Emmett Haskell came in at 5:41 on Tuesday morning, with a beagle under his arm.
I had been standing at the grill since four, watching the door the way a woman watches a pot she has been told will never boil. Ruth was slicing rye. Tilly, who is not allowed on the premises before six and had come in through the coal chute at 4:30, was arranging forks. Kane was at his stool already, on eight, in his waistcoat, with a cup of black coffee and a look of professional patience, like an undertaker at a christening.
The bell over the door rang its thin, ordinary ring. Everyone stopped.
He had no coat on. He wore the same checked shirt as the day before, and he had not shaved, and his hair stood up behind like a rooster’s. He stood on the mat for a moment, blinking in the light, a tall stooped man of sixty-five with a face like a good-natured horse. Then he lifted the beagle a little higher against his chest, as if she were a document he had been told to deliver.
“She was in the Elks hall lot,” said Emmett. “Under the truck. I went back for her at four.” His voice was hoarse. “Her name is Pie. She’s Maude’s. She got out, Monday, at two in the morning, when I left the gate open.”
Nobody said anything.
“I’d like to put her down somewhere,” said Emmett. “And I’d like a cup of coffee. And I’d like, if it’s all the same to you, Hollis, to say something to the room before anybody orders.”
“Sit down, Emmett,” I said.
“Not yet.” He put the beagle on the floor. Pie, who had no sense of occasion, trotted straight down the length of the counter to Kane and began to lick his shoe. Kane, to my lasting amazement, put his hand down and let her. “Maude will be here at six. I think I’d like to say it twice. I think she ought to hear it the second time as well.”
---
He told it at the counter, standing, with his hands on the rail.
By six there were ninety people in the room. They had come in as they come to a fire, quietly, in coats, one and two at a time, and stood against the walls. Aunt Verna took the pie-case stool. Dane stood at the end of the counter in his shirtsleeves, with his bandaged hand against his chest. Ruth had put down her knife.
Maude came in at six sharp, in the green coat. She stopped just inside the door. She looked at her husband’s back. She did not say a word, and she did not sit, and she did not take off her gloves. She walked down the aisle between the booths as if it had been laid with a ruler and stood at the end of the counter, beside Dane, where the lamplight did not quite reach.
“I’ll start from the feed store,” said Emmett, to the counter. “It’s the quickest way.”
*It was sound till the fertilizer year,* he said. He had borrowed, as one does, from the bank in Boise, and the bank’s paper had been bought by a trust, and that trust’s by another. It was always the same voice on the telephone. It was never unkind. When the interest came due they let it ride. When the principal came due they let it ride. For two years, he said, he had been ridden by a creditor so polite that he had thanked it.
“A little over six hundred thousand,” said Emmett. “With the interest. I owe six hundred and twelve thousand dollars to a firm called Ames and Pell. I didn’t know whose firm it was till last Thursday.”
“Thursday,” said Maude, from the end of the counter. It was the only word she said.
On Thursday, he said, Julian Ardent had come to the feed store himself, in a pewter coat, and stood in the aisle between the layer pellets and the hog starter, and been very kind. He had not threatened anything. He did not threaten. He had observed, pleasantly, that the debt was large, and the Haskell family was old, and that a man ought not to leave his wife a note like that when there was a way to be quit of it with a few small favors.
“What were they?” said Kane, from stool eight.
It was a calm voice. A very calm voice. I had not known Kane could ask a question without leaning on it.
“The first was a key,” said Emmett. “From the till. I was to take it on Sunday night when I paid my check, wrap it in a rag he’d give me, and put it back by Monday noon. He said it was a *courtesy* to the sheriff’s office. He said they were checking something about a chief deputy.” He swallowed. “I knew better. I’m not that stupid. I just didn’t know what I knew.”
“And the second?”
“At two o’clock Monday morning I was to go to the back door of this diner, which I was to find unlatched, and use the key on the lock in the walk-in, and let him in.”
There was a sound in the room like ninety people deciding not to gasp.
---
“He came alone,” said Emmett. “He’d a flashlight, and a little black bag, and he wouldn’t let me carry it. He went down the stair like a man who’d done it before. He knew about a panel in the office wall.” He rubbed his face. “I stood at the bottom and held the flashlight while he opened Hollis’s safe from the back, with a little brass hook, and took out the book, and read in it.”
“Read what?” I said.
“The page. The one with the list. Fourteen lines. He read it under the beam with his lips moving, like a man reading a bill of sale.”
He lifted his eyes, and they were wet, and entirely sincere. “And then he took out of that black bag a pen, a fine pen, and a ruler, and he struck out two lines. And he wrote a note. He said: *There. It’s all in order. Void by her own device.* And he told me to put the ledger on the barrel with the light on it, so you’d see.”
“And the jars.”
