Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 63

The Viewing

The Viewing opens at noon on parcel 1, which is the floor of the courthouse lobby, and by twenty-five past eleven Ms. Szabo has been told by three separate county employees that she may not set up a stenotype machine on a floor.

“It’s a floor of the Commonwealth,” she says, to the third, a facilities man named Dwight with a ring of keys. “It has been taken. I have a Declaration. I’d be glad to read it to you.”

She reads it to him. By eleven-thirty the lobby of the Tamarack County Courthouse has become, with no particular ceremony, a hearing room. Nair sits on her camp stool before the information desk, in her state parka, with both pairs of glasses on and her tote at her feet and the stapler from the oak in plain view, like a trophy. Ms. Szabo has the machine on its folding stand beside the wet-floor sign.

Tully has the rule on a folded dish towel on the floor tile, at the center of the room, and is sitting beside it with the air of a man guarding a very small, very important dog.

The lobby clock above the stairs says twenty to four, as it has since before I was born.

I stand at the left, with my hands in my coat pockets and a pen I cannot use and a pale nib I must not lose. I am a party. I have been told what that means. It means I may speak when I am asked, and say nothing I would not like to see typed.

“I’d like to say,” says Nair, to the room, “that this is not a court.”

Nobody had said it was.

“It’s a Board of View, convened under the Eminent Domain Code to ascertain just compensation for a taking. I may receive any evidence I find helpful and decline the rest. I do not sit as a judge of animals.” She looks over both pairs of glasses at the front doors. “I mention it, because I understand there is an animal.”

There is. It stands at Ruth’s left side, on the black-and-white tile, with its blazed face lifted, and it came up the courthouse steps at twelve minutes past eleven with Ruth’s hand on its withers and has not looked at anything in the room but the stopped clock. Beside it, on a bench by the door, Wren sits with her composition book open on her knee and the pencil on its tape, and an expression of terrible solemnity.

*

Mr. Sproule comes in at a quarter to twelve.

He is the Commonwealth’s senior examiner, and he is nothing like what I expected. I expected a gray man. He is pink. He is a round, careful, silver-haired man of sixty or so in a three-piece suit with a gray cardigan under the jacket, as if he feels the cold of institutions, and he carries a leather briefcase in one hand and in the other, open on his palm, a pocket watch, which he consults every time he finishes a sentence.

Behind him comes Aldous Kerr, with a second briefcase and the look of a man carrying someone else’s lunch.

“Ambrose Sproule,” says the pink man, with a little bow to Nair. “Asset Review. I’m obliged for the opportunity.” He looks around the lobby with a mild, fond, proprietary interest, the way a man looks at a house he used to rent. “I haven’t stood on this floor in thirty years.”

“Thirty,” says Nair.

“A joke. A very small one. It’s the same floor.” He consults the watch. “Madam Auditor, the Commonwealth has filed an Application for Custody of a Stray. I’ll be brief.”

He is. He is the most reasonable man I have ever watched take something. He reads the Act of June 14, 1893, section four, to the room in a pleasant light baritone: *An animal found at large upon land held by the Commonwealth, the owner being unknown or disclaiming, shall after notice be the property of the Commonwealth, to be cared for or disposed of as the Secretary may direct.*

He reads the Declaration. He reads that parcel 109 was taken on the twentieth of January. He reads the foal’s description, with its blaze and its sock.

“That is the whole of it,” he says. “It is, if I may, a kindness. A young animal in cold weather, on taken ground, with no one to answer for it.” He looks at the foal with what I believe is real concern. “The Commonwealth has the means to answer.”

“Mr. Strake,” says Nair.

Strake rises. He has been sitting on the end of the bench, in his charcoal coat, with a legal pad on his knee, and as he stands he says, quietly, to nobody, “Point one for rising,” and writes it down.

“Auditor. I object to the box.”

“Which box?”

“The one on page two of the Application, marked *owner, if claimed or disclaimed.* It does not appear on the Secretary’s prescribed form.” He holds up a copy. “It has been added, on a different machine, by a person the Commonwealth’s own examiner declines to name.”

Sproule consults the watch. “The box was added by direction of the Secretary’s counsel as a courtesy to claimants, so that anyone with an interest might state it.”

“A courtesy,” says Strake. “Point two. If a person says *mine,* the animal is chattel on taken ground and the Commonwealth takes it with the ground. If no one says it, the animal is unclaimed and the Commonwealth takes it as a stray.

“A box that has the same answer whichever way it is filled.” He lowers the paper. “My clients are not required to put a name in it. I have advised them to leave it as it is. I bill that at two tenths.”

