Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 66

A Fair Offer

The Commonwealth comes into the diner at twenty to three on Thursday afternoon, which is the dead hour between the lunch plates and the early-birds, and it orders a cup of coffee.

It does not take a booth. A booth would make it a meeting. Aldous Kerr, in the gray topcoat with the collar up and a leather folio under his arm, sits on the third stool from the door and counts a dollar seventy-five onto the counter in exact change, quarters on the left, singles on the right. Then he folds his hands and waits to be served with the stillness of a man in a dentist’s chair.

“Mr. Kerr,” says Ruth.

“Mrs. Tolliver. I understand I’m not a customer you have to serve.”

“I serve anyone who sits.” She pours. It is the good pot, the one she keeps for people she has not made up her mind about. “I don’t serve them twice if they stand on my sill and hand me paper.”

“That was a courtesy. The twelve hours’ notice.”

“I know what it was,” says Ruth.

---

Thursday is the Board’s amendment hour, and since the oak has now pushed out eight of Nair’s staples, it is held in the back booth of the diner, under the calendar from the feed store.

Nair sits on one side in her state parka with the Roll binder open and both pairs of glasses on. Ms. Szabo has the stenotype machine on the other, wedged between the ketchup and the sugar caddy. The brass rule lies on a dish towel on the counter near my elbow, and Tully sits beside it with one hand an inch from the metal.

Hal is on the end stool with a slice of apple pie and his felt hat on his knee. Raymond is at the pass-through with a rack of cups. Jonah is flat on his back under the pie case with a flashlight in his teeth, chasing a rattle in the compressor, and from where I sit I can see only his boots and one hand, opening, and closing, on nothing.

Wren is on her milk crate. She has written, in pencil, *2:40. A man came in and paid exact.*

“Auditor,” says Kerr. He has not turned his head. “I’m told the Board sits here on Thursdays.”

“The Board sits where the furniture lets it,” says Nair.

“Then I’d like to give notice. I’m here for the Secretary on a matter of compromise.” He opens the folio. “Under the Code, the condemnor may tender a settlement to any claimant at any time before the Board reports. A claimant who accepts is paid, and the claim is released. It is the Commonwealth’s practice, in a taking of this size, to open with a fair offer.”

“A fair offer,” says Nair.

“I’ve been instructed to use the word. I’d ask the clerk to enter that it isn’t mine.”

“Noted,” says Ms. Szabo, in a voice that I think is meant to be neutral and is not.

---

He starts with Raymond, because Raymond is nearest, and he has the manners to rise to do it.

He crosses to the pass-through with a single typed sheet and holds it out through the window, and Raymond wipes his hands on the blue apron, one finger at a time, and takes it.

“The Commonwealth tenders a hundred and ninety-two thousand dollars,” says Kerr, “for the assignment of the recourse of R. Fanning against H. Ashcombe, saved to the second chair under Section Nineteen of the Hedge’s rules, as scheduled.” He swallows. “The figure is the statutory rate for a day of wrongful detention, applied to thirty-two Aprils, of thirty days each. I’m to say it is, in the Secretary’s view, generous.”

I check it later on the back of an order pad, with the diner’s pencil. It is right. To the dollar. It is the most frightening thing I learn all day, that the Commonwealth did its arithmetic and got it right.

Raymond reads the sheet. He reads it all the way down, the way he reads a ticket, and then he lays it on the sill of the pass-through and puts his left hand flat on top of it, as he does on the brass.

“I said I’d ask in front of the whole table,” he says. “And not on a Tuesday.”

“Yes, sir.”

“This isn’t a table. It’s a counter.” He considers the clock over the grill. “And it’s a Thursday. I mention the day because I’d hate for you to think I’d lost track. I haven’t. It’s the wrong day, and it’s the wrong room, and I wasn’t asked by the right party.” His hand does not move. “No, thank you. I’ll keep it. It’s the only thing I ever came out of that place holding.”

“I’ll record that you decline.”

“I decline,” says Raymond, “with thanks for the arithmetic.”

---

“Miss Tolliver,” says Hal.

He has not touched the pie. He has put down the fork and is looking at the sheet under Raymond’s hand with the mildest expression in the world. It is the face of a very large old animal who has just been shown the price of his own collar.

“I should like to understand,” he says. “If the Commonwealth bought the Fannings’ recourse, it would be the second chair.”

“Yes.”

“And I should owe it what I owe them.”

“Thirty-two Aprils,” I say. “By the sheet. And it could call the debt in any form the Hedge’s rules allow, because it would be holding the paper, and the paper doesn’t care who holds it.”

“I see.” Hal turns his hat once on his knee. “As it were, I am a thing that can be purchased by assignment, from a man washing cups.” He looks at Kerr, not unkindly. “I find that I should like very much to be told when I am for sale.”

