Rena came on Sunday with a pot of soup wrapped in a towel, and said at the door of the community room kitchen that she was not staying.
“I’m staying to eat,” she said. “That’s different. I’ve a stack of shift sheets at home that would make a saint swear, and I’m going back to them at four.”
“You didn’t have to come.”
“I know. That’s why I came.” She put the pot on the hob and lifted the lid, and the smell of leeks and barley filled the small warm room. “Della sent the summary last night. Eight o’clock, as promised. It ran to three pages. I read it standing in the hall with my coat on.”
“I’m sorry.”
“Don’t be sorry. I asked for it.” She turned, with the ladle, and looked at him straight. She was a woman of forty-five with short gray hair and a way of looking at a person that went down him like a finger down a timetable, checking for gaps. “I asked to be told, and I was told, and I’ve been sitting on a bus since six this morning thinking about it. I want to see the video. Not the glove. Him. You, saying it.”
He had not expected that. “Why?”
“Because I was in the back row on the first Tuesday, and I watched you say it, and nothing in my head went off. If somebody has taught it to answer you, they learned how somewhere. I’d like to know what I missed.” She said it without heat. “That’s not an offer to be your witness. It’s me being nosy about my own evening.”
He found, to his surprise, that he was grateful. It was a modest reason, and it asked nothing of him.
“Soup first,” said Della, from the doorway. “Then video. I’ve the laptop.”
---
They watched it at the long table, with the lamps off and the winter light coming gray through the high windows. Della, Orrin, Rena with her bowl, Gareth at the end with his hands flat.
Mags’s footage was clean. It had a time in the corner, and a small white scale card at the foot of the chest, and the glove filled the frame like a creature in a nature film. They watched it turn. They watched the unhurried, soft unrolling of the fingers, and heard Orrin’s thin attempts, and Hollis’s, and Della’s own flat one, and the glove going on regardless through every voice.
Then there was Gareth’s, small and dry in the speaker, and the glove stopped.
“Again,” said Rena.
Della ran it back.
“Again. Slower. Not the glove. The edge of the picture.”
“What am I looking for?”
“You.” She leaned forward. “You’re by the rope. Your left hand’s on the post.”
He looked. There was a short post of pine, which Hollis had hammered into a crack between the boards to carry the rope, and on the post, in the lower corner of Mags’s frame, his own left hand lay with the fingers loose. The thumb was down on the wood.
“There,” said Rena.
It was small. He would never have seen it. As he said the word, or a hair before, the pad of the thumb lifted and came down, once, and the first two fingers lifted with it and rested again, so quickly that it might have been a flaw in the film.
“I do that,” he said slowly.
“You do that all the time.”
“I know. It’s the count.” He lifted his left hand from the table, and set it down again, and heard it: four little taps, and a rest. He had done it at the bench for thirty years without ever knowing, a tailor’s habit, a cobbler’s, marking time on the wood while the other hand worked.
It was the shop count. It was what his thumb had done on the steel wall of the shed in the dark, and at seven fifty-two on the first Tuesday, before he said hold.
“Pip’s clip,” Orrin said. “The recording. There’s a sound on it.”
“Play it.”
Della found it. She turned it up. There was the room, the faint scrape of chairs and the cough of someone at the back, and the small dry voice at the head of the room saying hold. And before it, under it, soft as a mouse in a drawer, so low that no one would have noticed unless they were looking for it, four taps on a table, and a rest.
“It’s on the recording,” said Della. “But the glove didn’t stop for the recording.”
“No.”
“So it isn’t the sound of the tap.”
“It’s not the sound of anything. It’s...” He stopped. He was a man who had spent a long time not saying things he did not know, and he said it carefully. “I think it’s me doing it. My hand. The thumb tapping where the glove can feel it. Through the chest, through the wood, through the post. I think it’s something that has to be near enough to feel the tap.”
“A glove feeling a table.”
“I said I think.”
“I’m not arguing,” said Rena. She put down her spoon. “I’m saying that’s a very particular lesson to give anything. Someone had to know about your thumb.”
It was quiet. Orrin said, in a very low voice, “Not everyone saw it. The thumb. It’s only on the wood. At the class you sit at the head with it on the table. Anyone who’s been in the room.”
“Or anyone who watched him at a bench for a while,” said Rena, gently. “Anyone who stood where I stood, once, years ago, in his shop, and looked at his hand because it was the only way to see what he was doing.”
She looked down at her bowl. He looked at her. He knew, in that instant, what she was saying; it was the same thing she had said at lunch, in other words, in the careful voice. *I am not the person you are looking for. But I am someone who looked.*
“Nobody thinks it’s you,” said Della.
