Strake comes to the diner on Thursday with a letter he does not want to read, and he orders pie first, to put it off.
“Stool six,” says Ruth, and does not ask. She has not asked him anything since the church, where he sat in the back row with a hymnal open at the wrong page and stood up for the fourth verse without being told. She slides the plate in front of him and a fork on a napkin, and adds a second napkin, which is the nearest thing to a blessing that my mother has in stock.
“I shall bill the pie,” says Strake, “as a working lunch.”
“You’ll bill it as pie.”
“As pie.” He eats two bites. He is a small, damp, careful man in a suit the color of old gravy, with a leather folder squared on the counter beside him and a packet of paper handkerchiefs in his breast pocket, and he is afraid. I have known him since October, and I know the look. It is not the look of a man who has been caught. It is the look of a man who has caught something and cannot decide which end to hold.
“Miss Tolliver,” he says, “I have been retained by a client to convey an offer. I want it understood that I convey it as a courier. The advice I give you on it is separate, and is billed separately, and may be contrary.”
“Contrary to the offer?”
“Contrary to my instructions.” He wipes his fingers, one at a time. “That is what is separate about it.”
---
It is half past one. The lunch crowd has thinned to the two-tops and a man at the window reading the Courier with his hat on. Wren sits on the end stool, the one that is not Frank’s, with the composition book flat on her knee and her pencil behind her ear. Jonah has come through from the kitchen with a dish towel over his shoulder and has not gone back. Raymond, at the pass-through, has stopped pretending to scrape the grill.
Strake takes the letter out of the folder as though it might go off.
It is a single sheet of heavy cream paper, folded in three, with an envelope that is cream too, and addressed in a clean copperplate hand to The Board of View, Tamarack, Care of the Tolliver Party. It is not a lawyer’s letter. A lawyer’s letter has a rule across the top and a reference number, and this has a border of small leaves. It looks like an invitation to something you would not want to attend.
“I’ll read the operative parts,” says Strake. “*The undersigned, being persons of record in the county of Tamarack and its adjoining ground, though not persons in law, hereby offer to purchase from the Commonwealth, upon the completion of its valuation, the whole of the taken ground, being one hundred and nine parcels, at the value found, and to hold it thereafter in common, for protection, against all claimants whatsoever.*” He stops. “That is the heart of it.”
“All claimants,” says Wren, writing.
“I noticed that too.”
“Who signed?” I ask.
He turns the sheet around. At the foot there are seven marks.
---
They are not signatures. Nobody has signed anything. There is a small iron nail, pressed into the paper so hard that it has left a rusty dent. There is a gray feather, laid flat and gummed. A thimble has been inked and printed, a little ring of dots like a tiny crown. There is a damp, round thumbprint, still not quite dry, which smells very faintly of well water. A burnt match, charred end down. A bus transfer, punched, from a line that has not run since 1971.
And a seventh mark, lower than the rest, in a corner, by itself.
It is a thumbprint. It is not the damp one. It is dark, the brown-red of old rust, and it has a scar across the pad, a small white crescent. I do not have to be told where I have seen it. I have seen it at the foot of a page in a locked volume, below a compact of 1790, on a line that has no name.
“Mm,” says Strake. He is looking at my face. “You’ve seen that.”
“Where did you get this?”
“It came to my office on Monday, by hand, in a box of the kind that holds a good watch. There was no messenger. I did not hear the door.” He folds his handkerchief into a square, and then a smaller square.
“I should say that in twenty-six years of practice I have been handed a great many things by a great many persons who did not wish to be seen. I know the feeling of it. This was not that. This was a letter that had no one to be seen.”
“The nail,” says Raymond, from the pass-through.
“The Annex,” says Strake. “The lintel nail. It holds up the sign that says RECEIVING. The feather is the owl’s, Miss Tolliver, the one with the watches. The thimble is the seamstress’s chair in the Lyle building, which has been rocking without a sitter since 1969. The thumbprint is the well on the empty lot, and I don’t care to say how I know. The match is, I believe, from the cinder pile. The transfer I cannot place.”
He looks at his hands. “They are small things. They are small things that the county has kept, and the county has not counted, and they have, I think, been frightened. They have watched you take a hearing a week. They have drawn the conclusion that a thing which gets counted gets taken.”
Ruth, at the coffee urn, says quietly, “Poor things.”
“Yes,” says Strake. “That’s what’s wrong with it.”
