Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 97

Rainsford’s Black Book

Dr. Hollis laid it on the study desk as if it were a dish he had been asked not to drop, and then stood back from it with both hands behind him, like a boy who has brought a dead bird to the schoolmaster.

It was a very small book. Black cloth over boards, a brass clasp worn to the colour of a penny, a pencil in a loop down the spine. We had searched Rainsford’s surgery for it the morning he was found dead and found a stethoscope, a drawer of pills and his silver watch, still running.

“Where?” said Matthias.

“In the surgery wall,” said Dr. Hollis, and swallowed. “Behind the calendar. I took the cottage on the second of January, you know, and I was putting up my own diploma, and the nail went in and there was a hollow. A little cupboard in the plaster, no bigger than a bread-tin, with a loose board. I thought at first it was a mouse nest.” “It was the book. I have been ill with it for four weeks.”

“Four weeks,” said Matthias.

“Four weeks and five days.” Dr. Hollis’s round pale face was quite damp. “Mr. Caldwell, I did not know what to do. The last entry says that somebody in your house has been bought, or has not needed buying. And it was written by a man I did not know, about a house I did not know, and the only people I knew in it were Mrs. Dunning, who made me a custard, and Miss Birdie, who is fourteen. I was afraid it meant Mrs. Dunning. She has the keys.”

“Agnes,” said Matthias, and I saw something hard and quiet come into his face and go out again. “Agnes has not been paid a cent above her wages in thirty-eight years. She would sooner swallow the keys.”

“I see that now,” said Dr. Hollis. “But on the second of January I did not, and I thought, if I give this to Mr. Caldwell and it is her, he will turn her out, and she is sixty. And if I give it to the Sheriff, and it is the Sheriff —” He stopped.

I sat down on the horsehair sofa and held out my hand. He put the book into it.

The hand was neat, round, upright, a physician’s clerkly hand with the descenders gone a little soft. The entries were short, ruled off by year, and written in a kind of shorthand he must have thought nobody would learn: initials, dates, a sum, a single dry sentence.

I will give the ones that matter, in the order I read them aloud, with Matthias at my shoulder and Dr. Hollis standing in the window with his hat.

“‘Albany, March the twelfth, 1879. G.V.C. in my rooms in Hamilton Street, very drunk. Owes nine thousand to a gentleman at Saratoga. Proposes to die. Letter from a Denver physician composed by me on Windsor Hotel paper, which he has in his valise, in a hand not my own. Three hundred dollars.’”

“He was in Albany,” said Matthias, “on the twelfth of March. The letter was postmarked there. We have the envelope.”

“He was not in Denver at all,” I said. “He was never there. Someone had told Mrs. Fitch he was dead and given her a certificate, and she mourned him for three years in Kinderhook church, and he was sitting in a doctor’s rooms in Hamilton Street with a bottle.”

“And Rainsford wrote his death,” said Matthias, very low.

“For three hundred dollars.”

I turned the page. There was a long gap, as if the writer had been ashamed, or well employed. Then, in a smaller hand, under the heading “1881”:

“‘Sunday, March the sixth. Hall. G. as Mr. S. at table, beard and spectacles. He is better than I at it. Cup at eleven, by my hand, as he wished: a posset, to be given by the husband. Note: I did not know what was in it.’”

I stopped reading. There was nobody in the study who was breathing.

“‘Did not know,’” said Matthias, at last. His voice was entirely flat. “He wrote it down. ‘I did not know.’ And at the foot of the page he blots it. Look.”

There was a blot, round and purple, at the end of the sentence, where the pen had rested too long.

I read on. “‘Tuesday the eighth. A. dead at ten past five, in the morning. G. came to my door at midnight on Monday and swore he found her so. I do not believe him. I do not disbelieve him. I wrote lung fever as I was told. Two thousand dollars.’”

“He found her so,” said Matthias.

“He says.”

“He took the draft will,” said Matthias, “and the note to Mother, and left a woman dying on a pillow and called it finding.” He put his hand quite flat on the book beside mine, and I saw that it was perfectly steady and perfectly white. “I carried her a cup, Miss Whitlock. At the doctor’s request. ‘A husband’s hand.’ And in the morning he wrote lung fever, and dined with me for a year, and patted his pocket for his pencil.”

There are four pages more, and I have gone through them four times since, so I will give only the ones that touch us. Under 1882: “‘G. in Albany again. I owe him now what I cannot pay. He has the Troy matter in his keeping, and Crane’s boxes, and knows what Crane knows.’” Under 1883: “‘Nov. L. suspicious. G. says: she will be seen to.’” (L., for Lavinia, and my mouth went dry.) And under the last year, in a hand that had begun to slope downhill like a man walking home late:

“‘Sunday the fourteenth of December, 1884. Called by G. at the Landing. I said I would do no third winter. He laughed, and said the Hall would be no difficulty, as he has a friend there with the run of the house who does not need paying. I asked who. He said, a man who thinks he is doing a kindness. He said he would send another friend to my surgery to settle me down. I am afraid. I shall write no more.’”

Under it, in the margin, in the same hand, but smaller and shakier, as though it had been added by lamplight, were four words.

“‘Candlemas. The lights. Be careful.’”

That was all. Rainsford died the next night, with chloral and arsenic in a basket of port from a boy in a cap, and his tumbler on his left side when he was right-handed.

Nobody spoke for a long time. I read the entry for the fourteenth of December twice, to be sure. “‘A man who thinks he is doing a kindness,’” I said. “Not a villain. Not a man who is paid. A man who has been persuaded.”

“With the run of the house,” said Dr. Hollis, hoarsely.

“There are fourteen people with the run of the house,” I said. “There are fifteen, if I count the Sheriff’s horse-boy. There are three who stood in the nursery on Thursday.”

“And I am one of them,” said Dr. Hollis, and sat down very suddenly on the edge of the window seat. “Mr. Caldwell, I beg you to remember that I brought the book.”

“That is why I think you did not take the minutes,” said Matthias, “and why I do not think you are to be searched. A man who steals a green book does not walk down the drive with a black one.” He closed the clasp. For the first time since the dinner I saw something almost like a smile cross his mouth, grim as a cut. “You will say nothing of this to Colby, nor to anyone. It stays in my vault. I will make a copy of the last page in my own hand, and read it aloud when I am sure of it.”

“Candlemas,” I said.

Matthias looked up.

“It is on Monday,” I said. “The second of February. Mr. Caldwell, in the valley, what does one do at Candlemas?”

“One lights every window in the house,” said Matthias slowly. “From dusk till the morning. It is the old Dutch custom. To keep out the dark.” He stared at the book under his hand. “Every door standing open, to bring the light in. And nobody in the Hall has ever counted who comes through them.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!