Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 43

Two Nibs

Exhibit one, broken; exhibit two, never used; custodian, nervous: that is the state of the evidence on Monday the twelfth of January, laid out on a clean blotter on the oak counter, where I have finally, after four days of carrying them against my ribs like a woman smuggling her own heart, unwrapped the Tolliver pen and both of its nibs in front of witnesses.

The witnesses are Tully, archive page, sworn to the Ground to the elbow, and Wren Elm, witness third class, probationary, who has brought a second composition book because the first is, in her words, almost full of important things.

It is drill day. Tomorrow at dawn we go to the ford, and a witness who has not practiced is, per Dee, a camera with the cap on, so the morning is for rehearsal: Tully plays the water, I play Jonah, Wren witnesses, and we run the crossing like clerks run a closing, every paper in order, every mouth knowing its one job.

“Legally speaking,” says Tully, standing on a chair to be taller than the river is wide, which is not how any of this works but has been deemed good for morale, “I am a four-hundred-year-old body of water and I keep the oldest ledger in the county. State your business.”

“Crossing,” I say, in Jonah’s flat furnace voice, which makes Wren put her face in her composition book. “Paying the toll.”

“The toll is one answer, true.” Tully extends a ruler over the blotter with great ceremony. “What do you want?”

And here is where the drill keeps mattering, because the wrong answers are all easy and the right one is work. We have run it nine times.

I have answered as Jonah might on a bad day: *to be left alone* (too big; a river could do a great deal with that). *To protect her* (not his to buy; the water strikes what is not the speaker’s). *To stay* (dangerous; it perfects Teague’s clause in the water’s own book with the water as witness).

The true answer, the small one, the one he built himself on the ridge with his own fault-finding: *to stay because I say so, not because it is written.* Want shaped like a choice. Nothing in it for a ledger to hold except the man himself, holding.

“Again,” I say. “From the top. And this time, Wren, you’re not watching Jonah. You’re watching everything that isn’t Jonah. The witness covers what the parties can’t afford to.”

“The wrist,” says Wren, solemnly, “not the sneaky,” and writes the scene number.

On the tenth run Tully, warming to the river, leans out over the ruler and goes off script.

“And the *other* one on the bank,” he says, in a voice like a long cold pipe. “The Tolliver. What does *she* want?”

“That isn’t in the drill,” I say, in my own voice.

“The water doesn’t use the drill. Dee said it might ask.” He lowers the ruler, apologetic. “Legally speaking, I’m being thorough. I’m being a river.”

So I am Jonah again, flat, furnace-voiced, with my hands in my pockets like a man at a fence. “I don’t answer for her. It isn’t mine to spend. She’ll say it herself, in her own words, when she’s asked it herself, and if you ask me again I’ll tell you the same.”

“Good,” says Wren, writing. “Entry. Jonah didn’t answer for Mags. He didn’t answer *around* her either. He said where the toll stops.”

“Say the last part again,” says Tully, who has stopped being a river. “Mags. You said it faster than the rest.”

“I said it the way he would.”

“You said it the way you *wanted* him to,” says Wren, without looking up from the page. “That’s different. That’s the wrist. Your jaw did a thing.”

I do not ask her what the thing was.

There is a three-word answer behind my teeth, with a name at the front of it that nobody in this archive has ever heard me say, and I have carried it for a day without once turning it over where a child could see. So I say, “Again, from the top,” and Tully climbs back onto his chair and becomes the river, and we run it again, and again, until the words go smooth as a stair that has been climbed ten thousand times.

We break at noon. Tully goes up for the sandwiches. And that is when the morning stops being rehearsal, because Wren Elm, who has been looking at the blotter between scenes the way she looks at everything, which is entirely, puts one finger an inch from the pale nib, not touching it, and asks the question I have been failing to ask correctly for four days.

“Why would a pen need two?”

*

I have been asking it wrong, is the thing. Since Thursday night I have stood at this counter twice with my palm on the brass and the question *what is the second signing* on my tongue. Both times the counter weighed it and sent up its price, and both times the price was the same, and both times I took my hand away as if the brass had gone hot.

The price is my father’s voice.

Not a memory of him entire. Just the voice. The counter was specific the way a surgeon is specific: the sound of Frank Tolliver saying anything, saying *that’s the boss’s parking spot*, saying *you’d want the light on*, the register and grain of him, paid out of me the way October went, the way my first Christmas went, leaving the shape of knowing with nothing in it.