“I know,” said Rena. “I’m only saying it’s a long list. And the longer the better. It means whoever it is didn’t need to be clever. They only needed to be watching.”
---
Prue’s result came on Monday, in a short email, with a table.
June had warned them. Prue was a friend from college, a materials technician at a university lab in a town two hours away, and she had done it in her own time, on a half-day, with a borrowed instrument and the half of a postage-stamp square of tape.
She wrote in short, level sentences and she did not use adjectives. Gareth, who had spent a lifetime among people who did, found it restful.
*Sample: a half of the tape square, 8 mm by 11 mm, with one graphite mark. Method: stereo microscope, raking light, and a surface scan of the mark under three wavelengths. Findings:*
*1. The graphite is a single mark, but not a single stroke. The figure 3 was made twice.*
*2. The first pass is light and narrow. It sits in the groove of the cloth and has been polished by handling to a dull, flat sheen. The second pass follows it exactly and is heavier and darker. It sits on top, and its particles are fresh by comparison, with sharp edges. I would say the two passes are separated by a long interval, though I can’t put a number on it.*
*3. Under the first pass there is an older mark, in carbon ink. It is the figure 2. Neither pass follows it: the 3 crosses it.*
*4. I found no trace of an eraser on either.*
*5. In the weave of the tape, near the cut, there is one blue cotton thread, about 3 mm long, with a hard twist. It matches nothing else on the tape. It was not sewn in. It looks to me like it came off something that rubbed the tape.*
*I can’t tell you who. I can tell you the number was written twice. Someone made it, and someone, later, made sure of it.*
*P.*
“Made sure of it,” Orrin read, aloud, twice. “That’s a good phrase.”
“It’s a bad one,” said Gareth.
They were at the hall again, at the long table, with the heater ticking, and the printout laid out between the mugs. It was Monday evening, and June was on the screen from her kitchen, with a pencil behind her ear.
“It’s what I’d have expected,” she said. “The old 3 was written by someone who thought it was the third piece. Years ago, maybe soon after the second was done. Then it sat. And then recently someone came along with a hard pencil and went over it, because it had faded, or because they wanted it to be unmistakable.”
“Why?”
“If I were building a case that this was a third piece, I’d want the number fresh.” She tapped the pencil on her chin. “If I were the original maker and wanted to know it was still there, I’d do it too. I can’t tell the difference from here. That’s the honest answer. A blue thread that fell off something. That’s all.”
“Off the glove,” said Della.
“It’s the same twist as the stitch,” June said. “I looked at your photographs. Same lay, same hardness. But I’d want to see more than a thread.”
“Of course.”
“One more thing. And it’s not about the lab.” She looked at him through the screen. “Half of that square’s gone. It’s a clean job and she’s been careful, and I’d do it again, but it’s gone. The rest is in your bag. I’d like you to hear me say that I wouldn’t hand it to anyone.”
“I wasn’t going to.”
“I’d like to hear it said.”
“I won’t hand it to anyone,” said Gareth.
---
The argument took the rest of the evening, and it was the worst of the week.
It began with Orrin, which Gareth had not expected. He had thought it would be Della, who loved a rule, or himself, who loved nothing so well as to stay at home. But it was Orrin, white about the mouth, who said across the cold tea, “We’re not going.”
“Friday?”
“We’re not going to a unit in a trading yard at six in the evening because a card came under a door. I’ve been in your shed. I’ve seen what happens to an object when you go to it. We have a glove under two locks. We have everything we need to keep it that way. If we don’t go, nobody is any worse off.”
“Somebody is,” said Gareth. “Tamsin. The woman who got the key, and her cat, and her mat. And Alma Ferris, and the man in the Pellam Street hall, and the clerk who opened the log. Somebody has been walking in my footsteps for a year. They’ve now left their calling card. If I don’t answer it, they’ll try something I haven’t foreseen.”
“You said you’d stop doing this. Going alone.”
“I’m not going alone.”
“Then take Hale. Take the police.”
“And say what? A card under the door? A glove?” He heard his own voice rise, and brought it down. “I’ll tell them. Della will. It’s already in the log, and Imre Tolliver at Tarn Road has been told, and a man at the council. But what we want to know isn’t something a policeman can be sent to arrest. It has to be asked for, politely.”
“She asked you politely.”
“She did. She asked for a square of tape. And I said no, and she thanked me for holding something.” He pressed the heel of his hand against his eye. “I don’t want to go, Orrin. I’d like to be left alone to teach shoe repairers how to hand a tool. I’d like my life to be small. But I’m the man who made the stitch, and someone has used it to leave a glove in my house. I think I have a right to ask why.”
