Matthias came up the goodnight stair at ten minutes past seven with Teel behind him carrying a mason’s hammer and a cold chisel, and I will say that I have not in my life been so glad to see a pair of tools.
He had left the party, and Lavinia on the great stair with a cup of cider in each hand, receiving the Vicar. Below us in the Hall, two hundred people were singing a Dutch carol with a verse that nobody knows. Up here, in the lady’s sitting-room, with the one candle burning on the desk and Rosalind pressed against my side with her slate, it was as quiet as a church before the sermon.
“It was warm,” I said. “The chair, the glass, the candle. Within a quarter of an hour. The passage door was locked from outside with the key in it. I came up the stair and nobody passed me, and Constance and I were at the pond gate when it lit. There is only one way out of this room.”
“There are two,” said Rosalind. “We are standing in the other.”
I looked at the little carved door-post, with its rose, and the stair beyond, which she had come up alone behind me, with a lantern. “Nobody came down it,” I said.
“Then he did not leave,” said Matthias slowly, “by any door.”
He walked slowly round the room. It is a small square room papered in faded blue convolvulus, with a rosewood desk, a sofa, a clock that has never been wound, and a long mirror between the windows that gave back the candle three times over. He stopped at the foot of the mirror, where the wall between the sitting-room and the nursery was thickest, and laid his palm against the paper. Then he knocked, twice, with his knuckle. I felt the sound in my back teeth.
It was hollow.
“Nineteen inches,” I said. “We measured it in November, from the nursery side. A gap between the nursery wall and the east wing, with no latch. You would not tear it open.”
“I would not,” said Matthias. He stood for a moment with his hand on the paper, the right hand, the one that has learned to feel a warm cup. “I told you in November it was a house that had been opened enough. My grandmother built this stair. I have been afraid, I think, that if I began, I should not know where to stop. That I should take down a wall and find another behind it, and another.”
“That is not an unreasonable thing to think,” I said, “about this house.”
“Papa,” said Rosalind. She had put down her slate. She was looking up at him, and her face in the single candle was like a small stern coin. “Is it a rule or a suggestion?”
“Which?”
“That nobody breaks the walls.”
There was a pause. I saw Matthias consider it with great seriousness, as he considers all her questions.
“It was a rule,” he said at last, “that I made for myself. And I find I am the only person in the house who has been keeping it.” He turned to Teel. “Give me the hammer.”
He did it very carefully, which surprised me; I had expected violence. He set the chisel to the paper at the height of his chest and struck, not hard, and the first blow brought down a little fall of grey dust, and the second a flake of the convolvulus, and by the sixth the lath showed through like the ribs of a drowned boat. Teel took a pry-bar to it. Within three minutes, under the long mirror, there was a ragged hole the size of a dinner-plate, and out of it came a breath of air that was colder than the room.
Teel held up the lantern, and I looked in.
I had expected, I suppose, a tomb. It was a corridor, no wider than my shoulders, running up and down in the thickness of the wall between two partitions of old lath. A panel on the nursery side, with a slot cut at the height of a child’s eye, let in a thread of light from behind the curtain: so that anyone standing in that dark would have seen into the nursery as through a keyhole. There was a stool. There was a stub of tallow candle in a tin saucer, and a pencil, the short flat kind carpenters use, and a mark on the lath at shoulder height, rubbed shiny by a person leaning on it for a very long time.
I put my hand on the stool. It was warm.
“The cellar,” said Matthias. He had gone down on one knee. “The shaft goes down. Look. There is a rope.”
It was a rope, tarred, knotted every foot, hung down a square black chimney in the wall as far as Teel’s lantern could throw. It went down past the first floor, past the passage where Lavinia’s trunk once stood, down to the ground. I remembered the key board in the back passage, the long oak plank with its twenty-one brass hooks, hung against the plaster beside the cellar door. And I understood, with a small cold clap in my chest, that the plank was not hung on the wall at all, but on a door.
“Teel,” I said. “Go down the back stair and take the key board off its nails.”
He went. We waited. The carol had come to the verse nobody knows, and the whole house seemed to hold it. Then Teel’s voice came up the shaft, small and hollow, as if from the bottom of a well.
“Sir. There is a hole in the wall behind it.”
“Of course there is,” said Matthias, to nobody. He took a very long breath. “Thirty-eight years I have lived in this house.” He sat back on his heels in his shirt-sleeves with plaster in his hair and looked at the hole. “And Honora said there was somebody in the wall, in her letters, in eighty-two, and I thought she was ill.”
“She was ill,” I said gently. “Somebody was making her so.”
At that moment I heard a slow tread on the nursery stair behind us and a cough, and Sheriff Colby came through the door-post with his lantern and his Bible-pocket and his grey face. He had been fetched, I suppose, by a villager. He looked at the hole in the plaster for a moment without speaking. Then he took off his hat.
“Mr. Caldwell,” he said. “I wish to ask a question, and I do not want it taken as an insult. When was the east wing spare key lent?”
“The sixteenth of December,” said Matthias. “To the night watch.”
“To whom?”
“It does not say. It says ‘the night watch.’”
“Then I will tell you,” said Colby, and sat down very heavily on the sofa. “When Rainsford died I drew the sheet up, and I thought: I have two men and I cannot be on watch every night of the year. So I took the days, and I gave the nights to one man alone, so that the house should have one pair of eyes in it and not three. And I told him that he would have the keys.” He lifted his face. “Wick Lyman has had the night watch at Blackwater Hall alone since the sixteenth of December.”
Nobody spoke.
“It was a kindness,” said Colby. His voice cracked, slightly, on the last word. “I thought, he has had a hard year. He has a mother at Castleton, a widow, and a mortgage on a poor farm that the Troy bank called in last summer. I said I would speak to the bank. He said no, sir, he would manage. And then at Christmas it was paid. I thought it was a bonus out of his savings.”
I did not answer. I was thinking of a young man on a cold step in a good blue coat, calling out “A grand evening!” as I ran past him, and of what Rosalind’s tally had said on Friday morning about the third step, left-hand side, quick, and I was thinking of a small thing I had put down without noticing and had not thought of since: that at twenty past six, when the lanterns first came up the drive, Deputy Lyman had not been on the steps. He had gone, I had been told, to the gate lodge for more lanterns. Ten minutes. A grand, ordinary, hospitable ten minutes, and I had not counted them.
“Matthias,” I said.
He looked up. His eyes met mine, and I saw that he had followed me to the end, and that neither of us was willing to say it first.
“Tomorrow,” said Matthias, very quietly, “we shall ride to Castleton, and ask to see the mortgage.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!