Raymond has borrowed the straw from a man he will not name, and he says it is the best straw in the county.
It is stacked in the lean-to behind the diner, in a bed a foot deep, with a galvanized pail of water at one end and a plastic milk crate turned over to make a manger, and in the middle of it, at twenty to seven on Wednesday morning, a small roan animal with a white blaze lies folded up like a coat somebody has dropped.
It has not slept. I can tell, because its eyes are open and brown and fixed on the back door of the diner, and every time the door moves, its ears do.
“It’s not eaten,” says Wren. She is standing in her boots with the composition book under her arm. “I offered it an apple, and a carrot, and half a ham sandwich, because Hal said that’s what *he* eats. It looked at all three like they were a forwarding address.”
I look at the foal, and the foal looks at me, and for a moment I have the feeling that I am being weighed against something I cannot see, and that I have not come in under. Then it lowers its head onto its knees. Raymond, in the doorway with his apron on, lets out a breath.
“The man who gave me the straw wanted to know what it was for,” he says. “I said a Nativity. He said it’s February. I said we’re early.”
*
The Borough of Ketterly, it turns out, has a code.
Tully brings it in at nine, in a three-ring binder with colored tabs, and lays it open on the counter between the napkin holder and the pie case with the air of a man who has been up all night and is delighted.
“Section six, one fourteen,” he says. “Livestock in a commercial district. A person may not keep a horse, mule, cow, goat, sheep, or swine on premises zoned C-2 without a permit, *unless*—and this is the good part—the animal is, one, in transit to a fair; two, part of a bona fide religious display; or three, a ward of the court.”
“Which is it?” says Ruth, from the grill.
“Legally speaking, none of them.” He lifts a finger. “But I’ve drafted an application for a working-animal exemption on behalf of the witness. Under the heading *Assistance Animal, Other.*”
“Assisting whom?”
“Wren.” He looks at her kindly. “Is that all right?”
Wren considers it. “It’s not wrong,” she says.
“Out back,” says Ruth. “In the lean-to.”
Tully goes to look. He stands at the lean-to door with the binder against his chest, and the foal rises in the straw and turns its blazed face toward him, and he looks at it for a long moment, and for once has nothing legal to say.
*
Ms. Szabo comes at eleven with a book.
She has not been asked. She comes in the front door in her good gray coat, with the stenotype machine left behind for once, and lays on the counter a thick green volume with a cracked spine: *A Field Guide to Domestic Livestock of the Commonwealth,* state extension service, 1961.
“I thought it might be useful,” she says. “For the record.”
“For which record?”
“For whatever the Review files.” She has gone pink. “I’ve been a reporter thirty-one years, Miss Tolliver. I take down what is said. I don’t often get to take a side. I find I have a feeling about being asked to type *stray.*”
She opens the book at a tab of yellow paper and shows us a plate, a plain black-and-white drawing of a horse. In the margin someone has written in a tiny hand: *Roan. Blaze. Sock. See also “stray, how to tell from.”* She has been in the courthouse library since five this morning, I realize, with a flashlight.
*
At eleven-thirty I carry the coat down.
It has hung on my bedroom door since December, a canvas barn coat the color of a dry leaf, with a corduroy collar and the fourth button gone and the fifth hanging by a thread, and for six weeks it has been smelling a little more of smoke each morning. This morning it smells like a house on fire.
I have it over my arm and I have to hold my face away. I lay it on the end stool of the counter, where nobody sits, and Ruth looks at it, and does not touch it.
“Raymond,” she says.
He has put down the dish towel. He has been the one to say it, I think, and he does not look pleased about it. He is thin and gray and careful in his shirtsleeves, with his flat hand held a little out from his side like a man carrying a tray.
“I’ve only the one clue,” he says. “I said a thing in the pit on Monday about what a door weighs, with no more notion than the dishwater what it meant.
“Then last night at one in the morning I thought: *there was nobody at the door.* At the spring, every one of you had a hand on somebody. Jonah on the stone, Ruth on the horse, the girl on the page. Nobody was holding the way out.” His mild voice is steady. “A thing like that doesn’t stay open on its own. I’ve kept doors thirty-two years, Miss Tolliver. It wants a hand on the frame, on the near side.”
“It’ll be cold,” says Wren.
“I expect so.”
“You don’t have to.”
“It’s my clue,” says Raymond. He folds the towel and sets it over the pass-through. “A man who has an idea ought to be the first to lean on it.”
