Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 88

The Court of Common Pleas

Strake files the Answer at three minutes to four on Monday, which he says is the only civilized hour to file anything, and Mr. Voss stamps it without looking up.

It is a page and a half. I have read it eleven times. It does not say that I am the owner, and it does not say that I am not. It says, in six numbered paragraphs, in Strake’s dry and perfect prose, that the Respondent *denies that she holds the parcels in her own right; denies that the parcels are without a holder; avers that the title of the ground has stood since the nineteenth of January in the keeping of a depositary; and will produce, at the hearing, the deposit book and the half of the slip that evidences it.*

It does not say what I am. It says what I am not, three times, and leaves the rest as a ledger leaves a column, with the ruling done and the figure blank.

“It will not satisfy him,” says Strake, on the courthouse steps.

“I know.”

“It will not satisfy the Court.” He puts the file receipt in his breast pocket and pats it. “But it is true, and it does not close a door. That is the best an answer can do, when the client has not yet been told her own name.” He puts on his hat. “Point four, drafting. Point two, filing. Point one, a very cold feeling in the stomach, which I do not propose to bill.”

---

The Court of Common Pleas sits on the second floor of the courthouse, in a long high room with tall windows and a ceiling of pressed tin painted the color of weak tea.

I have been in it twice in my life, for a jury notice and for a funeral. The benches are oak. The bar is brass. Behind the bench, where in a different country there would be a flag, there is a portrait of a county judge from a century ago, with a beard, who looks as if he had been asked a question and was thinking it over.

By ten on Tuesday the room is full.

I had not expected it. The Company has come, in its dress uniforms, in their dark blue coats with the brass buttons that I have seen only at funerals, thirty of them, the Chief at the front with his cap under his arm. Dutch Eckert is in the second row, with his cane and his service bar.

The Auxiliary has come in navy cardigans. Ruth sits among them, in her good coat, straight-backed, with her purse on her knee, and does not look at me, which is a kindness.

On the other side there are three men in suits I do not know, and a young woman with a laptop who is, Strake whispers, a deputy attorney general named Garrity. And at the aisle, in the very front, with his silver head bent and his watch chain across his waistcoat, sits Ambrose Sproule. He has a pad and a pencil. He is writing nothing. He looks up, once, as I pass, and bows, and the whole room sees him do it.

Kerr is at the back, by the door. He has come alone. He sits with his hat on his knees and his eyes on the floor.

“All rise,” says the tipstaff, “for the Honorable Alma Brenneman.”

---

She is a small woman of sixty with iron-gray hair cut square, and half-glasses, and a black robe that is a little too long. She takes the bench without ceremony. She looks at the crowded room with the flat, tired attention of a person who has spent twenty-four years on the same chair and has seen every kind of crowd, and then she says, “Sit,” and they do.

“This is a petition for review and for declaratory relief,” says the Judge. “In the matter of a Declaration of Taking, and the order of a Board of View, and the title to a hundred and nine parcels in this county and four others.” She puts down the file. “I have read it. I have read the answer. I have read it twice, because the first time I assumed that the clerk had omitted a page.”

“Your Honor—” begins Garrity.

“Sit down, Ms. Garrity, I’m not finished.” The Judge turns a page. “I am told by the Prothonotary that this is the first petition filed in this court on behalf of a body called the Asset Review of the Western Division since before the Prothonotary was born. I should like to know what it is.”

Garrity stands again. “The Review is an agency of the Commonwealth, Your Honor. Chartered—”

“By whom?”

“By the Assembly. In—” She looks at her laptop. “It’s a little unclear.”

“It is entirely unclear,” says the Judge. “I have looked. It is not in the Pennsylvania Code. It is mentioned once, in a footnote of a nineteenth century opinion, as *a body that has not been abolished.*” She takes off her glasses. “I will hear it, because it has been before me properly. But I should like it understood that I do not take a body’s existence on its own word.”

I do not dare to look at Sproule. I hear him, in the front row, very gently, set down his pencil.

---

They begin with the form.

Garrity is good. I see it at once. She is thirty, quick, with a clear hard voice and a way of laying a paper down as if she were setting a table. She calls the first witness at ten forty, and it is Lena Dube, in her good blazer, with her hard hat left in the truck, and she sits down in the box and puts her hand on the book as a woman puts her hand on a stove she has been told is off.

“You are an assistant district bridge engineer?”

“I am.”

