Boyd Hensley taught him the eighth stave on Dovie’s porch, in four passes, with his satchel in his lap and his sister on the step below him, refusing to be more than three feet away.
It was short. Everett Lyle had made it up in the dark, Boyd said, to keep time with, and sung it so many nights that the Hollow had picked it up like a hymn. A stave for a man with nothing but his breath.
“I count the breath of the one I love. I count it, one by one. I count it low, I count it slow, until the night is done.”
“That’s all of it?” said Silas.
“That’s all of it,” said Boyd. “He told me a man doesn’t need much of a tune if he means it.” He put his big ears to the wind. “Now the blank, mister. You’ll want something that’s yours.”
Silas had the answer before the question. It had been in his notebook for three years. On the way up to the Lip that evening, with the frost coming down on the road and Cade’s lantern bobbing ahead, he took the notebook out for the first time in a week and turned it to the inside cover. Five strokes and a slash, over and over, in blue pen, down to the bottom of the page, and then onto the back of the cover. Eleven hundred miles.
He read it and closed it.
Marian Voss held the pull-off at the Gap with a clipboard and a hand-lettered sign that said TRAIL CLOSED. PLEASE GO HOME. Nobody got past her. Dusk came down hard and blue. The cairn lantern caught on the first try. When Silas put his palm to the first stone and hummed the flat third, the laurel breathed out cold, and the whole stair opened in front of them, bright and wet, to the bottom of the dark.
“Five staves,” whispered Cade. “Six. Seven.”
“Eight,” said Silas.
“I know. I’m counting.”
“You’re not counting. You’re muttering.”
“Same thing.” Cade’s hand settled on his shoulder, light as a bird on a wire.
Behind them Rena Lyle said, “One,” in a low steady voice, and the whole line of people on the frozen grass got a little quieter. Hester held the second lantern. Cora held Hester. Dovie held her cane and her peace. Odell and her brother stood at the cairn, not touching, Boyd with his cap in his hands.
Silas took a breath.
He sang the Calling backward, from the top, from the eighth, and a lean cold voice from far below sang it with him a half beat late, hoarse and steady and exactly in time. It counted as it sang, in the gaps: a little rasp of air at the end of every line, small as a thread.
“That’s one,” said Rena, quietly, from her chair. “That’s a living man. Oh, Everett. That’s one.”
At the blank he stopped.
He had the hole in the verse in front of him, a plain black space the shape of three years. He thought of the tally, and what a tally was for.
“I counted miles,” said Silas. “So I wouldn’t have to count the nights. Eleven hundred miles. I walked it, and I wrote it down, and every one was a night he was down there waiting, and I wanted a number that was only mine.” He swallowed. “I’m done counting miles. I’ll count his breaths.”
The Hollow rang.
“Hold the light,” he sang, and June’s steady voice took it up beside him, and the stair lit gold, a stand, two, three, four, five, six. It went right down into the dark. At the seventh stand someone stood up.
He was forty. He was a big man in a canvas coat, with a rough brown beard and a faded cap, and shoulders like a doorframe. His hands hung at his sides, square and scarred, and they were exactly Cade’s hands. He stood on the seventh stand in the gold light and looked up.
“Rena?” said the man.
She made a sound. She could not say it.
“Dad,” said Cade. It came out of him in a croak.
“Cade,” said the man on the stair, and took a breath, and something in it caught. “Little man. You’re so tall.”
The voice had been warm. It had been kind. And behind it, out of the dark beyond the seventh stand, another voice came up, too perfectly, in the same register, in the same tone. “Cade. Son. Come down. It’s warm down here.”
Cade’s hand clenched on Silas’s shoulder.
“Count,” said Rena, very sharp. “Both of them. Count, Cade. Listen. Who’s tired?”
They listened. The first voice breathed again, a rough and tired and ordinary breath. The second sang on, smooth as water, with nothing in the gaps.
“That one,” said Cade. His face was streaming. “That’s you. You’re the one who’s tired.”
“I’ve been tired nineteen years,” said Everett Lyle, from the stair, and almost laughed. “Be quick, son. It’s been learning my voice.”
“I know.”
“Sing the blank.”
It was the closing verse, and Silas gave it long and low, the way June had taught him, with everything he had left in his chest. I did not go for lack of you. I went for one who cried. So hold the light and sing it true, and tell me what you hid.
Cade’s hand lifted off his shoulder. He stepped forward on the frost. He stood at the lip of the stair, facing down into the gold, with his father forty feet below and his mother behind him in the chair.
“I stood at the top two nights,” said Cade Lyle. “For Wyatt. I told everybody it was for Wyatt.” His voice was hoarse and level. He did not look away. “It was for you. It was for you, Dad. I ran every race looking for you. I wanted to be good enough to be sent for. Come up. Mama said stay. I’m saying it too.”
The rope went tight and gold as wire.
“I was coming back for supper,” said Everett Lyle, to his son, from the stair. His voice broke clean in the middle. “I am so sorry I’m late.”
He climbed.
He climbed the way Boyd had, slow, surprised, one stone at a time, and when he reached the lip Cade went down on both knees and took him by the coat, and the man put both big hands on his son’s head. Then he looked over Cade’s shoulder at the woman in the chair.
“Hey, Rena,” said Everett. “You’re breathing better.”
“I am not,” said Rena. “Come here.”
He crossed the grass and she stood. Silas had not known she could. She came up out of the chair with the tube in her hand and one hand on the armrest and she stood on the frozen ground, fifty-eight years old and not much taller than a child, and put both hands flat on her husband’s chest.
“Count,” she said.
“One,” said Everett, and she put her ear to the canvas, and counted with him.
Dovie blew her nose like a trumpet. Ferrell Quillen took the toothpick out of his mouth and wrote, with enormous care, on the slate: HE’S GOT HER BREATHING.
It was nearly dawn when the wind turned.
Silas felt it before anyone. It came from the south, warm as bathwater, and it smelled of wet leaves and a long way off. Cade’s lantern leaned. Odell looked up. Then a single drop fell on the cairn with a sound like a thrown coin, and another, and Dovie said, from her crate, in a very quiet voice:
“Well. There’s the thaw.”
“It’ll sleep now,” said Hester.
They all watched the Lip. The frost ring on the grass should have shrunk and gone out. It did not. It stayed, white as salt, no wider than the lantern’s light and no narrower. The rain began to fall softly on the laurel, on the cairn, on the stair. The Hollow lay open in the warm gray dawn like a mouth in a sleeper’s face, and the stair did not close.
“It’s not sleeping,” said Everett Lyle, very low, with his arm around his wife. He was looking down the stair, past the seventh stand. “Somebody’s holding it open.”
Then two voices rose from the eighth stand, both at once.
“Si,” said the first.
“Si,” said the second.
They were dry and warm, with a laugh at the back of each. Both of them cracked on the G. Both took a breath.
And Rena Lyle, who had never once been wrong about a breath in all her thirty-one years, lifted her head from her husband’s coat and said in a very small voice, “Silas. I can’t tell.”