“Noted,” says Ms. Szabo.

*

“Then I’ll ask it plainly,” says Sproule.

He has turned, in a pleasant, unhurried way, to the room. His round face is kind. He holds the watch in one palm, face up, as if he were asking it for a ruling.

“Does any person here claim to own this animal?”

It is very quiet. In the wet-floor sign’s yellow shadow, nobody moves. I feel it before I understand it, the whole of the lobby turning, one head at a time, as a field of sunflowers turns, toward the man who is standing a little behind Ruth’s shoulder in his work jacket with his hands at his sides.

I do not look at him. I have told him that I will ask. I look at Strake, and Strake has gone white, and has started, with great speed, to write *advise not to answer,* and I think, *he is too late.*

“Nobody,” says Jonah.

He says it in the voice from the ford. He has not stepped forward.

“It was carried as mine, for twenty-eight years,” he says. “On my word. I said it, and the book wrote it down. I’ve said otherwise.” His left hand opens at his side, and closes. “Nobody owns it. I tried.”

“I see,” says Sproule gently. “Then it is unowned.”

“It’s *attending,*” says Wren.

She has stood up on the bench. It is not at all what a witness, third class, is supposed to do, and nobody stops her. She is a thin girl in a brown corduroy jacket with leaves in her hair, who has been told that she has to be exact, and she holds the composition book out in front of her like a hymnal.

“Auditor. May I enter?”

“The witness may enter,” says Nair, with the face of a woman who has been ambushed by her own good sense.

“I wrote it from the front door.” Wren clears her throat. “At eleven-twelve the animal came up the steps at Mrs. Tolliver’s left side. It didn’t stop at the grass. It didn’t stop at the bench, or at the man with the keys, or at the pigeon on the rail, which it looked at for about a second and let go. It didn’t eat. It didn’t go to the door that was open. It went where Mrs. Tolliver went.” She takes a breath.

“I wrote six things it didn’t do. A stray doesn’t do *six things it didn’t do.* A stray goes wherever it likes.”

“That’s a remarkable definition,” says Sproule, with real interest.

“It’s the Field Guide,” says Wren. “Ms. Szabo found it. It’s under *stray, how to tell from.*”

*

Wren looks at the foal. She looks, for a longer time, at Sproule. “The Act says *at large,*” she says. “Mr. Sproule, would you agree that an animal at large is one that goes where it pleases?”

“I would.”

“And that an animal that doesn’t is, by the plain meaning, not at large.”

“Within reason.” He consults the watch. “The animal is on a leash of Mrs. Tolliver’s affection, Madam. I should not call that a legal restraint.”

“It has no leash,” says Nair. “I have been looking at it for twenty minutes.”

Nair takes off both pairs of glasses and folds them in her lap.

“I propose a test,” she says. “I’m told by Miss Elm and by the Recorder’s own instrument that this animal is a witness of the ground. I am not in a position to say what that is. I can say what an animal at large does. It goes where it likes. Mrs. Tolliver, will you take your hand away?”

Ruth lifts her hand.

For a moment the foal does nothing at all. It stands on the black tile with its blazed face lifted to the stopped clock. Then it takes one step, and another, not toward the door, not toward Ruth, not toward the heat of the radiator, which is on, and where a stray would have gone.

It goes out across the middle of the lobby floor, at a slow, even, unhesitating walk, past the rule on its dish towel, past the end of Tully’s boots, and Tully draws them in, and I understand that it is not walking in a line at all. It is following one.

“Chalk,” says Wren.

Tully has it. He has had it in his pocket since eleven. He drops to one knee behind the foal and draws, on the tile, where the small hooves have come down, a dotted line, a dash for every hoofprint that is not a print, and Brandt, at the other side of the room, has opened his briefcase and taken out a roll of paper, and spread it on the information desk, and stands with a finger on a mark.

“Nineteen eleven,” says Brandt. He does not raise his voice. “The Bureau’s resurvey slide. The plat puts the line between parcel one and parcel two along the north wall of the lobby, three feet in from the baseboard. That’s what I was taught. That’s what’s on every sheet in the Annex.” He looks up. “It’s not where it’s walking.”

The foal has crossed the middle of the floor. It passes under the stopped clock, through the shaft of dusty light from the transom, and I watch the hoofprints go down on the tile, one, two, three, four, in a line as straight as a plumb.

It reaches the front doors. Raymond, who is at the frame with his hand ready for noon, steps aside, and the doors stand open on the cold, and the foal goes out, down the courthouse steps, across the walk, over the curb. At the edge of Water Street, where a small brass disc is set in the cement, it stops, and stands with its forefeet on it, as a very old dog stands on a grave.

