Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 50

The Witness

On the morning of the sixth I lost my first roll of tape: the first time I heard my own voice on one.

I would like to say that I felt it go. I did not. I woke on the narrow bed in the spare room, with my toes wrapped in gauze and a hot water bottle at my feet that I was nearly sure Theo had put there, and I reached, as I did every morning, and the hole was simply there, tidy and cool. I was seven, or eight.

There was a cassette recorder, a gray one with a little red button. There was my own voice coming out of it, thin and high and strange, saying something I’d thought of as brilliant, and I knew that I had stood in a kitchen with my hands over my mouth and felt, for the first time, that a person could be put into a box and carried around. That was the moment I’d wanted to do what I do.

I could remember that I’d had the moment. I could not remember what it was like to have it.

I wrote it on my hand, between the bicycle and the beans. TAPE. KITCHEN. MY OWN VOICE. Then I turned my hand over and looked at the knuckles, and for the first time in four days I thought, with perfect clarity: if this goes on until the twenty-first, I’ll have a body covered in notes and nothing under them.

---

Priya had a theory about the toes.

“It’s the smallest price yet,” she said, over breakfast. She had slept about two hours on the Kerrigan sofa and woke up with the sort of focus that comes after long nights. She was cutting toast into strips, for Danny, who was eating with a faint shadow of embarrassment, as if the strips were a lingering concession. “It’s the smallest price and it’s the least connected. Everything else has been a thing you lose. The arm. The name. The bicycle.

“But the toes are just damage. They aren’t entered anywhere. They’re only what a mile in socks does.”

“So?”

“So I think the Office didn’t bill you. I think the night was free. The Reader said the price was the interest, and that you may withdraw until the end of the hour. You didn’t. You walked back up the pier. And now we know, because of the, the thing the lake said to Theo, that the recipient isn’t necessarily who you think.” She wiped her fingers on a napkin. “I want to find the witness.”

“The voice said the witness would tell me on the twenty-first,” I said. “And I know it’s a man. ‘He is a person of long standing.’”

“Which is a lot of people in this town.”

“It is a lot of old men,” said Danny. “But he kept silence before. Sadie. Who in this whole business has kept something silent for a very long time?”

I put down my coffee cup. It rattled against the saucer.

“Priya,” I said. “What did the Pine Haven log say?”

“What log?”

“The visitors’ log, from that Sunday. You said there were blank lines on the Sunday.”

“The Thanksgiving Sunday, yes. I photographed it at the desk while the aide was getting your coat. There were blanks. I never asked about the rest.” She had her phone out already, thumbing through. “Hold on. I took a lot of pictures. I can’t, wait.”

She turned the screen toward me.

It was a page from a ruled spiral log, in a tidy ballpoint, with six columns: DATE, TIME IN, VISITOR, RESIDENT, RELATION, TIME OUT. It was the page for the last days of November. The Thanksgiving Sunday, the twenty-ninth, was almost blank, with a single scrawled line at ten past eleven: our own. And the next entry, near the bottom, was dated the thirtieth, though the time in read one-twelve a.m. The night nurse had dated it by the shift it belonged to, which meant the small hours after Monday.

S. Kerrigan, it said. In blue ink. In my own looped hand. Resident: E. Harmon. Relation: former pupil.

Time out: 1:40.

“Pine Haven’s in Brainerd,” said Priya, slowly. “It’s two hours.”

“Monday night I was home. I remember supper, and then I don’t remember anything.”

“I know.”

“I was at the pier at eleven fifty-two.”

“And at Pine Haven at one-twelve,” said Priya. “An hour and twenty minutes later. In another town. With a signature.” She looked up at me with enormous eyes. “Sadie, they sent a Porter for you. The Office carried you.”

---

We drove to the church. Not to Brainerd; the church was nearer, and Elias Harmon was no longer in Brainerd.

After the ice he had been given a cot in the corner of the fellowship hall by the kitchen, with his composition notebook on his chest and a plaid blanket pulled up under his chin, and he had said, to Betty Soderlund, with a courtesy that had melted her at once, “I’m told I’m here. I’d be obliged if I might stay.”

He had a cot. He also had, by now, a small following. When we came in, at a quarter to ten, there were six Harrow children cross-legged in a ring around him, and he was telling them, in a thin dry voice, about the Mill Road lamps.

“They lit the lamps at five in the winter,” he said, “and Mr. Hobart who lit them used to say that a town was a thing you could see from the road. So he lit them evenly. Not to see by. To be seen. He was a great one for being seen.”

He had a mug of cocoa, held in both hands, and when he saw me over the heads of the children he nodded, gravely, as one nods to a visiting dignitary. “Children, I think this lady wants a word. Go and see if Mrs. Soderlund has any cookies.”

