Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 12

Eleven Feet More

At 7:04 on Monday morning Colm Strake serves my mother with a lawsuit and bills her for the coffee.

I am in the back booth with a plate of toast I am not eating, so I see it from the best seat in the house. The bell on the door says its one note, the one it has said since 1981. Strake comes in out of the cold in his camel coat, takes stool number six without being asked, lays a cream envelope on the counter, and says, to his gold pen, “Seven-oh-four. Point one, service.”

“We open at seven,” says my mother. “Coffee’s a dollar eighty.”

“I’ll pay it, Mrs. Tolliver. I always pay for what I’m served.” He slides the envelope an inch toward her. “And so, Mrs. Tolliver, are you.”

Ruth wipes her hands on her apron. She does it slowly, front and back, the way she does before she says something that will cost a customer a tip. Then she picks up the envelope, reads the front of it, and sets it down again.

“Notice of Claim,” she says. “Returnable at the rule, Tuesday, nine a.m. To the strip.”

“I’m afraid so.”

“What strip?”

“Eleven feet, by one hundred and twelve, along the back of Parcel Fourteen.” He takes his coffee in both hands. “Under your walk-in cooler, the kitchen ell, the loading step and, I’m told, a very fine tomato bed. My client holds Parcel Fifteen of record. My client’s title, as the blue books read for nine years, includes that ground. Your occupation of it, Mrs. Tolliver, rests on a survey line your daughter forged.”

He does not look at me. That is the courtesy he offers, and I feel it as plainly as a slap.

The diner has gone quiet in the way a diner does. Two truckers and a woman from the credit union have stopped chewing. Ruth’s face is as flat as the griddle.

“Marguerite Anne,” she says, without turning. “Come here.”

I come. I have a piece of toast in my hand, God knows why. My mother takes the envelope, tears the top, and reads the first page in the same voice she uses on the specials board.

“It says here my husband’s walk-in is trespassing.” She looks up. “Frank built that cooler in 1996. He borrowed Walt Kowalczyk’s father’s chain and a level, and he said the line could argue with him.”

“The line has argued,” says Strake. “Point one.”

“Get out of my diner.”

“I haven’t finished the coffee.”

“Then finish it on the sidewalk.”

He gets up. He puts two dollars on the counter, and then, with great gravity, a dime beside them, for what he calls the pause. He nods to me. “Ms. Tolliver. I understand you have taken up searching as a hobby. I wish you a pleasant morning in the blue books.”

“One more thing,” he adds at the door, to the street. “The Board fills the Recorder’s desk on Wednesday at ten. I mention it as a courtesy.”

The bell says its note. The truckers resume chewing.

My mother sets down the envelope, picks up the pot, and refills the credit union woman’s cup, and the cup is full before she notices.

“I paid that bank in March,” she says to nobody. “March. Every penny. And I’m to be sued for the ground under my own walk-in by a man in a coat.”

“Mom.”

“Don’t, Marguerite Anne. Not yet.” She puts the pot back. Her hands are shaking, and she puts them under the counter where I can’t see them, and I see them anyway. “I want to know how much it costs. Can you find that out?”

“I can find out what the record says.”

“Then find that out.” She meets my eyes, and what is in hers is not anger, which I could stand. It is trust, which I haven’t earned. “I am not asking you to be a lawyer. I’m asking you to be the one who reads.”

By nine o’clock I have a library card for the Recorder’s Archive, which turns out to be a piece of green paper with a stamp.

Tully hands it over the oak with ceremony. “Public searchers must sign the book at the door, legally speaking. And leave their bags. And not eat.” He eyes my pocket. “Is that a pen?”

“It’s a pen.”

“Is it a county pen?”

“It’s a pen,” I say. “It is not bound to anything this morning.”

He lets it go. I take a pad of yellow paper, a bundle of green slips for copies, and go down to Sub-subbasement C, where the air tastes like pencil shavings and eleven thousand bundles of mineral leases wait in the dark, and I put the lamp on its brass arm. I do not take the lamp off the arm. My hands curl once, in habit, and then I flex them, and they open.

The fever is gone. The itch is not. It is smaller than it was, a pilot light where a furnace used to be, but when I pass a drawer of brass hardware I can hear it, like a dog at the end of a very long leash.

I work the chain of Parcel Fifteen. It is the most boring work in the world, and I have never been happier. A deed is a conversation that has lasted a hundred years. You listen to a man hand a lot to his brother, who hands it to his widow, who sells it to a bakery. You wait for someone to say a sentence they will regret.

Fifteen was an empty lot behind Water Street, owned by the Lyle family from 1923 and by no one that paid taxes after 1988. It went to the county tax bureau in September. I find the notice in the blue binder: Sale, September twelfth, Parcel Fifteen, as shown on Plat Book Three, page forty-one, sold to Strake Mineral and Land LLC, for the sum of four thousand one hundred dollars.

