Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 2

The Man Who Does Not Receive

The little door was shut in the morning. Not merely shut, but bolted on the nursery side with the bolt I had thought was oiled, and the curtain hung straight over it as if nothing had ever stirred it.

I had not shot that bolt. I put my hand flat on the wood, which was cold, and then I got dressed, because there is a limit to what a person can learn from a door.

Rosalind was already at the window with her ledger, watching the river go from black to the color of a pewter spoon. “You didn’t scream,” she said. “That’s two points.”

“What do I win?”

“Nothing. It’s a tally, not a game.” She wrote something small. “Miss Fenn screamed. Miss Amsel prayed. Miss Barrow cried, but only into the washstand, so she was very nearly brave.”

“She came,” said Fitch from the rug, where he had resumed his buttons. “Mamma came. Did you see her?”

“Fitch dreams,” said Rosalind, without lifting her pen.

“Fitch does not dream,” said Fitch, with dignity, “he reports.”

I said I would think about it, which is what I say when I mean to look into a thing without promising anything. Rosalind’s pen stopped for exactly one second. I noticed, and she noticed me noticing, and we went down to breakfast like two duelists who have agreed on a distance.

Mrs. Dunning showed me the house before ten. Blackwater Hall had been built by a man who believed a staircase should make a point, and it had four, each darker than the last. The rooms smelled of beeswax and coal smoke and, underneath, something sharper and cleaner that I could not name until the third landing. It was cold. Not the cold of a draft but the clean, mineral cold of a place built over a great store of ice.

“East wing is shut,” said Mrs. Dunning, walking ahead with her keys. “Pond is shut, though it has no gate to shut it with. The cellar passage you’ll not need. The children keep to the garden wall. Mind that one too.”

“Which one?”

“The wall, miss. It is not so sound as it looks.”

In every room I enter I look for three wrong things. It is a game I play to keep my hands still. In the great hall they were a clock that had been wound that morning in a house with no one at leisure to wind it, a vase of chrysanthemums with the stalks cut cleanly by someone who loved flowers, and a stair carpet worn threadbare along the left side, as though the people who used it were in the habit of keeping to the wall and listening.

At eleven o’clock Mr. Caldwell received me, which Mrs. Dunning informed me was not his habit.

His study was at the back, over the river. The grate was laid and unlit. It was colder than the passage. Three wrong things: that, and a ship’s model of an ice plow on the sill, which was the only toy in the room, and a woman’s steel pen laid across the blotter, exactly square to the edge, as if someone were expected back to use it.

He stood at the window with his back to me. When he turned, I saw a man of perhaps thirty-eight, tall, with a face that had been left out in weather and grey coming in at the temples in two clean wings. His hands were clasped behind him like a boy’s hiding stolen apples. He did not ask me to sit. I understood presently that he did not sit himself, and that this was a rule of the room.

“Miss Whitlock.”

“Mr. Caldwell.”

“Mrs. Dunning chose you out of four applicants. I read your letter.” He looked at me with a steady, tired attention. “Mrs. Lyle was unusually frank.”

I felt it go down my back like a drop of cold water. My forgery had not been frank. My forgery had been dull, which is the first rule of the craft: a lie should be as boring as a bank. But he was watching me, and I have been lying fluently since the Alderdices dismissed me for telling the truth.

“Mrs. Lyle was known for it,” I said. This was accurate, at least. Her real letters to my father’s shop had been blunt as bricks.

“Mm.” He did not smile. “Then you will find we agree. The children keep within the garden wall. They do not go to the pond, the river path, or the vaults beneath the house. They will not be taken into the village without my leave. Dr. Rainsford and Mr. Crane dine here on Sundays, and you will bring the children down. That is all.”

“It is a good deal.”

“It is not enough,” said Mr. Caldwell. “They will tell you that their mother visits. It is a thing that children do. You will not encourage it.”

I could have said, yes, Mr. Caldwell. Instead I heard myself say, “Which of the three?”

He did not move. The quiet in the room changed. For a moment I thought that I had finished myself in under a day, and that I would be on the evening train with forty-one dollars and a trunk.

Then his hands came out from behind him. The right one was bare and weathered, with white scars across the knuckles from some long-ago accident with iron. He looked at it as though he had forgotten it was his, and put it back.

“You have been in my house eighteen hours, Miss Whitlock.”

“Seventeen and a half. I counted.”

“You count.”

“It is a habit.”

“I am told that you notice things.”

“Who told you?”

The pause was very small. “Your letter.”

Another cold drop. I said nothing. It is a rule of mine that when you do not know what a person knows, you stay quiet.

“I will ask you one thing,” said Mr. Caldwell. “Three governesses have told me the house frightened them. They did not say what frightened them in it. I would like to know what frightens you.”

He had not asked about French, or arithmetic, or how I would manage a girl with a ledger and a boy with buttons. A man who has gone through three governesses in a year ought to have a list. He had one question, and he asked it as if it mattered more than the answer.

“Being believed,” I said.

“Explain.”

“It is so seldom followed by anything pleasant, sir.”

Something moved behind his face and was put away. “That will do,” said Mr. Caldwell, and turned back to the window, and I found that I had been dismissed in the politest way I had ever been dismissed, and that I was not sure whether I had passed or failed.

That afternoon Rosalind and Fitch were set to their copybooks, with Birdie, the kitchen girl, to sit in for an hour, and I told Birdie that I wanted to learn the house. Birdie, who was fourteen and had the round, reliable face of a girl who tells everybody everything, whispered that the back stairs went down to the cellar and that I mustn’t, because Mrs. Dunning kept a broom for that.

The back stairs were narrow and smelled of cold. Someone had swept them that morning, thoroughly. But a broom leaves what it cannot reach, and I knelt on the fifth step, with my skirts bunched in my fist, and ran a finger along the underside of the tread above.

Sawdust. Fine, pale, clean pine, the stuff they pack the ice in. I followed it down, tread by tread, to where it lay thick in the angle at the bottom. And there, in the dust at the foot of the stairs, were prints.

Boots. A woman’s, narrow and small, with a worn spot on the left heel and a row of nail heads along the sole. They went up, and they came down, and they went up again, a good many times, in the way a path is made. I put my hand over one. It was a smaller foot than mine.

At the end of the passage was the cellar door itself: oak, black with age, strapped in iron. A padlock hung from the hasp, bright as a new penny. It had never been touched by weather or by a thumb.

Ghosts, I have always understood, go through doors. This one had used the stairs, in good boots, and someone had bought a brand-new padlock to stop her. Or to stop me.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!