“That was after.” Emmett’s hands were shaking on the rail. “He took my father’s jar off the shelf. Everett’s. E.H. He opened it, quite gently, with a little knife, and he took the cloth out and he put it in his breast pocket. And he took out another cloth, a white one, and put that in. And he said: *This is what I’ll give back to you on Thursday. Whole. When the Council of Four is called, and the notice is signed.*”
“You were *paid,*” said Maude.
It was the second word she had said, and it landed like a dropped tray.
“Not paid,” said Emmett. “Promised. The note was to be forgiven. All of it. And Everett’s jar was to be put in my hand, to take out of the building, the way a man takes his father’s ashes. I thought: it’s the only thing of his I’ve got. He had a voice like a bell. He sang in the choir. I haven’t heard it in thirty years, and the jar has it, Maude, I was told it has it—”
“Emmett.” She did not raise her voice. “Your father’s jar has a thumb in the wax.”
“I know. I sealed it myself, at twenty past seven, when every eye in the building was on the grill. I put the till key back after.” He turned, at last, and looked at her down the length of the counter. “He told me to go back and do it neat. He gave me a candle stub. I used my own thumb because I’d forgotten the spoon.”
---
“There’s a thing you ought to hear before you decide anything,” said Emmett, to the room.
He took a breath. I realized that he was braver than I had given him credit for. It is a particular kind of courage, the kind that shows itself in a man who has spent his life avoiding the front of a room.
“He had a book. At the bottom of the stair, while he was reading Hollis’s, he put his own on the barrel next to it. A green book, the same size. Hollis’s has a number one on the spine in pencil. His had a number two.”
I heard my own breath catch.
“I looked,” said Emmett. “I’m sorry. I couldn’t help it. The lantern was right there. It was open at the first page, and I saw one line.”
“What did it say?” said Dane.
“*1974. Haskell. One chair kept warm. Paid: a loan never called.*”
He did not say anything else for a moment. In the dead quiet I heard Pie, under the counter, working at Kane’s bootlace.
“That’s my father,” said Emmett. “That’s his name. He had a *loan.* He had a good one, from a man who came through town that fall.
He was thirty-nine, and in trouble with the feed store, and the man in the pewter coat said: come into the diner on Saturday and swear a little oath, and sit for an hour on a stool. And that was all there was to it. And the loan was never called.” His voice cracked. “And it wasn’t called, and it wasn’t called, and it passed to me with the store, and it was never called, Hollis. Until the fertilizer year.”
“Fifty years,” I said.
“He’s been *keeping the seat.*” Emmett wiped his nose on his sleeve. “Everett kept it. I’ve kept it, whether I wanted to or no, on a note somebody else was holding. We’re not a family that *owes.* We’re a family that was bought.”
Kane set down his coffee.
“A ledger, number two,” he said, in a thoughtful tone, as if to himself. “It’s got the first line in it. A man who keeps a ledger is a man who has a *list.*” He turned on his stool, with the beagle hopping off his boot. “Mr. Haskell, I’m going to ask you one thing, and I’d like a straight answer, and I’m not going to ask you twice. How many lines were on that page?”
Emmett looked at the ceiling. His lips moved.
“I saw only the first,” he said. “But the page was a long one. It went down and down. It went to the bottom. And there was a second column on the right.”
“Of names.”
“Of *prices,*” said Emmett Haskell. “I could see the figures.”
---
I could not Parse a man in front of ninety people. I had promised myself that after Wren, and had broken the promise twice in a week, and had the nosebleeds to show for it. But I had also, somewhere in the course of that confession, begun to feel, in the dim furnace of my own gut, the old stirring that my grandmother called the work.
I walked down the counter and I put a plate in front of him.
It was a small plate. Biscuits, two. A spoonful of gravy, the plain flour kind, made in the iron skillet, with a lot of pepper.
Everett Haskell’s, if I am to be exact, because Aunt Verna had told me once, over a piece of pie, that Everett’s favorite plate, in the years that he sat at my grandmother’s counter, had been biscuits and pepper gravy, and no meat. He had been a vegetarian before there was a word for it. It had been, she said, one of the reasons he was thought to be a little peculiar.
“Eat,” I said.
He looked at it. “I can’t.”
“I know you can’t. Eat anyway.” I put a fork in his hand. “I’m going to ask you to eat what’s set before you, Emmett. And you may ask me for nothing else. Not forgiveness, not your note, not a hand on your shoulder. There’s a woman at the end of this counter and the plate is for her, and for you, and nobody else.”
He ate.
I stood across the counter, with my hands flat on the zinc, and put my nose to the steam that rose from the gravy. And I did the thing that costs.
