The Alder County Board of Revision consists, by statute, of the Auditor, the Treasurer, and the president of the Board of Commissioners. Since I was a party, I could not sit.
So on Monday, the second of August, at nine o’clock, in the third-floor courtroom with the ceiling fans turning and the windows open on the lawn, I sat at the left-hand table as Surety for the Land, and Felix, as Acting Auditor, sat at the bench between Treasurer Hank Orlovsky, a stout, anxious man who had never in his life heard a case, and Commissioner Tess Ahlgren, a retired schoolteacher who took notes with a fountain pen and looked at everyone over her glasses as though they had forgotten their homework.
The room was full. It was so full that Marge from the front desk had propped open the doors to the hall, and people stood in the stairwell, on the landing, in their church clothes. Wilma Haskett had the front row, with her hymnbook. Abel sat beside her. Dessa Kimbrough was in the second row with a thermos. At the back of the room, by the door, leaning on a long black umbrella, stood Gideon Hale, in his gray coat, who had come, he said, to observe a procedure.
At the right-hand table sat Loretta Vance, in her navy blazer, with a single blue folder, alone.
“We are here,” said Felix, in a voice that only wobbled once, “on a complaint of the Land of Alder, owner, against the notices of valuation issued the sixteenth of July. And on a separate question, the Reserve, parcel one of section twenty-two, Weller Township.” He cleared his throat. “Ms. Vance, for the Appraiser?”
“For the Lender,” said Vance, rising, “in a very modest way.” She smiled at the bench. “Members of the Board. I have not come to make trouble. I want to say at once that the Appraiser accepts the Auditor’s agricultural use values. Every one of the eleven hundred and forty. I accepted them in writing. They are a very sound basis, and the notices on those parcels are withdrawn.”
A great sound went through the room, like a field of wheat in a wind. Wilma Haskett put her hand to her mouth.
“I do not, however,” said Vance, “accept the Reserve.”
She said it so pleasantly. She stood at her table with her folder, a woman who has never in her life been in a hurry, and she laid out the case in about six minutes. The Reserve, she said, was a hundred and eighteen acres in the county. It had been, on the date of valuation, the first of January, idle. It had been idle on the first of January of every year since 1915. Under the Code, land idle on the lien date does not qualify for the use valuation. And land that had been withheld from production, and was now put to a crop, was not entitled to a retroactive benefit. “A crop sown on the second of August,” said Vance, “is not a farm on the first of January. It is a gesture.”
“The Reserve,” said Commissioner Ahlgren, looking up over her glasses, “has been in your appraisal as a parcel with no price.”
“It has had no price,” said Vance. “It has a lookback.”
“A hundred and ten years.”
“A hundred and eleven in January,” said Vance, apologetically. “I am only the arithmetic.”
I rose, and said the first thing that came, which was the truth.
“Members of the Board. The Reserve was not idle.”
“It was bare stubble,” said Vance, gently.
“It was held,” I said. “In reserve. By the owner, for the Association, and for the people of this county, as the compact had it. It was not a field that nobody had thought to plant. It was a field that was kept back from planting because the land was bearing another crop.” I turned a page. “I ask the Board to take notice that the Reserve was farmed. Every night, for a hundred and twelve years, by three hundred and sixty-two persons, in the late crew. They worked it. It is in the Book. A hand is one night’s labor. The ground was in use every night since 1917.”
There was a long hush.
“And was it,” said Vance, “agricultural?”
“I do not know,” I said, “what else you would call it.”
She did not answer. For the first time that morning her smile went still, and she looked at me with the unguarded face of a woman looking at someone who has made a move she respects. Then she smiled again, and I saw that she had not been surprised.
“The Auditor argues beautifully,” she said. “And I must say, the Board might find it persuasive, if the late crew had been laboring on the Reserve at the pleasure of its owner. But the crew did not labor at the owner’s pleasure. The crew labored on the Lender’s call, by the book. They were not the owner’s hands. They were mine.” She said it very softly. “They were the Lender’s. I am obliged to say so.”
“I will make it short,” said Vance. “It all depends on one thing, and the Auditor has said it herself. Whose use? A farm is used by its owner, or by a tenant of its owner. The Reserve is owned, by deed, in the Recorder’s vault, by a person named Alder, aged nine. If she farms it, the Reserve is farmland. If she does not, it is not. I have the Auditor’s own words. She said, in a creek bed, to a child, ‘If it is to count, it must be yours.’” She stopped. “I was nearby. I take no credit.”
I felt the room tilt.
“Members of the Board,” said Vance, “I do not believe this child has ever farmed. She has been, by every account, a nine-year-old, for a century, in the care of an old lady. I put it to you that the crop on the Reserve was not sown by its owner. It was sown by a county. Which is a very different thing.”
“She planted the first row,” I said. “I was there. Three hundred people saw it.”
“One row.”
“One row is a use.”
“Then,” said Vance, with great sweetness, “I would like to ask the owner.”
She turned. She had not looked at the door all morning. Now she looked at it, and every head in the room turned with her, and I saw her, in the doorway, in her gray pinafore, with her plaits crooked and her hand in Mrs. Pilcher’s glove, the smallest person in the building.
“I should like to answer,” said Mabel, in her small hoarse voice, “if I may.”
“You may, dear,” said Commissioner Ahlgren, who had gone quite pale.
The child came down the aisle. She walked all the way to the front, past the pews and the people, with her feet in their buckled shoes ringing on the old boards, and she stopped before the bench, a very long way down from it. She looked up.
“I planted it,” she said. “I did the first row. And I did the second. And the third, until my arm hurt. And Mr. Truitt helped. But it was mine.”
“Thank you, dear,” said Vance, warmly. “I have only one more thing. It will not take a minute. Do you remember a paper that you signed, on Saturday, at a little table by the bridge?”
Mabel frowned. “I signed the list. Mrs. Pilcher said that everyone did.”
“And did you sign anything else?”
“Oh,” said Mabel, and her face cleared. “The kind lady’s paper. She asked if I would be so good. It was only a form.” She looked at Vance with bright trust. “You gave me a peppermint.”
Nobody moved. I think I stopped breathing. In the second row, Mrs. Pilcher rose halfway to her feet and sat down again, with her gloved hand over her mouth.
Vance opened her blue folder. She drew out a single sheet, a long narrow sheet of ruled ledger paper, buff, ruled in red, headed in the old careful lettering of the white page. She held it up between two fingers. At the foot of it, in the upright, unimproved hand of a nine-year-old, was a signature, and a date, and a time, and the single word she had been taught to write after it, as one writes the end of a letter.
RETURN OF THE OWNER. County of Alder. As described. Signed: Alder, the Land. Sat. July 31, 7:04 a.m.
“I only wished,” said Loretta Vance, to the whole silent room, “to be sure that the owner had made a return.”