*
At eleven fifty-eight the lunch rush is in full voice. Jonah is at the grill, Hal is at the pass-through in an apron, with his hat on a hook, plating pie with great dignity, and there are fourteen people in the booths and Mr. Dolan at the counter with his coffee, and every one of them is going to see nothing.
I know it the way I know where the stairs are in the dark. At the line of the minute they will look at their plates. It will not be a spell. It will be the polite blankness of people in an elevator, and the feeling afterward that it was a minute ago.
Ruth has trimmed the wick, a quarter inch longer than yesterday, and lit it with a kitchen match, and set the lantern in the front window, on the sill of the Water Street strip, which is parcel 2 and was never in any grant. Raymond stands at the front door. He has propped it open on its old brass closer and put his left hand flat on the frame, on the inside, with his feet apart. Tully has set the rule on the counter.
*11:59.*
The sound goes out of the room. It does not stop. It sinks, like a plate going under in a sink, and the people in the booths go on eating, slowly, with their eyes on their food. A girl with a stroller outside the glass has lifted one foot and held it, and a pigeon on the curb is a gray stone.
The lamp leans. In the open doorway, where there is daylight, the daylight has gone dark, not black but a deep still brown, the color of a held breath.
Raymond’s hand goes white on the frame.
A boot comes out of the brown.
He comes in as a man comes in from a job, with his shoulders a little forward, and wipes his feet. Then he sees the room. I watch him see it: the long chrome counter, the pie case, the stools, the pass-through with a dragon in it. The corner of his mouth goes up.
“It’s the same,” says Frank. “I’d have thought she’d have moved the napkins.”
“I tried,” says Ruth, from the end of the counter. “You’d have noticed.”
He comes down the room. Nobody turns. He puts a hand on the back of Mr. Dolan’s stool going by, and Mr. Dolan, who has known him forty years, lifts his cup and sets it down again without a flicker. Frank looks after him with an odd, tender expression.
“He still takes it black,” he says.
“Wednesdays he takes it with a doughnut,” says Ruth.
“Does he.” Frank turns. He sees the stool at the end, and the coat laid across it, and he stops.
He looks at it for a long moment, as at a thing a man has left in a room and been told is still there. Then he takes it by the collar, shakes it once to settle the shoulders, and puts it on.
It fits. Of course it fits. The smell of smoke, which has been choking me for an hour, goes quiet. It does not vanish. It goes down, like a fire banked for the night. The smoke has been a cry in that coat for six weeks, and now it has found where it belonged.
“Hold still,” says Ruth.
She has a needle in her apron, with a length of black thread, and I did not see her take it out. She steps up to him in front of fourteen people who cannot see her do it, takes the loose fifth button between finger and thumb, and puts the needle through it, twice, and bites the thread. It takes eleven seconds. It is the quietest, most ferocious thing I have ever seen.
“That’s the one gone,” says Ruth, “since you weren’t about. I’ll find the other.”
“Take your time.”
“I’ve had it,” says Ruth.
*
He sits on the end stool.
He sits as a man sits at his own counter, with his back to the wall and one boot on the rail, and Ruth, without a word, takes down a thick white mug with a glued handle, and a pot, and fills it. She sets it on the counter in front of him. It is the cup from the empty place, from the night of the potatoes. The coffee steams.
He does not pick it up. I understand, watching his hand, that he cannot. It lies beside the mug, square, scarred, resting, and he looks at the steam rise with an expression of such plain, sorrowful appetite that I have to look away.
“I can’t,” he says.
“I know.” Ruth turns the mug a quarter turn, so the handle sits where he likes it. “I thought you’d like it in front of you.”
“Ruthie.”
“Don’t.”
He is quiet. Then he lays two fingers against the side of the mug, lightly, a man testing a pot. His face changes. “It’s warm,” he says, in a voice of mild astonishment.
“It’s coffee. It’s meant to be.”
“No, I mean it’s warm. I can tell it’s warm.” He lifts the fingers, and puts them back. “It’s been a while since I could tell that.”
I ask him, because it is my job to ask, what he needs to come: what the rule is. Tully lays the brass bar by the napkin holder. Frank looks at it with his head tilted, and at the lamp in the window leaning toward him, and at Raymond, at the door, with his hand white on the frame.
“A lit lamp on ground,” he says. “And a hand on the frame. On your side.” The rule rings, soft and whole. “That’s what I know. I can’t tell you why. I can tell you it’s cold if it’s let go.”
“We’ll not let it go,” says Raymond, through his teeth.
“I know you won’t, sir. I’m sorry for the cold.”
“It’s my clue,” says Raymond.
