Courtroom Two is the small one, at the back of the second floor, with a low ceiling and a drinking fountain and room for forty people if none of them is large.
Hal is large. He sits at the respondent’s table in the cinder-colored coat, in a chair that was not built for him, with his hat on his knee and his hands folded on it, and the whole table seems to lean a little toward him, as a table does when a heavy man sits at one end.
He has not been to a court in four hundred years. He told me so in the corridor, at a quarter to ten, in a low rough voice. “The last was a manor court. I was fined for a goose.”
“Did you pay?”
“I ate it.” He turned the hat. “It was a bad goose.”
Strake sits beside him. He has brought a briefcase, which he does not open, and a legal pad, on which he has written, in a large hand, *Point one: a dragon.* He has not struck it. He has underlined it twice.
“You will say as little as possible,” he says to Hal, without moving his lips.
“I’ll say what’s true.”
“That,” says Strake, “is what I am afraid of.”
---
I sit in the second row with Ruth.
The room fills slowly. The Company has come, though it has no stake, in its blue coats, and fills the third and fourth benches in a long dark line. Dube is there, and Nair, and Brandt, and Raymond, who has left Dee with the diner’s frame and come with his cap in his hand, and the three old men from the Home, who have taken the back bench by the door without being asked and sit in a row with their canes.
Kerr is in the corner, in the gray raincoat, with a small notebook open on his knee. He has been appointed to watch. He is watching Sproule.
Sproule has not come. He is not at the petitioner’s table. Garrity sits there alone, with her laptop shut and a single manila folder, and when I look at her she looks, with what I take to be relief, away.
“All rise.”
The Judge comes in at ten, in the long black robe, and sits, and takes off her glasses, and says, “Be seated.” She looks at the shape at the end of the respondent’s table. She looks at it for some time.
“Docket one-one-four-one,” she says. “In the matter of the Application of the Commonwealth, by the Asset Review of the Western Division, to reserve, as a creature found at large upon the Commonwealth’s lands, one—” she looks at the paper, “—*Halvard. Of the ridge.*”
“Himself,” says Hal.
“I beg your pardon?”
“I’m to say *Himself,*” says Hal, with great dignity. “It’s the end of the name.”
---
Garrity makes the application. She does it briefly, in the clear hard voice, from a prepared page. The Reservation Act, she says, a statute older than the Code, gives the Commonwealth the power to take into custody *any wild animal, or creature of an uncertain species, found at large upon unappropriated land of the Commonwealth, and having no known owner,* and to hold it for the protection of the public and of itself.
She says the Review has reason to believe that the respondent is such a creature. She says that he has, on a number of occasions, burned a barn, devoured a field, kept an unlicensed hoard, and taken from the Commonwealth’s land a number of articles of value.
“The petition recites,” says the Judge, “that he is a thing which has lived on the Commonwealth’s ground for four hundred years.”
“Yes, Your Honor.”
“How does the Commonwealth know that?”
“It is the respondent’s own account.”
“Given to whom?”
“To Miss Tolliver,” says Garrity. “In a number of conversations. As reported.”
“By whom?”
Garrity stops. I see her look down at her folder, and I understand that she has been handed a page by a man who is not in the room, and does not wish to say where it came from.
“I will not ask,” says the Judge. “Mr. Strake?”
---
He rises.
I have thought, for months, that Strake is a man for whom the law is a kind of weather: a thing one reads, and dresses for, and complains of. I see now that I was wrong. It is, for him, a house. He stands up in it as one stands in the hall of a home he has lived in all his life, and has not been asked in a very long time to show a guest.
“Your Honor,” he says. “I should like to begin with the notice.”
“Go on.”
“The Application was served, I understand, upon the respondent, on the thirteenth of this month, at the ridge, by a courier of the Review. I have the return of service. It is in the court’s file, and I should like to read the third line.” He lifts it. “*Served personally upon Halvard, of the ridge, who accepted the paper, read it twice, and said, ‘As it were.’*”
“Personal service,” says the Judge.
“It is the only kind that is good against a person. One does not, Your Honor, serve a notice upon a heifer. One does not read it to a stray cat and enter that the cat accepted. The law of process, which is the oldest part of the law, assumes at every step that the thing served is *someone.* That it can hear. That it can read. That it can answer to its name.”
He sets down the paper. “The Commonwealth served my client by name, at his residence, in the form for a natural person. It cannot now be heard to say that it served a creature.”
“It served him that he might be heard.”
“Then he is heard.” Strake bows slightly. “And a person, Your Honor, is not *found at large.* He is at home. He has an address, a barn, a spring, a road, and a reputation. He is not *without a known owner,* because the only claimant to the title of Halvard, of the ridge, has appeared in this room to dispute it.” He glances at Hal. “He is not an unappropriated thing. He is his own.”
---
“There is a difficulty,” says the Judge.
“There is, Your Honor.”
“I do not know what he is.”
“No.” Strake sits down. “I do not either. I have been his counsel for eighteen hours.”
“Then I should like to ask him.”
