“I have one thing of hers,” said Mrs. Dunning, “and I have not looked at it since the day I put it there.”
It was Wednesday, past eight at night, and she stood in the doorway of the study with her Bible held against her apron, the big black one with the ribbon, as a woman holds a baby she has been told to give up. Matthias had asked her only whether Honora had left anything behind that was not paper. I had not known it was a question that could break a person.
She opened the book at the Psalms. Between two pages lay a coil of brown hair as long as my forearm, the thickness of a finger, tied at one end with a bit of faded blue ribbon. It was soft and slightly oily and as alive-looking as a hank of silk.
“I cut it myself,” said Mrs. Dunning, “on the morning, before they closed the box. I thought somebody should have it, and I could not think who.” She wiped her hands on her apron, which she had remembered to put on. “It is cut at the root, the ribbon end. The other end is the tip.”
Dr. Hollis took it from her with the delicacy of a man picking up a bird’s egg. He turned it to the lamp. “Madam,” he said, quite gently, “if I may borrow this. It will be returned to you in better order than I found it. Arsenic is a stubborn guest. It goes into the hair as it goes into the nails, and it stays. A hair grows half an inch a month. It is a kind of ledger.”
I stood in the scullery with him at ten that night, with the Marsh flask going on the table and Birdie holding the lamp, and watched him cut the coil with scissors into pieces, and label each in his small tight pencil: the first quarter inch from the root. The second. The third. He burned each in turn in the acid and the zinc, and held a cold white saucer over the jet. We did it eleven times, until nearly midnight.
The first piece, the quarter inch from the root, gave nothing. A white clean saucer, as if the woman had never lived in a house with sugar in it.
The second gave a faint grey breath. The third gave a mirror. And so on, through the rest, a bright shining stain on every saucer, going back and back through the coil like a thread of dark through a skein, until, at the inch marked five from the root, the saucers went quite clean again, and stayed clean to the tip.
“There,” said Dr. Hollis. He sat down on the flour bin, a little out of breath. “That is a very pretty piece of arithmetic. Five inches is nine or ten months back from August. That is November. She married in November. From the month of her wedding, to within ten days of her death, this woman took arsenic, by the mouth, in daily quantity. And for the last ten days, my dear Miss Whitlock, nothing. Not a grain.”
“She stopped,” I said. “She stopped eating the sugar. Crane told me she asked him who put it in her bowl.”
“Then she did not die of it.” Dr. Hollis rubbed his bald crown. “She was going to live, you see. She had given it up, and she was going to get well, and somebody who wished her dead found that his slow method was not going to be quick enough. So he found a quicker one. It was rather a short step to a pond.”
At ten past midnight Matthias took down the iron bar from the bracket in the kitchen passage, and rang the ice keeper’s bell.
Four times. Slowly.
“Edmund taught it me when I was eleven,” he said, to nobody. “It means Come at once. He has never failed to come to it.”
Dr. Rainsford was at the back door in nineteen minutes, with his bag, his greatcoat buttoned wrongly, and his silver watch chain. He had run, or ridden hard. In the lamplight of that scullery he looked old. He looked at the Marsh flask on the table, and the row of little saucers, and the coil of brown hair in its paper. And Mrs. Dunning in the corner with her face in her apron. And he said, “Now, now,” in his soothing way, and put his hand to the breast of his coat, and drew it away empty, because he had no pencil to pat.
“Honora’s hair,” said Matthias. “Clean for ten days. Poisoned for nine. Agnes says you laid lace over her left shoulder, Edmund, and would not let her lift it.”
I turned to look at him and saw that his face was perfectly steady, and that he had been waiting, for two years and three months, to ask.
“Yes,” said Dr. Rainsford.
He sat down on a stool, quite slowly, like a man whose legs have been taken away. He did not weep. That was the terrible thing. He had wept before the whole county on Sunday, and tonight, when it mattered, he was dry.
“I saw it when we laid her out,” he said. “On the left shoulder, high, where a man’s hand lies when he puts it there to steady a person from behind. Four marks, like four fingers, and a thumb at the back. It had come up after death. It would. I covered it with the lace.” He looked at Matthias. “You were in Albany. I sent a wire to you that morning, and you came on the first train. I stood in that room, with Agnes, with her lying under the sheet, and I thought: who has a hand like that. And I thought of you.”
“Of me.”
“Of your hands.” He said it gently. “Because I have known them since you were eleven, Matthias, and I had known for a year that you were not yourself. I thought, he has come home early on the night train. He has walked her out in a fit. He is a man in grief, and he does not know it, and I must not let it be known. So I did the only thing I could do for you.” He swallowed. “I screwed down the lid with my own hands, before the vicar came. I wrote nerves and misadventure on the certificate.”
“You thought I had killed her.”
“I thought you had loved her, and could not have borne it.” Dr. Rainsford covered his face. “I have been kind to you for two years because I could not tell you what I thought. It is a very bad way to be kind.”
Matthias stood very still. I saw the tremor in his right hand, which has not entirely gone, and I saw him put it behind him.
“And the certificate,” said Dr. Hollis, sharply. “Who drew it?”
“Mr. Pruett.” Rainsford lifted his head. “He came on the Wednesday morning, before the funeral, with the form already written. All I had to do was to put my name.”
I wrote it on my cuff.
“There is one thing more,” said Dr. Rainsford. He was fumbling in the pocket of his waistcoat. “It has been on my conscience. The day before she died, Honora gave me a sealed letter to post to her sister, Miss Constance Vance, of Kingston. Sealed in blue wax. She said nobody else should post it. I posted it myself, at the Landing, at four. And no answer ever came, Matthias, not a line, not to the letter and not to the news. I thought the sister had never forgiven us.”
“Constance did not come to the funeral,” said Matthias, slowly.
“Nobody wrote to her until after the burial. I wrote myself. It is possible she never had it.” He looked round at us all. “It is only that I do not like a letter that goes unanswered.”
It was nearly one when the bell over the kitchen door rang twice, and it was Mr. Boyce again, in his nightshirt and greatcoat, with a lantern, a very respectable man out of bed. He had come, he said, because a telegraph ought not to wait for the milk train, and he counted the words aloud as he handed it to the Sheriff, who had been sleeping on the sofa in the study since Monday.
The Sheriff read it once and gave it to me. It was from Albany. It was eleven words. Sheriff Colby had wired the company on Tuesday night, after the deed.
Will see Mr. Caldwell or his representative ten tomorrow. Marrable.
“I have a petition to answer on Friday,” said Matthias. “I cannot leave Lavinia undefended. And I cannot go.”
I looked at the clock over the range. It was one in the morning. The first train up was at a quarter past eight.
“I can,” I said.

