Eli Brandt believed that a lock should answer questions, and the first question he taught me, through a day-book he never lived to hand me, was *who has been here?*
I did not know that yet. At 10:20 on Monday morning I knew only that I was standing in my grandmother’s cellar with a ruined jar in each hand and a stranger’s fountain-pen line across her pencil, and that I wanted very badly to hit something with a ladle.
I put the jars down. I put the ledger under my arm. I went up the cold stairs, through the dark behind the lard rack, and out into the walk-in, and I called for Dane in a voice that made Ruth put down her knife.
He came in from the lot with his bandaged hand held up like a man hailing a taxi. He had driven Wren to the motel and back. He had also, by the look of him, not slept since Saturday, because Dane Marlowe sleeps the way other people pay taxes, late and under protest.
“Somebody’s been in the cellar,” I said.
“Today?”
“This morning. Between seven and ten.” I held out the ledger and opened it to the page. He read the line, and the note, and the initials, and I watched his face do what it does when he is angry, which is nothing at all. It goes smooth as a plate.
“The door was locked.”
“Yes.”
“Both keys?”
“Mine’s in my pocket. The other’s in the till.”
“Then it’s a copy,” said Dane.
“Eli didn’t make copies. Eli made keys, and wrote down every one in the day-book, and Granny kept the whole count in her head like a grocery list.” I rubbed my forehead with the back of my wrist. “I need your nose.”
He did not ask what mine had been doing. He knew. For three days it had been a thread, and I had learned what that was like: a house where somebody has taken all the furniture and left the wallpaper. I could tell that the cellar smelled of beeswax. I could not tell you what else it had been smelling of before I came down.
“Show me,” said Dane.
---
The cellar door in the walk-in is not a door. It is a panel, on the back wall behind the lard rack, painted the same dull enamel as the shelves, with a latch you would call a drawer pull if you saw it in a hardware store. Granny kept a tin tray of lard on the top shelf so that anyone who moved the rack would have to move it quietly.
It has a lock, though. A small round one, set low, in a brass plate the size of a coaster. I had been through that lock a hundred times in the last two weeks and had never once looked at the plate.
Dane looked at it. He crouched with his bandaged hand tucked into his armpit and put his nose to the metal, an inch off, and he stayed there for a long time with his eyes shut.
“Well?”
“Tape glue.” He opened his eyes. “Hand rub. The same as the key in the till. Eucalyptus and something sour, like a sprained ankle.” He frowned. “It’s on the plate, and on the knob. Not on the lock itself.”
“What does that mean?”
“It means somebody wanted me to find it.” He sat back on his heels. “It’s too much. A man who has used a door puts a smell on the door in a thin film, once, and then another film on top, if he comes again. This is thick. This is a *rag.*”
“A rag?”
“If I’d wiped a lock with a rag that had been rubbed in a man’s hands, it would smell like that. I’d be doing it to leave a trail.” He sniffed again, and his mouth tightened. “I could be wrong. I haven’t had a lot of practice at being the nose. I’ve mostly been the paws.”
“You are never wrong about a smell. It’s insulting.” I knelt beside him. “Look at the plate.”
It was a plain brass disc, a little tarnished, with the keyhole in the center and a flower cut into the rim, a six-petal flower with a pin through the heart. I had seen it so often I had stopped seeing it. But I had also been awake for most of two nights with Eli Brandt’s green day-book, and the day-book has a drawing, on page nineteen, of exactly that plate. And under the drawing, in blocky capitals, three words I had read and not understood.
*THE PLATE COUNTS.*
“There’s a wheel,” I said. “Behind the flower.”
“A what?”
“Hold the light.”
I ran my thumbnail around the rim until it caught on a notch, and the petal-plate turned a quarter inch on its pin, and a little brass window opened beneath it, no wider than a matchbook. Inside, on a spindle, was a wheel with a number on it, and the number was 2.
Dane breathed out. “It counts the doors.”
“Every time the lock turns, it clicks over by one. Eli put them on any lock he thought mattered. And Granny,” I said, with a strange, giddy pride in my dead grandmother, “turned it back to zero every New Year’s Day, with a brass key like a watchmaker’s, so she’d know what had happened to her house in the year.”
