“I have not eaten since Monday,” said Mr. Wren, “and I would sooner tell you everything than be offered a sandwich.”
I gave him half of mine. I had learned that it was the quickest way to the truth. He ate it with his collar up, in four bites, like a person stealing, and the lamp swung over our heads, and the black river slid by outside the window with a few lights on it, and all the time he talked, he held the portfolio against his chest with both arms.
“I am twenty-four,” he said. “I have a hand. It is the one thing I have. At the commercial academy at Troy they said I could write like a copperplate, and then like anybody. A boy can lose his head over that.” He swallowed. “Mr. Pruett took me from the academy at eighteen and said, Wren, a hand like yours could write a man’s whole life. I took it for a compliment.”
“Go on.”
“For four years I have written what he gave me. Letters. Copies. Specimens, he called them, for the trustees’ file, in case a signature should ever be questioned. Mr. Caldwell’s signature, Dr. Rainsford’s, one or two ladies’. He had them already, in bundles. He would say, practise this, Wren, an hour a day, and he would put the bundle on my desk. I practised. I was very good.” He looked at his boots. “I was very proud.”
“The docket,” I said. “The green book, in the third ice house.”
“I filled it in. He dictated. He said it was a record of the company’s rat-killer, for the insurers, and that the owner always signed for it, and that it was merely a matter of keeping the book up to date.” His voice dipped. “I wrote M. Caldwell, Esq. four hundred and some times. I thought it was a kindness to a sick man, who could not be troubled. I did not know the stuff was real arsenic. I did not know it was going anywhere.”
“And the bottle label on Tuesday.”
“A practice. For the surgery file. He said Dr. Rainsford would send his own.” He shut his eyes. “And on Thursday afternoon your draft, Miss Whitlock. He gave it me with a brown wrapper and a pen, and said, Make me a fair exhibit of the hand for the court, address it as you see it. I did. I never knew it would be posted, I swear on my mother. I did not post it. But Mr. Pruett went to the post office at six.”
I let the train answer for me for a little while, which it did, in a long clank over a bridge.
“I want you to tell me about Saturday night.”
“Saturday night he had me write two notes.” His fingers were white on the leather. “One for Mr. Crane, in my own hand, to bring the key to the quay at ten, for a private word on the stores. One, unsigned, in the same hand, which I was told to fold and put under his own door at midnight. I thought it a game. A thing for the file. It said, Look in the third ice house.”
“Mr. Pruett told you to put a note under his own door.”
“So that he should find it, I suppose. He told me to remain at the inn and write fair copies until morning.” His lip shook. “He went out at nine with a lantern. He came back at half past ten smelling of the cold, and bay rum, which he wears on Saturdays, and he was very cheerful. I did what I was told. I put the paper under the door. And I heard his key on the stair, and I did not want him to see my face, and I went out through the window. I have not been to the inn since.”
I did not speak. I was thinking of a lantern held low, under the chin.
“On Sunday I stood in the third ice house,” said Mr. Wren, “behind the Sheriff, and I saw Mr. Caldwell’s name in that book, in my hand, in a column of poison, and I understood what I had been. I ran, Miss Whitlock. I have been in a boarding house in Albany for four days, paying for the bed with my watch, deciding whether I had the courage to hang. Today I saw you go into the Terminal Company, and I thought, if she comes out alive, I shall follow her.”
“Why?”
“Because I saw him buy a ticket at the station an hour ago.” He raised his eyes at last. They were pale and swollen and very young. “Mr. Pruett. He is on the next train, the six-o’clock. He will be at the Landing seven minutes behind us.”
I stood up and looked at the dark window. In the glass I saw my own face, white as paper, and behind it the lamps of Tarrow Landing coming round the bend one at a time, as the stars come out.
Mr. Boyce was on the platform with his lantern and his new boots, and he said “Miss Whitlock” and “Mr. Wren” in the voice of a man counting aloud, and then he looked at our faces and did not say the rest.
“Mr. Boyce,” I said, “there is a gentleman on the next train who will ask whether a young man in a long overcoat got off.”
“I count every passenger, Miss Whitlock.” He frowned. “Eleven years. It is the one thing I do properly.”
“I am asking you to count wrong.”
He stood quite still. A sound came out of him, a small cough, as of a clock about to strike. “I have not told a lie since I was nine,” he said. “It is a difficult thing to count.” And then he took us by the elbows, and steered us between the freight shed and the water tank, to the little door under his own stair, where his wife kept the brooms. “Seven minutes,” said Mr. Boyce. “It is a distance I know. In you go.” Before he shut the door I heard him say, low, to a boy on the shed roof, “Run. Teel and the Sheriff. No lantern.”
It smelled of soap and dust and a cold stove. We stood in the black with our shoulders touching and I could hear Mr. Wren’s teeth. I counted. At two hundred and nine I heard the engine, and at two hundred and sixty a door, and boots on the boards, and a voice I could have picked out of a thousand, like a ledger shutting.
“Mr. Boyce. A word. A young man in a dark overcoat, thin neck, a portfolio. A clerk of mine.”
“Evening, Mr. Pruett.” The lantern bumped on the wall. “There was Mrs. Hyde off the six-twenty, sir, and a drummer in buttons, and the Misses Teller to the village. I counted. Four.”
“Four.”
“Four, sir. It is my duty.” I heard him cough. “And you are seven minutes late by my clock, sir, which I keep fast on purpose. People hereabouts are always behind.”
There was a silence in which I should have given anything to see Mr. Pruett’s face. Then a dry step, and another. “I am obliged to you,” he said. “Good evening.”
We came out when the trap had gone. Teel was waiting behind the water tank with the cart and no lantern, and Sheriff Colby had stepped out of the dark of the road with Deputy Lyman at his shoulder, and Mr. Wren, who had held his breath for twenty minutes, put both hands to his face and sat down in the gravel.
“You counted wrong, Mr. Boyce,” said the Sheriff, mildly.
“I counted four,” said Mr. Boyce, with great dignity. “Mrs. Hyde, the drummer, the Misses. There was nobody else.” He took out his handkerchief and blew his nose, rather loudly. “It is the first time I have enjoyed it.”
It was in the cart, on the road up, with Mr. Wren shaking between Teel and me and the Sheriff’s lantern on the dash, that the boy said the last thing, almost in a whisper, as if it had been waiting at the back of his teeth.
“Mr. Pruett burned the letters in blue wax, Miss Whitlock. After every one. He did it in the grate at the inn on Saturday while he dressed. I was at the table, and I saw the last of it curl. Under the initials, always, a line. The same line every time.” He lifted his head. “Not a hair of the children.”

