Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 51

Disinterested Parties

Notice of Valuation, served at the oak at two minutes past eight on Thursday the twenty-second of January, received without fee, and the first thing Auditor Priya Nair does when she sets her tote on my counter is apologize to the furniture.

“I’m sorry about the stapler,” she says. She has been trying to staple Form 7-V, in triplicate, to the Notice itself, and the oak has declined, in the way it has of declining things, by letting the staple go in and then pushing it back out again, bright and unbent, onto the blotter. “I have been defeated by a counter four times now. I would like it noted that I am a patient woman.”

“Noted,” I say.

“Ms. Szabo has already noted it.”

“Seventh time, Auditor,” says Ms. Szabo, from her stool, without looking up from her machine. “I counted the stapler as a separate defeat.”

Nair takes her glasses off, both pairs, folds them into the tote, and reads me Section Seven the way you read a diagnosis to someone who has been brave about the symptoms. A Board of View of three disinterested persons of the county shall be constituted by the auditor. The Board shall walk each parcel in Schedule A. The Board shall state its value, and the statement shall bind the Commonwealth.

“Three,” I say.

“Three. Disinterested. The Manual defines the word.” She turns a page. “*Holding no claim, lien, debt or expectation against the property to be valued.* I’d hoped it was one of those words that means whatever the room agrees it means. It isn’t. It’s a definition.”

“And the viewing?”

“Thursday the nineteenth of February, at noon, beginning with parcel one, which is where we are standing.” She puts a finger on the oak. “Before I can state a figure I need the list. The counter told me it is the sum of what is owed on the ground, and a sum needs addends. The Manual calls it a Schedule of Encumbrances. Nobody in this building enjoys that word, so I’ve left the heading blank. I need it in writing by Thursday the twelfth.”

I look at the date. It is twenty-one days away. I have a number on my palm that counts itself down whether I work or not, and I have never in my life had a deadline that counts down by what I do. My first feeling, to my shame, is relief.

“The declarations,” says Nair, “I’ve set for half past four. A witness of the third class has attended every proceeding in this matter and I should not like to explain her absence to the transcript. School lets out at three-ten.”

“That’s kind.”

“It’s procedure,” says Nair, and puts her glasses back on, and does not meet my eye.

*

By half past four the archive has the look of a waiting room in a very old and very strange clinic. The candidates sit on the public bench in a row, as if for a photograph nobody has agreed to take.

Dee has her cane across her knees and her good ear turned to the room. Raymond sits beside her in the blue apron, because he came straight from the pit, with a dish towel still folded over one shoulder. Hal fills the end of the bench, hat in his lap.

Tully has put on the laminated card, LAY RECORDER: SECTION NINE FIELD USE, on a lanyard, over a clean shirt. Brandt sits a little apart, with his briefcase on his knees and both hands on the clasp.

Wren is on the second rung of the stool with her composition book. She came straight from school, with her backpack still on, and she is the only person here who looks entirely happy.

“Form 7-V, Part B,” says Nair. “*Declaration of Disinterest.* Each candidate will step to the rule and state: *the ground owes me nothing.* If the statement stands, I will accept it. If it does not, I will thank you and excuse you.” She hesitates. “I’m told the second case is not a reflection on your character.”

“It’s a reflection on the ground’s,” says Strake, from the corner, and writes down a number.

He has come in his good coat, the charcoal one, with his notebook open on his knee. I do not remember inviting him. I do not remember uninviting him. He catches my eye over the top of his glasses.

“I have been retained,” he says, “by Mr. Brandt, who is an examiner of the Bureau, who has been unable to say since the nineteenth whom he works for. I will bill the room. It’s what I do.”

Tully goes first, because he is nearest.

He steps to the rule. He puts one green hand on the oak and squares his shoulders, a twenty-four-year-old who has memorized a statement for the occasion, and opens his mouth, and what comes out is a small dry click, like a drawer sliding shut.

He tries again. The click again.

“Legally speaking,” says Tully, in a different voice, much more his own, “it owes me a stool. I was sworn to it in the dark, and the seat has never once been offered. I’m not saying I mind. I’m saying I’d be lying.” The rule gives a low, clear, rueful note. “That rang. I’m declining the declaration.”

“Entered,” says Nair. “Thank you, Mr. Brandt.”

“Tully, Auditor. The other one’s—”

“I know. I’m tired. Mr. Tully.”

Hal rises, which takes a moment, and sets his hat on the oak, and lays two enormous gray fingers on the brass. “The ground,” he says, and the rule stays silent. He tries it a second way.

“The ground owes me nothing, and I owe it a very great deal, and I have lived a long time in the space between those two sentences.” The rule hums, hollow, the note of a thing that is true and not the whole of it. “That is the best I can do.”

“I’ll enter it as *hollow,*” says Nair, carefully, as a woman handling a new word. “I will not be able to accept it.”

