“The Keeper may look at what she keeps,” said Julian Ardent.
It was the first thing in the whole morning he had said without a pause, and I understood that he had been ready for it. He stood back from stool fourteen, with his hands folded in front of his coat, and made a small gesture with two fingers, like a host showing a guest to a chair.
“You’ll want to see the back,” he said. “I should.”
“Yes.”
“The screwdriver is in the bag. Mr. Haskell, if you would hold the bag for her.”
Emmett took it as if it were hot. I did not need the screwdriver. I had one in my apron, a stubby yellow one with a chipped handle that had lived in that pocket since I was fifteen, and I took it out and knelt on the black-and-white linoleum in front of the stool, in front of ninety people, and set the tip into the first brass screw.
It turned easily. It had been set by someone who knew his business. The second came out as cleanly. I put them in my palm, two small bright things, and lifted the plate by its edges, and the brass came away from the zinc with a small dry click.
I turned it over.
“Hollis?” said my mother.
“Wait.”
It was smooth. I ran my thumb across it, the whole width, from corner to corner. It was as smooth as the inside of a spoon. There was no dent. There was no whorl. There was not even a scratch. It was a flat brass back, machine-milled, with a faint dull sheen in long parallel lines like combed hair, and in the lower right corner, very small, a stamp: *R&L ENGRAVING SUPPLY, CHICAGO.*
I got to my feet. I did not trust my knees, so I put one hand on the counter. I lifted the plate high enough for the room to see.
“It has no thumb,” I said.
Nobody said anything. It is hard to describe the quality of that silence. It was the silence of a church in which someone has finally said aloud the thing the congregation has been murmuring in its pews.
---
“May I?” said Verna.
I carried it to her. She put on her glasses, and took the plate in both hands, and held it to the pie-case lamp, and turned it twice, slowly, as one turns an egg.
“R and L,” she said. “Chicago. They sold blanks by the gross. You could order a hundred and put your own words on them.” She handed it back to me and took off the glasses. “It’s a good plate. It’s a very good plate. It is a perfectly ordinary plate. It has no more business on that counter than a hubcap.”
“Does it matter?” said Maude.
It was the first time she had spoken since the lane had opened for Ardent. She did not raise her voice; she had never in her life raised it. She was standing at the end of the counter, in the green coat, with Emmett behind her, and she looked at the plate in my hands as she had once looked at the report on her father’s death.
“It matters to the Table,” I said.
“Says who?”
“Says him.” I went back to the counter, where my own plate lay on the tea towel beside the clock: Granny’s, with its blocky capitals, *HOLLIS B.* I turned it over and held it up in the other hand, so that the room could see the back of each, side by side. “Look. A thumbprint. Eli Brandt’s.”
“He pressed his thumb into every plate he ever cut for the Table, before he cut a letter. It’s in his day-book. ‘Table knows its own. A plate without a hand is a sign, not a seat.’”
“You’re reading from a locksmith’s daybook,” said one of the young men in dark suits, from the wall. He was very young, and fair, and had a cold. “With respect. It isn’t evidence of anything.”
“No,” I said. “I know. It isn’t evidence.” I put both plates on the zinc, back up, side by side. “It’s the Table. It’s whether a thing is a plate, or only looks like one.”
“Ms. Brandt,” said Ardent.
“Yes?”
“You are quite right.”
---
I had expected a good many things from him. A denial. A technicality. A little lecture on the history of engraving. What I had not expected was that he would look down at the two plates, with their upturned backs, one smooth and one thumbed, and nod. It was a slow, thoughtful, almost appreciative nod. He might have been a teacher whose best pupil had handed in the expected answer.
“It is a counterfeit,” he said. “In the sense that Mr. Brandt meant. It has no hand. I ordered it from Chicago in November.”
“You admit that?”
“I have never denied it. You did not ask.” His eyes lifted to my face. “It has been the whole of my principal’s difficulty, Ms. Brandt, for fifty years. The Table knows its own. It will not seat a sign. A name will sit on a plate only when a hand has been *in* the plate: when a person who is of the Table has cut it, and pressed it, and put herself behind it.”