“Measure it,” says Nair.

*

Brandt and Tully run the tape from the plat’s north wall, across the lobby floor and out the doors to the curb, and Ms. Szabo types the figures from her folding stand.

“Twenty-four feet, nine inches,” says Brandt, from the curb, in a flat voice. “From the plat line to the walked one. It’s a rod and a half.”

“The 1911 slide,” says Nair.

“The slide moved it a rod and a half. It never moved anything else.” He stands up, with the tape in his fist. “That’s not a guess, Auditor. That’s the one number in the whole of the Bureau’s history nobody has ever reconciled. And it walked straight to it, from a standing start, without a map.”

“I find,” says Nair, slowly, “that I need a category.”

*

She does not have one. I watch her turn the tabs of the Manual, *Person, Party, Witness, Animal, stray,* and put her finger on each, and take it off.

“I’m going to write,” says Nair, “*unclassified; attending.*”

“I’d like it noted that the Commonwealth objects,” says Sproule.

Ms. Szabo types it, and does not look up.

“It will go in the margin, Mr. Sproule. In pencil. If the Board of View ever requires a witness of the ground to be a thing, it will say so, and I will erase it.” She does not look up. “It is not a stray. It is not at large. It is attending a recorded instrument, which I’m told is the Deed of Standing, filed on the sixth of February at one minute past midnight.

“I’ll hear it as a witness. It will have a place on the floor at my hearings, and nobody will charge it with anything.”

“The Commonwealth will ask for a further statement,” says Sproule, “from a person with direct knowledge of the animal’s—”

*11:59.*

It comes in at the front doors, as it did at noon the day before. I feel it come up through the frame in my hand: the straw, the faint thread of smoke, and the sound going out of the room like a plate under water. Raymond has taken the frame on the other side.

I let go, and step back, and he puts his flat hand on the paint, and his lips, already, begin to go blue. Ruth has set the lamp on the information desk, and it leans.

“*Madam Auditor,*” says Mr. Sproule, and stops.

He has looked at his watch. He is looking at it now with a strange, polite, fixed attention, and I see that the hand, the small thin gold one, has stopped on the dial. He holds it to his ear. He shakes it, gently. When he looks up his round pink face has gone the color of tallow.

In the doorway, where there is a bright cold February noon, there is a deep still brown. A boot comes out of it.

*

Frank walks down the middle of the lobby in the canvas coat with the pencil behind his ear, and he does it as he would walk down a church aisle on a morning he was late.

He does not look at the room. He looks at the floor, at the chalk line, at the little prints, and then at the clock, which says twenty to four, and the squint goes soft, and I think he is going to say something about the clock. He says nothing. He stops a polite distance from the camp stool.

“Madam Auditor,” says Frank. “I’m told I’m wanted.”

Nair has risen. She has risen with the Manual in both hands, and I see that she is shaking, a little, along the line of the jaw, and that she is doing what I have watched her do for a month with every impossible thing that has been laid before her. She is reaching for the form.

“I am the Board of View,” she says. “Mr. Tolliver, I’m going to ask the clerk to enter that you appear, and I’m going to swear you. I should like to know, first, whether you can be.”

“I can be asked, ma’am. I’ve found that’s most of it.”

“The Manual says the Board may take the statement of any person who can be asked.”

“Madam,” says Sproule. He has stepped forward, and it takes him three tries. “Madam, the Commonwealth’s file shows Francis Xavier Tolliver, volunteer fire captain, deceased the seventeenth of October, nineteen ninety-eight. I have the certificate. I should like it noted that the person in the room is not a person who is *able* to be—”

“The certificate is in your file, Mr. Sproule,” says Nair. “I have been looking at the gentleman for a minute and a half. If your certificate is correct, then I’d be grateful to know what you would call him.” She turns her back on him. It is the rudest thing I have ever seen her do, and she does it with perfect composure. “Mr. Tolliver, raise your right hand.”

He raises it. It is the hand with the scars.

“Do you swear to answer what you can, and to say plainly what you can’t?”

“I do.”

Under Tully’s knee the rule rings. It is a clear, plain, ordinary note, and it carries to the stairs and comes back from the dome. I find I have put my hand over my mouth.

“Mr. Tolliver,” says Nair, “I am a Board of View. I’m to say what the ground is worth. I have not the faintest idea how to do it. Can you tell me?”

He thinks about it. He thinks about it as he thinks about a board.

“No, ma’am,” he says. “I can’t tell you what it’s worth.”

“I see.”