“I should think not,” says Hal, and signs the form in Wren’s pencil, *Halvard. Of the ridge. Himself.,* with all the loops, and hands it back with a small bow.

*

Dee does not stand. I carry the rule across the oak to the bench, and she lays her palm on it as if it were the head of an old dog.

“The ground owes me nothing.” The rule rings, plain and full. Dee’s face does not change. “It doesn’t. I paid every bit of what I paid to the Hedge. I don’t have a quarrel with a road.” She lifts her hand off the brass. “I’d like to add that I’ve been sitting here for ten minutes thinking about a certain night in nineteen ninety-eight, and it’s not the ground I owe it to. The ground’s the one that’s been keeping the book.”

“That ring was for the first sentence,” says Nair, slowly. “Only the first.”

“Yes, ma’am.”

“You’re excluded as the spouse of a retained person who is in turn assigned to the holder.” Nair writes. “It’s a very long sentence and I’m sorry for it. Mr. Fanning?”

Raymond does not need to be asked. He gets up, folds the towel over the back of the bench, and walks to the oak with the unhurried gait of a man who spent thirty-two years walking to counters he was told to stand behind. He lays his hand flat on the brass, a flat hand, certifying.

“The ground owes me nothing,” says Raymond.

The rule rings.

“It set me down on the ninth of January in a place with a stove and a kettle,” he says. “It has been generous. I’m not in its debt and it isn’t in mine.” A pause. “I’m assigned to the holder, though, so I’m disqualified. I don’t mind. I’ve never been on a board. I’d have felt I should wear the tie.”

“You are wearing the tie,” says Wren, from the stool.

“It’s Ruth’s,” says Raymond, and looks, briefly, startled, as though somebody had told him whose it was.

Nair writes it down. She does not look up. She says, “Thank you, Mr. Fanning,” in a voice I don’t think she knew she owned.

*

Brandt does not come to the rule. He stands, with his briefcase, and he looks at the oak, and then he sets the briefcase down on the stone, which he has never done in my archive, and says from where he is:

“I would like to withdraw the declaration.”

“You haven’t made it.”

“I have made it every day of my adult life,” says Brandt, mildly. “In a box on a form. *No claim, lien, debt or expectation.* I signed it every year of my career. I did not know until the nineteenth that it was a false statement.

“I did not know there was a place in the world where it would not go through.” His hand, the scarred one, closes and opens at his side. “I do not intend to find out in front of my own counsel.”

“It’s a courtesy,” says Strake, unexpectedly. “I’d waive the rest of the afternoon, Lowell.”

“Thank you, Colm.”

“Point-one.”

“I know.”

He sits. Nobody speaks for a moment. In the corner, Strake takes the glasses off and looks at them, and I think, for the length of the pause, that he has forgotten what he came in for.

He remembers.

“With the Auditor’s permission,” says Strake, rising, “I would like to be heard on whether my client is disinterested, and also on whether he is not. I have been instructed to argue both. Form 7-V is silent as to sequence.”

“Noted,” says Nair, wearily.

“May it please the Board. Mr. Brandt’s interest is in a name, not a parcel. A name is not an encumbrance. He should sit.” Strake pauses. “That was point-two. I would now like to say that the argument is nonsense.

“A man whose mother’s name is on parcel thirty-one is not disinterested in parcel thirty-one, and I would so argue if I were on the other side, and I find that I am. Point-two. I bill point-three to each. The difference is a loss I am taking on myself.”

“Is that a joke?” Tully whispers.

“I think it’s an apology,” I whisper back, “in tenths.”

*

Nair rises last. She does not need to be told to. She sets down the pen, takes off both pairs of glasses, and walks to the rule with her hand out like a woman about to take an oath. She has the face of someone who has just worked out the answer to a question she hoped would have a different one.

“The ground owes me nothing,” says Nair.

The rule rings, clean as a struck glass.

She looks at her hand on the brass. She does not smile, because she is a professional. But something is happening at the corner of her mouth.

“I’d like to note that it is a true statement,” she says, “and the only one of its kind made at this counter in forty minutes. I don’t expect to be able to make it for very long.” She looks at me. “It is a footnote.”

“*Not yet,*” I say.

“I didn’t say that.”

“It’s what the footnote says.”

“It is a prediction,” says Nair, “and I don’t make those.” She puts both pairs of glasses back on. “Section Seven provides that when a Board cannot be seated from persons of the county meeting the definition, the auditor shall act alone, as a Board of one, and her finding shall carry the force of the whole. I am entering that finding now. Ms. Szabo?”

“I have it,” says Ms. Szabo, with deep and quiet satisfaction.

“The Board is one person,” says Wren, in a hushed voice, to her composition book. She writes it down. “*Entry. The Board has one member. It’s the smallest board I’ve ever heard of. I was there.*”

“Ms. Elm,” says Nair. “The Bureau cannot make that finding.”

