Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 90

The Sixth Chair

On Saturday night we laid the table for thirteen, and Rosalind, who says that thirteen is not unlucky but merely untidy, insisted that nobody should leave it until the sixth chair had been accounted for.

I had never seen the dining room so full. Agnes had lit every lamp and both branches of candles, and put out the good damask and the green-and-gold, and she did something I had not seen in all my weeks at the Hall: she sat down. The Three-Hand Rule says that servants and family share a board on a day of reckoning, and it was Matthias who said that this was one. So Agnes sat at the foot, between Teel and Birdie, with her cap very straight and her hands folded, and did not once get up to see to the soup. Mrs. Orris sat beside her. Deputy Lyman sat on Colby’s left and Dr. Hollis on his right, and Constance and Lavinia sat across from one another, like two halves of a locket. Fitch was on a cushion. Rosalind was at her father’s right hand with her ruler and her slate.

I put myself at the corner, where I could see the whole table. It is a habit of mine. I have found that one understands a room better from the corner.

There were thirteen of us and one empty chair. It was on Adelaide’s left, as before, with the fire behind it, and a single place laid, with the good glass. Nobody had asked for it. It had been set by a hand that knew the way, and I looked at Agnes, and she looked at her plate, and I understood that she had put it there at six o’clock, quite alone, as one lays a stone on a grave.

Matthias said grace. He said it plainly, in six words, and then he rapped twice on the cloth with his knuckle, quite lightly. I do not think he knew he had done it. Hollis put down his fork. Colby turned his head. Birdie gave a small gasp, and Agnes said, very low, “Mr. Matthias,” and he looked down at his hand as though it were someone else’s.

“I beg your pardon,” he said. “That was not mine.”

“It was the Dutch, sir,” said Teel. “For luck.”

“It was his,” said Matthias, and sat back.

It was a long dinner, and a strange one. We had the roast beef that Agnes had promised Colby for three weeks. We had the apple pudding, which I noticed nobody left on the plate. Between the courses Rosalind called us to order with her ruler and said that she would like to read the account into the minutes, and she stood on her chair, which is forbidden, and read from her slate.

“Item,” said Rosalind. “On the sixth of March, 1881, six persons were at table, being Papa, Mamma, Aunt Judith, Dr. Rainsford, Mr. Crane and a Man. The Man was introduced as Mr. Stannard, which was inaccurate, because Mr. Stannard was at home with a telegram. He sat on Mamma’s left with his back to the fire, and wore a beard, and blue spectacles, and a coat with horn buttons, and a grey glove on his left hand, and he knocked twice. He ate nothing and drank water from the Delft jug. He left at ten past seven.”

“Not quite left,” said Colby, gently.

“No. He came back.” She looked at her slate. “He is our mother’s uncle. He is named Gerrit Cornelis Van Cuyler. He was born in 1846 and is in the Bible as dead, which is inaccurate. He taught her the stars.” She stopped. Her chin did something, and she steadied it. “She called him Uncle Rit. I should like to say that she was very fond of him, and that she was not wrong to be, because he must have been kind to her once. It is only that he was not kind afterward.”

Nobody spoke. Lavinia put out her thin hand and laid it over Rosalind’s on the tablecloth, and the child allowed it.

“That is the account,” said Rosalind. “Papa, is it complete?”

“It is as complete as we have it,” said Matthias, and I saw that he was holding his water glass in his right hand and that it did not move. “I think there is a thing you have left out.”

“What?”

“That he was in this house,” said Matthias, “in October. Birdie, who was the man from the stove firm?”

“Mr. Barnes, sir.” Birdie’s eyes were enormous. “He had spectacles. Mrs. Dunning let him in.”

“Mrs. Dunning let him in because she believed that I had sent for him,” said Matthias. “Who told her so?”

Agnes took a long breath. Her hands came apart on the cloth. “It was a note,” she said, in a clear small voice. “On the Tuesday, in the week of the inquest. A slip, on the kitchen table, under the bread-board. In your hand, Mr. Matthias. It said, a man from Albany will come to measure for the stove, let him have the dining room. I put it on the fire, after.” She looked up. “I thought it was yours. I thought it was the first thing you had written in three years.”

“It was not,” said Matthias.

“No,” said Agnes. “I know it now. It was a good copy.”

A good copy. I sat at the corner of the table with my fork in my hand and a taste like pennies in my mouth. A good copy of a man’s hand; and a man who had learned that Matthias never read anything, and so would never ask.

“And the Book of Days?” I said.

Nobody answered. I looked down the long table at faces I had known two months and some of them hardly that. Agnes, white as a candle, her hands knotted. Birdie, who was fourteen and would not hurt a spider. Teel, with his hat in his lap. Constance, whom I had loved in a week. Lavinia, who had lain ten months in an ice keeper’s room. The Sheriff. The Doctor. The Deputy, red as a beet, with his mouth a little open. Rosalind and Fitch.

A page had been razored from the household ledger since September. A black horn button had been put into the cushion of a chair that nobody sat in. A note had been left under the bread-board in a forged hand. The man in the spectacles was a big man in a beard, who could not walk into the Hall and pick up the Book of Days and cut it out without someone seeing.

Somebody had handed it to him.

It was Mrs. Orris who spoke. I had not heard her voice since the stair, and I do not think anyone else at that table had heard it at all. She put down her knife with great care, and rose, and stood with her hands folded at her waist as she must have stood for nineteen years in a house in Lodge Street, and said, in the low flat hoarse voice that she kept in a drawer, to nobody and to everybody:

“I was told to say it when you had the name, and not before. I was told by my mistress.” She drew breath. “‘He had a hand in the house in March of eighty-one, and he has a hand in it now. It is not the same hand. Dr. Rainsford was a tool, and Miss Judith was a fool, and neither of them could cut a ledger in the autumn. Tell them to count the table.’”

Nobody moved. A candle guttered, down the long cloth. I heard the fire, and Fitch breathing on his cushion, and, a long way off, the faint tick of the clock in the hall.

“She said one thing more,” said Mrs. Orris, and her face was quite white. “She said that he does not need to come in. He has only to ask, and somebody in this house will open the door.”

I counted. I counted them twice, as I always do. There were thirteen at that table, and one chair, and one of them, whoever it was, was sitting with a smile on a face I knew, and a fork in a hand I trusted, and eating Mrs. Dunning’s apple pudding.

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!