They went. A pack of them, at a gallop, with a great deal of shrieking.

Up close, in the daylight from the high basement windows, I saw what Voll had meant. He was thicker. On the second he had been a pale smudge of a man, half there, held together by names. Now there was something solid in him: color in his cheeks, a cleft in his chin I hadn’t noticed, the faint blue of a vein along the back of the hand that held the mug.

He was eighty-three years old and a boy of fourteen. He was thin, and he looked, for the first time, like a man who had breakfasted.

“It’s you,” I said.

“What’s me?”

“The bicycle. The first thing, the Harrow account got a bicycle. And this morning, my first tape recorder. You got that one.”

“I got that one.” He set the mug down. A flush rose in his face, and something very like shame. “Miss Kerrigan, I woke at dawn and I could hear it. Do you know the sound? A little click, and then a hiss, and then a girl, saying something so earnest that I had to put the pillow over my face. ‘Testing. This is Sadie Kerrigan. I am going to be on the radio.’” His mouth trembled.

“I laughed until I was sick. And then I understood where it had come from, and it wasn’t funny at all.”

“I’m sorry.”

“For what?”

“For giving you something that isn’t mine to give.”

“It isn’t a gift if it’s mine to refuse,” said Elias Harmon. “I’ve been thinking about that. I’m told that’s the rule.” He took a long breath. “I’ve been dead for sixty-nine years, Miss Kerrigan. I’m eating again. I’d be a poor sort of man to quarrel with the one who set the table.”

---

Theo had come with us. I had not asked him, and he had not asked to come. He had simply been on the porch at nine, in his coat, with his hands in his pockets and his face carefully empty, and when Danny opened the door he’d said, “I’m only driving.”

He sat now at the far side of the hall, on a folding chair by the coffee urn, with his hot water bottle in his lap, not looking at us. I understood why. If he heard the wrong word, he might ruin it for someone else. And he would not be the one who was told.

I pulled a chair up beside the cot and sat.

“You’re the witness,” I said.

Elias said nothing. His eyes went to the notebook on the blanket. Then they went to Priya, who was standing at the end of the cot with her phone held up, and then to the photograph on the screen, a ruled page, a single line of blue ink. He looked for a long time. When he looked up, he looked old again, and kind, and entirely without surprise.

“Ah,” he said. “The young lady who writes everything down. You got the log.” He smiled faintly. “I thought you might. I told her not to sign. I told her, ‘Miss Kerrigan, it leaves a track.’ But she said that was exactly the point, because somebody would have to follow it.”

“She.”

“You,” said Elias. “I beg your pardon. It’s a thing I find difficult. You came on the night of the thirtieth, a little after one, and the night nurse let you in because you were wearing a coat the color of the lake and she thought you were a deputy. You said you’d come to ask me for a favor.” He drew the blanket up. “It wasn’t the Sadie I’ve met. It was the same face. But she was calm.

“She’d got a lantern with her, and a very thin man in a cap, standing in the corridor, very still, and she’d, you’d, forgive me. The woman I met that night had made up her mind about something.”

“What did I ask you?”

“I can’t tell you.”

“Elias.”

“I can’t. I’m sorry.” The old man put his palms flat on the blanket. “You asked me to hold a record. A sealed one. I agreed. You made me promise that I would not tell you until the twenty-first, and that I would not tell anyone else at all, and that if you asked me, in the meantime, I would say no.” He met my eyes. “I gave my word. I haven’t given it lightly, in sixty-nine years.

“I gave it to a teacher once, and kept it, and I gave it to you.”

“And Voll?”

“I didn’t tell Miss Voll. I’ve held that one with both hands.” His mouth quirked. “She would have asked me very politely and I’d have been in considerable danger.”

“Is it that bad?”

“It is not bad at all,” said Elias Harmon. “That’s the trouble with it.”

---

I tried everything. I am not proud of it.

I asked him in a dozen ways, in the ordinary and the oblique. I asked him whether the thing I had given was large or small, and he said, “It is not for me to say.” I asked him whether I had given it willingly, and he said, “You did not seem to me a person in any doubt.”

I asked him whether it was something I had, or something I was, and he looked at me with a kind of pained admiration and said, “Miss Kerrigan, you ought to have been a lawyer,” and did not answer.

I did what I should never have done. I pushed. I put my elbows on the cot and my face very close to his and said, “I’m giving you permission. I’m withdrawing the promise. It was mine. I’m ending it.”

And Elias went pale.

