Mr. Alvin Tolland of Tamarack arrived at 7:20, in a good brown suit, with a briefcase he held in front of his stomach like a man carrying a tray through a crowd.
He was the one Strand had called all right but afraid. I had telephoned him at six, from the office, with the door shut and my mother’s laugh still going round in my head, and he had said he would come at once, which in my experience is what lawyers say when they intend to come at the last possible moment. He came at 7:20. I counted that as a miracle and put a cup of coffee in front of him before he had sat down.
“Ms. Brandt.” He shook my hand with a damp, kind palm. He was perhaps fifty, small and neat and balding, with the anxious eyes of a man who has spent thirty years explaining bad news in a soft voice. “I’m so sorry about Ms. Strand. She’s a first-rate advocate. She told me, on the phone at a quarter to six, that I should take you only if I could stand it.”
“Can you?”
“I’m not sure yet.” He looked at the counter. At my mother, sitting on nine with her wrists in her lap and a second cup of coffee; at Sheriff Dunmore, one stool down, with his hat over his knee; at Kane. “That is a great deal of the county, in a small room.”
“It’s a Table,” I said. “It’s supposed to be.”
“Yes. I read the clauses. I read them twice, last night, and I’m afraid I haven’t the faintest idea what to make of them.” He took out a legal pad. “Shall we begin with what is actually going to happen at ten o’clock?”
“Judge Tate’s holding the cellar hearing here.”
“So I’m told. In a diner.” He wrote it down, and I saw him underline the word *diner* twice, as if it might otherwise try to leave. “And before that?”
“At nine, a man named Ardent calls a Council. Under a custom of 1974.”
“Which has no force at law.”
“It has force at the Table.”
“Which has no force at law,” said Mr. Tolland, kindly.
I said nothing. It was the oldest argument in my life, and I had heard it from better lawyers. The trouble with it was that it was right, and that it did not matter, and that the two facts lived side by side like cats.
---
I told him as much as I could.
I did not tell him about the slip. I had folded it into the pocket of my apron, against my hip, where I could feel the paper every time I leaned, and I said only that I had been told to open the door at ten past nine, and to count what the man carried, and to ask for a plate. He wrote it all down. His pen slowed on the word *plate.*
“What plate?”
“I don’t know.”
“A dinner plate?”
“I don’t know that either.”
“Is it a *metaphor*?” said Mr. Tolland, in the voice of a man who prays it is.
“It might be a brass plate,” I said. “There’s one on the shelf. It was on stool fourteen.” I went and took it down from beneath my grandmother’s portrait, and laid it in front of him on the zinc, next to the Westclox, with its two small screws. “My grandmother had it cut in 1974. *Hollis B. Stool fourteen. Reserved.* Mr. Ardent’s side seems to want something done with it.”
He picked it up. He turned it in the light.
“A very ordinary piece of engraving,” he said. “I don’t see—” And then he stopped, and put his thumb on the back.
It was a brass rectangle, about the size of a playing card, a little over a sixteenth of an inch thick. On the front it said what it said, in my grandmother’s blocky capitals cut deep into the metal by somebody’s tool. On the back, which I had never in my life examined, there was a pair of shallow brown marks, like the mouths of two tiny craters.
“What are these?”
“Screw holes.”
“No. Here.” He tilted the plate. “Just below the center. There’s a depression. A dent, like a thumb pressed into wax. Do you see it? There are ridges in it.”
I took the plate back from him. I held it to the pie-case lamp.
He was right. About an inch below the middle of the back, there was an oval dimple, shallow and clean-edged, about the size of the pad of my own thumb. It had been pressed in; I could tell by the way the brass had risen in a thin lip round the edge. It showed a faint whorl, a pattern of lines curving to the left like a river seen from the air.
It was not Granny’s. Granny had a small hand. This was a big thumb.
“Somebody’s fingerprint,” said Mr. Tolland.
“Somebody’s hand,” I said.
---
It was Ruth who found the day-book.
She had gone home at six to change her apron, and returned at ten past seven carrying a flat tin biscuit box under her arm, with a coat over the box to keep it from the damp. “I took it off the Alder Street shelf on Sunday,” she said, “when you were upstairs. I thought you’d rather have it than have it in a cold house. I’ve read it, Hollis. I didn’t want to say. It seemed like prying.”
