Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 95

Five Posts

I did not go anywhere on Thursday. I want that understood, because on a day when five people were sent about the valley after a lie of mine, the person who told it sat in a nursery with a darning egg and a child with a ruler, and received her news like a lady in a novel, by telegram.

We had agreed the matter on Wednesday. Matthias told Sheriff Colby about the shack over breakfast, in the study, with the spyglass laid on the blotter between them; and Colby, who has seen a great deal in his sixty years and says so, turned grey and put on his spectacles and said, “That is not a thing a friend does.” A county man was sent to sit in the shack. He sat there until dawn with a rug and a stone bottle of Agnes’s tea, and the stove went cold, and nobody came. We left the fibs standing. We posted watchers. And here, for my own records, is what the twenty-ninth of January brought, in the order the boy from Boyce’s station pushed it under the nursery door.

At 10.19 a.m. The first was from Teel, on the up platform, in pencil, in Boyce’s telegraph form. “10.15 gone. No beard. No blue spectacles. Sheriff Colby came in his buggy to see you off. Said where were the children. I said sick. He says a great advantage in being a deacon, one can pray over a cold. T.”

At 11.52 a.m., from Lavinia at the Troy Dispensary, in a large looping hand that I knew at once: “Corridor empty save matron. At 11.20 Dr. Hollis arrived in a hired gig in a state of great helpfulness and asked for the specialist. There is no specialist. He is now in the matron’s parlour having his chest consoled. He is on his third cup of tea and I believe has forgiven nobody. L.”

I laughed aloud, which was very bad for Rosalind’s concentration, and I told her that Dr. Hollis had been very kind to turn up, that he had not been in the least a suspect, only a gentleman who believes a fib when it is told him by a woman he likes. She said, “That is a conclusion from a sample of one.” I said that she was a prig. She said she accepted the word.

At 1.04 p.m. Matthias, from Greenfell, in five terse lines which I have since had framed in my mind: “Exhibits shown to Justice Orne’s clerk at noon. Nobody else. No sleigh on the road. The clerk had a cold and wished to know why we had come. I said it was a rehearsal. He said of what. I said of a funeral. M.”

“He is getting a great deal better at it,” said Lavinia, afterwards, “and I should not like to be the clerk.”

At 2.40 from Constance, at St. Aidan’s vestry: “The Vicar put out the small hymn books and has been waiting forty minutes for two children, a ruler, a slate and, I think, a miracle. Four ladies of the altar guild, a sexton, and a draught. Nobody else came in. He is very hurt. I have promised the children shall sing on Sunday. C.”

“That is a lie of mine,” said Rosalind, who had been told, “and now it is a debt.”

At 3.15, last, from Boyce himself, who wrote in his own round hand on the back of a ticket: “Twelve-twenty, Kinderhook, children. Nobody asked after them. Nobody asked after anything. The clock was right. Yrs., J. B.”

That was all. I laid the five telegrams side by side on the nursery table, with the Dispensary one on the left, and sat down and looked at them for a quarter of an hour.

“It did not work,” said Fitch, hopefully, from the hearthrug.

“It worked perfectly,” said Rosalind. “It showed nothing.”

“That is not working,” said Fitch.

“A control shows nothing,” said Rosalind. “That is what it is for. It is a different thing from an experiment that has failed. But I must say,” and here her chin went up and her ruler came down on the table and I saw that the eleven weeks of her tally had begun, very slightly, to tremble, “that this is an experiment that has failed.”

She was right, and I have to set it down. It had been a beautiful plan. It had been small, specific and unique. And five honest and ordinary people, told five separate lies, had behaved like five honest and ordinary people, and not one single stranger had come within a mile of any post. Either the hand had not been told, or the hand had been told and had smelt the trap, or the hand was somebody I had not thought to tell; and if it was either of the last two, then whoever was feeding Gerrit Van Cuyler knew that we were looking for him, and was cleverer than we were.

“He knows,” I said aloud. “He lit the lamp so that we would cross. He sat in the dark, I think, and watched us go over the ice with our lanterns, and counted us. And then he went away.”

“Why would he want us to cross?” said Lavinia.

“So that we would see the glass,” I said. “And be afraid for the children. And do something stupid.”

“We did something stupid,” said Lavinia. “We told five people five lies.”

“It is not stupid,” said Rosalind, “if one writes it down.” And she picked up her slate, and wiped the plan out with her sleeve, and began, very neatly, to write the conclusion.

It was half past three and I remember the light in the window was thinning to the colour of a pearl. I remember Fitch had lined his buttons along the hearth by size. I remember Constance came in at four with a frozen nose and her hat in her hand and said that the Vicar had been so kind about it that she wanted to be sick, and Lavinia took her by the shoulders and made her sit down. I remember Agnes’s tea at five, and the ham sandwiches, and the lamps being lit.

And then at a quarter to six Rosalind went to the shelf above the nursery table, where she keeps her minutes, to add the conclusion; and she stood quite still.

The minutes of the Blackwater household are kept in a green cloth-bound book with a ribbon and a cardboard spine, that she has had since December, and it holds every item she has read out at table: the account of the sixth chair, Mrs. Orris’s message, the roll of those present and the names of the thirteen. It stands on the second shelf, beside the ink, always in the same place. She says that a book which moves is a book which is lying.

“It is gone,” said Rosalind.

I looked. There was a pale oblong in the dust where the green book had stood, and the ribbon, a blue one, lay across the shelf in a loose small curl, as though somebody had untied it from the book with great care and set it down.

“I put it there at eleven,” said Rosalind. “I wrote the item about the shack. I wrote it myself.” She turned around and I saw that her face had gone quite colourless, and her ink-stained hand was shut very hard on the ruler. “Miss Whitlock. I have not left this room since a quarter to ten. Nor have you. And the door was open the width of a hand.”

I counted. It is what I do. The nursery had been in my sight for the whole of the day, but for ten minutes at twenty past three, when I had gone down to the study with the Dispensary telegram, and a quarter of an hour at noon when Agnes came with the soup and I helped her lay the tray. I counted every visitor I could remember, and every pair of boots on the back stair, and the rose carved on the goodnight door.

“Somebody has walked into my nursery,” I said slowly, “in broad day, with five of us out and the house full, and taken the only book that has the thirteen names in it.”

“And left the ribbon,” said Rosalind, “because he did not need it.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!