And, at the foot of the notice, in the small print nobody reads, I find my first clue of the day.

Conveying such title only as the delinquent owner may have held.

I copy it out. A dollar a page. I will have run up forty-seven dollars before the end of the afternoon, out of a savings account of two thousand one hundred and fourteen, and a pension that stopped existing when I told the truth.

The sentence matters, so I go slowly. A tax sale does not sell the ground. It sells whatever the owner had. If the Lyles owned the strip, Strake owns it. If they never did, he bought air.

I take the deed from Dunmore to Lyle, 1923. The paper is soft as a cloth. It describes Fifteen in the language of its day, metes and bounds, an iron pin, an oak, a branch of the creek. Halfway down the second page, in a sentence that has been running ahead of me for ninety minutes without my noticing, a scrivener’s pen has stopped and written:

Excepting and reserving unto the grantors, and to the ground, a strip along the water side, eleven feet in breadth, as the same hath ever been reserved.

I read it three times. It does not change.

Eleven feet.

I take the next, Peck to Dunmore, 1871, and it says it. I take the one before that, a patent of 1796 in a brown hand like a fence, and it says it. Two hundred years of deeds on that ground, and in every one of them somebody has written, in whatever hand the year gave them, the same little sentence, the way a congregation says a response without hearing it.

Reserved. Eleven feet. The water side.

Then, because I cannot help it, I go for the chain of Parcel Fourteen, my own, my mother’s. I pull the Tolliver deed of 1951. It is on the shelf as if it had been waiting for me. I read the description with my finger.

Excepting and reserving a strip along the water side, eleven feet in breadth.

The air in Sub-subbasement C has gone cold. I notice it the way you notice a draft after the door has been closed. Behind me a ladder creaks, and I turn so fast that I knock the lamp.

Jonah is standing at the end of the aisle with two cups. He has been there a minute, I think.

“You look like someone’s walked over your grave,” he says.

“It’s the same strip.”

“What strip?”

“The one Strake wants. The one I moved the line across.” My voice comes out at a very small, clear pitch. “Eleven feet, Jonah. It’s in every deed on that ground since 1790. Excepting and reserving. They reserved a strip. Every one of them. Nobody ever owned it.”

“Nobody?”

“Not Fifteen. Not Fourteen. Not the Lyles, not Strake, not my father.” I hold up the paper. “The Tollivers’ walk-in is standing on ground that was never conveyed to anyone.”

He puts down the cups. He picks up the deed, which is brittle and soft at once, and reads it with two fingers on the corner, the way he reads everything. When he looks up, his face is very careful.

“The strip beside the water,” he says. “As it lies.”

“Yes.”

“And you moved the line eleven feet. Nine years ago. At two in the morning, with a pen that did what you told it.”

“Yes.”

“Why eleven?”

I open my mouth. I had always known why. Eleven was the number of feet it took to leave the kitchen ell, the one that ties my mother’s house to her diner, out of the bank’s description. I had measured it. I had measured it on a stair in the dark with a tape from the diner’s drawer.

But the sentence that comes out is not that one.

“I don’t know,” I say. “I thought I did.”

Neither of us says what we are thinking, which is that I did not pick the number. The pen did. And I do not want, at a quarter past ten on a Monday morning, to wonder what a Tolliver pen knows that a Tolliver does not.

“Hal reported,” says Jonah, after a while, because he is a kind man and has noticed that I need a different subject. “On the hour.”

“The hour.” I let out a long breath. “I forgot the hour.”

“He took it in a chair, wrapped in a quilt of keys. He told me it was like being dropped through a frozen lake and asked to hold the lake. He wanted a pencil to write down his impressions.” Jonah’s mouth turns at the corner. “He says he has never been so interested in anything in his life. He has given up the claim that cold is a form of death. He now says it is a form of weather.”

“And the owl?”

“He moved it to the window. He says it keeps the street honest.” He looks at the deed in his hand. “Mags. It’s a quarter past ten. You said the Board meets Wednesday.”

I had not said that. Strake had said it, at 7:04, on his way out, to the pen. I have been trying not to hear it.

“The vacancy,” I say. “They’ll fill it Wednesday.”

“With who?”

“Commissioner Dombrowski has a name.” I fold the deed. “A retired magistrate. A man who is afraid of the word ground.”

“He’d be the Recorder.”

“He’d be the Recorder of Volume Z. He’d have to take the oath, and the book would accept anyone with a clean hand and a good opinion of himself, and it would take him.” I can feel my pulse in the paper. “Strake would have a desk in the one room that can’t be lied to. That’s what the claim is for. The strip is nothing. The strip is the reason for the hearing.”