“Eli’s?”
“The last year of it.”
It was the black clothbound book I had seen on Sunday, with the locksmith’s marks and the short, dry, abbreviated entries of a man who bills by the hour. This time I did not read from the front. I turned to the end, where the entries ran out and the pages went blank, and found the last one that had been written in ink.
*Nov. 1974. For H.,* it said. *Plate for the Fourteenth, cut and set. As always, thumb pressed in back before the cut. Table knows its own. A plate without a hand is a sign, not a seat. Left key blank on purpose. Let her file it herself if ever she must. God keep the girl. —E.B.*
I read it three times. I turned the book round and put it under Mr. Tolland’s nose.
“*A plate without a hand,*” he read, “*is a sign, not a seat.*”
“That’s it.”
“That’s what?”
“That’s the thing I was told to ask for.” I could hardly get the words out. “Eli Brandt cut every plate for the Table by hand. He pressed his thumb in the back first, before he cut anything. It’s how you know. A plate with his thumb on it is a plate the Table knows. A plate with no hand on it—”
“Is a counterfeit,” said Ruth, from the end of the counter. She did not often say a long word. “Is what I’d call it. Like the pin.”
“Like the pin,” I said.
The pin lay beside the clock on a square of tea towel: the silver clover-bow key, stamped 0014, with its seven forged teeth. *Any cut 0014 is forged,* said Eli’s book. And in the margin of that last page, I now saw, there was a very small drawing in pencil. It was a thumb. Under it, in Eli’s hand: *Every one. No exceptions.*
I sat down on the nearest stool. It happened to be fourteen. I did not notice until Mr. Tolland said, very carefully, “Ms. Brandt, you’re sitting on the reserved seat.”
“There’s no plate on it.”
“Would that matter, in a body of custom?”
“It might.” I did not get up. The stool was cold under me, with a different cold than the others, as a lake is colder in the middle. It was neither hostile nor friendly. It simply waited. “Mr. Tolland, I think Ardent has a plate. I think he’s going to put a plate on this stool at ten past nine and say the name on it is the fourth. And I think the plate has no thumb.”
“How do you know?”
“I don’t,” I said. “I’ve been told. By a woman who writes in blue ballpoint, in a handwriting I’d know in my sleep.” I looked at the lawyer. “What would that do for me in court?”
He took off his glasses. He wiped them on his tie. It took him a long time.
“Nothing,” said Mr. Tolland.
---
I will give him this: he did not lie to me.
“It is a very moving fact,” he said. “I’d love to be able to say that it moves a magistrate. It doesn’t. Judge Tate will want to know whether the Table is an association with bylaws, a trust with a trustee, a tenancy, a nuisance, or a clerical error. A thumbprint on a brass plate from 1974 has no legal weight. It might make a fine exhibit at a county fair.”
“It’s the whole fight.”
“In *your* world.”
“In my world,” I said, “is a woman paid to cook for ninety people a day, who cannot smell her own cooking, and who is about to be named an unneutral party in her own kitchen by a piece of paper. That’s the only world I’ve got.”
“I understand that. I only mean that as your counsel I can’t stand up and argue it. It would make you look unstable.” He paused. “It would make *me* look unstable.”
“Then argue the other things.”
“Which other things?”
“The standing. The trustee. The Notice. The forged proxy, the pin, the tape, the sheriff’s seal on the cellar.” I heard my own voice rise. “You can’t tell me there’s nothing.”
“There is a great deal. There is quite a large amount.” He put his glasses on again. “But Ms. Brandt, may I be frank? I’ve read the Ames and Pell file. I’ve read what Mr. Ardent has been very kind enough to send, courtesy of his clerk, at four a.m.” He took an envelope from his briefcase. “Which I’d rather you didn’t see until I’ve made up my mind.”
“What is it?”
“It’s a copy of my mortgage,” said Mr. Tolland.
---
He did not say anything more for nearly a minute. I watched him not say it. His eyes went to the window and the empty lot, and then to the coffee, and then to the clock, which said 8:16.
