Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 87

A Witness for Ellis Marsh

On Fridays at ten, three old men take the corner booth, and have since before I could carry a tray.

Clarence Dunn is ninety-one and orders eggs. Bunk Reiser is eighty-nine and orders the same eggs and complains about them. Stanley Tobin is eighty-eight, the youngest, and orders toast, and brings his own jam in a jar with a cloth lid. They do not say where they have come from.

I learned, at about twelve, that they were wards of the Tamarack County Home for Children, which closed before I was born, and that this was the reason, among others, that nobody ever asked them to leave the booth.

This morning there are four of them. Wren is sitting at the end, on a stool she has dragged over, with her composition book closed on her knees.

“I’ve asked them,” she says, when I bring the coffee.

“Asked what?”

“Whether they knew Ellis Marsh.” She says it with great calm. “I said I was the witness. I said I’d a case, and that I needed three, and that I’d been told by the Manual that a guest with no kin may be answered for by a witness, if she can say what he was owed out of the mouths of three who knew him.” She looks at Clarence. “They said they’d have to think about the toast.”

“We did not say that,” says Clarence.

“You said it with your face.”

“It’s a very expressive face,” says Bunk Reiser, and gets, for his trouble, an elbow from Stanley.

---

I leave them alone. It is the hardest thing I have done all week.

I stand at the pass-through with a dish towel and do not listen, and listen, as Ruth does, with the back of my neck. Wren has her book open. She does not take notes. I think, after a while, that she has understood a thing about this work that I have taken half a winter to learn: that a person who is writing is not listening, and a person who is listening is not writing, and the old men will tell her more if she keeps her pencil in her ear.

It takes forty minutes. At the end, when the eggs have gone cold, Clarence Dunn takes off his glasses, and wipes them on his napkin, and says, in the dry soft voice of a man who has not said the thing in sixty years, “He was the best shot in the Home.”

“Of what?” says Wren.

“Marbles.”

“I know about the marbles.”

“You know he had a bag,” says Bunk. “You don’t know what he was *doing.*” He pushes his plate away. “He was in the last game of the spring. The ring behind the Home, where the creek bends, the one we scratched in the dirt. We’d played it all March, sixteen of us, for the whole of the bag. The big bag. Everybody’s. It was the one game that counted.”

“And Ellis?”

“Was winning,” says Stanley Tobin, quietly. “He’d one shot left. He’d two left in the ring, and a clear lane.”

“And he went into town.”

“On a Friday.” Stanley folds his hands. “To the Market. For a peppermint stick. The matron gave us each a penny on the nineteenth because it was her saint’s day. We all went. He was the one who didn’t come back.”

---

I have heard it told, in pieces. I have never heard it told so plain.

The Home boys had walked to town in a line, in their gray Sunday jackets, for the one penny. They had stood at the stall where the peppermint stick-man kept his candy, under a striped awning, on a street that no longer has a name.

Ellis Marsh had been eight. He had a bag of marbles in his jacket and a shooter in his fist, a big blue one, a *steelie,* that he had won in January from a boy who was now a plumber. He had asked the man for a stick. The man had said, *Come round behind.*

“We thought he’d gone to the privy,” says Bunk. “We waited. We went home. The matron said he’d run off. They looked for a week.”

“Nobody came for him,” says Clarence. “He’d no people. He was left at the Home at two, in a basket, like a pie. He’d the name from the county. Marsh. It’s the name they gave to boys they found by the marsh.” He takes out a handkerchief. “I’ve thought about it all my life. I did not think a girl would ask.”

“The game,” says Wren. “What happened to the game?”

“Nothing.” Clarence blows his nose. “It stayed. We didn’t play it. We couldn’t. There was a ring in the dirt, and two marbles in it, and his shot not taken. It was there all summer. In the fall the matron had it raked.” He puts the handkerchief away. “I’d like to see it finished, miss. That’s the whole of what I know. I’d like to see him take the shot.”

---

The Home stood on a rise above the creek, and now the rise is a lot.

I have driven past it a thousand times. It is a plain, fenced, weedy rectangle on the east edge of town, with a chain link gate, a sign for a lien sale, and a curb where the road bends. Walt Kowalczyk, who has laid it over the plat, says it is parcel ten: a strip at the back, between the old kitchen garden and the creek, never deeded, never taxed, a corner of the Home’s ground that fell, in a surveyor’s error before the first war, between two lots and into no one’s name.

We go on Friday afternoon, at three. All of us.

Nair has the Roll sheet. Szabo has the machine. Tully has the rule, and Brandt the frame, and Strake, with his topcoat over his arm, stands at the gate and says that he is attending in no capacity at all, and has left the pad in the car.

The three old men come in the back of the van, in a row, with their canes between their knees. Ruth has packed sandwiches. She does not come. She says it is a day for the young, and gives me a look that is, I think, a good deal older than she is.