“She’s been gone four years, and the habit outlived her. I found the zeroing key in the day-book’s back pocket on Saturday, and I set the wheel back every night after I locked up.” I swallowed. “Last night at ten-forty, after I counted the jars. Zero. I know it was zero because I watched it.”
I looked at the little brass window. It said 3.
Dane did not say anything. He took the flashlight out of my hand and looked at the figure for a long time, with the beam bobbing very slightly, because the hand that held it was the burned one.
“Three openings,” he said.
“One of them was mine. I turned that lock at ten this morning, to go down. Which means someone has been through it twice since I locked it, and neither time was me.”
---
The second thing I learned that morning, I learned from the safe.
It sits in the corner of the office behind the walk-in, between the filing cabinet and the shelf where Ruth keeps the fire extinguisher and a framed photograph of a prize heifer. A black Mosler, three feet high, with a combination dial worn silver. It had held the Westclox, the check, Ellen Kane’s letter, a clover key and a green ledger since Thursday night.
I opened it for Dane with my hands shaking a little. The check was there. The letter was there. The key was there. The shelf where the ledger belonged was empty, and had the faint pale rectangle in the dust of a thing that had lately been lifted off.
“I put it back in the safe,” I said. “Sunday night, at ten. I locked it. I spun the dial.”
“I know you did.”
“Ruth saw me. Nobody has the combination. I haven’t told Maude. I haven’t told *you.*”
“Hollis.” Dane was down on one knee in front of the safe, with his hand flat against the left side of it, where the black steel met the wall. “Does this thing sit flat?”
“It’s a safe. It weighs four hundred pounds.”
“There’s an air gap.” He leaned his ear against it. “Here. Between the wall and the side. Cold air. I can feel it on my cheek. You’ve got a draft behind your safe.”
I got down beside him.
There was a draft. It was faint and thin, and it carried a cold, wet smell that I could only half catch. Dane put his shoulder to the corner of the safe and pushed, and the safe, which weighed four hundred pounds, moved a half inch on a hidden track, as smooth as a drawer.
It swung out from the wall on a brass hinge like a cupboard door. Behind it was a dark rectangle in the plaster, and the sharp wet smell of the walk-in’s back wall, and a very narrow brick passage, no wider than my shoulders, that ran back and down in the direction of the cellar stair.
“Oh, Eli,” I said.
“You never knew about this?”
“I never knew about *any* of it.” I put my hand on the brick. “It’s a back door. Granny’s safe doesn’t open into the office, Dane. It opens into the cellar, through here. So that she could take the ledger down to the barrel without carrying it through the kitchen where I’d have seen her. She wanted to do it in the middle of the night, with nobody to see.”
“And whoever has the cellar key can come up behind the safe and take out whatever’s in it.”
“If they know about the track.”
“Somebody knew.” Dane sat back on his heels, and looked at me with his long unreadable face. “Granny’s husband built it. Eli wouldn’t have told many people. Maybe two.”
“Granny. And whoever she told.”
“And whoever *she* told.”
We sat in the dusty office with the safe standing out from the wall like a half-open door, and neither of us said a name, because there are only so many things a person can say before breakfast.
---
At half past eleven I made Dane sit down at the counter and eat a bowl of oatmeal, because he had not, and because it gave me something to do with my hands. Ruth, who had worked out within about four seconds of the first strange silence that she was not going to be told, banged a pan on the grill with great significance and went on cooking.
Okonkwo came back at noon to take our statement. He sat at the end of the counter with his hat on his knee, writing in a small black book with a short pencil, and I asked, slowly, to be sure I had it right: “Where was Chief Deputy Gorman last night and this morning?”
“At the Tamarack station,” said Okonkwo, without looking up. “He signed in at ten to seven. He had his coffee at the desk, and he took a call about a mailbox at eight-twenty, and I was with him from ten past eight to about nine, because I came back after the pin. He had a bad cold. He sneezed the entire time.”
“He could have left.”
“He could have done a lot of things.” Okonkwo looked at me, steadily, over the pencil. “But he’d have had to take his car, and the station camera on the lot has been broken since the twentieth of December, but the one on the Tamarack bridge hasn’t. I’ve asked. He didn’t cross it, not once since Sunday supper.” He paused. “I’d have liked to find him on it, Ms. Brandt. I’d have liked it a good deal.”