---
I read the whole letter myself, while he finishes his pie, and I want to say that it is a good one.
It is better than good. It is humble, and it is kind. It says that the undersigned have no wish to dispossess anyone, that they honor the claims on the Roll, that they would pay each in its season out of a common fund of held things.
It says that the Commonwealth is a clumsy landlord and the Review a hungry one, and that the ground, which has been taken so many times, ought at last to be kept by those who would never take it. It says *protection* eleven times. It uses the word *own* once, in the last paragraph, in the negative.
And then it offers me three things.
The first is a seat. *The Board shall be a standing one, and Miss Tolliver shall hold its chair.* The second is a payment, in full, to every name on the Roll, out of the fund, without a hearing, so that no one need stand at a fence and say it aloud. *Without the cost of the saying.* I read that line twice. Wren, beside me, has stopped writing.
The third is a sentence on its own.
*The undersigned will further undertake to purchase from the Hedge, at such price as it shall name, the hour between, and to return it to the claimant, that she may sleep.*
I put the paper down.
“That’s the sweetener,” says Strake gently.
“I know it’s the sweetener.”
“I should tell you the Hedge has not agreed. I have not asked the Hedge. I do not think the Hedge has been asked by anyone. But I put it to you that it is, as a draft, a very precise sentence, and it was not composed by a heron.”
It is a quarter to two in the afternoon. In ten hours and a quarter I will be standing in my mother’s kitchen with my hands gone to wood, trying to hold a cup, and I have done it every night for five months and some, and I will do it every night until October of next year.
I did not say that to anyone. I did not put it in a ledger or a memo. I have a way of crossing the kitchen at five to midnight that does not look like anything, and I thought I did it well.
Jonah has put the dish towel down on the counter. He does not say a word.
---
“I will now give the contrary advice,” says Strake.
He sets down his fork. He squares the folder. He draws a long breath through his nose, like a man about to step off a dock.
“Miss Tolliver, I have read this letter nine times since Monday. It is a lovely letter. I would sign it myself if I were a feather. And if you accept it, you lose.”
“Why?”
“Because it is a sale.” He spreads his hands flat on the counter. “Your whole case, in every hearing since December, has been a single proposition: that the ground is not owned. That it was given, once, to no one, by someone who had no right to give it, and that all the trouble since has come from people telling themselves they hold it.
“The Review wants to own it. The Hedge wanted it kept. The Commonwealth has taken it. You have said, in this room, in front of a stenographer, that you would hold it for nobody. And here is a lovely, humble, tearful offer that you should *sell it to the seven things that love it best.*” He taps the paper. “It is still a sale. A thing that is sold has an owner. Do not mistake the owner for being kind.”
“They said in common,” says Wren.
“Yes. In common is a way of owning where nobody can be found to blame.” He winces, as if he has said something he intends to bill.
“And look at the payment. Every name on the Roll paid out of a fund, *without a hearing.* No claimant on a fence. No hymnal. No hour at the school. No Hal at the gate saying that he did it, and he’s sorry. You would not need a Roll at all. You would have a ledger with a total. A creditor who is paid without being heard is a creditor who has been closed.”
I sit with that.
I think of Lyle Teasdale with his shoe held to his chest, saying that it was only a Tuesday. I think of Billie Garrity Doyle on a muddy bank with a plate on her knee. They were paid. They were also asked, and a fund does not ask.
“That’s it,” I say slowly. “That’s what it’s for.”
“What?”
“The letter. It isn’t a theft. It’s a very kind way of making it so nobody has to say it.”
“That,” says Strake, “is what I was going to say. I am obliged to you for saying it first. It saves me the tenth.”
---
He is not finished, though, and I can see it.
He picks up the envelope. He turns it over, and holds it by one corner at arm’s length under the window, and looks at the flap, and the sound he makes is the one a man makes who has put his hand in the water and found it warm.
“Miss Tolliver. I should like you to look at the back.”
There is a stamp on the back of the envelope, in the flap’s crease, where I would not have looked. It is small, a half-inch, in thin red ink: a line of capitals and a date.
RECEIVED. MAR. 26. 11:59 A.M.
It is eleven minutes to two. The stamp is ink that has not yet gone dry. I put my thumbnail near it and a little dark comes off on the nail.
And the R is whole.
It is the clean R. It is not the broken one with a chipped leg that I have seen on every receipt in this county since October. I have two dies in the coat on my door, one in amber paper and one in green baize, and either would make a letter very like this. I do not carry them today. It does not matter. I know the leg.
