The better stone arrives on Friday at ten to eight, in a box that once held a ream of copier paper, with a sticker on the lid that says HANDLE AS HEAVY.
The courier sets it on the counter and waits for a signature. Ruth signs, because nobody else is quick enough, and the courier tips his cap to the pie case and goes out into a morning the color of dishwater. Strake is already in the back booth, in the charcoal coat, with his legal pad squared beside the sugar caddy. He has been there since seven, drinking tea he does not like, in case something came.
“Motion to Strike and for a More Definite Statement,” he reads aloud, from the first page, and lifts his eyes to the ceiling. “Forty-one pages. I’ll bill the reading at four-tenths.” He turns a leaf. “And the second reading, in the hope that I’ve misunderstood it, at two.”
“Have you?” says Tully.
“No,” says Strake, with real regret. “It’s very good.”
---
It is very good in two parts, and the second part is the better stone.
The first is the one Sproule promised from the information desk: a body politic cannot be owed by a stone, and the entries name no person. Tully has an answer to that, and has had it since Thursday, and says it with the pillowcase in his lap and his green-stained hand flat on the table so that it will not shake. The ground is a party to the Compact. The Compact’s fourth column is headed *For the Ground.* A party may claim.
“That’s the weak one,” says Strake. “He wrote it so that you’d win it, I think. Page nineteen.”
Page nineteen is a different argument. It says that, whatever the ground is, the Commonwealth did not move the line. The survey of 1911 was the act of a county officer, the surveyor of Tamarack County, and a county officer’s act is the county’s. The Commonwealth may be a creditor of a county, or its landlord, or its heir. It is not its surety. Sproule has cited a decision called *Boyd’s Run,* from 1923, and has set it in the middle of the page like a stone in a ring.
“So it’s a hole,” I say.
“It’s a door,” says Tully. His voice has gone thin. “Legally speaking. It’s a door with a very nice lock, and we have to find where the key was kept.”
---
Nair sets argument for Monday at four, in the lobby, because the oak will not let her staple the notice anywhere else. Ms. Szabo has typed it, in capitals, and Wren has carried it to the post office on her bicycle, where she reports that three people read it over her shoulder and one tried to pay postage on it.
By Friday noon we know where the key might be, because we know where it is not.
It is not in the County’s vault. Walt Kowalczyk comes in at half past nine, in the suspenders and the hunting cap, with a thermos of tea the color of creosote, and he does not need to look at the plat Tully lays down. He has been looking at it for forty years. The margin of the Water Street sheet carries a note in a clerk’s hand, a thing nobody has read since it was written, *Line closed per F.B. 14, pp. 38 to 61.*
“Field Book Fourteen,” says Walt.
“You’ve seen it?”
“I’ve seen one through thirty-one, in the vault in the basement, on the left-hand shelf, in a row.” He turns his cap in his hands. “Fourteen’s a hole. A little gap, the width of a book, with a card in it. I asked in eighty-eight, when I took the job. The clerk said it was out.”
“Out where?”
“In the Commissioners’ minute for August of 1912. I read it once on a rainy day.” He drinks his tea. “*F.B. 14 to be kept in the room under the clock, the same being dry, the key with the keeper of the clock.* That’s the whole entry. Nobody asked about the book again. It’s a county. We lose things in it all the time. We’ve just never lost them on purpose.”
“Is there a keeper of the clock?” says Wren.
“There’s a man,” says Walt, “who winds it on Saturdays.”
---
His name is Cyrus Landry, and he is eighty-four years old, and the county carries him on the payroll as *Maintenance Engineer, Grade Two,* which he has been since 1974.
We find him on Saturday morning at nine, at the foot of the tower stair behind the courthouse’s back vestibule, in a gray work coat with a ring of keys the size of a dinner plate. He does not seem surprised. He looks at Tully, and at Wren, and at the pillowcase, and at Jonah, who has come because somebody must carry the lantern, and he says, “You’ll be wanting the room under the clock.”
“How did you know?” I say.
“Nobody’s ever wanted it.” He is already climbing. “I thought one of these years someone might.”
It is a hundred and eighteen steps. I count them because Wren is counting, in a whisper, and I cannot stand to be wrong in company. The stair is stone to the first landing and iron after, painted the green of the Commissioners’ courtesy, and it goes up through the building’s dry thick middle past the backs of rooms I have never entered. At the sixtieth step the building’s sounds fall away, the telephones and the radiators and the lobby’s great echo, and there is only the tick.