“So the hand-rub was a rag.”
“I don’t know about any rag. What I know is, if you’re telling me his smell is on your lock, I’m telling you he wasn’t at your lock.” He wrote something. “I think someone’s been dressing a scarecrow.”
It was a very good phrase. I wrote it on the inside of my wrist with a grease pencil, because I did not trust myself to remember it, and I kept looking at the brass window in my mind, the small figure 2.
Two times.
Once in the dark, once in daylight. Somebody had come into my kitchen, and opened a locked door, and used a dead man’s secret track to lift my grandmother’s ledger out of a safe I’d locked, and carried it down the stair, and laid it open on a barrel with a flashlight beam falling across the page. And then somebody had put the smell of another man’s hands across the lock, as thick as paint, and gone away.
I thought of the till, and the key in it, and I went to look.
---
It lay in the cash drawer, under the slot for the fives, where it had lain since New Year’s Eve. A small brass key on a loop of white string, and it smelled, to a man’s nose, of eucalyptus and a sprained ankle.
Dane unwound the string.
“Rag,” he said at once. “It was *wrapped* in one. A rag cut from a shirt-sleeve, I think. Flannel. It’s been taken off and the key’s been put back on its string, but there’s a thread caught in the loop.” He held it up to the window. A pale blue fiber, a quarter inch long, wavering in the light.
“Gorman’s shirt?”
“Not blue. His are gray, he wears the department issue.” He frowned. “And there’s another thing.”
“What?”
“There’s a splinter in the keyhole of the till drawer.” He bent his head over the little brass lock, and I saw his nostrils flare, and for a moment his whole face went still and young. “It’s wood. It’s been in there a day. Somebody was working the lock with a toothpick, to see if the drawer was locked, and it broke.”
“A toothpick.”
“Cinnamon.” He said it flatly. “Cinnamon oil. It’s very strong. I can smell it from here. It’s the kind that comes in a plastic box.”
I had known a man who chewed cinnamon toothpicks since my first week at the Table. I had watched one in the brim of an upside-down hat on my own counter, jabbing the air like the flag on a very small ship. I did not say the name, and neither did Dane.
I think that in the whole of that quiet noon we were both being very careful with it. As if it were the last good plate in the house.
“That’s not enough,” I said, after a while.
“No.”
“That’s a habit. Half the town chews them. Tilly’s been giving them out to the kids at the register since Thanksgiving.” I heard how it sounded. “Anyone could drop a splinter.”
“Anyone could,” said Dane.
“And a thing that points that straight is a thing that’s been *aimed.* Okonkwo said a scarecrow. A scarecrow’s the wrong place to look. Somebody wants me to look at the rag, and then at the toothpick, and then at whoever I trust least.”
“Who’s that?”
“At the moment? Everyone.” I closed the till. “Ardent is tidy. If he’d wanted to hand me a man, he would have handed me a better one.”
“Maybe he didn’t hand you this one.” Dane’s voice was so carefully level that I turned and looked at him, and he was looking at the till drawer and not at me. “Maybe it was only a bad night for somebody.”
I did not answer. If I answered, I would say something I could not take back, and I had promised, on Sunday, to a woman in a kitchen on Alder Street, over tea, to say very little.
---
It came out of him a minute later, as I had known it would.
I was wrapping the ledger in a clean dish towel, to take upstairs to my apartment where I could look at it with a pencil. Dane was standing in the office doorway, with his bandaged hand resting on the frame and the safe standing out behind him like a stage flat, and he said, in the careful flat voice he uses to approach a skittish horse:
“Did June come yesterday?”
“Dane—”
“Verna said there was a sedan in the alley behind Alder Street at three. A gray one. Verna doesn’t miss things.” He did not look at me. “She said she thought she saw a woman at the back window, with her sleeves rolled.”
The thing about a promise made over tea is that it is made with its own kind of weight. I thought of June’s hands around her cup, steady, with the almond cream on them. *Do not tell Dane.* She had not given me a reason. She had asked as a person asks who has used up all her reasons and is down to the last small stubborn thing.