“You issued, on the tenth of April, a Class Three finding at Structure forty-oh-one-seventeen, and removed a facing stone?”

“I did.”

“And on completion you took a receipt from the Respondent?”

“I did.” Dube’s mouth is a thin line. “On the Department’s form.”

“Would you identify the yellow copy?”

It is passed up. It is a flimsy sheet the color of mustard, and Dube holds it as one holds a bill. “That’s the district copy.”

“Read the line marked *received by.*”

“*Tolliver, owner slash agent.*”

“And no qualification.”

“There’s—” Dube stops. “On that copy, no.”

“Thank you. Your Honor, the Commonwealth offers the district copy as evidence that the Respondent took delivery of a stone, at the hands of a state officer, in the capacity of owner of the ground.” Garrity sits. “No further questions.”

“Cross?” says the Judge.

Strake rises. It is, I think, the first time in his life that I have seen him stand up to speak without a pad.

---

“Ms. Dube,” he says. “Was there a pink copy?”

“There was.”

“What did it say on the line?”

“*Mags Tolliver. By next friend of the ground.*”

“In whose hand?”

“Hers.” Dube looks at me. “In pencil. I watched her write it. It was long. I told her the box was short.”

“And why does the yellow copy not say so?”

“Because it’s a carbon set.” She says it tiredly, to the Judge, as one who has said it to a district supervisor. “The top sheet is the pink. The Department’s file copy. You write on it with a pencil and the pressure goes through to the yellow and then to the white, on carbon backing. The yellow’s an impression. It takes the box. It doesn’t take the whole line if the line’s longer than the box.” She holds up the yellow. “The pink is the original. The yellow is what’s left on the pad.”

“A shadow,” says the Judge.

“Yes, Your Honor.”

“Of the original.”

“Yes.”

“And the original says *by next friend.*” The Judge takes off her glasses, and rubs the bridge of her nose, and puts them back. “Ms. Garrity, is the Commonwealth offering the shadow as better evidence than the thing that cast it?”

“It is the version the Department’s file will bear, Your Honor—”

“That is not an answer.” The Judge writes something. “The pink will come in. The yellow will come in as a duplicate, to be given the weight of a shadow. Ms. Dube, you may step down, and I should like to say that I do not often thank a state engineer for her candor.” A pause. “I do now.”

Dube steps down. She walks the length of the aisle with her eyes straight ahead and sits in the back row, next to Kerr, who, without a word, shifts to give her room.

---

Sproule does not seem troubled. He has risen, very slightly, as the Judge speaks, and sits again. He writes a line. I see Garrity glance at him and he shakes his head, a quarter inch, and she does not call a second witness.

“The Commonwealth rests on the receipt,” says Garrity.

“And on the petition,” says the Judge. “Which is a good deal wider than a receipt. Mr. Strake, I don’t believe I’ve seen you in this courtroom in eleven years.”

“Twelve, Your Honor.”

“You had a grayer head.”

“I had a larger practice.”

“And now you have a Respondent.” She looks at me. “Miss Tolliver. Will you stand?”

I stand. It is a long way up. The room is very quiet, and I can hear the dry whisper of the Auxiliary’s cardigans, and the ticking, above the door, of a clock that has never been stopped. It strikes me that it is the first clock in this building that I have trusted in six months.

“I’m going to ask you two questions,” says the Judge. “I should like you to answer them as you would at your own counter. Are you the owner of this ground?”

“No.”

I hear a breath go out of the Company, behind me. I do not turn.

“Do you disclaim it?”

“No, Your Honor.”

“Those are the only two doors,” says Judge Brenneman. She does not say it unkindly. “The Commonwealth has built a room with two doors. If you are an owner, you are answerable for what is owed. If you are not, and say so, it is nobody’s, and falls to the Commonwealth. You have said you are not an owner, and you will not say *nobody’s.* So I must ask the thing the Commonwealth has been politely not asking.” She folds her hands. “What are you?”

---

I have rehearsed it. I have said it to Strake and to Ruth and to the bathroom mirror. I have stood in the Room Below with the rule, and tried it, a dozen different ways, and heard the bell give a hollow note.

I open my mouth. And what comes out is the truth.

“I don’t know yet.”

The room goes still.

“I know what I’m not,” I say. “I’ve said it. I know there’s a word, and that it’s in a book, and that half of it is on a slip in a tin box, and half of it is somewhere I haven’t been. I know that a woman I never met kept the book for me, and that she’s written *ask her.* I know that I was asked.”