Quill is at the fence.

I did not hear him come. He stands by the gatepost in his long gray coat, a lean pale man with a face like a shut door, holding a drawstring bag in both hands. His cuff, where it shows beneath the coat, reads in faded ink: MAR. 19.

“I bring this,” he says. “I’m told it’s wanted.”

“Is it all of it?” says Wren.

“Thirty-one. There were thirty-two.” He holds it out. “I have never found the shooter.”

---

She does not take it at once.

She looks at the bag. She looks at the three old men, who have come up behind her in the weeds. She looks, for a moment, at me, and I understand that she is not asking leave. She is checking that I am there.

I nod.

“The rule,” says Wren.

Tully steps forward. He has it ready, the brass held level on his two hands. He says, in his thin careful voice, “The Board is sitting on parcel ten. A witness has asked to answer for a guest of the ground. The rule is lent. It will ring for what is true.”

“I am Wren Elm,” says Wren. “I am a witness, third class. I am twelve. I’ll answer for Ellis Marsh, who has no kin, because I’m told a witness may. I’ve been told, by the three who knew him, what he was owed.”

The rule is silent. It waits.

“He was owed a game,” says Wren. She says it softly. “He was owed the end of it. He had a ring and two marbles and a clear lane, and he was called off in the middle, for a stick of candy, by a man who said *come round behind.* He was eight. He has been in the middle of that turn for seventy-eight years.”

The rule rings.

It is a clear, small, bright note, a little like a marble dropped on a stair. It rings a second time, and Quill, at the gate, puts a hand over his eyes.

“Then I’ll finish it,” says Wren.

---

They find the ring by the bend of the creek.

I do not know how. It has been raked, and plowed, and leveled, and grown over with burdock and thistle. But Stanley Tobin walks to it as a man walks to his own front door. He stands at a place in the weeds beside a rotten fence post, and he says, “Here,” and Bunk says, “Further,” and Clarence says, “It was by the post, you fools, I was holding it,” and they argue it out, for a minute, with their canes, in the thin sun.

Wren kneels.

She has a spoon. It is one of Hal’s. I do not know how she came by it, and I will not ask. She scrapes at the dirt in a careful circle, a foot across, and the old men watch her, silent, with their hats in their hands.

A little way below the surface, in the dark soil, there is a line, a faint pale arc, where the dirt is paler than the rest. It is a ring. It has been there for seventy-eight years, scratched with a stick. It has not healed.

She sets the bag at the edge of it.

“Thirty-one,” she says. “And two in the ring. They’d be here.”

They are. She finds them with the tip of the spoon, one, then two, little glass marbles the color of milk, lying where they were left, in the earth, in the middle of a game. She lifts them out and sets them in the arc. She sits back on her heels. She looks, in the sunlight, as small as she is, and as old.

“Where was the shooter?” she says.

“In his fist,” says Clarence.

“Then it’s not in the ring.”

“It’s with him.”

“No.” Wren shakes her head. “He’d have put it down. It was a game. You put your shooter down at the line before you shoot.” She is looking at the ground, not at us. “He’d taken his turn. Hadn’t he? Mr. Tobin. He’d gone first, and rolled, and it was somebody else’s lane, and he was *waiting.*”

Stanley Tobin makes a sound.

“He’d walked away,” says Wren. “To the fence. To think. Boys do. He put the steelie down on the post.” And she turns, quite slowly, and looks at the post, a leaning gray stump with a flat top, three feet from the ring, with a hollow in it like a bowl.

---

There is a marble in the hollow.

I do not see it until she lifts her hand. It has been there so long that it has grown into the post, a drop of glass the size of a walnut, blue, with a white swirl inside it like a cloud in a window, held in a cup of gray wood that has closed around it for seventy-eight years. Rain has run over it. Frost has cracked the wood and not the glass. It is, quite perfectly, a bright blue steelie, on a post.

“It was *waiting,*” says Wren. “He didn’t take it. He said he’d be back.”

She lifts it.

It comes out of the wood with a small dry sound, like a tooth from a gum. She holds it in her palm, in the light, and then, without a word, she puts it in the old man’s hand. Not Clarence’s. She has looked at the three of them and chosen, as I should not have thought to, Stanley Tobin, the youngest, who has not said a word since the ring.

“You,” she says.

“I couldn’t.”

“It’s your turn.” Her voice shakes, only slightly. “I’m answering for him. I can’t carry it. A witness can answer, and she can’t pay. The one who owes has to. And it’s—somebody has to say *go.*” She wipes her nose on the back of her hand. “You owe him that. All three of you. You didn’t play.”

Stanley closes his fingers over the blue marble. He looks at the other two. Clarence nods. Bunk, with a shaking hand, says, “Go on, Stan. You’ve the best eye.”

