The Pell County Commission met on the first and third Monday of the month in a basement room with a drop ceiling, a flag in a stand, and a countdown timer on the lectern that gave every speaker three minutes and not a second more.
On the first Monday in November, there was standing room only, and the room smelled of wet wool and coffee and the particular static of people who have come to be heard.
Silas sat in the fourth row between Dovie Rankin and Cade, with his hands under his thighs. Dovie had worn her good black coat and left her cane across her knees like a judge's gavel. Behind them in the back row, small and upright, Magistrate Oleta Fairchild sat with a crossword in her lap and a pen she had not lifted in twenty minutes, in the manner of a woman who intended to see the whole performance.
"Item six," said Chairwoman Bunny Hatcher, a large cheerful person in a cardigan the color of tangerines. "Emergency Management. Mr. Mabry."
Dwight Mabry stood up with a binder. He was a thin pale man in his fifties with a lanyard, and he had laminated everything. He had laminated the maps. He had laminated, Silas noticed, the laminated map's legend.
"Madam Chair," said Mr. Mabry. "As of Sunday morning, this county has experienced what my office is calling a cluster event. There have been, to date, forty-two documented medical presentations of a nonspecific fatigue syndrome among visitors to the Rankin Gap area, three near-misses involving unauthorized descent of a steep slope, and one rescue of a civilian named Marcus Delaney from what my report describes as, quote, a nonstandard terrain feature, unquote."
"He means the Hollow," said Dovie.
"Ma'am, you'll have your turn."
"I'm sixty-one years early for it already."
Somebody laughed. Bunny Hatcher tapped her pen. Mr. Mabry turned a page, and described his proposal in the voice of a man reading his own sentencing: a chain-link fence along Gap Road, three hundred yards on either side of the trailhead; a gate, locked; a full-time deputy; a thermal drone on a tether; and, in a second phase, a rope-rescue team under county command to descend the feature, quote, and characterize it, unquote, with the aim of recovering any persons found.
There was a pause. Then it came in a rush, the way water comes over a dam, a dozen people trying to speak.
The timer ran. The room fought. A woman in a church cardigan said it was the work of the devil, and a man in a camouflage cap said it was the work of the government, and a girl in a blue sweatshirt said, in a trembling voice, that nobody who had been there would ever call it that.
Dovie rose.
She did not come to the lectern. She stood in the fourth row with her cane planted, and the whole room went quiet as if somebody had turned a tap. She was seventy-eight, and a head shorter than the girl in the blue sweatshirt, and she had the white braid down her back and the face of somebody who had been listened to by a mountain.
"I don't object to a fence," said Dovie. "Fence Gap Road if you've a mind. It's a county road. Put a gate on it. I'll bring you a thermos for the deputy."
Mr. Mabry blinked.
"But the Lip is on my land," said Dovie. "A hundred and ten acres, deeded, my daddy's daddy's. Nobody's laying a rope or a drone on a thing I own, and I'll ask Judge Fairchild to read you the plat. And I'll tell you what else." Her voice did not rise. "Every person who has gone down that stair since the first frost went because somebody gave them a reason, a song or a light or a map. You can fence a road. You can't fence a reason."
She sat. There was a moment of silence, and then a few people, startled at themselves, began to clap.
"Thank you, ma'am," said Mabry. "I do take your point on the, on the deed. The next speaker is a Captain Tolliver."
A woman stood up near the door.
She had been standing there since the meeting began, with her back against the wall and her arms crossed, and Silas had marked her without knowing it. She was in her middle thirties, tall and lean, in a navy uniform shirt with a reflective stripe and a county patch, and a ponytail so tight it looked like punishment. She had the face of a person who has been awake for a day and a half and intends to be rude about it. The patch said P. C. EMS. Over the pocket, on a bar, was stitched TOLLIVER.
She walked down to the lectern and did not look at the timer.
"Imogene Tolliver," she said. "I run the rope-rescue team. I'm the county's technical lead on the plan Dwight just read. I've been asked to say whether we can do it." She put both hands on the sides of the lectern. "We can. We've got four people certified to go down a hole on a rope, and we'd go tomorrow."
Mr. Mabry looked relieved.
"I want it said," said Tolliver, "that I do not believe a word of what I've been hearing for a week. I don't believe in a staircase that goes to China. I don't believe in singing to open a hillside. I think there's a sinkhole, I think there's a lot of hysteria, and I think a rope and a harness will do more than a hymnbook."
"Which is why," said Dovie, to no one, "you'll want a good hymnbook."
"Ma'am," said Tolliver, without turning, "I'm on the clock."
"So's the frost."
"Captain Tolliver, your time," said the chair, gently.
Silas, on a dazed impulse, found that he had stood up.
It was not a decision. He had been sitting on his hands for forty minutes with one sentence going round in his chest, and it just got out. He said, "Ma'am, please, if you go down on a rope, it won't haul you back. I mean the rope's going to hold. It just won't pull. You'll need somebody sitting with you."
Every head in the room turned.
Tolliver looked at him for a long time. It was not a hostile look. It was the look of a woman who has been told by a stranger that her tools do not work, and is weighing how many seconds to give him.
"You the Ketterman kid," she said. "The one who walked."
"Yes, ma'am."
"Then I've got a thing to say to you, and I'll say it outside."
The vote, when it came, was five to two. The road would be fenced and gated and watched. The rope team would stand by at the trailhead Wednesday morning, under county orders, and would not descend without a further vote. Mabry sat down with an air of having been robbed of something he had not known he wanted. Bunny Hatcher banged a gavel she had borrowed from the county clerk, and the room broke up, in knots, into the cold parking lot under the single sodium light.
Gene Tolliver was waiting by the open door of a white pickup with a light bar on the roof.
She did not wait for him to speak. She had a thermos in one hand and a Styrofoam cup in the other, and she poured, and held it out. He took it. It was black, and it tasted like a battery.
"My partner's name is Travis Olin," said Gene. She was looking out across the lot, at the dark ridge beyond the courthouse roof. "Trav. We've worked the same ambulance eleven years. Halloween night he caught a call, a silent 911 off a cell phone up at Pinch Gap, no voice, just breathing, and I was home asleep, for the first time in thirty hours, because he told me to go." She turned the thermos in her hand. "He took it alone. He radioed once, from the pull-off. Said he saw a light up the hill, somebody's camp. Said he'd walk up and have a look."
The cold was getting into Silas's wrists.
"I found his rig Saturday," said Gene. "Still at the pull-off. Door open, radio on. His boots weren't in it, and the keys were in the cup holder." Her voice was perfectly level. "I've been up that hill four times with a light and a dog, and I'll tell you what's there. A path nobody cuts, and an old log chute, and a lantern burning in a glass globe on a stump at the head of it, every single night. Nobody tends it. Nobody's ever there."
She looked at him then, at last.
"So if you've got a sentence about ropes, Ketterman," said Gene Tolliver, "you can say it to me, and you can say it fast. Because somebody keeps a light at Pinch Gap. And I'd like to know what it's waiting for."