“I’m not the Bureau. I’m a witness.”

Nair opens her mouth, and shuts it, and puts her hand to the bridge of her nose.

“Noted,” she says.

I find that I am smiling. I have never watched a court dismiss a jury so gently.

On the third step of the stair lies a sixth sheet that is not a declaration: ivory stock, folded once, my name on the outside in a hand I have learned to recognize.

*The Hedge cannot declare disinterest. It has six tables on Schedule A. This one declines the form with regret, and asks to be reckoned as a party. O. R.*

A hedgehog sits beside it, waiting to be paid. Ruth has already sent down the gravy.

*

The Roll is born on Friday afternoon, in the back booth of the diner, under a swinging lamp, and it is born with a name because a twelve-year-old gives it one.

“It shouldn’t be called a Schedule of Encumbrances,” says Wren. She has commandeered the booth. She has a ruler, two pencils sharpened at both ends, a stack of my mother’s green guest checks, and the expression of a general with a map. “Nobody wants to be an encumbrance. And it isn’t a schedule. Schedules are for buses. It should be a roll. Like attendance, when you read out who’s here.”

“The Roll of the Owed,” says my mother, from the pass-through, and I can hear her tasting the words.

“That’s too long.”

“It’s the right length,” says Ruth Tolliver. “It tells you what it’s for.”

Wren thinks about this, with her whole face. Then she writes ROLL OF THE OWED at the top of a green slip in letters of equal height, and underlines it with the ruler, and that is that.

She has designed the slip. It is the guest check with the printed columns ruled out and new headings over them in her square script: NAME. OWED (WHAT). WHEN. And at the bottom, boxed off, a line that is on no form I have ever seen.

*RECEIVED:* and a blank.

“What goes there?” I ask.

“What was received.” She turns a page of the river transcript, which Nair has let her copy, to a page with a strip of tape on it. “It’s the water’s receipt. Page fourteen. *Received, at the ford, for crossing: one answer, true.* It says what it got. It doesn’t just say *received.*” She taps the line. “A receipt that doesn’t say what it’s for isn’t a receipt. It’s a stamp and a wish.”

“That’s a good rule,” says Dee, from the end of the booth. She is peeling a potato, because my mother has handed her one, and she is doing it with a tenderness that suggests she has never peeled anything in her life.

“It’s evidence,” says Wren.

On the back of each slip there is a second box, smaller. THING LOST.

“Why?”

“Because if you’re going to pay somebody back,” says Wren, “you have to know what they lost. I don’t think it’s ever the money.”

*

They come to the booth one at a time. Nobody is asked. That is a rule we have made, my mother and I, in the kitchen, without ever saying it aloud.

Ruth does the first.

She comes out from behind the pass-through with the order pad in her apron and the stub of a pencil, and she sits down across from Wren, and for a long time she does not write. Then she writes, in the clean slanting hand she uses for *two eggs over easy,* FRANK TOLLIVER.

*Owed:* she writes. She stops. *Supper. October 17.* She turns the slip over and looks at the box on the back, and her pencil hovers there, and she says, to nobody, “They gave me his helmet. And a boot. And his ring, in a paper envelope.” She writes. “He kept his pencil behind his left ear. The flat one. He’d have gone back for it if he dropped it. It was never in the envelope.”

*Thing lost,* the slip says. *His carpenter’s pencil. Flat. Behind the left ear. Not found.*

She hands it to Wren. Wren takes it in both hands, as if it might spill. She writes a number, *1,* in the top corner, in red pencil.

The second slip is Wren’s own, and she writes it fast, in the booth, with her chin down and her tongue just showing, so nobody will see her face. *WREN ELM. Owed: a day. (Birth, pending.) Thing lost: the W I rubbed out.* She puts it under Ruth’s. She does not look at anyone. My mother passes her a glass of milk across the table, and says nothing, and Wren drinks the whole thing.

Dee does the third, and it takes her twelve minutes. FANNING, D. and R. *Owed: thirty-two Aprils.* On the back she writes a single word, *Tuesday,* and when Raymond reads it over her shoulder, he says only, “That’s the right word.”

I do the fourth. I write HORSE.

“You can’t,” says Wren.

“Frank’s leaf says he’s bringing one.”

“That’s an expectation. It isn’t a debt.” She takes it from me and holds it a moment. Then, with a sigh, she writes along the margin: *Pending. Not yet received. I’m putting it in the pending pile because I think it might be.* “I was there,” she mutters, and tucks it in her book.

The fifth is the one Jonah will not write.

He comes in at four-thirty from the lumber yard with sawdust on his shoulders and reads the slip I’ve started, D. ASHCOMBE, in the plain pencil I have used for the heading. He does not take it. He does not push it away. He sets his two knuckles on the Formica, a little to the left of it, and leaves them there.