He kneels. It takes him a long time. He is eighty-eight, and the creek bank is damp, and he has to put down his cane and take the arm of Bunk, who lets him. He puts his fist to the dirt at the edge of the ring, with the steelie between his thumb and finger, and the whole bright afternoon holds still.

“Ellis,” says Stanley Tobin. “Your shot.”

---

He does not throw it. He is too old. He rolls it, the way a very old man rolls a marble to a child, with a small flat motion of the wrist.

It travels four inches, over the pale scratched line. It goes into the ring. It strikes the first of the milk-white marbles with a soft glass *tock,* and knocks it out of the circle onto the grass. It stops. The second, in the middle, trembles, and rolls, and slowly, as if it had made up its mind, follows. It lies, at the edge, beside the first.

The rule rings.

It is not a note. It is a long, bright, rising sound, as of a thing going upward on a string. From the weeds along the fence, from the thistle and the burdock and the dry gold of last year’s grass, there comes a small sound that I know now. A child’s laugh. It is high and short and astonished, a laugh of a boy who has just made a shot.

“Did you see?” says a voice.

It is not loud. It comes from nowhere, from the ring, from the post, from the long afternoon. It is the voice of an eight-year-old with a cold. “Did you see it? *Both.*”

“We saw,” says Stanley, and begins to cry.

“Who’s that?” says the voice. “Is that Stan?” There is a pause. “You’re *old.*”

“I know.”

“You’re all old.” It says it with wonder. “Where’s the matron? Is it dinner? I’ve still to—” It stops. “I’ve won. Haven’t I? I was winning.”

“You won,” says Wren.

“Who are you?”

“Wren Elm. I’m the witness. I answered for you.” She is on her knees in the dirt with the spoon in her hand, and her face is wet, and she does not wipe it. “I’m sorry it was late.”

“It’s all right,” says the voice. “I didn’t mind. I was only waiting for the end.” And then, very faintly, going, with the courtesy of a child who has been taught not to leave without saying: “Thank you. You’re good.”

---

The Roll sheet has a line for him. Nair fills it.

She does it herself, with the cap off her pen, standing on the creek bank in her state coat. She does not hand the pencil to Wren. She says, without looking up, “A witness who has answered for a guest is a party to the entry, and cannot record it. It is in the Manual. I’m sorry.”

“I know,” says Wren.

“It is only for this one.”

“I know.” She is holding her pencil. She has taken it from behind her ear, and she looks at it as one looks at a thing one is about to put down. “I’d rather. It isn’t mine. It’s his.” She holds it out. “You’ll want a pencil. Yours is a pen.”

Nair takes it.

She writes. I watch the line go onto the sheet in a hard clear hand: *Parcel 10. Ellis Marsh, taken the nineteenth of March, aged eight. Owed: the end of a game. Paid by those who did not play, by their own hands. Answered for by Wren Elm, witness. Received.* And under it, after a pause: *In part. He did not leave.*

“He didn’t?” says Wren.

“The low end is not the ground’s to release,” says Nair. “It is the Hedge’s. He answered. He did not go.” She looks up. “He asked, I think, to hear the rest of the game.”

I do not understand. I look at the ring in the dirt. The two marbles, on the grass, are gone. In the place where they lay there is nothing. In the middle of the ring, in the dark soil, there is the blue steelie, quite alone, as if somebody had set it down for the next turn.

---

Odile is at the fence when we leave.

I do not know how long she has been there. She stands in her long dark coat, at the corner of the lot, beyond the gate, in the thin light, a tall straight woman with her hands folded and her face, as always, turned a little aside. She does not come in. She does not cross the line. She has never crossed a line that was not hers to cross.

“Miss Elm,” she says.

Wren stops. She has the spoon in her hand, and dirt to her elbows.

“I wished to say,” says Odile, in her low even voice, “that in all the years I counted, I did not once say *thank you* to a person who had paid a thing back. It was not in the book.” She is looking at the gatepost. “It is, I think, in the book now.”

“You’re welcome,” says Wren, uncertainly.

“There is a boy named Tommy Haas.” Odile’s mouth does something. “He has not said a word in seventy years. I should be obliged if you would not answer for him.” A pause. “I should like to see if I can.”

She goes. She goes down the road in the afternoon light, without a sound. Wren stands at the gate, a small stained figure, with her hands hanging, and does not seem to know what to do with them.

“I haven’t got a pencil,” she says.

“I know.”

“It’s the first time. I always have it.” Her voice cracks, just once. “I don’t know what to hold.”

I put the dish towel in her hand. I do not know why I have it. It is in my coat pocket, where it has been since breakfast. She looks at it, and at me, and takes it, and holds it in both her fists, hard, as one holds a rope, and we walk back to the van together, down the long gravel road, and nobody says a word.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!