“Sir,” says Kerr, to the counter, “I don’t think the Secretary’s counsel has asked me to say.”

“No,” says Hal. “I don’t suppose he would.”

---

Brandt comes in at five past three, in the overcoat, with the briefcase, and he is handed the second sheet before he has found a stool.

It is the cardigan. I see that from where I sit, because the type is large, and the Secretary’s typist has put it in boldface. *ONE BLUE WOOL CARDIGAN, THREE BUTTONS, LADIES’ MEDIUM. REPLACEMENT VALUE: $112.50.* There is a second line, in smaller type, for *recognition of the late Eleanor Brandt, teacher, by letter of regret from the Secretary of Education, framed.*

“They consulted a catalogue,” says Brandt.

“I’m told it was the same one the Bureau uses for office furnishings, sir.”

“It’s very thorough.” He reads it a second time, with his lips pressed, as if for typographical errors. “They’ve priced the cardigan at what it costs in a store. I admire the research. The only thing they have got wrong is that it isn’t in a store.”

“Mr. Brandt. I’m to say that if you accept, the slip is released.”

“I understand what a release is, Mr. Kerr. I have drafted four hundred of them.” He takes a pen out of the overcoat and writes across the face of the sheet, in the round plain hand he has used since Venango. I lean to read it upside down. *Declined. Not for sale.* And under it, smaller, *She is not a line.*

Kerr slides it into the folio with some care, as a man files a thing he would like to keep.

---

I know what is coming. I have known since he opened the folio. There is a third sheet, and it is thicker than the others, and it has a cover letter clipped to its front.

“Miss Tolliver.”

“Mr. Kerr.”

“I’m to tender in the matter of your slip.” He has gone pale along the jaw. “It reads *A father.* The Commonwealth is mindful that it is the only entry on the Roll for which no figure is stated, and that no figure could be.”

“That’s what I thought.”

“It’s tendered in full.” He lays the sheet on the counter, squares it with one finger, and stands back. “I’d ask that you read it, and that nobody read it for you.”

I read the cover letter first, because I read everything.

The offer is short and it is very well made. The Commonwealth will enter, on its Roll of Honor, the name of Francis Xavier Tolliver, captain, Ketterly Volunteer Fire Company, as having died in the line of duty on the seventeenth of October, 1998.

In the original report, the fire had been filed as an accident on private premises, which carries nothing. That is to be corrected. His name will be cut in the memorial wall at the Capitol, between a man from Erie and a man from Lancaster.

There is a benefit. It is paid to the surviving spouse, in a lump, retroactive. I read the sum once and put it out of my head, because I know exactly what it is. It is a new roof on a diner, and the end of every winter in which a woman has set out pots under the leaks.

I look up. Ruth has stopped, with the cloth in her hand, and a face I saw once before on the ridge, when a man in a wet vest came out of the dark and she did not run.

“A wall,” says Ruth, very low.

“Yes, ma’am.”

“With his name.”

“Yes. In stone.”

She does not say anything else. She folds the cloth, which she has no reason to fold.

---

I read the last paragraph of the cover letter twice.

It is on the second page. It is the only one that is not in the warm, regretful voice of the others. It is paragraph six, and it has the dry, dense, well-oiled look of a thing that was drafted before the rest and had the kindness added around it later.

*In consideration of the foregoing, the claimant, and all persons claiming by, through or under the decedent, acknowledge that the decedent is deceased, and release the Commonwealth and all persons from any assertion that the decedent is living, present, or standing in any capacity upon any ground, under any instrument, whether now or hereafter.*

Under it, in the Review’s neat hand, a note in the margin: *Presumption of Death, Act of 1921, s. 9. See Secretary’s Memorandum, “better statute.”*

I put it down. I have the clearest sense of every person in the room looking at me, and a clearer one of the dish towel under my other hand, with the rule on it, humming.

“It says *fully,*” I say.

I do not know why I say it. It comes out of me in the voice I use for the counter, flat and plain, and I find that I am looking at the word on the page, where it is printed twice. *Paid in full. Fully satisfied.*

I have been a creditor for a month. I have said, to a gray room, in a gray voice, *A father,* and I did not say what I meant by it, because I did not know, and now there is a sheet of paper that does.

“Miss Tolliver,” says Kerr. “I’m not authorized to ask this. I’d like to ask it under the rule.” He looks at Tully. “If the Board permits.”

“The Board is not a party to the tender,” says Nair. She has taken off both pairs of glasses. “It will be a witness. Say it as you like.”

“Are you inclined to accept?”

---

I put my hand on the brass.

“For one breath,” I say, “yes.”

It rings. It rings plain, low, and warm, and I hear Ruth’s breath go out of her, and I do not turn.