It is not the sound of a clock. It is the sound of something enormous deciding.
---
The clock room is a square of dry brown wood about the size of the diner’s dining room, with a plank floor and four small windows cut in four walls, and in the center of it stands the movement.
I have lived in this town all my life. I have never once thought of what makes the dials go around. It is brass and black iron, as long as a hay wagon, with wheels the size of manhole covers and a great slow escapement that turns like the jaw of a patient animal.
Cables as thick as a wrist run down through the floor to the weights. And from the ceiling, through a slot cut in the boards, a pendulum the length of a man hangs and swings, and swings, and every time it swings, the room is a little different.
The four dials are in the walls. From behind they are only milk-white glass with the numerals backward, lit by a gray March daylight that comes through them like water through a sheet.
“She’s never been wrong,” says Landry. “She’s been quiet twice. Lately she’s taken to holding her breath at twelve.” He lays his flat palm on the iron frame, as I have seen Raymond lay his on a doorframe. “I’ve stopped greasing her for it. It isn’t a thing grease will fix.”
“She?” says Jonah, mildly.
“The movement. I don’t know what else to call a thing that old that’s been that patient with me.” Landry points with his chin. “The press is behind the case. Everything that’s paper’s in it. I dust it. I don’t read it.” He takes the ring from his belt. “A man who reads what he’s keeping starts keeping it for himself.”
---
The press is an oak cupboard, black with more than a century of oil and hands, standing in the angle behind the pendulum case with its door shut on a brass key. It opens on four shelves. They are not what I expected. They hold a Commissioners’ seal in a wooden box, a stack of Sunday-school hymn cards, a roll of bunting, two flags, and a long, narrow, heavy leather book, laid on its side as a man lays a sleeping child.
It is brown with a dark red spine, and it has a number in gilt on the front. *14.* The back board is thick. When I lift it, the weight is wrong, it hangs to the left, like a loaf that has risen on one side. I do not stop to think about it.
“Heavy for its size,” says Wren, who has taken the other end.
“She always was,” says Landry, from the door. “Heavier on the left.” He has the grace not to look at what we do. “I figured it was the leather.”
---
*Field Book No. 14. H. Linsey, County Surveyor. Tamarack Co., Pa. 1911.*
It is written in pencil, in a small clear upright hand, by a man who spent his life putting things where they were. There are tables of bearings and distances, and little sketches, and weather in the margins. I read it on the clock room’s plank floor, with the lantern by my knee, and Wren at my elbow with the composition book on hers, and I read it aloud, because that is the only way I have ever been able to read anything for the record.
*Oct. 3. Fair. Party: H. Linsey; head chain, W. Pike; rear chain, the Clerk’s man; axe, J. Pike. Chained the Water Street line from the Court House corner east to the creek monument. Fails to close by 1 rod 1½.*
*Oct. 4. Chained it again. Chain tested. Fails to close by 1 rod 1½.*
*Oct. 5. Rain. Chained it a third time in the wet, against my own judgment. Fails to close by 1 rod 1½. The Clerk’s man says the line is true and that it is the town that is wrong. I told him the town is the town.*
“The Clerk’s man,” says Tully, softly.
“It’s a man,” says Strake, later, when I read him this on the telephone. “It says so. He’s the Clerk’s man.”
---
It goes on for twenty-three pages in the same small hand.
There is a pleasure, even now, in reading a surveyor who cannot make a line come out. He chains it from the creek, and it comes up a rod and a half short of the courthouse. He chains it from the courthouse, and it comes up a rod and a half short of the creek.
He tests the chain against a standard. He borrows the railroad’s. He goes out at dawn, in case it is the heat. *Oct. 12. The line does not agree with itself.* And, three days after, in a smaller hand, more tired: *Oct. 15. The ground declines the line.*
He does not say what he means by it. He is a surveyor. He is not a man who says what he means.
The Clerk’s man comes into it again on the twenty-second, and on the twenty-fifth, always at the edge of the page. *The Clerk’s man asks that the monument end be held and the Court House end carried. Told him it is not usual. He says it would be safer so.*
On the twenty-ninth: *The Clerk’s man will pay for the stakes.* On the thirtieth: *The Court House end carried. Water St. line now closes by 1 rod 1½ in the town’s favor. The town is content. The strip between is no one’s.*
“No one’s,” says Wren, writing it.