Jonah is silent. Then he says, “Then you need a Recorder before Wednesday.”

“I need a Recorder before nine tomorrow.”

“Why nine?”

“Because he’s filing the notice at the rule at nine, and I’d like it denied before breakfast.”

I find Tully in the lobby. He is polishing the brass rule with a handkerchief, the way a man polishes a medal he has not been given yet.

“Section thirty-one,” I say.

He looks up. “I don’t have thirty-one memorized.”

“Of course you do. You have everything memorized.” I lean on the oak, public side, an elbow on the wood. “A page of two years and a day, in a vacant office, may take the desk.”

The handkerchief stops.

“Two years and a day,” says Tully.

“It was Saturday. You told me yourself, Saturday, with a plaque and a coupon.” I realize I am smiling, and it is not entirely a kind smile, and I do not mind. “I should have seen it last Tuesday. I was thinking about myself last Tuesday. I wasn’t thinking about the one person in this building who has loved the book without being paid for it.”

“Ms. Tolliver.”

“Mags.”

“Mags.” He is very white. “I’d have to swear.”

“You did, once. For one claim.”

“That was a lay oath. The book let me because the claimant consented. This would be, it would be...” He swallows. “It would be forever.”

“It would be until you resign it.”

“An oath given up can’t be retaken. You said that to me. You said it at the counter, with your hand on the brass.”

“I did,” I say. “I said it because I knew what it costs. It is the most expensive thing I ever owned. I gave it up, and I’d do it again, and I want you to know that, and then I want you to decide.”

He looks at the book, which is lying on its stand with the gutter shut. He looks at his own hands. He is twenty-four, and he has a lanyard, and a Discord with four hundred and nine members, and a mother in Erie who thinks he works for the county.

“Legally speaking,” he says, in a voice that has gone very quiet, “I’d be the best Recorder this building has ever had.”

“Legally speaking,” I say, “you would.”

Strake arrives at 8:58 on Tuesday with a briefcase, an associate in a good gray suit, and Commissioner Dombrowski, who carries the folder like a man who has been told it is his own idea. He puts the cream envelope on the oak and the pen on the envelope.

“Eight fifty-eight. Point one, filing.”

“Accepted,” says Tully, from the stool. He has a white shirt on. “Filing accepted at the rule, Claim Three. Fee, seventeen dollars.”

“Accepted, but not entered.” Strake smiles at him. “The Recorder’s desk is vacant, young man. A page may accept; only a sworn hand may enter. Without a Recorder, my filing sits. It sits, Mr. Brandt, until the Board fills the desk, which, I’m assured, will be tomorrow at ten.”

“That’s what I understand.”

“And in the meantime, Mrs. Tolliver’s cooler is on my client’s ground. And her daughter, the former Recorder, who falsified the record, is standing at the public rail, at a claimant’s hearing. In my experience that’s called a conflict.”

“It is called the public,” I say. “I’m a member. I paid a dollar a page.”

“I’d like to be paid for the hearing,” says Strake.

“You can bill the ground.”

The room does not laugh. It is a good room for not laughing. Dombrowski’s folder rustles. Jonah is on the stairs again, arms folded. Ruth is not here, because I asked her not to be, and because, I think, she could not stand to watch me do a thing for her.

I put my hand flat on the brass rule, public side.

“Mr. Strake. May I put a question, as a member of the public?”

“Section twenty-two is for the grantee and the claimant.” He looks at the commissioner. “Though I’d have no objection, for the record.”

“I’m obliged.” My hand is steady. The brass is warm and plain. “Does your client claim the strip by any deed older than the tax sale?”

“My client claims by the tax sale, and by the blue books of Tamarack County, and by the line that stood nine years.”

“Did your examiner read the deed from Dunmore to Lyle, 1923?”

A pause. It is a short pause. The rule goes dull at the edge, and then, as he thinks about it, bright again. “No.”

“Or the deed from Peck to Dunmore.”

“No.”

“Did your examiner read any deed in the chain of Fifteen before the year 1951?”

“I’m told,” says Strake, and for the first time I see him look at his associate, “that the examiner relied on the plat and the blue books.”

“Is the strip, to your knowledge, excepted and reserved in the chain of Fifteen, eleven feet in breadth, along the water side?”

The rule goes out.

There is no drama in it, only a candle snuffed in a room where nobody had noticed it burning. In the quiet I can hear the boiler, and Dombrowski’s breath, and the sound of a man calculating, not in six-minute increments, but in years.

“I am not,” says Colm Strake, “in a position to say.”

“Silence is entered in the record,” I say. “As silence.”

“There’s no Recorder,” says Strake gently. He has found his smile. “I’m afraid it isn’t entered at all.”