“I can only say what’s owed on it.” He says it mildly. “That’s all anyone can say, ma’am. It isn’t a thing to be worth. It’s a thing that’s owed, and on, and by. A man who gives you a figure for it has sold you a different piece of ground.” The rule rings, low and long. “You’d want to ask the ones it owes.”

“Thank you,” says Nair, and sits down.

I realize she is crying. She is doing it as she does everything, without fuss and with both pairs of glasses on, her short plain hands folded over the Manual, and she does not wipe her face. Ms. Szabo has stopped typing. She has taken a handkerchief from her sleeve, and leans over, and lays it on Nair’s knee, and goes back to the keys, and her face, for once, is not a record of anything at all.

The lamp stands up.

It does it as the doors thump shut, in a roll of cold, and the brown thins into plain white daylight. Frank has already turned. He looks once at the horse, at the open door, where it stands on the sill and has come back in out of the cold, and he gives it a little nod, as a man nods to someone who has done a hard thing and is not going to speak of it. Then he looks at me.

I do not know what he is telling me. I think he is telling me that I did not say anything I could lose, and that it was well done.

He steps into the brown. The sound comes back.

*

It is half past twelve before the room has stopped breathing.

Sproule has gone. He has gone, very quietly, with his watch in his fist, and Kerr behind him with the briefcases, and at the doors Kerr has turned, and given me one short look, and gone out.

Strake has billed the morning at one and three tenths and struck four tenths of it, and says that it is the first time in twenty-six years he has been pleased to be on the losing side of a motion that he won.

“It is not a win,” says Nair, from her camp stool. She has put away the handkerchief. She is looking at her notes, with a very straight back.

“Mr. Sproule has made himself plain. He’ll appeal, and he’ll be back, and he will bring a better statute. But I should like it recorded that for the first time since the Declaration was read, the Commonwealth was told in a public room that it could not have a thing. It isn’t a precedent. It’s a *habit.*” She snaps the binder shut. “Adjourned.”

It is as people stand and the lobby begins to loosen that I smell it.

It is faint, and it is not straw. It comes from the foot of the stairs, from the shadow under the stopped clock, and it is mud, and cold river water, and the green sourness of a bank in August. I have smelled it twice. It is the smell of a man who has stood a long time in a stream.

He has been there all morning. He is standing at the foot of the stair with his hat in his hand, a thin gray man with a fisherman’s squint and a canvas bait-shop jacket, and the cuffs of his trousers are dark to the knee. There is water in his shoes. It comes out of the soles when he steps, in a little round shining print on the tile, one, and then another, and does not dry.

“Evening, ma’am,” says Teague. “Afternoon, I mean.”

“Mr. Teague,” I say.

“Miss Tolliver.” He takes a step toward the camp stool. He does it with the extreme courtesy of a man crossing a stranger’s yard. “I wonder if I might have a word with the Board. I’ve a paper. I’d not have disturbed the hearing.”

“You’re welcome to disturb it now,” says Nair.

He holds it out. It is a single sheet, wet at one corner, and when she takes it, it is cold enough that she holds it by the edge. She reads it. I watch her read it, and then read it again, and then turn it, as though there might be more, on the back.

“It is addressed to me as the Board,” she says, “and I will read it to the room, because I’m not sure what else I am to do.”

She reads it aloud in her flat, careful voice.

“*THE WATER, claimant, against the Grantor, for one voice lent. Amount: as stated in the original. Terms: until the ground has a stead.*” She lowers it. “That is the whole of it. There’s no signature. It has a date, which is older than the county.”

“It’s in the water’s hand, ma’am,” says Teague. “I only carry.”

“Mr. Teague.” Nair takes off her glasses. “I have a valuation to make. I’m told that it’s what is owed on the ground, by name and by head. This is a debt. It is plainly on the ground, or on the person who gave it. I can’t enter it as a *figure.* I have no figure.”

“No, ma’am.”

“Then the Board will say this. The valuation will not close until this entry is answered.” She says it quietly, to the paper. “I’ll not state a total with a debt on it that nobody has stated. It would be a false number.”

“That’s right,” says Teague, “and kindly said.”

“It can’t be answered until October,” I say.

I did not mean to speak. I have said it to the room, in the clear flat voice I keep for the counter, and the room has turned. It is the only thing I know, and the only thing I have been sure of, since a night on the ridge when a woman said that a stead is not a successor. *Until the ground has a stead.* I am looking at Teague, and he is looking at his wet shoes, and then, without hurry, at me.

His face is very mild. It is the face of a man who has told a hard thing to a good many people and has never once enjoyed it.

“Yes, ma’am,” says G. Teague. “That’s what the water said, too.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!