I swallow. “I’d like to tell the Court what I am. I haven’t got the word. I’m sorry. It isn’t a thing I’d care to guess.”

“Thank you,” says the Judge, gravely.

“It’s not a good answer.”

“No.” She nearly smiles. “It’s an honest one, which in my experience is rarer than a good one.” She looks at the room. “I see, Mr. Strake, that you propose to put in a deposit book.”

“With Your Honor’s leave.”

“Where is it?”

“In the Room Below, Your Honor.”

“I beg your pardon?”

“The county’s Room Below,” says Strake, with perfect composure. “Beneath the courthouse lobby. It is reached through a door at the foot of the Recorder’s oak, by a lift. It contains the old registers of the county, and a drawer. The deposit book is in the drawer.” He pauses. “It has not been removed from the room. It is, I am told, a thing that will not be.”

“Mr. Tully,” says the Judge. “Is that true?”

Tully, in the second row, has gone the color of milk. He rises with the rule in his two hands. “It’s—Your Honor, it’s the Recorder’s room. It isn’t on the plan. It’s—yes. It’s true.”

“I have been on this bench twenty-four years,” says Judge Brenneman, “and I have been in this building for thirty-one, and I did not know there was a basement.”

“It’s not a basement.”

“What is it?”

“It’s—” He looks at me, wildly. “It’s where the county keeps what it owes.”

---

The Judge looks at him for a long moment. Then she looks at the Company, in their navy coats, and at the old clock above the door, and at the portrait of the bearded judge, who goes on thinking it over.

“The Court will view it,” she says.

“Your Honor—” Garrity is on her feet. “The Commonwealth objects. A view of an unrecorded—”

“You will have the right to attend. Mr. Sproule, too, if he has not yet been in it, though I rather suspect he has.” The Judge does not look at him. “We will continue the hearing to Tuesday next, the twenty-eighth, at ten, and sit it below the lobby, if the lift will bear me. I am not a light woman.” She writes. “In the meantime, I am going to make an order, and I’d like it understood that I make it with some reluctance.”

I wait.

“The Respondent will file, by noon on Friday, a statement of the capacity in which she holds. Not a pleading. A sentence. One.” She lifts a finger. “I will not take *I do not know.* I will not take *a friend of the ground,* which is a role, not a capacity. I will not take *the person it was left to,* which is a history. I want a word that goes in the space between *owner* and *nobody,* and if she cannot find it, I am going to have to treat the silence as a disclaimer, which is what the Commonwealth has asked, and which would make Count Three the law of the case.”

She looks up. “I’m sorry, Miss Tolliver. It is the only thing the Court can do. It is not a threat. It is a clock.”

---

They do not leave at once.

The room stands. The Company files out by rows, in their blue coats, and each of them, as he passes the rail, looks at me, a quick sidelong look, like a man checking a gauge. The Chief nods. Dutch Eckert does not. He walks the whole length of the aisle with his cane, stiff and slow, and stops at the end of my row, and says, without turning his head, in his old dry rasp, “Friday, then.”

“Friday.”

“Do not say it to be said.” He goes on. “A word is a thing you have to have *paid.*”

Garrity packs her laptop. Sproule rises, and buttons his jacket, and comes, with his easy tread, along the aisle to the rail, and stops there, an arm’s length from me. He is smiling. It is not a cruel smile. It is the smile of a man at the end of a good chess game who is sorry that the other side is so near to the edge.

“You did very well,” he says.

“I didn’t answer.”

“No. And that is the loveliest thing about it.” He puts his hand on the brass. “A person who knows what she is can be told she is wrong. A person who does not can only be asked, on Friday, at noon, to guess. I do admire it.” He takes out his watch, and looks at it, and puts it away. “It’s still stopped. Do you know, Miss Tolliver, I think it is *waiting.* I have begun to think that it is on your side.”

“Whose side are you on?” I say.

“The side of the thing that can be held,” says Ambrose Sproule, quite gently. “I’ve never understood why people find it so hard to say.”

He goes out. I stand by the rail until the room is empty, with the dust going up in the long tall windows, and Strake beside me with his hat, not billing. Then I go down the stairs, and across the lobby, past the counter and the oak, and out into the thin bright afternoon, with three days, and a half of a slip, and a tin box that has already begun to wait.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!