“Safer so,” I say. I do not know why it makes my mouth go dry.
---
The last entry is on page sixty-one.
*Nov. 2. Fair and cold. Line closed by consent of the party in possession, being present and making no sign. H. Linsey.* There is nothing under it. There is no witness’s name, and no seal, and the next page is blank to the end of the book.
I read it twice. I know the sentence. I do not know why. I have the feeling a person has in a strange house, on opening a drawer, of finding her own handwriting.
“Who is the party in possession?” says Jonah.
“The ground,” I say.
“Did it consent?”
I put my hand on the brass. Tully has brought the rule up in the pillowcase and set it on the plank floor, between the lantern and the weights, and it lies there in the gray light with the great pendulum going over it, back and forth, like a man looking for a coin. I say it in the voice I keep for it.
“*The ground consented to the closing of the line.*”
Nothing. No ring, no sour. It is the clean flat nothing of a thing asked a falsehood, and I feel Landry, in the doorway, let go of a breath.
“*The ground made no sign.*”
It rings, low and plain. It is true.
“*The ground could not refuse.*”
It rings. It rings so long that the pendulum goes over it twice, and the sound goes out among the iron and comes back in the dials, a half second late, and Wren stops writing and puts the pencil down on the page.
“That’s it,” says Tully. “That’s the whole case.” His voice cracks, on the last word, as it did when he first called the noon hearing. “It’s not a consent if the party can’t say no.”
---
On Monday at four the lobby has the look it gets before a hearing, of a stage that has been swept.
Nair on the camp stool, with both pairs of glasses. Ms. Szabo at the machine. The Manual, the binder, the stapler, which she does not look at. Sproule stands at the end of the row of exhibits with his gold watch in his palm and the Review’s second briefcase set beside him. Kerr is not there. A different young man in a gray topcoat holds the folio, and he is very pale, and has not yet learned where to put his hands.
Tully argues. It is the first time he has argued before the Board standing up, and he has put on the dark green knitted tie, and the pillowcase hangs from his belt like a purse. He does it badly for a quarter of a minute and then very well.
The strip was reserved in 1790, he says, and the ground has been held in trust by the Commonwealth since the conveyance of 1894, which is on the record, in the Memorandum, and which nobody has challenged. A trustee that approves a survey of the trust ground, without hearing the beneficiary, and in a way that reduces the trust, has acted. It does not matter whose hand held the chain.
“It matters very much, Mr. Tully,” says Sproule gently. “It matters in *Boyd’s Run.*”
“*Boyd’s Run* is about a county road that was a county road, sir. This was never a county road. It was a thing the county never owned, and the Commonwealth did.” Tully swallows. “Legally speaking.”
---
I lay the field book on the information desk. I read the last page. I read it under the rule, and the rule rings for the part that is true and keeps its silence for the part that is not.
It is Brandt who rises. He has been at the end of the bench, in the overcoat, with the briefcase between his feet, and he has said nothing since I arrived. He gets up now and stands with his hands at his sides.
“Auditor. I should like to say that I know that sentence.”
“Mr. Brandt?”
“*The party in possession being present and making no sign.*” He says it without inflection. “I read it three weeks ago, in the Annex, in my grandfather’s hand, at the foot of a card. It was how he recorded the taking of a plaster cast from the Tamarack counter stamp on the ninth of November, 1953. It is a formula. It has been in the Annex’s file of approved language since long before him.”
He looks, for the first time, directly at Sproule. “It is the Commonwealth’s phrase. I should say it is its oldest one. It means *he did not object.* It has never once, in my experience, meant *he was asked.*”
“Mr. Brandt is partial,” says Sproule.
“I am,” says Brandt. “I’m a claimant. I’m saying it anyway.”
Nobody speaks. Ms. Szabo has stopped typing. It is the thing I have noticed about this lobby, that a room can go quiet in more than one way, and this is the way it goes when someone has said the thing in the family’s own voice.
---
Nair rules at ten past five, sitting, with the Manual shut on her knee.
“The Board denies the motion to strike as to the entry for the survey of 1911.” She says it quickly, so that it will be over. “The Board finds that the Commonwealth has held the courthouse ground in trust since 1894, and that its approval of a resurvey of trust ground, without notice to the beneficiary, is the act of the trustee. *Boyd’s Run* is distinguished. The entry stands.”
She takes off the glasses. “The Board reserves the entry for the signal at Colliers Run. Mr. Sproule, I am told you have a better stone. I should like to see it.”