“It was sold in March,” he said. “To a trust. I was told it was routine; the bank wanted the liability off its books. I paid on time. I’ve paid on time for fourteen years. This morning, at four, I was woken by a courier, who gave me a copy of the assignment and the name of the assignee. And a note, in a good fountain pen, that said, *With compliments. No obligation of any kind. J.A.*”
“That’s a threat.”
“It is not,” said Mr. Tolland. “That’s what makes it so very clever. It says nothing. It threatens nothing. It’s a courtesy.” He shut the briefcase. “I could represent you, Ms. Brandt. I’d do it honestly. Every motion I filed would be one I’d have filed in any case. And the day after the hearing, I’d get a second courtesy, and a third. And I would know, with great precision, that it was because I’d filed them.”
“You’re afraid.”
“I’m afraid,” he agreed. “I told Ms. Strand so. She said it was the first sign of a good lawyer. She was kind.” He stood up. “I think I’m going to be a worse one this morning than I was a week ago. I’m sorry. I’m so very sorry.”
I did not argue. There was a time in my life when I would have. But I had watched Strand go out of that back door at four in the morning with her briefcase and her bare conscience, and I had learned something about how much it costs a person to be honest, and what it costs to be asked.
“Take a plate to go,” said Ruth, from the flour bin.
“I beg your pardon?”
“Take a plate. It’s cold out.” She had a slab of apple pie on waxed paper already. “I’d not have it said you went from this counter on an empty stomach.”
He took it. He took it with the fixed, glassy smile of a man who has been handed a decent thing at the wrong time. And as he stepped out, onto the mat, with the bell clanging behind him, he turned and said:
“If it helps, Ms. Brandt. I read the clause. Fourteen. I read it very carefully. It is the only one in the whole Instrument that doesn’t say *shall.* It says *may.*”
“What does that mean?”
“I haven’t the slightest idea,” said Mr. Tolland. “But I felt somebody ought to hear it.”
The door closed on him. I stood and watched him go down the lot to his car, with the pie held out in front of him like a tray, and I had a feeling I would see his face again, and that it would not be at a hearing.
---
Dane came in at 8:35.
He had been in the lot since seven, with the pack. I had seen them go by the window in twos, in their ordinary coats, taking up places along the fence and the bumpers and the doorstep of the hardware store, not looking at the diner. It’s a way wolves have of declining to loom. Dane had come in last, and stood on the mat with his hat in his bandaged hand, and said nothing at all, and looked at my mother.
June looked back. They had not spoken since Sunday.
“Dane,” she said.
“June.”
“You look tired.”
“So do you.” He put the hat on the counter. He did not sit. “Sheriff. Would it be improper to say good morning to the prisoner?”
“Not at all,” said Dunmore. “I’m told she’s a guest.”
“Good morning, then.” He bowed his head to her; I had never seen him bow to anyone. Then he turned, and walked the whole length of the counter to me, and stopped on the other side of the grill, where the pass-through made a kind of frame. “A word, Hollis.”
“I’ve got ten minutes.”
“It won’t take ten.”
I wiped my hands. I took him into the dry-goods pantry, which is the only place in the building where there is a door and no window, and shut the door behind us. It smelled of flour and sacking. I knew, from the shape of the dark, that it smelled that way, since I could not smell it myself.
“What’s in your apron?” said Dane.
“Dane—”
“You’ve had your hand on it since seven. Every time you turn, you touch the pocket. Like a woman checking her purse.” He did not raise his voice. “It’s paper. It’s the same sort of paper as the card Wren had. It’s folded small.”
“I can’t tell you.”
“I know that you can’t. I’m not asking you to say what’s on it.” He put his good hand on the shelf. “I’m asking to read it. Just to read it. I won’t say a word, and I’ll hand it back, and you can tell her you told me nothing.”
“That’s the same thing.”
“It isn’t. You promised not to *tell* me. You didn’t promise I couldn’t read.”
It was a lawyer’s distinction. It was, in point of fact, exactly the sort Strand would have made, and I felt a hot, bright, shameful wish to give it to him. I wanted to put the slip in his hand and watch his face and be done with it. I wanted somebody to carry the thing for me.
“I’d be keeping the promise in the way that doesn’t count,” I said.
“Yes.”
“She’d know.”
