Matthias took it better than I had feared and worse than I had hoped, which is to say that he said nothing at all for the whole of the train and then broke a chair.
It was a rush-bottomed thing in the gate lodge, where we had put Mr. Thorn for the night, and it had been on its last legs for years. He did not throw it. He picked it up, quite gently, by the back, to move it out of his way, and the back came off in his hand, and he stood there in the lamplight with a piece of wood and a face I did not know.
“Three years,” he said. “Three years and ten months. I have knelt on that stone in the Tarrow yard every Sunday. I took the children. I told Rosalind her mother was there. She laid a bunch of lilies and a drawing. And it was a laundress who died of a cough.” He turned the wood over. “And there was a woman who knew. Who wrote a letter in March and did not send it. Who could have sent a line to me, a line, Eleanor, on a sheet of blue paper, saying, Matthias, do not bury her, she is not in that box. And she let me.”
“Yes.”
“You defend her.”
“I explain her,” I said. “It is not the same. She has lost the only daughter she had. She sat in a hotel behind a red screen and dictated a paper in that daughter’s hand so that when the girl was dead she should be kept where the man who killed her could not find her. And then she put her in a stranger’s lap on the ice and let a husband mourn the wrong grave, because if that husband had known where Adelaide lay, so would everyone who looked at his face.” I did not raise my voice. “You cannot lie, Matthias. You have never in your life been able to lie. You told me so. She could not afford to tell you.”
“That is not an excuse.”
“No,” said Lavinia, from the doorway. “It is a reason. The two are not the same.”
We had not heard her come. She stood on the lodge threshold with her grey shawl round her cropped head and her fingers at her lips, and the snow behind her was blue under the stars, and Matthias looked at her and I think he saw the cellar.
“I kept myself in an ice keeper’s room for ten months,” she said, “and I did not tell you that I was alive. You stood in the Great Vault and told the jars you were sorry. I watched you through a vent. I might have said, I am here. I did not. I had a reason. It was a good one, and I should do it again.” Her thin hands fell. “It does not make it a kindness. It makes it a thing that was done by a frightened woman who was right and cruel. I think your Dutch lady is the same. I think we shall have to forgive her and be angry at once, which is what one does with a mother.”
Matthias put down the piece of chair.
“She was not my mother,” he said.
“No. But you were her daughter’s husband,” said Lavinia, “and that is the nearest she ever got to a son.”
He did not answer. I do not think anyone could have. He went out past us into the snow, and I heard him walk down to the gate and stand there, and Lyman, who had been sitting in the chair outside the lodge door with his rifle across his knees and a mug of cocoa that Birdie had brought, said carefully that he thought the master would be better for being let alone.
That was at nine o’clock on the Tuesday night. Mr. Thorn was in the lodge, in the small bedroom, on a feather tick Agnes had made up with her own hands, with a lamp, a basin, a plate of cold ham, a Bible, and a stout oak door that had a lock on the outside and a key in Lyman’s pocket. There was a window, a foot square, high up, barred. There was a chimney the width of a loaf. I looked at it all myself. I counted the bars: four. I went to my bed and for the first time in a week I slept without dreaming.
At ten minutes past six on the Wednesday morning Birdie came running up the back stair with her cap crooked and said that Deputy Lyman could not be woken.
He was in the chair, quite comfortable, with his chin on his chest and his rifle across his knees and the key in his pocket. I smelt his breath. There was nothing on it. I smelt the mug, which stood on the step, and the dregs at the bottom were thick and brown, and under the cocoa there was a very faint sweetish taint that I had met before in my father’s shop, on the lip of a bottle that had a skull on the label. I tasted the end of my little finger. Chloral.
“Who gave him the cocoa?” I said.
“I did, miss, at nine. Mrs. Dunning made it.” She was ashen. “But she put the cups on the dresser, and I carried it. Nobody touched it. I swear.”
“You did not leave it?”
“Only for the one minute. I went to take the blanket to the lodge.” She stopped. Her mouth fell open. “And Mrs. Orris was in the kitchen.”
We shook Lyman by the shoulders, and he came up out of it slowly, like a swimmer, saying, “Capital,” and then, in great distress, “Oh, my Lord.”
The key was in his pocket. I took it out with my own hand and put it to the lock, and it turned without a sound. The door swung inward. The room was empty.
The bed had been slept in. The ham was eaten. The Bible lay on the pillow, open. The little window, high up, was barred, with four bars intact, and not a flake of snow on the sill. The chimney was the width of a loaf. I turned round once, slowly, the way I do in a room I am going to be asked about, and counted what was wrong.
A door locked from outside, with the key in a sleeper’s pocket. A window too small for a child. A man gone in a night, and his boots with him, and not one sound.
There was a slip on the pillow, on the open Bible. It was blue.
“He is safe,” it said, in the upright copperplate that I knew by heart. “He will be asked again. Do not look for him. He has said what he came to say.” There was no signature. The paper smelt of orris root so strongly that I felt it in my teeth.
“It is hers,” said Constance, behind me.
“Or somebody who has her paper,” I said. I did not know why I said it. I think I was frightened that I was easy. “A man who writes Honora’s hand can write blue paper.”
“Eleanor.” It was Matthias, in the doorway, with the snow on his shoulders. He had not slept. I think he had stood at the gate until it was light. “How did he leave?”
“I do not know,” I said. “Not through the door, or the window. There is a floor.” I knelt and put my palm on the boards. They were solid. I turned the Bible over. I lifted the pillow. And on the small deal table, beside the basin, where Mr. Thorn had been given his pen and his ink and his sheet of paper to write the end of his statement, I found the pen-wiper.
It was a little round of grey flannel with a scalloped edge, the sort that a lady makes for a gentleman at Christmas. It was black with ink. He had used it, I think, to take the last drops off his nib, and then had taken a clean corner of it, and written on it.
I held it up to the light. It was covered, edge to edge, in the finest of small hands, a clerk’s hand, in rows. It said, forty times, the same two words, in the same signature, with the same bold stroke on the S and the same little snag on the final d. It said it as one writes a name one has had to say too often and will not say again.
A. Stannard. A. Stannard. A. Stannard.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!