’s shins, then his knees, and it did not splash or pour or behave like water at all. It rose the way a tide rises in a photograph, with no hurry and no sound, and every inch it climbed took something with it. First the color went out of the cardigan. Then the leather slippers went pale, and then they went transparent, and I could see the lit gravel of Mill Road through the toes.

“Don’t let go of his wrist,” said Theo.

“I’m not.”

“You’re not holding it. You’re holding where it was.”

He was right. I looked down at my own fist, closed on a thin spotted wrist, and I could see the knuckles of my hand through the old man’s skin, as if I had clamped down on a pane of smoked glass. The bones of his wrist were there, faint and gray, and the cold coming off them was not like the cold of the morning. It was the cold of the cellar under the library. It was the cold of being on somebody’s books.

“Pull,” said Marguerite Voll.

“We are pulling!”

“No. You are pulling against him. Pull toward him.” She had both of Elias’s hands in hers, and her bare violet finger was pressed into the center of his palm like a thumbtack. “He is an item in transit. You cannot haul an item. You must claim it. Say whose he is.”

“Whose he is?”

“Say it, Ms. Kerrigan, before the ice closes!”

I have never in my life been more aware of my own mouth. I had a mark on my left palm and a bond on file and a feeling in my chest like a held breath, and what came out of me, in a voice that cracked on the second word, was this:

“He’s mine. He’s Harmon, Elias Thomas, account one-seventeen, and I’m his witness. I’m the co-objector of record. You don’t get to take him till somebody who isn’t me says so.”

The water stopped.

It did not drop. It stopped, a black ring at the level of his knees, with a small clean edge like the rim of a glass. And in the cold air above the hole, very close to my ear, someone turned a page.

“Co-objector’s claim,” said the dry voice of the Reader. “Noted. Is it paid?”

“Is what paid?”

“The claim.” A pause. “A claim made on an item in transit is made against the claimant’s own account. It is a lien. I’m required to ask whether the claimant understands.”

“No,” said Theo, savagely. “She doesn’t. Nobody explained anything to her. She’s been told it’s a form.”

“Then I explain,” said the Reader, quite gently. “If the item comes out, it comes out on your line, Ms. Kerrigan. What is owed on him, you will owe a part of. If it does not come out, nothing is owed, and the item is received in full, in order, with every courtesy. I would not wish you to think it a cruel office. Receiving him would be very easy. He is tired, and he is willing.”

I looked at Elias.

He was looking at me. His eyes had gone the color of dishwater, a pale, faded gray-green, and the lashes were the only thing about his face that still seemed to be made of anything. But he was smiling, in that polite, puzzled, schoolboy way, and I knew, with a clarity I did not enjoy, that the Reader was telling the truth. Elias would go down quietly, and be thanked, and it would be the kindest thing that had been done for him in sixty-nine years.

“Mr. Harmon,” I said. “Are you willing?”

“I think,” said Elias, “that I’d like to see the sums marked.”

“The what?”

“The roll. They’ll mark it in the morning. I’d like to see whether I got them right.” His voice had the sound of a very old recording. “I never saw the marking. It’s a small thing to ask. Do you think I might stay for the marking?”

I do not know what the Reader would have done with that. I know what I did. I said, “Yes,” and pulled.

---

The first thing that came out of the hole was his left foot, and it came out with a sound I have never forgotten, the sound of a boot being drawn from deep mud. The ice shuddered. The black ring around his knees tore open like a cheap bag, and the water went down, and there was an instant when we were all four of us sprawled on the surface of Lake Harrow, with Elias on top, in a heap of parkas and elbows.

He was alive. I want to say that first. He was breathing in short dry pants, and the hand I held had a pulse in it, thready and fast, and his chest under my cheek went up and down.

But he was not all there.

I could see it in the light of the picnic-area lamp, as Theo and I dragged him off the wet patch toward the thick ice. His slippers were gone. In their place, his feet ended in a soft gray blur, like a photograph of a runner.

The cardigan hung on a shape that seemed slightly flatter than it ought to. And his edges, the whole outline of him, had that quality I’d spent a month trying not to see on my brother. A shimmer. A place where the old man stopped and the air began, and the line between them was not quite sure.

“Danny’s rule,” said Priya, who had come up at a dead run, her face wet. “Somebody has to say his name. Now. Out loud. He’s fading.”

“Elias Thomas Harmon,” I said. “Born October nineteenth, nineteen forty-three. Of Harrow, Minnesota. Teacher’s pet. Gave the Office a very hard time.”