I have twelve memories of my father. I have counted, and the counting is the most Tolliver thing I have ever done. In four of them he is talking.

“It priced it twice,” I tell Wren, because she asked, and because the rule of this winter is that Wren Elm is told the truth in full sentences. “The same price both times. The counter doesn’t haggle, it isn’t a market, the price is just what the answer weighs.”

I turn the pale nib a quarter inch on the blotter. “Which means the answer to *what is the second signing* weighs exactly as much as my father’s voice, and I can’t afford it, and I’ve been standing around for four days resenting a block of brass for the size of a fact.”

“Dee says keep your answer small,” says Wren.

“Dee says keep your *answer* small. This is a question.”

“Questions are just answers you don’t have yet,” says Wren Elm, twelve going on recorded-in-the-margins, and she looks down at the two nibs on the blotter, the brass one broken clean across the shoulder, the pale one with its water-sheen and its four words. “So ask a smaller one. You don’t need the whole signing. You told me a witness carries evidence, not verdicts. What’s the smallest true thing about the nib?”

I look at her. Somewhere upstairs, Tully is dropping the sandwiches.

“Who made it,” I say, slowly. “Not what it’s for. Whose hand made this nib.”

I put my palm on the brass, and I ask it exactly that, small, and the counter weighs it, and the price comes up cool and ordinary as a stamp pad: one hour. Flat. The clock’s hands will jump and my watch will disagree and that will be the whole of the bill.

“Done,” I say, and pay.

*

The hour goes wherever the hours go. My watch says 12:21, and the clock over the stair, which does not run, has swung its hands round to 1:21, and for a moment I have the vertigo of being an hour older than I am. Then it passes, and I am only a woman who has paid.

The answer comes up through my hand in the dry definitional tone, and it is longer than the counter’s answers usually run, which I will learn to read as a sign, because the counter, like Dee, spends words in proportion to what you will need them for.

*The nib was made by the water. One signing per nib; the metal takes the oath into itself and is spent. The first nib of this pen was likewise the water’s, and was spent in 1790, when the parties to the Compact walked to the ford, and the terms were read at the middle, and the water witnessed, and Josiah Tolliver paid the toll of the crossing.*

*His answer is not of record in this office. The record of the signing is held below as Z-2. The water keeps the questions.*

Tully has come down the stairs with the sandwiches in time for most of it, because I said it aloud as it came, which is now procedure when Wren is present, and he sets the plate on the counter with the care of a man who has understood something large and needs both hands free.

“Legally speaking,” he says, and stops. Starts again. “The Compact wasn’t signed here. It was signed *there.* The ford isn’t just where the water takes tolls, it’s the place of execution of the founding instrument of the entire county.”

He pushes his glasses up with the back of a wrist. “And the first nib, the nib your family has been writing with for two hundred and thirty-six years, the nib that broke Thursday, was the *pen of the signing.* Spent, and then used for every ordinary deed since. Like baptizing the parish in the creek on Sunday and then hauling water with the font.”

“And the Compact’s fourth column is unsigned,” I say. “For the Ground, who gave the ground, and who. Blank line. My thumbprint beside it, two hundred and five years old. The one question the whole county has been circling all winter: who signs the fourth column.”

“And the water keeps the questions,” says Tully, faintly. “It asked Josiah something at the crossing in 1790 and it kept his answer off our books, and there is a second nib, and it is inscribed *for the second signing*, and tomorrow morning you are going to stand in the middle of that river with it in your pocket.”

“Yes,” I say.

“Legally speaking,” says Tully, “I would like to state for the record that I hate this.”

“Entered,” I say, and mean it.

Because here is the shape of the thing, laid out on the blotter in two pieces of metal. The water made a nib for the Compact’s first signing and gave it to a Tolliver. The water has made a nib for a second signing and hidden it inside the barrel against the day it was needed.

The pen broke itself open on the first day in two centuries that a Tolliver recorded an instrument that cost nothing, as if it were waiting for proof that the hand had learned something. And tomorrow the sitting surety, the forward-passed signature-that-has-not-happened-yet, walks into the middle of the water’s own ledger carrying it.

The fourth column can be signed at the ford. That is what the counter has told me without being asked.