“That isn’t either of yours,” says Raymond. He has come to the end of the counter, wiping his hands on his apron, with his big dark face gone entirely still. He holds the flap to the window and lays a thick finger beside the stroke. “The foot’s dead straight, and there’s the little flat on the bowl. That’s the Review’s hand, Mags. There’s a third die.”
“It was stamped at noon,” says Strake, “or eleven fifty-nine, as the case may be. I did not see it stamped. I did not see it at all until I opened the box, which I did in the car, for the third time, by the dome light, and it was there, and it is the reason I have not eaten anything since breakfast.”
“What does it do?” says Wren.
She is looking at me, and I find that I know. It is a very plain sentence once you have it. I have heard it in the Hedge’s own market, from Odile, in a different tone. *A taken, unpaid guest is stamped RECEIVED, so that the line reads paid.*
“It washes it,” I say. “It makes it say *paid.* It’s an offer to purchase the ground, Wren, and an offer that’s received is an offer accepted, and an offer accepted for a hundred and nine parcels at the value found... What’s the value found?”
“What the Roll adds up to,” says Strake. “Under the Commonwealth’s own rule. The value of the taking is the value of what is owed on the ground. It is Ms. Nair’s whole valuation. The more is owed, the more the ground is worth to the Commonwealth, and the more any buyer must pay.”
“And if the debts have been washed.”
“Then nothing is owed,” says Strake. “And the ground is worth what a vacant lot is worth.” He closes his eyes. “And the seven small things sell the Commonwealth’s whole obligation to the Roll at the price of nothing, in the best of faith, to themselves, and the Review stands behind them with a die, and a pocket watch, and a perfectly ordinary appeal.”
---
The diner is very quiet.
A knife clicks in the kitchen, once. I hear Wren’s pencil scratch, and stop, and scratch. Ruth has put the pot down.
“When does it take?” says Jonah.
It is the first thing he has said. It comes out level, in the voice he uses on a rope that is fraying.
“Under the Manual,” says Strake, “an offer received is binding on the party receiving unless dishonored within one day of its stamp, by the presentment of a written reason, at an open sitting, before the Board. That is Section 14. Ms. Nair wrote it into the first draft herself. It was meant for the Review.” He looks at his watch. “One day from eleven fifty-nine, Miss Tolliver, is eleven fifty-nine tomorrow.”
“It’s an open sitting at the Board’s pleasure.”
“Ms. Nair’s pleasure is a great deal larger than people think. She is at the courthouse. She does not, as I understand, go home.”
I look at the letter in my hands. The seven marks lie along the bottom like a row of children who have been told to wait outside. I do not want to dishonor it. I want to say that, to someone, clearly, once. It is a good thing, and it was made by frightened small things who wished me no harm, and I am about to stand up in the lobby of a courthouse and tell the nail and the feather and the well that they have been used.
And it will cost.
I know that without having to be told. A written reason is a written reason. It has to be given in my own hand.
---
“It’s the brass pen,” says Wren.
“Yes.”
“It’ll want something.”
“It always does.”
I take the pen out of my inside pocket, where it has lain against my ribs since October, cold as a spoon in a drawer, and I lay it on the counter between the pie plate and the folder. It is a plain, heavy old pen with a split nib and a worn barrel, and when it touches the Formica the faint rim of frost that comes out of it spreads a quarter inch and stops.
Ruth takes my left hand. She does not say anything. She looks at the palm, where the skin has been peeling since the frame, and holds it in both of hers a moment, and lets it go.
“Eat first,” she says.
I do not eat. I walk to the courthouse with Strake on one side of me and Wren on the other and Jonah a half step behind, and the sun on the Square is the pale clean yellow of the first thaw, and a man on a ladder is hanging the borough’s flower baskets, empty, on the lamp posts. We go in under the tower. The lobby clock is stopped. The stairwell clock strikes two.
Nair is at the long table in the corner with the Manual open, as she is at all hours, and Ms. Szabo has her machine on its folding stand. They have both heard us come. Neither says a word. Nair lifts the Manual an inch off the wood, in the way that a person lifts a glass, and sets it down, and I understand that I have been expected since Monday.
“Section Fourteen,” I say.
“It’s open,” says Nair. “Take your time.”