It was a terrible thing to watch. It came on like frost on a windowpane, from the edges inward: his fingers first, going gray and then clear, and then his ears, and the cleft in his chin, and the faint color in his cheeks that the morning’s tape recorder had given him. The mug of cocoa, which he’d been holding, went on being held by a hand that was no longer quite there. Somebody dropped a tray across the hall.

“Stop,” said Theo, on his feet. “Stop it. Kerrigan. Look at him.”

“Elias?”

“It’s, it is quite all right,” said Elias Harmon, through teeth that did not seem to be entirely present. “It’s a surcharge. I’ve held a seal for six days and you are, asking me, to break it, early, and the Office, objects to, to being, asked.” He closed his eyes. “Say my name.”

“Elias Thomas Harmon.”

“Louder.”

“Elias Harmon! Everyone, say it, please!”

They said it. The whole hall, again, as they had on the night of Tobias Pruitt, with children’s voices in it, and Betty’s, and Priya’s, and from the far side of the room, a low rough voice I had never heard raised in all the time I’d known him, saying, over and over, like a man praying, “Harmon. Elias Harmon. Elias.”

He came back more slowly than Tobias had. He came back with a gasp, and a cough, and a long shudder that went right through the cot. When he opened his eyes, he was himself, and the cocoa mug was in his hand, and I was weeping, silently and without the least dignity.

“You will not,” said Elias, very gently, “ask me that again.”

“I won’t.”

“The seal is not mine to break. And it is not yours.” He looked at me for a moment with an expression I could not read: tenderness, and something harder under it. “It was meant, you know, to be difficult. That’s why it works.”

---

Priya took a deep breath. “Can I ask something that isn’t about the contents?”

“Of course, my dear.”

“The lake said, last night, that the recipient might not be who Sadie intended. It told Theo he wouldn’t be the one who received it. But the gift was written for Theo. In his name.” Her voice was perfectly controlled. “If it doesn’t go to Theo, where does it go? Who gets it instead?”

Elias was silent.

I watched him. He took a long time. He ran a thumbnail along the spine of the notebook, and then he looked past me, across the whole hall, to the coffee urn, where a man in a worn parka sat on a folding chair with a hot water bottle in his lap and his head bent.

“Mr. Lindgren,” said Elias Harmon. “Come here, please.”

Theo did not move.

“Please.”

He got up. He came across the floor with his shoulders slightly hunched, as a man walks to a bench to be sentenced, and stopped at the foot of the cot. He did not look at me.

“You have not asked me what I think,” said Elias.

“No, sir.”

“I will tell you something that isn’t the contents, since the contents are sealed. I will tell you what I decided on Wednesday, in the dark, on the lake, when I was going under.” The old man’s hands were quite steady. “I was fourteen when the dam broke, and no one told me it would. Not my teacher, not the clerk. I’ve spent a very long time believing that if a person had been told, it would have been kinder.

“I thought telling was the whole of mercy.” He glanced at me. “I have since had to change my mind.”

“Why?” said Theo.

“Because I was on the other side of that sentence once, and now I’m on this one. The truth is, Mr. Lindgren, that I was asked a question on the thirtieth that I’d waited sixty-nine years to be asked. The question was, ‘What would you have given, at fourteen, to be told?’ And I said, ‘Everything.’” He smiled, a thin and troubled smile. “And your Miss Kerrigan said, ‘Good. Then you’ll understand why you mustn’t.’”

Nobody breathed.

“I’ll say this much, and I do not believe it breaks the seal. The gift was written for you.

“It was written truly. I have read the page with my own eyes, and I am the only person alive who has, apart from the woman who wrote it, and she has forgotten.” He hesitated. “It was written for you and it is, I am almost sure, going somewhere else. The Office has its own way of reading a gift. And I think, Miss Kerrigan, that you knew that when you wrote it.”

“Then why did I?” I said. “Why would I give something to Theo that wouldn’t go to Theo?”

“Because you didn’t want him to know it was a gift,” said Elias. “And because you didn’t want to know yourself.” He looked down at the notebook, and for a moment I thought he would open it. He did not. He laid his hand flat across the cover. “But I’ll tell you the other thing, and I must tell it, because it concerns not you but me, and the promise you extracted is my promise.”

“What?”

“On the twenty-first,” said Elias Harmon, “I’m to tell you what you wrote. That was our agreement. That was the date, and the hour, and the purpose of the whole thing.” He took a slow, unsteady breath. “And you said to me, on the thirtieth, in the room, with your lantern and your coat the color of the lake: ‘On the twenty-first I’m going to ask you not to.’”

The hall was very quiet. Somewhere in the kitchen, a cookie tray rang on a counter.

“You said,” Elias said, very softly, “that I must tell you anyway.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!