The blank line in the Compact, the *and who*, the line the ground has been holding open for two hundred and thirty-six years: the place it can be executed is the place the rest of it was executed. The instrument of execution is riding in my coat in oiled paper, and everybody in this county’s long story has been very carefully not telling me to do it.

Which is how I know it is a decision, and not a duty. Duties come with instructions.

“I’m not signing anything tomorrow,” I say, out loud, at the counter, where it will be weighed. “For the record. The toll is Jonah’s. The crossing is Jonah’s. I carry the book and I witness, and if there is a fourth column to be signed someday, it will be signed the way everything true has been done at this counter all winter: asked, not taken. The water has not asked me. An unasked signature is just a grab with a pen in it.”

The rule hums, low, the kind hum, and takes the statement at no charge, and I feel the cold specific comfort of having said a true thing in a room where false ones die.

“Unless it asks,” says Wren, not looking up from the composition book.

“Wren.”

“I’m just witnessing,” says Wren Elm, and writes, in her careful looping hand, a line I read upside down and leave uncorrected, because witnesses carry evidence and this is evidence: *She means it. But she brought the nib.*

*

Jonah comes at six to drive me home, which is a sentence I can now write without the pen slowing, and finds me at the counter wrapping the nibs. I have changed the packaging, and he watches me do it, because he watches my hands the way I watch his, it is the dialect we learned first.

Before I fold the handkerchief, Jonah picks up one half of the broken brass nib and holds it to the bulb, the break catching the light like a cut stone.

“Dad would have kept that,” he says. “In a cigar box. With a label.”

“What would the label say?”

“*Having-been-held. Tolliver. One.*” He sets it back in the cloth as carefully as a coin. “You don’t have to keep everything, Recorder.”

“This one I do,” I say.

The broken brass nib, both halves, goes back in the handkerchief, in the inside pocket, over the ribs, where family things ride. The pale nib I wrap alone, in fresh oiled paper from the drawer, and then in the square of red flannel Ruth uses for the good silver, and I put it in the outside pocket. The one with the button. The one a hand other than mine could reach.

“Separate pockets,” says Jonah.

“Separate instruments,” I say. “One’s an heirloom. One’s an offer. You don’t file an offer you haven’t accepted next to your own heart; that’s how people end up married to their mortgages.”

He almost smiles, the almost that is his whole smile. Then he reads my face the rest of the way, because he has fourteen years of back payments on reading it and he is caught up and current, and the almost goes out of him.

“Say it, Recorder.”

So I say it. Short and bare, because it is the truest thing I have, and the procedural voice is for fear, and what I feel standing at my counter with the water’s offer buttoned into my coat is not fear. It is the thing underneath fear, the thing fear is the paperwork for.

“Tomorrow the water asks you what you want, and you’ll answer, and that part I’m not afraid of, because I’ve heard your answer and it’s the best instrument I’ve ever reviewed.” My hand is flat on the oak. Steady. I make it stay steady. “But Dee says witnesses get asked things too. And the counter says the water keeps the questions. And if, at the middle of that river, the water sets a question in front of me, and offers me a pen—”

Two knuckles, on the oak, soft as a pulse.

“—then you say my whole name,” I tell him. “Marguerite Anne Tolliver. All of it, out loud, the way Tully’s collar works, the way you’d call a sleepwalker down off a roof. Not because the name will break anything.”

I breathe once, through my nose, the way I do before a figure I do not like. “Because I have spent my whole life answering to the record, and the record of me is you now too, and I want the reminder standing in the water where I can hear it. A surety is a signature that hasn’t happened yet. If my hand starts to happen tomorrow, you make sure it’s my hand.”

Jonah Ashcombe looks at me for a long moment, fire-kin steady, the only warmth in the county that costs me nothing.

“Whole name,” he says. “I can do that.” A beat. “You’d do it anyway, you know. The right thing. You don’t need me for it.”

“Noted,” I say. “I’m not asking because I need it. I’m asking because asking is how it gets entered.”

We bank the stove. We climb the stairs. Behind us in the dark the archive settles, drawer by drawer, holding its questions like the water holds its own, and in my two separate pockets, two spent-and-unspent pieces of metal ride home through the cold: the signature that happened, and the one that has not happened yet.

Dawn is at 7:41. The ford is at dawn.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!