“Elias Harmon,” said Theo. “Writes the neatest hand I’ve seen on a man who isn’t a bookkeeper. Thinks the ice is bracing.”

“Mr. Harmon,” said Priya, “who never got my number.”

His outline firmed. Not all the way. It sharpened by about a third, the way a blurry picture does when someone turns the focusing ring partway, and the cold coming off his skin dropped from a cellar to a refrigerator. He opened his eyes. He looked at the three of us in turn, and then past us, at the shore, and the small gray shape of the woman who was crouched at his side with both his hands in hers.

“Ah,” he said. “Is it very bad?”

“It is the most irregular procedure I have witnessed in sixty-nine years,” said Voll, in a voice that shook, “and I would like you to stay precisely where you are.”

“Yes, Miss Voll.”

“And not say anything else.”

“No, Miss Voll.”

She put her forehead down against the back of his hand, just for a second, and I looked away, because it was not mine to see.

---

I had to look somewhere. So I looked at my arm.

I had not felt it go. That is the horrible thing about the lien. There was no shock, no flash, no clean line of pain. I simply glanced down at the hand I had thrust into the hole, the left one, the one with the violet stamp, and I saw that it was lying on the ice at the end of my arm with the fingers curled loosely, like something a person had set down.

I told it to move. It did not. I told it again, in my head, firmly, in the voice I use for the printer at the station, and the index finger twitched about a quarter of an inch.

“Sadie?” said Theo.

“Fine.”

“You’re not.”

“It’s numb,” I said. “It’s just numb. It went numb to here.” I touched my elbow with my right hand and felt the touch only on the right. “It’s like your mittens. It’s the same. I’m in the club.”

He didn’t say anything. He took my dead left hand in both his dead ones, and the three of us sat there, my arm and his two hands, and I understood that we had made a very small, very ugly joke of ourselves, and that there was no way to stop being it.

“It’s the price,” said Voll, from the other side of Elias. She did not look up. “The Reader would tell you it is a modest one. A claim is booked against the claimant’s feeling. It is a rate. It will go back, in part, when the account balances. I am sorry. I should have stopped you before you spoke.”

“You told me to say it.”

“I did.” Her face was gray and exact. “In all my years at the dais I have given that instruction to nobody. I find I am a poor examiner, Ms. Kerrigan. It seems to have taken a sunrise.”

I started to answer. And that was when I noticed the silence.

---

I had been so busy with Elias that I had stopped listening to the lake. It had been ringing a minute ago, a bell, a hum, a sea of small sounds. Now there was just the wind, ticking the snow against my hood, and the faint tick of Priya’s boots on the ice. I raised my head.

They were all standing there.

There were two hundred and ninety-six of them. I can give you that number because I have counted them since, on a film Priya took, a dozen times, and it comes out the same every time. They stood in a loose crowd on the clear black ice between the lit road and the east shore, in aprons and flannel pajamas and Sunday coats and bare feet, and the snow was settling on their shoulders as it would on anyone’s.

A woman in a green housecoat held a sleeping baby against her chest. A boy of about twelve had a cat inside his sweatshirt, which looked out of the neckline with an expression of great distrust. A tall girl in a letter sweater had her arms around two smaller girls. And the heavyset man in the plaid coat, who had asked whether it was Monday, was now politely trying to help an old woman in a nightgown to a seat on his own overturned bucket.

They weren’t frightened. That was the strange part. They were something quieter and much harder to look at. They were bewildered and courteous and very tired, like passengers who have been told the train is late.

“Miss,” said the heavyset man.

He had come across the ice toward us in his stocking feet, with his cap in his hands. He wasn’t young. He might have been fifty, with a farmer’s red neck and a big, soft, anxious face, and when he reached us he looked at Elias on the ice and then at Voll and then at me, as if sorting out who in this group was in charge.

“Miss,” he said again. “I beg your pardon. We were at the school. The siren went, and we all went down to the school, because that’s what you do. Dale had the key. And then it got dark. And I just wanted to ask, only if it’s not an imposition, what’s the date?”

I opened my mouth, and discovered that I had no idea how to say it.

“Gus,” said Elias, from the ice, in his thin dry voice. “Gus Brandvold. It’s Elias Harmon. Don’t you know me?”

The big man turned, and bent, and squinted. A look crossed his face, a puzzled, then a wondering, then a dawning sort of look.

