Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 84

Memorandum to File

She gave it to me on Tuesday morning in the corridor outside 9-F, before the day began, and she did not wait while I read it. She put it into my hand, a thin manila folder with a rubber band around it, and said, “It is my own. It is dated the third of December, 1971. I should like you to have it before you decide what to say about me,” and walked away down the hall with her tote bag, her flannel suit and her blue pen, and I was alone with it at the window.

I read it standing up. Here it is, in her hand and her voice. She was twenty-nine.

MEMORANDUM TO FILE. Office of the State Examiner. Date: Dec. 3, 1971. Prepared by: C. Teague, Staff Examiner. Subject: Peer review of T. Corley, Chief Examiner; subsequent events.

Purpose. This memo records what I did, what I found and what I was told, as completely as I can. It is not for the Chief Examiner’s office. I do not know who it is for. I am typing it because it is the only thing I know how to do.

Background. On Nov. 19 I was assigned to review the Chief. I had been a staff examiner for six years and had not been given a review before. It was an honor and I felt it. Mr. Corley is fifty-three, tall, a little stooped, and is the only man in the office who stands when a woman enters the room. He keeps his lunch in a paper sack and eats at his desk with the door open. He shares it with the typist, Mrs. Abbott. He has a green pen that he will not lend.

Procedure. I reviewed the Teasel engagement over nine working days. I tested forty items. I reperformed the footings, confirmed the schedule of fields with the county plat, and spent two afternoons in the Teasel Courthouse looking at a ledger that balanced to the penny. Mr. Corley sat with me on the second afternoon. He said, “It is too clean, Miss Teague.” I said that clean books were no crime. He said, “They are when nobody has ever found a mistake.” He said it as a man says a thing he is trying to forget.

Findings. None. I wish to state that clearly, because I have gone back over every page. He had not skipped a step. His workpapers were the best I have seen. His tick marks were legible. I wrote the report on Nov. 29, a Monday, and typed the opinion in the usual form. It said Unmodified. I took it to him myself. He read it standing, at the window, and I saw him close his eyes.

I thought it was pride. I thought: he is moved. It was not pride.

Events of Nov. 30. I do not know all of them. I know that on Tuesday at 4:40 p.m. he signed the Certificate of Examination for Teasel, in green, in the courthouse, in front of the trustees. I know that at 4:51 the trustees declined a grant, in person, from a representative of the Public Department, a young woman in a red coat who had brought a cake. I know that at that minute two hundred and eleven residents of the county went out into a field. And I know that Mr. Corley left the courthouse after the signing and drove to the Marrow Fork Overlook, where he gave his coat to a boy and went down to the water. These I have from the courthouse clerk, a Mr. Pruitt, and from the Overlook’s gatekeeper, who was crying. I have not seen it.

What I did. On Wednesday morning, Dec. 1, I went to Records to file my report and found the room very quiet. Mrs. Abbott told me. I went to Mr. Corley’s office. The door was open. The paper sack was on the desk with a sandwich in it, uneaten, and a note in his hand on the blotter that said only: Not her fault.

I do not understand what he meant. I have read it eleven times. I think he meant mine.

What I was told. On Friday evening, Dec. 3, at about seven, a woman in a red coat rang the bell of my apartment on Neil Avenue. She carried a coffee cake. She was perhaps twenty-six. She did not give her name. She said that I had an eye, and that the Department had noticed it, and that there was a post.

I asked what the post was. She said that it was a kind of review. She said that I would examine the examiner, in every county, at term, and that I would be permitted to say only what was true. She said it was a great honor. She said that no one else could do it, because most people, when they find a thing they cannot bear, look away.

I asked whether I should be required to pass anyone. She said that I should be required to be accurate. I asked what that meant. She said: “It means that you will have to see what you have done.”

I did not ask her what she meant. I am setting that down. It is the single sentence in this memorandum that I would give up the rest of my life to unsay.

What I did next. I ate the coffee cake. I sat at my kitchen table and ate it with a fork, and it was the best I have ever had, and I understood while I ate it that I had agreed. It is not that I decided. It is that I did not refuse. There is a difference, and it is the whole of my life.

I also did one small thing, and it is the only part I will defend. On Monday, Dec. 6, I went to the Auditor of State’s office in the tower and went down to the basement to see whether the clerk in B-14 was in. There is a clerk. I know because I have seen his hand. He had written on the back of my report, under my tick, one word, in a round clear script, in pale ink: Reviewed. I had never seen the door. I had never been in the room. It was on the back of the report when it came back to me, with no postmark.

I do not know who he is. I left a sandwich outside the wall where I thought the door might be, wrapped in waxed paper, with a note: In case you eat. I left it at noon. At twelve-forty it was gone, and I do not know who took it.

I mean to do it again tomorrow. I do not know why. I think that someone ought to.

Conclusion. I have been asked to continue. I said yes. I did not ask what it would cost.

C.T.

I stood at the window of the ninth floor for some time with the folder open in my hand. Below me Broad Street was gray and wet, with the buses coming up from the river.

There was a postscript. It was not typed; it was in blue ink, small, in her clear hand, and the ink was a different color from the rest. It was added, I thought, a long time later, perhaps decades, on a Sunday.

P.S. I have been in four hundred and eleven counties and I have written no finding that was false. I have never once been wrong. I should like to be wrong about one thing. I should like it to be you.

I closed the folder. I put the rubber band around it with great care. And I went down the hall to 9-F, where she stood at the head of the long table with her pen behind her ear and her tea going cold, and did not look up as I came in, as a woman does not look at the door of an operating room.

“Reviewer,” I said.

“Yes, Colleague.”

“I have read your memorandum. I do not have a question.” I laid it on the table in front of her. “I only want you to know that I have never been so glad to have read something I wished I had not.”

She raised her head. It was only for a second. Her eyes were very bright, and she did not say anything, and the clock on the wall, a plain round one, ticked off the minute, and the next, and the next, until Priya came in with the coffee and the day began.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!