It is very still in the little room. Hal looks at his hat. He looks at the high window, and the late April sun, and the elm on the courthouse lawn, which has put out, in the night, its first small leaves. He sets the hat on the table, very carefully, with the crown down, and stands.
I had forgotten how tall he is. His head is a foot from the ceiling. The coat hangs on him like a hide, and the light from the window picks out the gray of his hair and the long worn creases of his face, the face of something that has been outdoors for a great while, and, behind it, so faint that I could not say I saw it, a weight.
“State your name,” says the Judge.
“Halvard.”
“Your surname.”
“I haven’t one.” He says it without defiance. “I’d the name of the ridge, and the name of a man I took a farm from in the seventeenth century, and the one on the deed, which was Ashcombe. They were never mine. I took them because the clerk asked.” He turns the brim of the hat on the table. “I was Halvard before there was a clerk.”
“Where are you from?”
“The ridge.”
“Before that.”
“The north.” A pause. “There isn’t a word for it in English that doesn’t sound like a story.”
“Mr. Ashcombe—”
“Halvard,” says Hal. “If you please.”
“Halvard.” The Judge folds her hands. “The Commonwealth says you are a creature of an uncertain species. I do not wish to put words in your mouth. But a court that is asked to decide whether a being is a person is entitled, I think, to know what he says he is. Would you tell me?”
---
It is a long moment. I hear Ruth, beside me, take a breath.
“A dragon,” says Hal.
It is a small word, in a small room. I think, for a second, that it has not been heard. Then I hear the Company, behind me, a faint dry rustle, like wind in a field of corn, and someone’s cane falls on the floor, and the court reporter, a young man in a cardigan, looks up from his machine with his mouth open and his hands in the air.
“I’d rather not have said it,” says Hal, in the same flat voice. “In a county courthouse. It isn’t dignified. I only say it because I was asked.” He looks at the Judge. “I’m old. I’m a good deal bigger than I look. I’m not a thing you should be able to put in a pen. But I know that I’ve done harm. I’ve burned a barn. I took a man’s life by it, and I’ve said so, and I’ve paid in what the ground will take.”
He draws a breath. “I’d not ask you to excuse that. I’d ask you to hear me as the one it was done *by.*”
“The record will show,” says the Judge, slowly, to the young man in the cardigan, who has begun to type again with his eyes shut, “that the witness has stated that he is a dragon. And that the Court takes no position on zoology.”
“Thank you, Your Honor.”
“Sit down, Halvard.”
He sits. The chair groans. He takes up his hat, and holds it, and I see that his hands, on its brim, are quite steady, and that his eyes, for the first time since I have known him, are not looking at the floor.
---
Garrity has one witness.
She says so quietly, from the table, and I think that she would rather not call him. She reads it from the folder. “The Commonwealth calls Mr. Dutch Eckert.”
He comes forward from the third bench, in his Company jacket and his service bar, with the cane. He does not look at Hal. He takes the oath standing, with his hand on the book and his chin up, and he lowers himself into the box as a man lowers himself into a cold bath.
“Mr. Eckert, you are a retired member of the Ketterly Volunteer Fire Company?”
“I am.”
“You were present at a fire at the Ashcombe barn, on the night of the seventeenth of October, the night of the fire?”
“I was.” His voice is a dry rasp. “I held the nozzle.”
“For how long?”
“Nine hours.”
“Would you tell the Court what you saw of the respondent?”
“Objection,” says Strake, rising. “The question assumes.”
“I’ll hear it,” says the Judge. “Mr. Eckert, you may answer.”
He is quiet for a time. The old hand on the cane tightens.
“I’d been told,” says Dutch, “in the car, by the Chief, who’d been told by dispatch, that it was the Ashcombe place and that the old man was in the yard. I thought, *he’ll be drunk.* I thought, *there’ll be a body.* There were forty of us. We came up the hill with the lights going and the tank running dry. And the barn was—”
He stops. He looks at his own knuckles. “I’ve seen a lot of fires, Your Honor. I’ve never seen one go up *from the inside.* From the ground. As if the floor had decided.”
“And the respondent?”
“Was standing in the yard.”
---
“He had no hat on,” says Dutch.
“What was he doing?”
“Nothing.” The rasp thickens. “He was standing in the mud in the light of the thing, with his hands at his sides, and the sparks coming down. He didn’t run. I’d not have blamed him. Anyone else would’ve run. A thing that burns a barn and kills a man, you’d say, it’ll be gone before the trucks. A *creature.*” He lifts his head. “He stayed.”
“Mr. Eckert—”
“He stayed nine hours. He stood at the edge of the yard while I held that hose on a wall that wouldn’t go out, and he said, at about three in the morning, to me, in the dark, *Is there someone to be told?* And I said, *There’s a captain gone in.* And he said, *I know.*”
The old man’s mouth works. “And then he said, *I’ll wait.* And he did. He stood there until it was light. He stood there when they took the roof down, and he stood there when the Chief went to the house to tell her, and he stood there when she came, in her coat, at six, and looked at him.”
