Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 21

Which One

The rain came down warm on the back of his neck, and for the first time in a week Silas was not cold.

That was the strangest part. He stood at the lip of the stair in his gray cap with the frost ring white around his boots, and it was like standing in a snow globe somebody had set down in a spring shower. Water ran off the cairn. The laurel dripped. Below him, past the seventh step, the mist went on rising in the gray light as if the thaw were somebody else's business.

"Si," said the first voice.

"Si," said the second.

Nobody on the grass moved. Cade's lantern hissed softly under its cardboard box. Rena Lyle, in her chair under the tartan blanket, had her eyes closed and one hand lifted off the armrest, the way a woman holds up a hand in church to say not yet.

"Okay," said Silas. It came out flat and dry. "Okay. Hold on."

"Take your time," said the first voice. It was Wyatt's. It was warm and a little hoarse and had a laugh at the back, the voice that had said Take your time at a hundred trailheads, at a hundred slow doors. "We're not going anywhere. Well. I'm not."

"Take your time," said the second. "We're not going anywhere."

It had the same laugh at the same place.

Silas felt his stomach turn over like a pan. He made himself breathe. He was a person who had walked eleven hundred miles in order not to be asked questions, and now he was the one who had to ask.

"What's on the kitchen clock," he said, "at Mama's?"

"A chicken," said the first voice. "It lays time. I told you that when I was fourteen and you were eleven and you laughed so hard you threw up a little."

"A chicken. You said it lays time." The second voice laughed, the very same laugh. "You threw up a little, Si."

"What did you wrap the radio in," said Silas.

"A bread bag. Everything goes in a bread bag."

"Everything goes in a bread bag."

"Which bunk was yours?"

"Top," said both of them, in two warm voices at once, as pleased as if they had been waiting for the easy one.

He had never told anyone about the throwing up. He had told June about the clock when he was in her kitchen, and June had told him Wyatt used to say it, and Dovie had been in the room for the bread bags, and half a county had been told about the bunks. He saw that now. He had spent a week answering and answering at the Lip, with his own voice and his own stories, and the Hollow had been writing it all down.

"Rena," he said, not turning around.

"I'm counting."

She had been. For a minute he had been so busy with the questions he had stopped hearing it, the old careful sound at his back. One. Two. A breath, a small rasp at the top of the first voice. A breath at the end of the second, a little different, slightly sweeter.

"That's a breath," said Rena, very low. "That's a breath. That's a breath. Silas." She opened her eyes. "They're both breathing."

"I know. You said."

"I know I said." Her voice shook, and it never shook. "I've sat with eleven hundred people at the end of their lives, honey, and I have never once been wrong about a breath. I'm not wrong now. I'm telling you there are two of them and they are both doing it right."

"It heard you," said Everett Lyle.

He had come up quietly on the other side of the chair. He was standing very straight in his canvas coat, with Cade's hands hanging at his sides and a beard full of rain, and he was staring at the stair like a man who had walked into his own house and found it rearranged.

"Every night for a week," he said. "Out loud. One, two, three, with the whole stair listening. I counted down there, Rena, but I counted to myself. I never said it where it could hear." He turned his head. "We taught it. We said, here is how you can tell, and it sat down and learned."

"Don't count," said the first voice.

Silas went cold from the scalp down.

"Don't count, Si. It's listening to the counting," said the voice. It was low, and urgent, and it sounded exactly like the person who had once told him to keep his head down in a hailstorm. "That's how it got the breath. It wants the count. Don't answer it. Don't let Rena."

"Don't count, Si," said the second, in the same breath, with the same urgent hush. "It's listening to the counting. That's how it got the breath. Don't answer it."

It was not a half beat behind. It was inside the first, like a hand inside a glove.

Cade made a noise like something coming loose in his chest. "Easy," he said, to nobody. "Easy, easy."

"Which one," said Silas, and heard what was in his own voice and hated it. It was the voice of a boy of sixteen standing on a porch. "Which one of you."

"Me," said the first.

"Me," said the second.

There was a silence in which the rain went on falling on the leaves of the laurel, and under it, very faintly, the low steady sound of one man and one thing breathing at the same time. He could not hear a difference. He could not hear a difference. He stood there with all of his three years of listening and his two weeks of lends and eight staves of mountain in his chest, and there was no difference.

If he answered the wrong one, the rope would run to the wrong end.

He saw it, then, quite clearly: that this was exactly what it had wanted since the first night. Not to pull him down. Only to have him stand at the top of the stair, calling in a perfectly even voice to the one thing that would never be home.

"I'm not going to answer," said Silas.

"Si," said both.

"No. Listen. I'm not going to answer either one of you." His voice was shaking. He let it. "I'm not going to say a word to either of you until I know. So be quiet. Both of you. Please."

He had not expected it to work.

The voices stopped.

They stopped in the same instant, in the middle of the same breath, as cleanly as two hands let go of one rope, and the Hollow was silent. The rain made small sounds in the leaves. The mist rose off the seventh step. For a long minute nobody moved at all, and Silas realized that he could not tell whether the silence was Wyatt's courtesy or the thing's obedience, and that was worse.

"Well," said Dovie.

She was sitting on her crate by the cairn with the quilt over her knees, her white braid dark with rain. She had not spoken since the thaw began. She looked very old and not at all surprised.

"I'd have liked to say it wasn't so," she said. "I knew it had a mimic's ear. I told you that, hon, the first night. I never told you it was a learner."

"It learned from us," said Everett.

"It learned from every one of us," said Dovie, "every night, whatever we gave it. A tune. A tell. A way to say sorry." She tapped her cane on the cairn stone, three times, not at a stand, just as a woman taps a table. "Every time we found a way to tell it from the real thing, we handed it a lesson."

"Then there's nothing left," said Cade hoarsely. "Is there? It's got the voice, it's got the G, it's got the breath. What's left? What can it not copy?"

Nobody answered him.

Rena shut her eyes again and put her hand back down on the blanket. The lantern hissed in its box. The warm rain went on falling, and the frost ring, white as salt around Silas's boots, was a little narrower than it had been at dawn.

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!