The renewed writ came on Thursday at noon, by the usual hand, and it was served in the usual place, which was now a supper table.
Frame brought it. He came down the shaft on his own two feet, past Dub’s coffee urn, and stopped on the landing to straighten his cardigan. He had bought a new one. It was still gray, but it was wool, and it fit, and I noticed that he had a small brown paper bag in his left hand with a grease stain at the bottom, and that he held it as one holds something one has been afraid to be seen carrying. It was a sausage biscuit. He ate it standing at the arch, before he came in, in four bites, and brushed his lap, and said, “It is noted that I did not have to ask.”
“You did not,” said Voight, from the Keeper’s chair.
We were seven, that noon. Voight, Frame, Mrs. Pilcher at the Clerk’s place, Felix with a legal pad, Teague at the foot with no pen, and Mabel, who had come in with Junie after school because she had asked, and sat in the Land’s chair with a coloring book and said that she would be very quiet. I stood at the Guest’s place with my hand on the chair. The candle burned. The book lay open on its plate, at the first page, and every hour or so, with no one near it, a leaf turned and fell back, as a sleeper turns in bed.
“It is a hearing,” said Teague. “Of a kind. I will enter the minutes. I would ask the parties to speak slowly.”
“There are no parties,” said Felix. “It is a supper.”
“It is the same,” said Teague, “if it is done in good faith.”
Frame cleared his throat. He took the cream folder from under his arm and set it down on the cloth, well away from the book, and opened it. “It is noted that the Depository has issued a renewed writ. It calls for the delivery of Volume Zero, by the Bailee, to the Lender, on demand. It is dated yesterday. It is signed, in the usual form.”
“Examined,” said Mrs. Pilcher.
“Yes.” He did not look at it. “I am directed to read it aloud, and to ask whether the Bailee will deliver.”
“Read it.”
He read it. It was short. It said that the Bailee had been put on notice, that delivery was demanded, that the volume had not been surrendered, and that the Bailee’s keeping was thereby converted into a charge, to be added to the arrears of Alder on the first of December. It stated what would be.
“Will the Bailee deliver?” said Frame.
I had thought about the answer for six days. I had written it out in the kitchen, on the back of a gas bill. I had not shown it to anyone. I looked at Teague, and Teague, who held no pen, gave me the smallest nod, as a swimmer gives one to someone on the bank.
“Yes,” I said.
There was a gasp. It was Felix.
“I will deliver,” I said, “on demand, to the owner, intact, as Section Nine requires and as Ms. Teague has taught me the law of bailment. I have kept it safe. I have not used it. I have not opened it. I have not put my hand to it.” I laid my left hand on the back of my mother’s chair. “The owner’s agent has demanded it. I deliver it. It is here.”
“It is,” said Frame, uncertainly. “Where?”
“There.” I pointed. “In the Lender’s chair. At the head of the table. With a card in front of it that says THE LENDER, in a hand that is not mine, on a plate that is not mine, in a room that I did not furnish. It has been there since the third of March, 1816. The Lender sat down at this table two hundred and eleven years ago and has not left it.” I took a breath. “I will not take it from its place. I will not carry it up a stair. I will not touch it with tongs. It is delivered. It is in the owner’s possession, at the owner’s seat, and I am discharged.”
Nobody moved.
“It is a point of law,” said Teague, very quietly. “A bailee may deliver by attornment. The goods are acknowledged to be in the owner’s possession, wherever they lie, and the bailee holds no more. It is an old doctrine.” A pause. “It is, I should add, quite sound.”
“That is not delivery,” said Frame. “That is a trick.”
“It is a table,” I said. “It is the place the Lender chose.”
“It is noted,” said Frame, with an odd, breathless look, “that I do not know how to enter that.”
“Enter that the Bailee has delivered, by attornment, at the Lender’s seat, at twelve forty-one in the afternoon of the twenty-sixth of August. Enter that the Stationer has been present.” Teague spoke without a pause. “Enter that the Stationer is invited to attest.”
Frame looked at the book. He looked at the chair. He looked, I think, at the card with its brown rust letters, THE LENDER, and the lamplit gray cloth on the plate, quiet as a loaf. Then he picked up his own pen, a black one, plain, and held it over the cream folder, and I saw his hand shake.
“If I attest,” he said, slowly, “then the Lender has the book. And the Bailee is discharged. And the Lender, it follows, is responsible for what is in it.” He looked up. “It is noted that this is the first time in nineteen years that I have been asked to sign a thing that I understood.”
“Will you?”
He set the pen down.
“I will not,” said Odell Frame.
“It is a perfectly good attestation,” said Teague.
“It is a perfectly good attestation,” said Frame, “and I will not sign it. I will not sign anything at this table. I have eaten here. I have been seated.” His voice was quite steady, which seemed to surprise him. “It is my understanding that a man who has eaten at a table is a guest of it. He is not its agent. He cannot be both.” He folded the folder. He put it in the canvas bag. “I return the writ unserved. I return it to the Depository, with my regrets, and my resignation, which I shall write tonight. I do not know what I will do. My wife is very practical. She says that I could keep bees.”
“Mr. Frame,” I said.
“Odell,” said Frame. He ducked his head. “If it is permitted.”
There was a sound in the shaft.
It was not loud. It was the small dry rap of a wet black umbrella set down on stone, at the foot of the ladder, in the dark beyond the arch. It was a sound I would have known anywhere, and it had a patience in it I had not heard before.
“It is permitted,” said Hale.
He stood in the archway, exactly where he had stood on Sunday, with his hat in his hand. In the lamplight his face was drawn. His eyes went round the table, to the Keeper, the Clerk, the Land with her crayons, the former Stationer in his new cardigan, and the notary with the empty hand, and last to the plate at the head, where the book lay open in the Lender’s chair. He looked at it for a long time.
“It was delivered,” said Gideon Hale.
“By attornment,” said Teague.
“It is sound.” He said it with something I can only call grief. “I should have seen it. I taught the doctrine.” He turned the hat in his hands. “The Lender accepts delivery. I enter it myself. Where it lies.” A pause. “The Bailee is discharged. The charge is struck. The Letter of Exigency is spent.”
“Then it is over,” said Felix, hoarsely.
“It is not over,” said Hale. “It has changed hands.” He looked at me, and the gray eyes were very bright. “It is a very old rule of the Table, Auditor, and I do not think you have been told it. Whoever holds a thing at the Lender’s seat is responsible for it. It is not a penalty. It is a courtesy. It is the reason the seat is kept.” He bowed from the neck. “The Lender has accepted its book. The Lender has no hand. Someone must sit with it.”
“Who?”
“The first of December,” said Hale, “I shall examine it where it lies. At this table. In the presence of all the places.” His eyes did not leave my face. “I would ask that the ninth be filled.”
He went up the stair. The drop of water on the brick, where the umbrella had stood, did not dry.

