Priya Raman read Standard Nine aloud at eight in the morning, standing at the end of the ninth-floor conference table with a highlighter in her teeth and a binder open on her forearm, and by the third paragraph Ostrander had stopped clicking his pen.
“Nine point one,” she said. “Scope. Nine point two, Reviewer independence. Nine point three, Classification of findings.” She took the highlighter out. “Here’s the part. A finding is Minor, Significant or Material. A Minor finding is noted. A Significant finding is reported and must be remediated. Three Significant findings in one review are aggregated, and the aggregate is treated as a Material finding.”
“And a Material finding?” said Ostrander.
Priya turned the page. She did not look at me. “Nine point six. A Material finding suspends the examiner’s tick. Every tick placed by the examiner within the scope of the review is deemed unsupported until reperformed by another examiner of equal standing.”
Nobody spoke. Down on Broad Street a bus kneeled at the curb with a long pneumatic sigh.
“Reperformed by another examiner of equal standing,” said Ostrander, “means.”
“There isn’t one,” said Priya. “Not in this building. Not that can tick like hers.”
I had known for twelve hours what a finding was, in the abstract. I had not worked out the arithmetic. Twelve thousand, four hundred and six hands of principal, ticked in green. Hester Lind’s thirty-one thousand nights. The Receipt Book with its flowers. Every figure I had ever spoken in a field with a table under it would, on the day a Material finding was signed, go gray and loose and become what it had been before I touched it, which was a liability nobody had labelled.
I had made them real. If I was found to have done it badly, they would stop being real. That is the whole terror of an auditor’s life, and I had never before had it spelled out in a binder.
“Where is she?” said Ostrander.
“Nine-F,” said Priya. “It’s down the hall. It wasn’t there on Friday.”
Room 9-F was between 9-E and the supply closet, and the nameplate was brass and said REVIEW. I would swear the corridor had been fifteen feet shorter the week before. Constance Teague stood in the doorway in her flannel suit with a mug of tea and the careful expression of a woman waiting for her guest to see the flowers.
Inside, the room was lined floor to ceiling with banker’s boxes. They were labelled in a neat blue hand, by year and client. There were two thousand of them, perhaps more. I walked down the first aisle and read the lids as I went. ROWAN PELL, STAFF ACCOUNTANT, 2014. ROWAN PELL, CARRICK COUNTY HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION, 2017. ROWAN PELL, CARRICK TOWNSHIP FIRE LEVY, 2019. My first audit had been a fire levy. I had forgotten that. I had cried on the way home because the chief had cried at the exit conference, over a hose.
“They came up overnight,” said Teague. “I did not do it. I would like to say that. It is simply that the building knows what a review needs.”
“Whose building?”
“It is an Auditor of State’s office, Colleague. It has always known.” She sipped her tea. “Mr. Ostrander, good morning. I have an engagement letter I believe you will want to countersign.”
I watched him take it. He saw a woman with a mug, of course. He had seen nothing else of the Lender in four months. He read the first page with his glasses on the cord and his lips pursed and the pen going click, click, and said, “This is a standard quality review under the Auditor of State’s peer program. Pell’s Certificate affects a surety. It’s routine. I should have scheduled it myself.”
“You are very kind.”
“It says here the reviewer is from the Office of Quality Review.”
“The name of the office,” said Teague, “is not on a plate. But I am from it.”
He signed. I wanted to take the pen from his hand, and I did not, because a reviewee who obstructs her own review commits a finding in itself, which I had learned from Priya’s binder at seven fifty-eight.
“Nine point four,” I said. “Reviewee’s rights.”
“Of course.” Teague set down her mug. “You may inspect the reviewer’s working papers at any time during fieldwork, on reasonable notice. You may name up to two assistants, who serve under the same independence rules as you. You may respond in writing to every finding before it is final. You may,” and she paused, with a little rueful smile, “have lunch.”
“Priya Raman and Felix Bascomb.”
“Accepted.” She wrote it on a pad in blue ink. “Ms. Raman, I like your highlighter. Mr. Bascomb is not in the building yet, I think? Excellent. There is a lot of work.”
I will say it was a long, strange, fairly cheerful day. Teague took the seat at the head of the table and a legal pad and a red box, and she began to go through me the way a good dentist goes through a mouth, quietly, beginning at the back. She asked for the planning memo for the Association’s engagement. She asked for the sampling plan. She asked, politely, what the unit was in my workpaper on the Long Bottom field, and when I told her, she wrote down the unit and the time I said it, and she did not look up.
By ten she had asked for forty-one items and I had produced thirty-eight. The three I could not find, she wrote down without comment, and the without-comment was the loudest thing in the room. Priya passed me sticky notes: Don’t explain. Say where it is or say it isn’t. Sound advice, and I hated it.
At noon I took the bread to the basement, because the window was thirty-one minutes now and I owed Priya’s lunch to the Marrow Fork box. I came back up with my hands cold from the stairwell and found the room empty except for Priya, who sat on the floor between two aisles with a banker’s box in her lap and a face I knew from the lunch hour in January.
“Reviewee’s rights,” she said. “I used mine. I opened her cabinet.”
The cabinet at the far end was gray steel, five drawers, with a brass label that read PEER REVIEW, PRIOR ENGAGEMENTS. I had passed it three times without seeing it. The bottom drawer was open. Inside there were eleven boxes, shoulder to shoulder, each with a name on the lid in the same neat blue hand and a blue tick with a hook.
The box in her lap had been the last in the row, wedged in at the end. She turned it so I could read the lid.
CORLEY, T., Chief Examiner, 1968 to 1971. PEER REVIEW, Nov. 1971. Reviewer: C. Teague.
“She told me yesterday,” Priya whispered, “that no one had ever asked her anything in fifty-five years.”
“I know.”
“She’s on his box, Rowan. She’s the one who reviewed him.” She put her hand flat on the lid. It was warm. “Section 9.4 says you can read the reviewer’s papers. It doesn’t say you have to want to.”
Down the hall I heard Constance Teague’s clear voice, humming. It was a hymn. I knew it from the Thanksgiving table. It was “Bringing in the Sheaves.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!