Nobody slept, and everybody pretended to have done so, which is a thing a house can do very well for exactly one morning.
I came down at six on Sunday to find the kitchen fire already lit and Agnes standing at the table with her hands flat on the board, as if the board might otherwise get up and leave. She did not say “Well now.” She did not say anything. Birdie was blacking the range with great violence. Teel had come in without his hat and was drinking tea standing, which he has never once done in my presence.
I set this down because it is the first time since I came to Blackwater that I looked round a room and counted the people in it as suspects. It is an ugly arithmetic. It makes the milk taste of something.
Matthias sent word that he would see us all in the dining room at eight, and we went in like children called to the front of a class. The table had been cleared of everything but the sixth chair, which somebody had pulled back a little from the cloth. Nobody had touched it. Nobody had sat in it. It stood there with its black horn button, long since removed, and its patient look, like a person waiting to be introduced.
“I am going to say three things,” said Matthias, “and then Miss Whitlock is going to say a fourth, and then we are going to do something useful.”
He stood at the head with his hands in front of him, not behind. I noted it. I have been noting it for weeks.
“First. Mrs. Orris has told us what she was told. I do not know if it is true. I think it is. Second. Nobody in this room is to be asked to leave under suspicion, nor to be watched by anyone but Rosalind, who watches everyone already.”
“That is accurate,” said Rosalind, from her cushion.
“Third. I am sorry. I did not read the household for three years, and a man who does not read leaves his house open like a book on a table. I mean to learn it now, page by page, and I should be glad if you would help.”
It was the longest speech I have heard him make that did not end in “That will do.” Agnes put her apron to her mouth. Birdie stared at the cloth.
Then it was my turn, and I had no speech, only a pencil and the back of a laundry list.
“A door,” I said, “is a thing that opens from one side. Someone has been opening ours from the inside. I should like to count them.”
So we did. It took the whole of the morning and was, I think, the oddest Sunday the Hall has ever had. Rosalind carried the slate and called out the doors in the order I found them, and Fitch went ahead of us with a button in each fist, trying every latch and announcing whether it was a rule or a suggestion. There are thirty-one doors in Blackwater Hall that open to somewhere else. Eleven have locks. Seven have keys that are in the right place. Four have keys that nobody has seen since Josiah’s time, and they are, I noticed, the four doors that are never locked.
“Rule Twelve,” said Rosalind, at the foot of the back stair, and wrote it on the slate as she spoke. “Anyone who is alone with a door shall say so afterward. It is not an accusation. It is a record.”
“Seconded,” said Lavinia from the landing, in the dry voice of a woman who has spent ten months in a locked room.
The key board hangs in the back passage, beside the cellar door, a long oak plank with brass hooks and a small card pinned above each hook in Agnes’s upright writing. I counted the hooks twice. There are twenty-one. I counted the keys. There are twenty.
“Which?” I said.
Agnes looked at the plank, and I saw her find the empty hook before I did, and her mouth made a little shape. “The east wing spare,” she said. “The lady’s sitting-room. Mr. Matthias lent it out in December, after the doctor’s death, because the sitting-room has the second door to the stair. It is in his book.”
“In my book,” said Matthias, and turned, and went to the study. We followed him in a small crowd. He took down a ledger from the shelf above his desk, a ruled foolscap one with a marbled back. I had not known he kept one.
“I began it on the fifteenth of December,” he said. “I told myself it was a kind of diary. I cannot write very much. Only what I lend and what I am lent.” He found the page with his finger, and I saw how carefully his lips moved. “‘Sixteenth December. East wing spare, lent to the night watch, for the sitting-room round, while Dr. Rainsford is not to be trusted with it.’” He stopped. “I do not like how that reads. I wrote it the day after we found the doctor dead, and I wrote ‘not’ where I meant ‘no longer’.”
“It is a very fair mistake,” I said.
“I am told it is a very common one among people who have begun to read,” said Matthias, and I saw something at the corner of his mouth that might have been the first of its kind since the dinner. “The night watch has had it ever since.”
“The night watch,” I said, “is a good many people.”
“It is whoever Colby sends,” said Matthias. “Which is a good many people, in a year. He has fewer now.”
I wrote that down on my laundry list, under the doors, and underlined nothing. I have learned not to underline a thing before I know why.
We went on counting. I will not give the whole of the afternoon, but I will give three wrong things, because it is my habit and because I have found that when I am afraid I become scrupulous.
First: the razored stub of the Book of Days, which had lain in a drawer since Wednesday, was brought out and laid on the study desk, and Matthias, without anybody asking him to, put on the spectacles he has begun to use and read the six words that survive of the entry for the seventh of March. “‘S., no pudding. Left ten past seven.’” He read it slowly, and without a mistake, and then put it down very gently, as if it were a thing that might bruise. Second: the razor that took the page had been drawn from left to right, with a downward tilt, by a hand that had not wanted to be seen taking its time. Third: the stub had been cut in September. Nobody in this house had been murdered in September, or put a button in a cushion, or been sent a blue sugar twist. Somebody had simply wished the page gone, early, before there was a reason to wish it.
Early. A person who cuts a page out of a household book in September is not frightened of an inquest. He is doing his housekeeping.
At four, Birdie came into the study with a face like candle wax and a folded sheet in her fist. She is fourteen, and she carries the household accounts down to Mr. Haskell’s at the Landing every Saturday and brings the bill back on Sunday for Agnes to look at on Monday. It is the only piece of arithmetic in the Hall that she is allowed to do without being corrected.
“I was not looking,” said Birdie. “Only the bill has lines on it, miss, that I do not carry down. I thought it was me. I thought I had put them in wrong. But I have counted the order three weeks back, and it is not me.”
I took the sheet. It was Haskell’s Landing reckoning for the week, in the grocer’s large round hand, and under the usual flour and tea and soap there were four lines Agnes had not ordered, and each of them was marked, at the margin, with the same small neat initials.
“A.D. per M.C.,” I read aloud. “Agnes Dunning, on the instruction of Matthias Caldwell.”
“I did not,” said Agnes, very white.
“I did not,” said Matthias, with the sheet already in his hand, and read it down for himself, one line at a time, and then he looked up at me. “Miss Whitlock,” he said, “I believe somebody has been laying a place for him.”
“Every Friday?” I said.
“Since the fifteenth of December,” said Birdie, in a very small voice. “I counted back. It is the day before the doctor was found.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!