They went up to the Lip on Tuesday at noon, because Wyatt asked, and because June had said that if they were going to be foolish they might at least be foolish in daylight.
Cade drove. He drove the way he ran, in long even strokes with no wasted motion, and he did not say anything on the way up Gap Road except, once, "Easy," when the truck hit a rut. It was a gray, mild, sweating day, sixty degrees under a lid of cloud. The laurel hung dripping on both sides. At the turnout he got out and said he would be at the truck with a thermos and a paperback, and that if anybody wanted him, they could whistle, and if they didn't, he would assume they were sitting.
So it was just the two of them, and the shadow, on the first stone.
The lantern was still there, in its yellow bread bag on the cairn, burning low and steady. The frost ring lay around it on the grass, a white table's width, and its rim glittered. Down the first dozen steps of the stair, in the gloom of the laurel, there was no light at all. It looked like any trail going down a hill.
Wyatt sat on the stone with a quilt and his hands round a mug, and put his face up to the cloud. "I forgot about weather," he said. "It's very strange, weather. It keeps happening to you."
At his right hand lay a small pale oval, a stain of frost where he had set his palm on the stone. It had begun to creep when he sat. Beside it, flat on the dull gray rock in the soft light, there was almost nothing. Without a sun, the second shadow had no edge. It lay so faint on the stone, so close to the first, that Silas thought it might be only a trick of the eye. Then it spoke.
"I would prefer that you ask," said Dennis. "You have been wanting to for two days, and you are being polite, and it is not helping either of us."
Wyatt coughed on his tea.
"All right," said Silas.
He sat down on the cold ground in front of the stone, cross-legged, with his back against the cairn. It seemed right. He had learned that much in the dark: you sit lower than the thing you are asking, and you do not stand over it. He looked at the faint place on the stone where the shape lay.
"My brother wrote me a letter," he said. "In the back pew of Mercy Chapel. He said to ask you what it costs. He said you'd never say."
"I never have."
"Why not?"
"Nobody has asked," said Dennis, "in a way that stayed to hear it."
The wind moved in the laurel, and a few drops fell. Silas waited. He had found out in the eighteen hours below that waiting was not the same as being quiet, and that the shadow could tell the difference. After a time, it began to speak, in the same dry small voice, with a slight hitch at the start of every sentence, like a person stepping over a sill.
"I am made of what was not said. That is the plain description. Every true thing a person has held back goes somewhere. It does not vanish. It goes to the bottom of the stair, where it is the same temperature as everything else, and it waits. That is where I came from."
"I know," said Silas. "You told me some of them."
"I told you the ones that had been waiting longest. You will remember what they did not cost."
He remembered. The hymn nobody had sung. The forty dollars from the register. The sister's ring. Each of them true, each of them heavy, and not one of them had made the sentence's owner so much as blink.
"They did not cost the speaker," said Dennis. "That is correct. A true thing said aloud ordinarily costs the one who says it; that is what the ballad calls the blank. I sing without a blank. I say what is true and I am not out of pocket by it. But the cost does not cease to exist, Silas Ketterman. It is a bill. It goes to someone."
He stopped. A drop fell from the cairn and burst on the stone.
"It goes," said Dennis, "to the person it was owed to."
Silas did not move.
"Mrs. Rankin, for sixty-one years, was owed a sentence by her sister, and she paid for it. Her ears. Her voice. The wax." The words came one by one, very clearly. "Mrs. Lyle was owed a sentence by her husband and paid in nineteen years of silence. Your mother was owed one by you. It is not only the people who held a thing back who carry it. It is the people who were waiting to be told. That is what I cost. I am the weight of every sentence that was never delivered, and the weight has to be set down somewhere, and it is set down on the one who was left waiting."
"That's why people at the vigil are sick," said Wyatt slowly.
"They were not owed anything. They only listened." Dennis seemed to consider this. "It is a small cost, to listen once. It is a larger cost to be me. I do not know how to say it kindly. I have never needed to."
"You said it kindly," said Silas.
It was out before he thought. The shadow stopped.
For the space of ten breaths nobody said a thing. Wyatt had put down his mug. Down the slope the laurel dripped, and far off in the ridge a crow said something short and unimportant. On the stone the pale shape had curled, as though it were pulling its knees up under its chin.
"That was a gift," said Dennis, "and it was not true. I would have said it was not kind. But you have said it, and I notice that you meant it, and I find I have no way to weigh that. You are the third person to do this to me this week. I would like it known that it is difficult."
Wyatt began to laugh, very softly.
It was easier after that. They sat in the gray and the damp, the three of them, and the shadow told them what it could, haltingly, in no order. It did not know why the frost followed Wyatt. It thought the stair was noticing him, the way a house notices someone who has lived in it a long time. It did not know the other Lips. It had never been to one. It had been, until Saturday, only at the bottom, at the place where everything left over comes to rest, and the bottom was a very quiet place and not one that had windows.
"Do you know the tenth?" said Silas.
"I know it begins in the voice of a girl who is sitting up with a door. I know the shape of its blank, which is large, and I do not think I am permitted to describe it, though I have tried." The faint shape shifted. "Ruth's ring is awake because she is holding it. Wyatt's frost is only the stair keeping him company. They are different. It is important that you do not mix them."
"I won't."
"You will mix them in three weeks, and be wrong, and it will matter. I am telling you now so that you will remember being told."
"That's a comforting sentence," said Wyatt.
"It is a true one."
The cloud had lowered. A fine rain was beginning to fall, too light to be heard, only felt, a mist on the backs of the hands. Silas got up, because his knees were stiff, and put his hand under his brother's elbow.
"Hold on," said Dennis.
It said it in a different voice. It was not a small voice, or a dry one, but quick and low and almost frightened. The pale shape on the stone had lifted its head. It was not looking at either of them. It was turned, plainly, toward the far side of the county, toward the morning's slate-colored sky.
"I can hear something," said the shadow. "Not here. A long way west. Not the Hollow." A pause. "It is a hum. One note. A single note held for a very long time, by a great many people who do not know that they are doing it. And it is not mine, and it is not Ruth's, and somebody there is being held by it."
"Where?" said Wyatt.
"I do not know the name of the place. I can tell you that it smells of cut pine," said Dennis, "and that the person it is holding is afraid of the dark, and has been sitting very still for four days."