It is Jonah I am watching, as the lamp begins to rise. He has come out from behind the grill, his apron in his hand. He stands at the far end of the counter, and Frank looks at him, and I know that something is going to be said that is not for the rest of us.
“I can see where it’s cold,” says Frank simply. “In the minute. It’s like standing in a long hall with a lot of doors, and I can tell which of them has a draft. Your mother’s not in it.”
Jonah has gone quite still.
“She’s not on the ground. She’s in an hour, I think. I can’t tell you which. I can’t see her. I can see where it’s cold.” He turns his hand over on the counter. “I thought you ought to have that, and not have to wait for a book.”
“An hour,” says Jonah.
“That’s all I’ve got.”
“It’s more than I had.” He swallows. “Thank you.”
The flame stands up.
*
It is two minutes. They are always two minutes, and I do not know why I thought, last night, that they would be longer today.
Frank gets up. He puts a hand on the coat’s collar. He bends over Ruth, who is standing quite straight with the pot in her fist, and says something I do not hear, and she says “Go on,” in the closing voice, and he goes, backward, up the room, with his eyes on her, to the door.
He stops beside Raymond in passing and puts a hand on the shoulder that is not holding the frame, and says, “Thank you, Ray,” and Raymond, whose lips are blue, nods.
He steps into the brown. The brown thins into daylight.
The sound comes back all at once. A fork clinks. The girl with the stroller puts her foot down, and the pigeon leaves the curb. Mr. Dolan turns on his stool, and looks around the room with a faint puzzled smile.
“Is it noon?” he says. “Funny. I thought it was a minute ago.”
On the counter the white mug sits full, and steaming, and when Ruth lifts it, with both hands, to carry it into the kitchen, she stops. She holds it a moment. Then she turns, very quietly, and sets it by the napkin holder where he was.
“Still warm,” she says, to nobody.
Raymond has let go of the frame. He stands there with his hand held out in front of him, white to the wrist, and shaking, and a long slow rime of frost across the knuckles, and Hal, from the pass-through, wordlessly, hands him a towel full of hot water from the kettle.
“Flat,” says Raymond, after a moment. “I’d say an hour. I can feel it going.” He sits down on a milk crate. He looks, I think, extremely pleased. “It was a good clue.”
*
At seven Ruth trims the wick.
She does it with the dedicated scissors, a quarter inch longer than at noon, standing at the sill in her apron, and the flame stands taller by the width of a thread. Nobody speaks. When she is done she wipes the glass with the hem of her apron, and says, “That’s right, then,” and goes to do the dishes.
Midnight is mine.
I do not volunteer. It is simply that Raymond has been flat since two, and Jonah is on the grill, and Hal cannot, because a dragon’s hand on a doorframe makes the frame nervous, and Dee, in her chair with her blanket, says she would be glad to if she could stand for a minute and a half, which she cannot.
So it is I who prop the door at eleven fifty, in my good navy coat, and set my left hand flat against the cold paint of the frame.
It is not cold yet. It is only a door.
The lamp is lit. Ruth sits at the end of the counter with her hands in her lap. The room is quiet. The horse has come in through the kitchen on its own and stands at the end of the counter with its blazed face lifted and its hooves quiet on the linoleum, as if it had been invited.
*11:59.*
It comes in through my hand.
I had not known that. I had thought it would come in at the eyes. It comes up from the doorframe through the heel of my palm into the wrist, a deep slow cold that is not like the Hedge’s. The Hedge’s is a knife. This is a weight, a long pressing cold, the cold of a very large door in a very old house, and it leans on me, and I lean back.
I understand Raymond. I would not have said I could.
The brown comes into the doorway.
He is in the coat. He has the pencil behind his ear and the buttons done. He comes in as he did at noon, and stops on the mat, and he looks at me, with one hand on the frame beside mine, an inch from it, not touching, and I see the squint go anxious.
“You’re cold.”
“It’s the hour,” I say. “It’s the other cold. It’s already midnight.”
“I’m sorry.”
“I’m told it’s my clue.”
“It’s Raymond’s.” He nods at the room. “Is that so?”
I do not answer. I am watching Ruth. She has got up, and is standing at the end of the counter with her hands folded, as straight as a woman in church, and she says, with no preface, the thing she has been carrying all day.
“The gutters want doing. The front. There’s a pine come down on the north side, and the booth by the window has the split in the seat, and I never fixed it, because it was yours.”
“It’s not mine.”
“It’s the one you sat in.”
“Then it’ll want a proper repair,” says Frank. He sits on the end stool. He does it slowly, with an air of settling in. “Not a patch. I’ll tell Jonah how. He’ll want to see the frame.”