“Well, I’ll be,” said Gus Brandvold. “Little Elias. The Harmon boy. Gracious, but you’ve gone gray.” He put out a broad hand and gave Elias’s shoulder a pat, with such honest warmth that a sound came out of the old man like a laugh and a sob at once. “You’ve got old, son. You’ve gone and got old on me.”

“Yes,” said Elias. “I think so. Gus, I have to tell you something. It’s going to be a bit of a shock.”

“Is it Monday?” said Gus, hopefully.

“It’s Wednesday,” I said, because somebody had to, “and it’s the second of December. It’s twenty twenty-six.”

Gus Brandvold stood very still. The snow fell on his cap. He looked at the sky, which was the color of pearl, and at the shore, with its picnic tables and its pickup truck and its sign about a boat launch fee. He looked at the long, bare, silver lake. And then he turned, with that anxious face, toward the crowd of his neighbors at his back, who had stopped talking, and were all watching him.

“It’s twenty twenty-six,” he said, carefully. “Did you folks hear? It’s Wednesday.”

Not one of them made a sound. It was the hush of a congregation. And then, from somewhere in the middle, in a thin, high, reasonable voice, someone asked the question that every one of them had been holding.

“But where is everybody?”

---

The first truck was a Crow Wing County deputy’s SUV with its lights going and no siren. It rolled to a stop at the top of the ramp at 7:12, and a young deputy with a patchy blond mustache got out, hitched his belt, and stood there with his mouth slightly open for the length of a held breath.

I do not blame him. He had been sent out on a call from an ice fisherman who had said, to the dispatcher, quote, there’s about three hundred people on the lake in their pajamas, and I think one of them has a cat. He had assumed the fisherman was drunk. The fisherman, I’d learn later, had been entirely sober and had gone home and had a very long lie-down.

“Ma’am,” said the deputy, when he’d come down the ramp. His name tag said LUND. “Ma’am, I need to ask what’s going on here.”

“A reunion,” said Priya instantly.

“A reunion.”

“Of a town that was relocated. In nineteen fifty-seven. For the dam.” She smiled the smile that gets her through campus police. “It’s a historical society event. We’re recording an oral history. It started early, I’m sorry. Everybody’s very excited. This is a permitted gathering, I have the paperwork, it’s in my car in Merrow. In a folder. Marked HARROW.”

“On the ice?”

“They’re very sentimental about the ice.”

Deputy Lund looked at the crowd. The crowd looked at Deputy Lund. A woman in a Sunday hat went toward him with her hand out and her face lit up and said, “Oh, young man, how kind of you to come out. Are you one of the Lunds from Brainerd? I taught your grandmother. She never would sit still.”

The deputy, in the grip of something he would not be able to name for the rest of his career, took her hand.

“She still doesn’t,” he said, faintly.

I got to my feet then, on one arm and one pair of knees I couldn’t feel, and Theo got his shoulder under Elias, and Moose came and leaned all his considerable weight against the back of my legs. Down the shore, a second set of lights was pulling in. A third. I could see the whole gray morning filling up with trucks, and a woman with a phone already held out in front of her at arm’s length, and a long, long, long day coming.

And I thought: we did it. We did what the Reader said. We went and got them, and they came, and not one of them is under the lake.

That was when I looked down at the notebook.

I had it in my good hand. I did not remember picking it up. It was Elias’s black composition book, the one with the roll, and I had been carrying it across the ice for I don’t know how long, held against my ribs like a hymnal. I opened it, and my thumb found the last page, the one with nine words in an old man’s ink.

Under them, in a different ink, there was a new line.

It was in violet, in a neat, small, upright hand that I had last seen filling in a form headed BOND OF CO-OBJECTOR. It had not been there at the ledge of the ice, and it had not been there at the roll. It was dated that day, and the whole of it said:

Two hundred and ninety-seven. Harmon, Elias T. Received in advance. Balance carried.

I looked at it for a long time. Then I looked at the man the line was about, who was leaning on Theo’s shoulder, watching the people of his town shake hands with a deputy, and whose feet were still not quite there.

“In advance,” I said, aloud.

“Of what?” said Priya, at my elbow.

I did not know. But I understood, in the cold, what the bell had been counting. I had stood on the ice and listened to it toll, and I had heard it wrong. It hadn’t rung two hundred and ninety-six and one. It had rung two hundred and ninety-six, and then, with a very slight and very deliberate pause, it had rung a payment on something that had not yet come due.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!