---
The reason takes eleven lines. I write it at the table in the lobby with the brass pen, on a clean sheet of Commonwealth paper that Ms. Szabo has punched for me, and my hand is my own hand, round and quick, for the first four lines, and then it stops being.
It is not the Hedge’s hour. It is the pen. The cold climbs my wrist, a clean inch at a time, and I hold the barrel through it, as one holds a rail in a stairwell in the dark, and I write.
*Offer dishonored. The ground is not for sale to any person, great or small, in common or alone. It was given to no one, and it will be kept for no one, and it will be paid by hearing. A creditor who is paid without being heard has been closed. I decline to close them. The offer was kind. I want that entered. The offerors were deceived, and I do not hold it against them.*
*Marguerite Tolliver.*
I sign it. The last letter of my name goes down, and I feel the pen take its fee.
It is not a thing I can feel the shape of. It goes out of me as a coin goes out of a pocket, quietly, while you are looking at something else. I lift my hand. Nair reads the sheet.
She reads it all the way through, which no one has yet done without moving her lips, and she initials it, and Ms. Szabo stamps it in the broken R, *RECEIVED, MAR. 26, 2:41 P.M.*, and the stairwell clock, in the corner of the hall, strikes the three-quarter hour, a little late.
“Dishonored,” says Nair. “Entered. Thank you, Miss Tolliver.”
“What did it take?” asks Wren, softly. She has come around the table. She is not looking at the page. She is looking at me.
I think. I go back through what I have. I go through the house on Water Street, and the one good winter, and the first cold week of school, and the bench by the river where Jonah once sat and ate an apple in a way I will never forget. All of it is there. Ruth’s hands. The smell of the kitchen. The boy who told the joke about the owl.
It takes me a long time to find the gap. It is only the winter I learned to skate. There was a pond, I think, and a pair of borrowed blades laced too tight, and a long gray afternoon, and someone’s red scarf. There is a place where I know it happened, as I know that there is a town called Erie. There is nothing at all in the place.
“The winter I learned to skate,” I say.
“Write it down,” says Wren. She already has the book open. “Write down what you know about it. So you’ve got the outline.”
“I don’t know anything about it.”
“Then that’s the outline.” She lifts her pencil. “*Mags learned to skate.* It’s a fact. It’s still true if you didn’t keep it.”
---
They stand on the courthouse steps at four.
I do not see them come. Ms. Szabo does, from the information desk, and says so quietly, and I go out through the double doors into the thin yellow light with the stamped receipt in my hand.
They are sitting on the top step in a row. There is a nail, upright in the stone, trembling. A gray feather, standing on its quill, turning. The thimble, tipped on its side, and the wet round thumbprint of the well, which is a small dark patch in the sandstone, no more.
A burnt match. The bus transfer is a scrap of pale paper stirring in the wind. They do not have faces and I do not need them to. I know what a row of children looks like when it has heard that it was wrong.
“You didn’t sign it for yourselves,” I say. “I know.”
There is a small, dry sound, like a bag being folded. The feather lies down.
“I’m not angry,” I say. “I want that clear. I turned you down because the letter was a trap, not because you were. It was kind. Somebody kind wrote it.” I crouch, with my knee on the cold stone. “Who brought it to you?”
The nail shivers. It does not turn toward the Square, or the Annex, or the tower, where I half expect it. It leans, very slightly, toward the seventh mark, which has not come with the others, which is not on the step at all.
It is on the paper in my hand.
I lift it to the light. The rust-colored thumbprint is as dark as it was at noon. And I see, now, what I did not see at the counter, with the pen cold in my fist and the pie going stale and Strake’s careful voice in my ear.
The mark is not at the foot of the letter. It is on the *back*, under the fold, pressed through from the other side. Somebody laid this letter on top of an older page, a very old page, and set a thumb on it from beneath.
Under the thumbprint, in the paper, as if it were pressed out by the weight of the hand, there is a faint pale line of writing that I cannot read.
I fold the letter in three, and I put it in my outside pocket, where the pale nib lies, and the tag. It is not the first thing that I have been given to carry that did not feel like mine.
“Mags,” says Jonah, behind me, very quietly.
He has not come down the steps. He is standing in the door of the courthouse with his hand on the brass, looking at the pocket where the letter went, and at me, and at the place on my face where I think that he can see something has gone.
“I’ll be at the diner at five to twelve,” he says. “I’ll be at the kitchen door.”
“You don’t have to.”
“I know,” says Jonah. “I want to.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!