“Madam,” says Sproule, and bows, not stiffly, with the look of a man who has been shown a piece in a game he has not seen played before and finds that he likes it. “I believe I may.”
On the information desk the stapler goes through the paper for the first time in nine days. It stays.
“It holds,” says Ms. Szabo, under her breath, and I do not think anyone but Nair hears the rest of it, which is, “It was only ever waiting to be asked.”
---
The book goes back in the diner’s back booth that night, to wait for Landry’s key.
Wren has it on her knees, on the vinyl, under the feed store’s calendar, with the composition book on top and Strake’s last fax folded in her sleeve.
The lamp on the sill has been trimmed, a quarter inch longer, as it is every night at seven, and there is the smell of the grill being scraped, and the sound of Raymond at the pass-through, running water over the last rack. Jonah is behind the counter drying a pan. Ruth has gone upstairs. It is almost the quiet part of the week.
“Mags.”
“Yes.”
“It’s heavy again.” She has the back board in her hands, and she is turning it over, and she holds the whole book out to me on both palms like a tray. “It’s heavier on the left. Mr. Landry said so. I thought it was the leather. But the front is leather and the back is thicker, and the pages are all the same.” She looks at me. “It’s the board, Mags. It’s got a *seam.*”
It has. It runs along the inside edge, under the marbled endpaper, a seam you would not find if you were not a person who has spent her life reading the edges of documents for the place where somebody has put something. It is sewn with a thread the same brown as the cover. Jonah gives me the pocketknife from his belt. I do it myself, a stitch at a time, with my tongue between my teeth.
It is a pocket. It is a flat leather pocket in the thickness of the board, made on purpose by a person who knew how to make one, and it is not empty.
---
It is a small brass tag the size of a half dollar, with a hole at the top for a thong, and it comes out into my palm as a drop of water comes out of a leaf.
It is warm.
It is not the warmth of a thing that has been in a pocket. I know that warmth, from a coin. This is the other, the one I have carried for four months against my ribs, the slow, even warmth of a thing that has been held a very long time by a person with a purpose. It is exactly as warm as the pen.
The tag is stamped. The stamping is old and sharp, in capitals, around a central bar with a notch in the bottom like the split of a quill.
*TOLLIVER, M. A. REAR CHAIN. 1911.*
I read it once. I read it again. The lantern in the window leans toward my hand.
“The Clerk’s man,” says Wren, very quietly. “It wasn’t a man.”
“No.”
“It’s your name. Those are your letters. It’s *her.*” She puts her palm flat on the booth’s table, as if it might tip. “She was on the chain. She was at the back of it, the end with the stake. She was the one who said it would be safer so, and she paid for the stakes.”
“Wren.”
“I’m not writing it,” says Wren. “I’m just saying it. I’m saying it because somebody has to.”
---
I know what it does. I know it before I have laid it down.
On Monday the Board of View held that the ground had been spoken over in 1911, that a line had been closed by a man who could not hear the party, and that the Commonwealth was the trustee who ought to have heard. It was the best day we have had since the lobby.
And here, warm in my hand, is the page Sproule has been looking for since he first read *the Clerk’s man,* a better stone than any he has cited: a Tolliver, the ground’s own surety, in the ground’s own place, with a chain in her hand. *Consent of the party in possession.* A surety stands in the place of the thing she is surety for. If anyone ever spoke for the ground, it was her.
I could put it back. I could sew the seam with Jonah’s knife, a stitch at a time, and set the book on its shelf in the room under the clock, and leave it to a man who dusts what he does not read.
I do not think I am the person who does that. I have it from a plat book, filed at four in the morning nine years ago, that I am capable of it. I have it from the loss of an oath that I am done being capable of it.
“In the morning,” I say, “I’m taking it to Nair.”
“It’s the better stone,” says Jonah, from behind the counter. He has put the pan down.
“Yes.”
“You’d be handing him the thing he’s been looking for.”
“I’d be handing her the whole book,” I say. “She’s an Auditor. She reads the back board.” I close my hand. The tag is warm against the scar on my thumb, and against the line in the palm where, if you believe such things, a person’s name is written, and I think of the woman who wore the same four letters, in the same order, and stood at the back of a chain and called it safe.
I put it in my outside pocket, beside the pale nib. The two of them lie together. The nib is cold, like water.
The tag is as warm as a hand.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!