The Board ruled for the Reserve at eleven forty. I will give it in one paragraph, because it took Commissioner Ahlgren about that long to read.
The Reserve was farmland. It was in crop on the day of hearing, by its owner and operator, who had planted the first three rows with her own hand and ridden the rest on a drill in the care of a competent farmer. The owner was a minor, and the law favored a minor’s industry. The notice of recoupment was dismissed for want of a lien date in the nineteenth century. “This Board,” said Ahlgren, taking off her glasses, “does not enforce a rule that was not written.” Orlovsky, the Treasurer, who had said nothing for three hours, blew his nose in a large red handkerchief, and Wilma Haskett in the front row said, quite clearly, “Amen.”
Vance bowed. She was entirely gracious about it. She said she had expected no less, and that she was in the Board’s debt, and she shut her blue folder with the Return still in it.
Then Gideon Hale asked for the floor.
He came up the aisle with his umbrella under his arm and his long gray coat and the expression he wore when he had come to a decision and would regret it later. He stood below the bench. Teague came behind him with the blue notebook open, and in the sudden hush I heard the pen scratching.
“I observe a procedure,” said Hale. “A return of the owner has been filed. It is signed. It is sworn. It is, I am obliged to say, a good instrument. A Return, once filed, may be amended only by the signer, and only for mistake.” He paused. “The Land is a minor. Her mistake is evident. But I am not the Board, and the Board has not asked me.”
“Mr. Hale,” said Ahlgren faintly. “The Board is asking.”
“Then I observe a second procedure. The County of Alder was erected by statute in 1816. The statute describes its boundary. It does not say by an owner. It does not say by survey.” He took a folded sheet from his coat. “It says, ‘by common reputation known and reputed.’ A boundary so held is not the property of any one person. It is held in common. It may be proved, or it may be disproved, by witnesses to reputation.” He looked, for the first time, at me. “A Return is the owner’s account of what she owns. Reputation is the county’s account of what it is. Where the two disagree, the Act prefers the county.”
I did not move. Beside me Felix had stopped writing.
“If the people of the county,” said Hale, “in sufficient number, affirm under oath what Alder is, and if what they affirm is a thing that is not property, then the Return describes a parcel that the Act does not recognize.” He drew breath, as a man does who is lifting something. “I would not like to say what is sufficient. I will say that the matter must be settled before the table is set. That is the old phrase. Saturday. At noon.” He looked at his umbrella. “I do not make the rules. I am only the person who has read them.”
He turned, with Teague behind him, and walked out of the courtroom through a silence you could have stood a spoon in.
“What,” said Felix, in a thin, awed voice, “did he just do?”
“He gave us four days,” I said.
“To do what?”
“To get the county,” I said, “to say what it is.”
I will not give all four days. They run together. They are the shortest and the longest of that summer, and in my memory they have the color of a tablecloth.
The form was Felix’s. It was a single sheet, in plain English, with a place for the person’s name and a line at the bottom for a notary, and in the middle a large square, about the size of an index card, headed with a question that took us two hours to settle: ALDER IS WHERE. A person was asked to finish the sentence in one line, in her own words, in ink, and to swear that it was true.
“There’s a rule,” said Felix, “against putting a conclusion in an affidavit. It has to be a fact. What the person saw or heard.”
“Then they must write a thing they have seen.”
“Alder is where,” said Felix, tasting it. “Alder is where I saw. Alder is where somebody saved me a seat.” He looked up. “It’s almost a poem. I wish it wasn’t legal.”
Strouse printed four thousand, and then ten thousand more. Orlovsky, to everybody’s surprise, volunteered the Treasurer’s office as a notary station and stayed in it for sixty hours with a pot of coffee, a stamp, and the manner of a man who has found his calling at last. Marge at the front desk handed out forms with a pen. The Methodist church ran a table. So did the Catholic one, and the Lutheran, and the little brick Mennonite meetinghouse out on the Morrow road. The barber put a stack on his counter. The Dutch Maid put one by every sugar caddy.
I want to give some of the cards. I kept a few. Felix has more.
Alder is where my father was buried and my daughter was married and I have never once had to explain myself. That was a man in a feed cap, aged seventy.
Alder is where the road crew plows the church lot before the school lot, and nobody complains. That was Gil.
Alder is where you can leave your keys in the truck and your pie on the porch, and both will be there. A young woman, in purple ink, with a smiling face drawn over the i.
Alder is where Mrs. Pilcher’s zucchini bread arrives whether or not you’ve been good. The name was Tate Rinehart. He signed it twice.
Alder is where I was fed. Eli Mullet, in plain black pencil, who would not swear, and was permitted by Orlovsky to affirm, which he did with grave attention.
Alder is where a stranger poured coffee for my wife at four in the morning. Walter Kimbrough, who was not from Alder at all, but had driven down from Tolliver in the night with the card filled out and his hat in his hand. I took it. I did not ask.
It came in stacks. People brought them from three counties. They brought them in envelopes and in a shoebox. Wilma Haskett wrote hers in a copperplate hand, on the third attempt, and sat in the Treasurer’s office for half an hour deciding whether to swear it, and in the end she did. Alder is where I was permitted to be useful. It is in a frame, now, on Junie’s wall.
By Thursday evening we had eleven thousand cards. By Friday, nineteen. I will not say I counted. I sat in the Auditor’s office in the long yellow light with the cards in stacks across every surface, and my right forearm, which I had not looked at in days, lay on the blotter like a thing that belonged to somebody else. I did not need to count. I could feel the weight of it, the county saying what it was, one line at a time.
It was at nine on Friday night, with the building empty and the cleaners gone, that I came to the last box.
It had been left on the counter in the front lobby, in a plain brown carton, with no name. Marge had put it aside. Inside, on top, lay a single index card, tucked under the flap, in a hand I would have known on the dark side of the moon. It was in green. It was in a round, firm, bookkeeper’s hand, with a flourish on the tail of the last letter. It was unsigned, except for an initial. It was sworn, in a manner I did not try to understand, by a notary stamp from a county that had no business having a notary in it. The stamp read, in tiny, blurred type: Tolliver, Ohio. Rear Chain.
I held it under the lamp for a long time.
Alder is where somebody saved me a seat. I am saving yours. M.