“I’d like that said where Ruth can hear it. I read *fully,* and I read *wall,* and I thought, I’d go. I’d stand in front of it on a Sunday in a good coat. I’d know where he was.” My voice is not steady, and I let it not be. “I wanted it. I’d like it entered that I wanted it.”

“Entered,” says Ms. Szabo, very quietly. She has stopped typing in the middle of a word.

“And now?” says Kerr.

“No.”

It rings. It is the same note, and it comes out of the brass like a door closing gently on a warm room.

“Is Francis Xavier Tolliver deceased?”

It is the question he came to ask. He has asked it with his chin up, like a boy at the front of a class. I look at his face. It has no cruelty in it at all. That is the dreadful thing about it.

I take my hand off the brass.

“Ask him,” I say.

The rule does not ring. It does not sour. It lies on the dish towel and does nothing, which is a thing it does very well, and in the silence Ms. Szabo types the line, and I hear the keys, and know what they say. *THE WITNESS: Ask him.*

---

Kerr does not move for a count of ten.

I see him decide. It goes down through the whole of him, from the shoulders, as a man sets down a heavy case he has carried a mile because someone told him it was his.

“I’m instructed,” he says, “to leave the tender open for ten days. I’m instructed to say that it’s a courtesy.” His voice has gone odd. “I’d like it noted that I think it’s a taking.”

He draws a breath, and the next thing he says is not in the warm voice or the dry one. It is only his own.

“The Code permits the tenderer to withdraw before acceptance,” he says. “The tender is signed by the examiner of record. That’s me. My name is on the cover sheet, in my hand. Mr. Sproule will have it re-signed by morning, I expect. But this one, here, today, is withdrawn.”

He closes the folio. He lays the three sheets on the counter between the ketchup and the rule, and then, with the particular awkwardness of a man performing the last courteous act open to him, he pushes them down the counter toward Nair.

“For the Board’s file. Withdrawn. By the tenderer. At three twenty-two.”

“Three twenty-two,” says Ms. Szabo.

“I’ll want a receipt,” says Kerr, “that I did it in front of everyone.” His hands, I notice, are shaking. He puts them in the topcoat. “I have not been refused. I have simply declined to proceed.”

Ruth puts a plate in front of him. It is a slice of the apple, with a wedge of cheddar, and she does not look at him.

“I’m not permitted to accept gifts,” says Kerr.

“It’s not a gift,” says Ruth. “It’s a Thursday. Sit.”

He eats every bite with great concentration, in the center of a diner that is not looking at him, and when he has finished he sets the fork down square, and says, to the plate, “It’s very good.”

“I know,” says Ruth.

---

Jonah comes out from under the pie case when the door has closed.

He sits up on the linoleum with the flashlight in his fist and a smear of grease on his jaw, and he does not say anything for a while. I have my hands flat on the counter. I find that I am looking at them.

“You said it out loud,” he says.

“I said it where it counts.”

“I wanted it too.” He does not look away. “For you.” His left hand opens, and closes. “I’m not telling you it was wrong. I’m telling you it was a fair offer, and a fair offer doesn’t have to be a lie to be a trap.”

“Mom,” I say.

Ruth is at the pie case, wiping a clean shelf.

“Marguerite Anne,” she says. “Don’t.”

“The roof.”

“I know about the roof.” She does not stop wiping. “He told me Wednesday. Another winter in it, not two.” Her voice cracks, once, on the top of the sentence, and she puts the cloth down. “I’d have wanted it. All my life I’d have said I wouldn’t, and I’d have wanted it, and I’d have gone to bed in a dry house and been a widow.”

“You’d have been right to want it.”

“I’d have been right,” says Ruth, “and I’d have been wrong. He told me to keep the lamp.” She turns, and her eyes are bright, and she has no handkerchief. “He’s coming at midnight. I’ll tell him myself. Somebody ought to give him the paper, and not a stranger.”

---

Wren, at the milk crate, has not written a word in a quarter of an hour. She is looking at the three withdrawn sheets on the counter as if they were a snake that someone had not yet decided was dead.

“It looks like they lost,” she says. “That’s what I don’t like. They wouldn’t send him with a thing that could lose.”

---

At noon on Friday Raymond stands at the frame with his left hand on the paint and his feet apart, and the room, for the third day running, goes down under the weight of the sound.

I do not know why I am so sure Kerr will be there.

He is. He has come at five to twelve, and stands on the pavement beyond the light of the window in the same gray topcoat, with no folio and no briefcase, and his hat in both hands like a man at a graveside. He does not cross the sill. When the brown comes into the doorway, and the lamp leans, and the boot comes out of it onto the linoleum, he does not look away.

Frank comes in wiping his feet.

