The Board recessed at ten past eleven for what Commissioner Ahlgren called, with a look that could have curdled a pudding, “a period of reflection.”
I do not remember crossing the hall. I remember the marble, and the long cool window at the end of the third-floor corridor, and Felix holding a paper cup of water I had not asked for. I remember Wilma Haskett, who stopped me at the stairhead and said only, “Auditor, if the child is harmed, I shall go to the Lord and complain,” and went on down.
Mabel sat on the bench in the corridor between Mrs. Pilcher and Junie, with her feet not touching the floor, swinging them, and a half-eaten peppermint in a twist of cellophane in her hand.
I sat down beside her. I did not know how to begin.
“I did something wrong,” said Mabel. She said it quite calmly, looking straight ahead at the wall. “Didn’t I?”
“No.”
“The lady looked so pleased.”
“I know.”
“I thought it was nice.” Her feet stopped. “Nobody has ever asked me to sign a thing before. In the Book it is only the hand. Mrs. Pilcher’s hand. Mine is only for the table.” She turned the peppermint over. “And she said it was a form to say that I had come. That I was there, and that I had helped. Like the sign-in sheet. I thought it would be on the wall. For the people. I thought it was a thank-you.”
I looked over her head at Junie. Junie’s face had gone the color of paper and her eyes were wet, but she kept her mouth shut and her hand on the back of the bench, as steady as a rail.
“She spoke to you first,” I said, “at the bridge. In the morning.”
“Yes. When the rows were done. When I was tired.” Mabel frowned, remembering. “She came and knelt down, very nicely, and said I had done a lovely job. She said no one had ever done it so well. And she had a peppermint.” She held it up. “I did not want to say no. It would have been rude.”
“It would not.”
“Mr. Truitt says it’s rude to refuse a person who is being kind.”
“Mr. Truitt,” I said, and heard my own voice, “is a very good man, and he has been wrong about that for sixty years. So have I.”
It was a strange thing to say to a child, and I do not know why it came out. Mrs. Pilcher drew in a sharp, small breath. I saw her take off her glove, and put it back on, and take it off.
“Do you know,” I said, “what the paper was?”
“A form.”
“It was a Return. It is a document that an owner files, to say what she owns. Where it begins and where it ends and what is on it. By signing, you swore that the county was as you had walked it. And the Lender’s Appraiser has taken your oath, and is going to put it before the Board, to say that the Land of Alder owns the whole of the county.”
“But I do,” said Mabel. “Don’t I? They told me.”
“You own the Reserve. You own a field, and a bridge, and a creek bank, and a child’s whole life in a spoon.” I breathed. “You were not told that you owned the people. Or the houses. Or the pantries. They are not yours. They are only inside the line.”
“Oh,” said Mabel, very small.
“And a person who owns a thing,” I said, as gently as I could, “can be made to give it up, to pay her debts. Your Note falls due on the first of December. If you own the whole of the county, then the county is part of what you owe. And the Lender may take it in kind. All of it.”
She sat very still. Then she put the peppermint down on the bench beside her, with great care, as a person sets down something that has begun to hurt.
“I would not have signed,” she said. “If I had known.”
“I know.”
“Mrs. Pilcher would have said. I would have asked her.”
“I should have said,” said Mrs. Pilcher. Her voice cracked. She looked at the child’s small bowed head, and then, to my great surprise, she knelt, a seventy-eight-year-old woman in a good wool coat, on the marble of the third-floor corridor, in front of a nine-year-old girl, and took both her hands. “I should have said,” she repeated. “I was making the tea. I saw the lady kneeling at the bridge, and I thought, how kind. I thought, how very kind. I did not look.” She bent her head. “I have been looking away for thirty-four years, Mabel. It is a habit I am too old to break.”
“It’s all right,” said Mabel.
“It is not.”
“It is,” said the Land of Alder, with sudden iron, in her flat old voice. “I would like it to be.” She put her small hand on Mrs. Pilcher’s white hair, and I saw, for just a moment, the thing behind her eyes, the thing that is not nine at all. It was very tired. And very kind. “You are not to apologize to me. I am not that young.”
Nobody said anything. Down the corridor a door opened and shut. A clerk went by with a file.
“Auditor,” said Mabel.
“Yes.”
“Is there a way to take it back?”
“I do not know.” I made myself say it. “A return is a sworn statement. It can be amended, by the person who made it. If she can show that it was wrong. That it was obtained without full knowledge.”
“Was it?”
“Yes.”
“Then it is wrong,” said Mabel.
“It is not as simple as that.” I took out my notebook, and my pencil, and I wrote, in the margin, in my neat hand, the one word: Estoppel. And under it: spent. “I used it in Tolliver. It will not work twice. The Lender’s Appraiser has seen it. She is a person who has been through this many times, and she will have been careful to ask for nothing that the law can call a trick.”
“She gave me a peppermint,” said Mabel, doubtfully.
“A peppermint,” I said, “is not a trick. It is a perfectly good peppermint. That is the whole of what is dreadful about it.”
Mabel looked at me, and a slow, wicked, entirely nine-year-old smile began at the corner of her mouth. It was the first one I had seen that day. “That is a very funny thing to say.”
“I am not a funny person.”
“No,” said Mabel. “But you are getting better.”
It was Felix who came for us at half past eleven, with his tie crooked and his phone at his ear, and the look of a person who has been listening to a bailiff. He put his head around the courtroom door. “The Board is ready,” he said. “They want, um. They want to take a ruling on the Reserve. And there’s a second matter.” He swallowed. “Mr. Hale has asked for the floor.”
I stood up. I took her hand, and she let me.
“Auditor,” she said, as we went toward the door, “there is one more thing. I did not say it in front of the others.”
“Say it now.”
“When the lady knelt down,” said Mabel, in a very small voice, “at the bridge. When she gave me the peppermint. I asked her where the last stake went. She told me. She said, not to worry, dear, it closes at the table.”
I stopped. The corridor was quite quiet.
“Which table?”
“She did not say,” said Mabel. “But I think she was being kind.”