“She would.” A pause. “And she’d forgive you, you know. She forgives everyone, in the end. It’s the one thing she can’t be talked out of.”
“I know that.” I put my hand on the pocket, as he’d said. “That’s why I can’t.”
He looked at me for a long moment, in the dark. Then he did a thing that I have thought about ever since. He took the bandaged hand off the shelf, the one that Betsy had burned, and he held it out to me, palm up, with the dressing coming loose and a little brown at the edge.
“I carried a coal two and a half miles for you,” said Dane. “I’m not complaining. I’d do it again. I’m only telling you what I’ve got in my pocket. It’s a *burn*, Hollis. It’s what I know how to give. It’s not a slip of paper, and it’s not a secret, and it can’t be hidden in a clock.”
“That’s unfair.”
“Yes,” said Dane. “It is.” He lowered the hand. “I’ll be in the lot. With the pack. I think there’s a thing that happens at ten past nine, and I think you’re going to need me to be where I can’t see it. That’s all I know. I don’t want to be there for it, and I can’t bear to be anywhere else.”
“Dane—”
“Open the door,” he said. “When you must. I’m not going anywhere.”
He went out through the kitchen, and across the back lot, where I heard the pack close round him in the dark.
I stood in the pantry for a minute more. I took my hand off the pocket. It stayed warm for a long time after.
---
By ten to nine the diner was full.
It filled the way a church fills before a wedding, in whispers. They came in by ones and twos, the people I fed: the Kessler girls and the Marlowe cousins, the old man with the hearing aid, the woman from the florist’s with a casserole, the wolf who sells tires. Verna took the pie-case stool and held court. Tilly passed round the coffee.
Maude came in at a quarter to nine, in the green coat, and took the end of the counter without a word, and Emmett came in after her and stood behind her, a pace back, his hat in his hands. She did not look at him. But she did not tell him to go.
At five to nine, Kane stood.
He walked to the door, and looked out through the glass, and came back. He had the paper bag under his arm still, and he put it on the counter in front of me.
“I brought you something,” he said. “Breakfast fifteen. I thought you might want it done.”
“What’s in it?”
“A pastry. I got up at two. I’d like it to be the kind of day that has a pastry in it.” He cleared his throat. “I was trained as a baker, Ms. Brandt. Before the rest of it. I haven’t told anyone. It was my father’s trade, before the mill.”
I opened the bag. A round, brown, crackling thing, glazed, with a split top and a slick of orange peel. It smelled of nothing at all, of course, but the weight in my hand said butter.
“Eat it,” said Kane.
I broke it in half. The inside was soft, and yellow, and slightly cooled. I put the first piece in my mouth, and chewed, and for a moment, a very small and cruel moment, I tasted something. It was thin as a thread: a little sugar, a ghost of orange, the sweetness of butter that has been worked. It lasted perhaps two seconds. It went, as a name goes when you reach for it, and left behind a sort of ache.
“Well?” said Kane.
“It’s very good.”
“You can taste it.”
“For two seconds,” I said. “I think I can.”
“That’s a beginning.” He sat on eight. “I’d say I was sorry for the delay. But I’ve a feeling I’m the last man alive who has the right.”
The clock said 8:58, by the old Seth Thomas.
I put the pastry down. I wiped my fingers. I walked to the front door, and drew down the bolt with a great cold *clack*, and the whole room turned and watched me do it, and fell silent.
Through the glass, on the pavement, in a pewter coat, stood Julian Ardent.
He had a black bag in one hand. He was looking at his watch. He wore the expression of a man who has made an appointment and intends to keep it, down to the second, and has no objection whatever to being kept waiting. Behind him, on the curb, Lyle Gorman in his sheriff’s tan stood with his thumbs in his belt. And there were others, three or four, in dark suits, with folders.
He looked up. He saw me through the pane. He did not smile, and he did not frown, and he did not knock.
He raised one gloved finger, politely, to indicate that he was early, and would wait.
At nine the Seth Thomas over the register, which loses four minutes a day and had been set right that morning by my own hand, struck the hour in its throat-clearing way. Nobody in the room moved.
I stood with my back to the bolted door and my hand on the apron pocket, and counted to six hundred.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!