Orrin said nothing. Della turned a page.
“There are conditions,” she said.
“There are always conditions.”
“There are four.” She counted them off on a finger, in the voice she used for the rules of the room. “One. It’s daylight, as near as we can have it. Six on a Friday in this season is dusk; we’ll take Hollis’s lamps. Two. We stay inside the open door of the unit, in sight of the yard.
“Three. We bring nothing real that she has asked for. No true square, no half-square, no photograph, no recording. Four. Anyone says hatch and it’s over, and we go to the van, and I don’t want a speech.”
“Hatch,” said Orrin, in a flat voice.
“That’s the one. You’ve heard it before.”
“I’d like it noted that I’m coming under protest.”
“It’s noted.” She wrote it.
---
Orrin walked him to the bus stop afterward, which neither of them had planned. It was a raw night, and the shelter’s glass had a cracked corner that sang a little in the wind.
“I’m sorry I shouted,” said Orrin.
“You didn’t shout. You went white and said no. I’d call it a very quiet shout.”
“I’ve been thinking about the sleeve. In my workshop. I sat with it for weeks, Gareth, and put a lamp on it, and made tea next to it. And all that time it was only waiting for you to come and take it back.” He pushed his hands deeper into his pockets. “I’d like to be sure that this time I’m not just being walked into a room.”
“So would I. That’s why you’re coming. And why you say hatch if you want to, and I’ll go with you out of the door, and I won’t say anything on the way.”
“Not even a lecture?”
“Not even a lecture.”
Orrin laughed, shortly, and then looked at Gareth’s hand. “You’re holding it down.”
He was. His left hand lay pressed flat against his thigh, through the coat, with the thumb pinned under the fingers like a bird under a cloth. He had not noticed he was doing it.
“It’s a habit I’d like to be able to break,” Gareth said. “I can’t break it. I tried tonight, and it only tapped more.”
“Then don’t break it. Just know where it is.” Orrin looked up the road, where the headlamps of the bus had begun to wobble in the wet. “That’s what you told me about my own left hand. Know where it is.”
---
June built the dummy, in the end, and was rude about it.
She did it from her own kitchen on Tuesday night, with a roll of white cloth tape from the shop, a fine pen and a lot of patience, and when the courier brought it on Wednesday morning in a padded bag, it lay in Gareth’s palm like a postage stamp that had been left out in the rain.
“It’s a forgery,” she said on the phone. “I’d like you to know I’m not proud of it. It’s a good one, from three feet. It’s got a flat three on a round two, and I rubbed the graphite with a fingertip for ten minutes. It won’t survive a loupe.”
“It doesn’t have to.”
“It has to survive her first look. After that, you’ll have said no.” She sounded as though she were chewing her lip. “I want one other thing. A line I’m drawing, not a rule. If she names a price, any price, you don’t pay it that night. You take it to Della. You sleep on it. Nobody ever solved anything good at six in the evening in a car park.”
“Agreed.”
“Say it.”
“I’ll take it to Della and sleep on it.”
“Good.” A pause. “Gareth. If anything’s warm...”
“I’ll say so.”
“Out loud.”
“Out loud.”
It cost what the others had cost. Hollis would lose half a Friday to fetch the lamps and drive the van; he said it was seventy and that it was not a gift, as Mags had, and Gareth paid it. The courier was twelve for the dummy, a small shameful sum.
Dwayne at the depot gave him the Friday afternoon and the Saturday morning off without the joke he’d half expected, and without pay for either: a hundred and ten dollars he did not have to spare, with the first-of-the-month rent not two weeks off.
He wrote it in his notebook that night, in the cold room with the lamp on, under the other figures. He added them up, and then, because it was late, and he was tired, he added them up again.
Then he put the pen down, and stretched his left hand flat on the page, and watched his thumb.
It was not tapping. He told it to. It did nothing.
He lifted it off the paper and put it down, once, the way one makes a first stitch on new cloth. Four, and a rest. It was a good, dry little sound in the quiet.
And down in the shop at Bellwether Junction, seven miles off, behind two locks and a ribbon, under a lid, a camera that Della had set to record in the dark began, quietly, to count the fingers of a glove coming in from the smallest.
He did not know it until Thursday. He would find it in the log, written in her level hand: *Wed. 11:48 p.m. Glove moved without word or person present. Stopped 11:51.*
*Thursday: Gareth reports one set of taps only, at about 11:48, in his own room.*
The distance was seven miles. The wall was brick, and the lid was down, and there was no wire between.
There was only a thumb, and a count, and a hand in the dark that had been waiting to be told what it was for.