“She’d want to write her own,” he says.

“I’ll leave it blank.”

“Leave it blank.” He doesn’t rap. He lifts the hand, and it is steady, and he goes to find the pie. I put the slip, unwritten, on the pile. *Owed: (she will say.)* It sits under the others like a stone in a coat pocket.

*

The sixth comes at ten past six.

The bell goes, and Brandt stands in the diner doorway in his gray overcoat, which he wears indoors the way other men wear a decision, with a manila envelope under one arm and the face of a man who has walked past a building three times to get here.

My mother says, “Sit,” and points at the booth. He sits, and she puts a cup of coffee at his hand without being asked, and that is the whole of it.

He takes the slip. He reads the box at the bottom, the one that says *RECEIVED.* He reads the one on the back.

“I’d have liked to write this in a more suitable place,” he says.

“It’s the diner,” says Wren. “It’s the most suitable place there is. People tell the truth in a booth.”

He nods, as though this were a legal principle. He takes a fountain pen from his breast pocket, a good steel-nibbed one that has signed sixty thousand forms, and he writes in his careful hand ELEANOR BRANDT. *Owed:* A long pause. *March 1976. Venango.* He turns it over.

*Thing lost.* The nib hovers, and the ink gathers, and I see him decide.

*A blue cardigan, wool, three buttons. The one in the photograph. It was not in her effects. I asked the school three times and the hospital once. They said she must have left it on the bus.*

He caps the pen.

“I was nine,” he says. “I thought it was a very ordinary thing to mind. I was ashamed of minding it. I have been looking for a cardigan for fifty years, Ms. Tolliver, and I have been too embarrassed to tell a single living soul.” He slides the slip across. “Please put it on the pile, before I lose my nerve.”

“Six,” says Wren, in a very small voice, and writes it in red.

I put my hand flat on the stack. It is nothing. It is six guest checks and a rubber band. It is not a legal instrument, and nobody has taken an oath on it, and it has no seal.

It is warm.

*

At half past eleven I go to the archive alone, with the Roll in a manila folder under my arm, and I lay it on the oak, and I put my hand on the rule.

I have been told, by a clerk who was told by a clerk who was told by a dragon, that I should never ask the counter a question I do not need answered. I have a question I need answered. It is a very narrow one, and I have made it narrow on purpose, in the dark of the stairwell, with the care of a woman threading a needle with the lights off.

“Whom does the ground owe,” I say, “in the order received?”

The bulb overhead holds steady. Volume Z breathes in its drawer. Nothing happens for a long time, long enough for me to count the bricks on the north wall, long enough for the cold of the Hedge’s hour to start up my spine from the base, the way it does, a hand at the small of the back.

I wait for the price.

It does not come. That is the thing I note, with my hand flat on brass, and I note it very carefully, because I have learned what it means when the counter does not ask for anything. A free answer is bookkeeping. It is a thing that arrives already paid. It is a sum that has been settled by somebody else, at some earlier date, in some currency I was not told, and the counter is only reading it off the receipt.

The rule hums. A note comes up from the groove, not the plain full ring, but something lower, something like the lowest string of a very old instrument, and under the hum I hear the clock-reading voice, small and clear and perfectly, almost kindly, certain.

*JOSIAH TOLLIVER. SEVENTEEN HUNDRED AND NINETY. UNCLAIMED.*

I do not move.

I know the name. I know it as I know my own hand. It is at the head of the column on the surety shelf, in a flourish that is the first T in the family, and a split-quill nib that I have seen brass-cold in my pocket every night since October. A man who stood at a river in the autumn of seventeen ninety and answered a question and paid his toll. A man whose answer the water kept.

Not a debt *he* owed. I am sure of that. I have read the page. A debt owed *to* him, standing open for two hundred and thirty-six years, at the bottom of the oldest ledger in the county, with nobody’s name on the claim line.

I told the river I was paid. I stood on the bank in the sleet, with my whole family’s account folded small in my hands, and I said, *Nothing I haven’t been paid,* and the river wrote it down and did not argue. It did not argue because it was true. It was true of me.

It was never true of the name.

I take a green slip from my pocket, and a pencil, and I write it in my own plain hand, in the family hand, the clerk’s hand, with the round letters I learned at nine at a counter: JOSIAH TOLLIVER. *Owed:* and a blank. *1790.* On the back, under THING LOST, I leave it empty. I have no idea what a man lost at a river that the river would still be holding.

I tuck it at the bottom of the stack, beneath the other six.

It is the oldest name on the Roll. It has been the oldest name on the Roll for two hundred and thirty-six years. I am the first person to have written it down, and I am standing at my own family’s counter at midnight, in the cold, with a pencil, and the nearest living person who could be said to have been billed for it is me.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!