“He’s got hands,” says Ruth.
“I know he does.”
“And the roof.”
“The roof’s got another winter in it. Not two.”
It goes on like that. A gutter. A hinge. A tax bill that came in the fall and the name of a man at the county.
They say it at either end of a counter, not looking at one another, and I stand with my hand frozen to a doorframe and my breath going out in a cloud and let it wash over me like the dishwasher in the next room. It is the sound of a house that has been waiting twenty-eight years to be talked to.
I do not speak about readiness. Neither does he. He looks at me once, at the end, as the lamp starts to climb, and it is the most careful look I have ever been given, like a man laying a plank across a ditch for somebody who has not yet said she is going to cross.
*
He goes at 12:01.
The brown thins. The sound comes back. The lamp stands up. I take my hand off the frame, or I try to, and find that it has stayed where it was, white, with the skin of the palm gone smooth and hard as a plate, and I have to peel it off with the other. Wren is at my elbow with the towel before I have thought of it.
“Flat,” I say. “An hour. It’s the Hedge hour anyway. I’m only doubling up.”
Wren says nothing, and wraps my fingers.
A car has stopped at the curb. It is a long, mustard-yellow shape with its parking lights on, and standing on the sidewalk beside it, in her camel coat, with her gloves folded in front of her and her face turned to the lit window, is Odile Rook. She does not come to the sill. She has her left foot a hand’s breadth from it, and her right, I notice, very exactly behind.
Then, through the glass, as if she had been rehearsing it, she says: “This one has not seen a lamp keep a man before. *I* find it is very orderly.”
“Twenty-six,” whispers Wren.
“Twenty-four,” I say.
“That’s evidence, and you’re wrong.”
Behind Odile, at the edge of the light, a small gray man stands with his left cuff turned to the street. JAN. 27. Odile gets back into the car and the lights go out. I think she has been waiting for someone to ask her in. I think nobody has told her the rules.
*
There is another figure on the pavement.
He has been there, I realize, since before the minute began, in a gray topcoat with the collar up, a little way beyond the glow of the window, not looking at the lamp, which is a courtesy, and not looking away from it, which is a duty. When the sound comes back he walks up to the door, and stops one step short of the sill, and does not cross it.
“Miss Tolliver.”
“Mr. Kerr.”
“I’ve been told,” says Aldous Kerr, “that service must be made not less than twelve hours before a hearing.” He consults a watch. “It is one minute past midnight. The hearing is noticed for noon. I’ve eleven hours and fifty-eight minutes, and I’m instructed to make use of them.” He takes from the inside of his topcoat an envelope, long, buff, with a state seal, and holds it out across the threshold at the end of his arm.
I take it. My hand is cold, and I fumble it, and he does not help, because he cannot cross the sill.
“What is it?”
“An Application of the Secretary for Custody of a Stray.” He says it in a clear flat voice, like a boy reading aloud in class. “One foal, roan, white blaze, white sock, left hind, unmarked. Found at large on parcel one hundred and nine, in the Commonwealth’s taking, on the seventeenth. To be placed in the Commonwealth’s care. The matter will be heard at the Viewing.”
He stops. I wait. He stands at the edge of the sill in the cold, the lamp throwing the small shadow of his hat across the pavement, and for a moment I think he has finished. Then he looks at the envelope, and not at me, and says, in a lower voice, off the form:
“Miss Tolliver. I didn’t write the box for *owner.*”
“What box?”
“Page two.” He swallows. “It’s on the prescribed form. There isn’t one. There is a space for *finder* and a space for *location* and a space for *description.* It’s a stray. It doesn’t have an owner, that’s what makes it a stray. Someone added it.” He lifts his chin. “I should like it noted that I don’t know who.”
“I’ll put it in the book,” I say.
He nods. He turns, a tall, thin, unhappy man in a gray coat, and walks away down Water Street with his hands back in his pockets, and I stand in the doorway of the diner at ten past midnight with my right hand dead and the envelope in my left.
I open it under the lamp. Page two. The form is the usual gray, with the usual crest, and the box is there at the bottom in a different typeface, a little too dark, a little crooked, as if it had been put in on another machine by somebody in a hurry.
*OWNER (if claimed, or if disclaimed): ________________*
It is the only blank on the page. I stand there in the cold with the lamp at my back and read it three times. If anyone says *mine,* it is property, and the Commonwealth is taking all the property on the ground. If no one does, it is a stray, and the Commonwealth takes it anyway.
It is waiting for a name. I cannot think of one that is not a trap.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!