It came up slowly. It came up like cold coming up through a stone floor. I smelled his fear, which was ordinary, and the cinnamon, which was a habit, and a man’s grief for his father, a deep sweet smell like a loft of old hay. I smelled the pen on the page, the cold iron-and-oak smell of Ardent’s ink, a long way down, carried in Emmett’s memory like a splinter in a hand. And I smelled, under all of it, one thing more, clear and small and unmistakable.
*He’s telling the truth.* Not a penny in him. Not a single penny. A frightened, silly, loving man who had done a terrible thing for an excellent reason, and was not even a very good liar.
And then it was gone. The steam went out of my nose like a lamp being turned down, and I put my hand to my lip and it came away red.
“Ruth,” I said.
“I’ve got a rag.”
“Tell me what the coffee smells like.”
She sniffed the pot, and looked at me with a long, level, motherly look.
“It smells like coffee, Hollis,” said Ruth.
“I can’t smell it.”
“No.”
“I can’t smell the *coffee.*” I tried to keep it light, and the voice came out the voice of a girl of six.
I had lost the thread. All of it. In three weeks I had lost my taste, and then gotten it back, and lost it again, and a thread of smell had remained, a thin silver wire that I had hung my whole life on. And now it was gone as well. The diner was a place without weather. The room had become, to my nose, a very large and very clean photograph of a room.
“For how long?” said Dane, softly. He had come up beside me.
“I don’t know.” I wiped my mouth. “He’s honest. Dane, he’s honest. I’d put my whole hand on it.”
“I never doubted you.”
“You should have. I’d have doubted me.”
---
Maude had not moved.
All through the confession she had stood at the end of the counter, with her gloves in one hand and her husband’s back in her eye, like a soldier at the end of a long parade. And now she walked the length of the counter. Not quickly. It took her perhaps ten seconds. She stopped beside him, and she looked at the plate, and at the half-eaten biscuit, and at the beagle’s tail sticking out from under Kane’s stool.
“Emmett,” she said.
“Maude.”
“You let him in.”
“I did.”
“For your father’s jar. And a note.”
“For the dog,” said Emmett, weakly, and put his face in his hands. “I mean— I didn’t mean— I’m sorry, Maude. You sleep like the dead, thank God. I left the gate open at two and Pie got out, I was in such a state. And I stood in your kitchen at four with the lights off, and I thought: I’ve done the worst thing a man can do to his wife, and I’ve lost the dog.”
There was a small, strange sound from the back of the room that might have been a laugh strangled at birth. It was not cruel. It was the sound of a roomful of people who have been holding their breath for twenty minutes, and have found, quite suddenly, that there is a beagle in it.
Maude did not laugh.
“I’m not going to forgive you this morning,” she said.
“No.”
“I’d like you to know that it’s not because I couldn’t. I’d like you to know it’s because I shouldn’t, yet. A woman who forgives a thing before she’s felt it is a woman who has not heard it.” She drew her gloves through her fingers. “I’m going to sit on thirteen, and I’m going to eat my breakfast, and you’re going to eat yours, and nobody is going to say a word to anybody. And in a day or two, Emmett Haskell, I’ll tell you what I think.”
“Yes.”
“Eat your gravy.”
She sat. The stool took her without a sound. She took off her gloves, one finger at a time, and laid them in a line on the zinc. Tilly brought her a cup of tea with the tag hanging over the rim. Emmett, on stool twelve, bent over his plate, and the whole room looked, with great tact, at the ceiling, the menu board, the clock.
The clock said 6:31. It was the Seth Thomas, running four minutes slow. And I stood under it in a silent room, with my nose gone, and I thought: *they take what you give them, and keep it in a drawer, and are very patient.*
---
It was Emmett who said it, at the end.
He was at the till, at seven-fifteen, after the room had half emptied and the beagle had been fed a sausage by four separate people. He had asked to pay. I had said it was on the house. He had said no, that he had once stolen a key from that drawer and he’d like, at the least, to put in what the breakfast cost, and I let him.
He laid down a twenty. Then he said, not looking at me:
“There’s a thing I haven’t told.”
I waited.
“He said the notice was to be signed on Monday,” said Emmett. “In his office. I walked there at three, after I left the truck, and signed. I wasn’t thinking. I was thinking about my father.” He turned the bill over, and smoothed it flat. “It was a Notice of Council of Four. Two of the three old seats could call it, he said, and he had one already.”
“Two of three?”
“Halvorsen, Marlowe, Haskell. The Council of Three of 1974.” He looked up. “I’m the Haskell. Maude’s father was the Halvorsen, and Maude’s the heir, but she’d never sign. And he said the Marlowe was on the paper already.”
The pie case hummed. At the end of the counter, Dane Marlowe set down his coffee cup.
“I haven’t signed anything,” said Dane.
“No,” said Emmett Haskell, in a small flat voice. “I didn’t think you had.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!