And Dane looked at me, then, at last. He is not good at hiding what he feels. In the whole time I have known him he has not learned how, and I have given up wishing he would.
“I saw her,” I said.
“Yes?”
“I saw her. She came while I was there, in the house. I won’t tell you what she said.”
His face did not change. His face doesn’t. It was the hand on the doorframe that I noticed, the burned left hand, with the clean bandage, and the knuckles turning slowly from brown to white.
“You won’t tell me.”
“I promised her. I’m sorry. It’s not a thing I like.”
“Is it about Wren? About Thursday?”
“I can’t—”
“Is it about *me?*”
“I don’t think so.” I made myself say it plainly. “I think it’s about what happens to a lot of people if I get it wrong. I think she’s more afraid of that than you could imagine. And I think she’s trying, in her way, to be on our side, and has not the least idea how.”
He was quiet.
“That’s a poor answer,” he said finally.
“It is.”
“I’ve known June since I was nine. She taught me to ride a bicycle, in the Halvorsen lot, and she never once let go of the seat when she said she had.” He drew his hand off the doorframe, slowly, and flexed it, as if testing the burn. “I’m not going to ask you again. But I want you to know that I know what the asking costs. I carried that coal two miles and a half. I don’t mind carrying things. I’d like to be told what I’m carrying.”
“Yes.”
“That’s all.”
He went out through the kitchen, and I heard the back door close, very gently, the way a man closes a door when he would prefer to slam it. I stood in the office with a dish towel in my hands and Granny’s ledger inside it, and I discovered that I had done the right thing, by every measure, and that it hurt exactly as much as the wrong one.
---
The envelope came at a quarter to one.
Ruth brought it back from the front, at arm’s length, between two fingers, like a woman bringing a dead mouse to the door. She had not said anything. She laid it on the office desk. It was a long white envelope with the county seal in the corner, and the address in a typewritten line: *Ms. Hollis E. Brandt, Keeper of the Table, Hollis & Daughter Diner.*
Inside there were three pages, stapled, and a yellow slip. I read the yellow slip first, because it said, in a young clerk’s careful hand: *Delivered by hand 12:41 p.m. by Chief Deputy L. Gorman, who declined to wait.*
The three pages were an order of the Cascade County Magistrate Court, signed that morning at 11:15 by the Honorable Imogen Tate, in response to an ex parte application filed by Ames & Pell, LLP, on behalf of the trustee for DH Holdings. I have read a great many legal documents in my life, none by choice. This one was very clear.
*Whereas the premises at 11 Main Street contain a cellar or storage room reported to hold items of evidentiary significance in the matter set for hearing on January 8;*
*And whereas there is reason to believe that said items are at risk of alteration, removal, or destruction;*
*It is ORDERED that the said cellar be sealed by the Sheriff’s Department at 4:00 p.m. on the fifth day of January, and that no item be removed from, added to, or altered within said cellar from that hour until the Court shall order otherwise.*
At the bottom, in a kind of small pained afterthought, someone had typed in a line the court had not wished to add and the law had insisted on: *Any person desiring to inventory the contents prior to sealing may do so between the service of this order and the hour stated.*
Three hours and a quarter. Four hundred jars.
I laid the paper on the desk and looked at the safe, standing a little out from the wall like a thing that had been caught in the act.
*I’d like it noted,* said a dry voice in my head, *that I told you he was tidy.*
It was the voice of my own sense, which I had been neglecting. A man who asks a court to seal your cellar at four does not simply happen to have left a note on your barrel that morning. He had arranged to be *angry.* He had arranged for a woman at a desk to read the word *alteration* with a pen in her hand.
And a cellar that is sealed cannot be put right. Whatever was in it at four o’clock Monday would be, in the eyes of the law, what had been in it all along.
I called Maude. She answered on the first ring, as if she had been standing beside the phone.
“I know,” she said. “Emmett just told me. He had a call.”
“From whom?”
“I don’t know. He didn’t say.” There was a small silence, and then, a voice I had not heard her use before, low and level and sounding very tired. “I’ll be there in twenty minutes, Hollis. Don’t count a jar until I come. I want to be the one who writes the numbers down.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!