“No,” I say. “Not yet.”

I turn.

Tully has gotten off his stool. I have never seen him stand so straight. He goes round the end of the counter and lays one hand on Volume Z, and one on the brass rule, and for a moment I think he is going to say the words he said on the fairground, I record what is brought, I alter nothing, in his lay voice, the voice of a borrowed coat.

But it is a different voice. It is the voice of a boy who learned the sentence from a book, and has known for two years and a day that he would never be asked to say it.

“I am Tully Brandt,” he says. “Page of the Recorder’s Archive of Tamarack County, of two years and a day. The desk is vacant. Under section thirty-one I take it.”

“Objection,” says the associate, finding his voice. “That is a stunt.”

“It’s a section,” says Tully. “I’ll show you.”

“I record what is brought,” he says, and the rule glows. “I alter nothing.”

The book opens.

It opens on its own, not at a page he has chosen, but at the empty line beneath the old oaths: Dee Fanning’s, in her square hand. Marguerite Anne Tolliver’s, in my own, nine years faded. The page has room. It is waiting for him.

The ink rises in the nib of the county pen on its chain, without a hand on it, and writes the date, and writes his name, in a clerk’s hand I have not seen before, small and upright and a good deal like mine.

And then, on the line beside his name, where every oath in this book has had one word, it writes something else.

To whom?

I have turned that page a hundred times. I have never seen those two words. Mine says, to the county, and I remember being faintly disappointed, at twenty-two, that the book had not asked.

Tully looks at the page. His mouth is open a little. “It wants an answer.”

“Then give it one,” I say. “Honestly.”

“The county,” says Tully, and it is the right answer. It is the answer in every oath. It is the answer I gave.

The ink does not take it. I watch it sit on the page like a drop on wax, and then it draws back, and, quite slowly, in the same small upright hand, it strikes out the word, and writes another over it.

The Ground.

Nobody speaks. Dombrowski’s folder has slid out of his hand, and the commissioner does not bend for it. Strake has stopped smiling. His gold pen is held an inch above his notes, and he is looking at the line the way a man looks at a lease he has just found out he does not understand.

Tully reads it twice. He does not say legally speaking.

“I didn’t say that,” he says.

“No.”

“I said the county.”

“You did.”

“Then why,” says Tully, in a thin, wondering voice, “does it think I’m sworn to the ground?”

I know. I do not say. I think of a forty-day deed, and a stub bound into a book in 1790, and a title that was set down as though nobody had ever needed to name her, and I think of a page that was cut around something. I think that the Recorder is not sworn to the county. The Recorder is sworn to whoever the county was built on.

And I think that nobody has told Tully, and that I will have to.

“Enter it,” I say, gently. “The claim. It’s the only thing in this room that has to be done today.”

He wets his lips. He turns back a page to the docket, and dips the nib, and writes in the careful voice of a man whose hand is no longer entirely his own.

“Claim Three. The instrument claims a strip eleven feet in breadth along the water side of Parcel Fourteen. The strip is excepted and reserved in every deed to Fifteen from 1923. The delinquent owner held no title to the strip, and the tax sale conveyed only such title as the delinquent owner held. Nothing passed. Claim Three fails. Entered.”

The ink takes it. It drinks the line, and the line closes up like a wound, and under it, on its own, in a hand that is no one’s, a second line arrives.

The strip is held.

By whom, it does not say.

Strake closes his case. He does it slowly. He picks up his pen and puts it away, and the associate takes the folder from the floor, and the commissioner mutters something about procedure that dies on the way out of his mouth. At the foot of the stairs Strake stops.

“Ms. Tolliver.”

“Mr. Strake.”

“I’d like to say, off the record, that I did not know about the reservation.” He does not turn round. “I’d like to say that the person who told me to buy Fifteen did.”

“Which person?”

“A person with an interest,” says Colm Strake. “I’m afraid that’s all I can say sideways.”

He goes up the stairs. His shoes sound like a man leaving a church for the second time.

Tully is still standing at the book. He has put both hands flat on the brass, and I think he is steadying himself, but when I come around the end of the oak, the gate swinging shut behind me for the first time as a courtesy, I see that it is not that. He is listening.

“It’s warm,” he says. “The floor. Under the, under my feet.”

“Yes.”

“It’s been warm since Saturday.”

“I know.”

“I thought it was the boiler.”

“It isn’t the boiler.”

He nods. He looks like a boy who has been handed his heart’s desire in a very large box, with the receipt on the wrong side. I put my hand on his shoulder, and I find that I mean it.

“Tully. Whatever she is. You took the desk.”

“I know.” He swallows. “Do you think she knows I did?”

“I don’t know,” I say.

Under his palm the brass rule stays bright. Neither of us is sure that is a comfort.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!