I have my hand in Ruth’s. I do not know when I took it. It does not move.
“I have asked myself for most of my life what kind of creature does that,” says Dutch Eckert. “A wild animal doesn’t wait. It goes. It goes *quick.* It’s the one thing it does.” He turns, at last, and looks full at Hal, down the length of the little room, with a long hard rheumy stare.
“I’d not say I forgive him. I’m not a man who does. But I’ll say what I saw, since I’m asked. It wasn’t a creature, Your Honor. It was a man who’d done a thing, and was too ashamed to leave.”
---
Nobody speaks.
Garrity, at the petitioner’s table, has put down her pencil. I see her look at the folder, and at the empty chair where a man with a silver head should be, and then, with a small decisive movement, close it.
“No further questions,” she says.
“Mr. Strake?”
“None, Your Honor.” Strake’s voice is not quite steady. “I think the witness has said it.”
The Judge writes. She writes for a long time, in the silence, with her half-glasses on the end of her nose, and when she has finished she reads the page over and sets it down.
“The Application is dismissed,” she says.
There is a sound, in the room, like a held breath going out.
“I make no finding as to species. I make no finding as to whether the respondent is, in the sense of the Reservation Act, a creature. I find only that the Commonwealth has served him as a person, by name, in the form for a person; that he has appeared by counsel; that he has answered to his name in open court; and that a thing which does all of these is not, within the meaning of the Act, *found at large* or *without a known owner.* It is, if I may say so, found at home.”
She takes off her glasses. “I will add that I have rarely heard so full an account of a defendant’s character from a witness called to destroy it. I do not think it was the Commonwealth’s purpose.”
“Your Honor—” begins Garrity.
“It is not your fault, Ms. Garrity. It is the fault of whoever drafted the petition and did not come to see it heard.” She rises. “We are adjourned.”
---
They do not leave at once. They never do.
Hal stands where he is, with the hat in his hands. He does not move. He is looking at the floor again, but it is different: he is looking at it as a man looks at a place he is about to step across. Then he turns, with a heavy, careful, slow motion, and goes down the aisle between the benches to the third row, where an old man in a blue jacket is sitting, with a cane, looking at nothing.
“Dutch,” says Hal.
“Halvard.”
“I’d not ask you to—”
“No.” The old man does not look up. “Don’t. I’d not know what to say.”
“I only wished to—”
“Say it,” says Dutch. “If you must. And keep it short.”
Hal stands in the aisle, a head higher than the benches, in the thin light from the window. He says it, in the end, in a voice I have never heard from him, hardly above a whisper, as one says a word in a church that is not one’s own.
“It was mine. Every minute of it. And I’m sorry I was the one who stood in the yard.”
Dutch Eckert looks at his cane for a long moment.
“I’d have preferred,” he says, “that it was you who went in.”
“So would I.”
“Aye.” The old man nods, once. “Well. It wasn’t. And here we are.” He puts out his hand, not to shake, but flat, palm up, between them, on his knee, as a man shows an empty hand to a horse. “Sit down, Halvard. You’re blocking the Chief.”
---
Sproule is waiting in the corridor.
I see him as we come out, in the pale light of the staircase window, with his umbrella furled and his hat in his hand. He has not been in the room. He has stood, I think, at the door of it, for an hour, with his ear to the oak, and he does not look in the least displeased.
He bows. He bows to the Judge, as she goes by, with her robe over her arm, and to Strake, and to Kerr, who does not return it.
“A very full account,” says Ambrose Sproule, “of a creature’s character. I am glad to have heard it.”
“You didn’t come,” says Strake.
“I did not need to. I had sent the better argument.” He smiles his mild, pleasant smile. “I had hoped, you understand, that the Reservation would fail. It was drafted to. It is a poor statute, and I think the Court has seen through it.”
He takes out an envelope, a long cream one with a blue wafer, and holds it out, not to me, but to the Judge, who has stopped on the stair. “I have a second paper. Ms. Garrity will file it this afternoon. I thought it only courteous to hand it up.”
“What is it?” says the Judge.
“A notice of the Commonwealth’s claim.” He inclines his head. “To the waters of the old bed under Sawmill Run. I am told, Your Honor, that since Saturday morning a stream has been running, on the Commonwealth’s soil, in a channel which has been dry for two hundred years, from a spring on private ground to a lock on the Allegheny, without a permit.”
“A stream,” says the Judge.
“It is a water of the Commonwealth. They all are. It is in the Constitution.” He opens his hands. “By the Water Code, every spring, stream and river in the state belongs to the people, who hold it in trust. I have just learned, Miss Tolliver, that the Commonwealth owns a river.” He looks at me, and the watch chain on his waistcoat gleams. “I thought you should be the first to know. It will be heard on the twenty-eighth of May.”
He goes down the stairs. I hear his shoes, on every step, unhurried, a good even tread, all the way to the bottom. And at the bottom, on the cold marble, by the revolving door, a cork float is lying on its side in a very small, very still puddle, which has no right to be there, and does not move.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!