He has the canvas coat on, and the pencil behind his left ear. He goes first to the end stool, where Ruth has the thick white mug waiting, steaming, and puts his hand around it for the warmth. Then he looks at the door.

“Ruth says there’s a fellow,” he says. “She says he’d a thing to ask and didn’t have the leave.”

“Mr. Tolliver,” says Kerr, from the pavement. “I wouldn’t presume to put it to you in the Commonwealth’s name. I’ve withdrawn the Commonwealth’s name.” His voice is thin. “I’ve a question of my own.”

“Come to the door, son. You don’t have to cross.”

Kerr comes. He stops a hand’s breadth from the sill, beside Ginny Dill’s red globe in its cage. He is a tall man and he has made himself small in the doorway, and he says it in the clear flat voice of a boy reading aloud.

“Sir. The file says you’re deceased. I’ve been looking at it for three weeks. I’d like to know whether I was right to withdraw the offer.”

“That’s two questions.”

“Yes, sir.”

“I’ll take the first.” Frank looks at him. It is the carpenter’s squint, the one that is judging the grain, and it is not hard. “I’m not deceased, son. I’m owed.”

---

The rule is in Tully’s pillowcase on the counter, and I do not need to see it. I hear it through the cloth. It is the new note, the low long one, neither whole nor hollow, and Kerr hears it too. His hat goes a little crooked in his hands.

“A dead man isn’t owed,” says Frank. He says it quite mildly. “They close the books on him. It’s a kindness, mostly. Nobody wants to go on adding up. But I’ve a wife who keeps a lamp, and a girl who keeps a ledger, and every day the ground puts another line under my name, and if you tell it I’m dead, it’ll put the pencil down.”

He turns the mug a quarter turn on the counter. “It’s not that I mind the wall. I’d have liked a wall. You can tell whoever sits behind you that I was pleased to be asked.”

“Sir.”

“I’ll take the wall when somebody’s put a roof on this diner, and not out of the same envelope.” The squint creases. “And you were right to withdraw. That’s the second one. It’s an unpleasant thing to be sure of in a gray coat on your own.”

Kerr says nothing. He is standing very straight, and his throat is moving.

“What’s your name?”

“Aldous Kerr, sir.”

“Aldous.” Frank says it with care, as he would say the name of a tool. “Eat something. You look like a boy that’s been reading to a room all week.”

“Mrs. Tolliver fed me,” says Kerr. “Yesterday. It was apple.”

“Then you’ve done what I’d do,” says Frank. “Go on.”

The lamp stands up. The brown thins. The sound comes back into the room all at once, with a clatter of forks, and a woman at the end booth says, “Is it noon?” and somebody tells her yes.

Frank has gone. When I look at the door, Kerr is gone too, and a gray shape is going along Water Street with its collar up, walking quickly, not like a man who has been dismissed, but like one who has just remembered a train.

---

Nair is at the back booth with the binder open, filing the withdrawn tender without reading it.

“It was withdrawn,” she says, to nobody. “I’m putting it in under *Withdrawn.* I’d like to put it away before someone reaches for it.” She lifts the three sheets, squaring them against the table, and the top one slides off the pile and lies face up on the vinyl.

She stops.

It is the cover sheet. It is the one Kerr signed. It has the Secretary’s crest, and the examiner’s signature, and below the signature, where there was nothing at three twenty-two on Thursday afternoon, there is a stamp.

It is not large. It is in good red ink. It sits a little crooked on the page, as if it had been brought down fast, and it says, in square capitals, with the date and the hour under it:

*RECEIVED. FEB. 26. 11:58 P.M.*

Nair has gone very still. She looks at the sheet, and at her tote on the seat beside her, where she has carried it every hour since three twenty-two, with the binder inside and the tote slung over her arm in the Tamarack Motor Lodge until seven this morning.

“I did not stamp this,” she says.

“No.”

“My stamp is the one with the wooden handle. It’s in the tote. It is a perfectly ordinary stamp.” She lifts the sheet to the window. “It is not that.”

I know what I am going to see before I lean over it. I look at the R.

It is whole. The leg is unbroken, a clean sweep down and out to its small serif. It is not the ground’s stamp, which has stood seventy years with a nick in that stroke. It is not Nair’s. It is the other one.

My hand has gone into my coat before I know it. The die is there. It is in its amber paper, in the inside pocket, cold as it has been since Raymond put it in my hand. I close my fingers on it, and it is mine, and it has not moved.

There are two of them.

“Ms. Szabo,” says Nair, in a very small voice. “I’d be grateful for the clerk to read me what the Code says a stamp of the Board’s receipt is evidence of.”

Ms. Szabo does not touch the keys. She has gone as white as the paper. She has the Code in her lap, open at a tab, and she reads it aloud without looking, because she has had it by heart since the first week.

“*An offer of compromise is accepted when it is received.*”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!