He folded his hands. “I have tried it with machines. I have tried it with a very patient engraver in Seattle. It does not hold. It was why, in 1974, the man in the pewter coat could not stay.”
“Your principal’s man.”
“The one in the pewter coat. It is a long story, and I think you have seen the part of it that matters.” He looked at the thumbed plate on the counter.
“He sat on this stool, and he said, *Keep it warm.* And Mr. Brandt, who was a better locksmith than anyone gave him credit for, cut the Fourteenth in the old Keeper’s name, and pressed his thumb in, and set it. It held. It has held for fifty years. And my principal has been trying ever since to get a plate that holds in someone else’s.”
“Then you’ve lost.”
“I have not,” said Ardent mildly. “I did not say I needed a plate that holds in *mine.* I said I needed a hand.”
He turned his head.
It was a short, slow, entirely courteous movement, as of a man looking down the length of a dining table to the person he has saved the best seat for. He looked straight down the length of the counter to stool nine, where my mother sat with the chain on the zinc between her wrists.
“I only need one,” said Ardent. “And I believe, Mrs. Brandt, that you have brought it.”
---
I thought I had understood.
I had stood at the grill with the slip in my pocket, and beside the lawyer’s chair, and in the pantry with Dane’s burnt hand held out to me in the dark, and each time I had thought, *Now I see.* Each time I had been wrong in a slightly more intelligent way.
I looked at the scribe on its white cloth. It had not moved. It lay where June had put it at 5:31: four inches of steel, with a brass tip and a wooden handle burnt with two letters, laid out in the light for everyone to see. *Where she can see it,* she had said. Not *where I can reach it.*
*They both want her here,* I had thought, and, *They can’t both be right.*
They could. That was the cold, clean, horrible fact. They could both be right, because they were not asking for opposite things. He wanted a hand, and she had brought one. She wanted to be at the Table when he asked for it, and he had made quite certain she would be. It had never been a quarrel over whether June would cut the plate. It was a quarrel over what she would cut.
“Mom,” I said.
“Hollis.”
“You knew.”
“I knew he would need me,” said June. “I didn’t know until Wednesday how he’d get me here. I thought he would ask. I thought he’d offer me something.” She lifted her wrists, and the chain clinked. “I didn’t think he’d arrest me.”
“It’s a very good way,” said Ardent. “It leaves you no room to refuse without refusing the Table.”
“You’ve never in your life been fair, Julian.”
“I have never been anything else. That is the unfairness.”
I wanted to scream. I wanted to take the screwdriver in my hand and drive it into the counter. I had been told, by the one person I trusted, to ask for a thing, and the thing was the only way to get exactly what he’d come for. And I had asked. And it was done.
“I never *said* I’d let her.”
“No,” said Ardent. “You did not. It is entirely her choice. I merely observe that it was the Keeper’s question that opened the form.” He paused, and for the first time there was something almost gentle in the long face. “It was kind of you to ask. I had thought I would have to.”
---
“Sheriff,” said my mother.
Dunmore had not moved. He had stood through the whole business with his hat in his hand and his tired face composed, like a deacon waiting to see whether he is to be called on. He cleared his throat.
“Ma’am.”
“I can’t cut in cuffs. I never could. It takes both hands, and the left one has to steady the right.” She held up her wrists. “May I ask you to take these off? I give you my word that I won’t leave the counter. I couldn’t, in any case. I’ve eaten.”
“I can’t, Ms. Brandt. You’re in my custody.”
“You are,” said Verna, “if you mean to remove her. You can’t. She’s a guest at the Table with bread on the board and a clean plate.” She rapped her stick on the floor, once. “And a guest can’t sit in irons. It was settled in 1951. A hand that’s fed is a free hand. If you want to take her out, she has to say so.”
“I know the rule, Miss Marlowe.”
“Then follow it.”
Dunmore looked at me. I did not know what my face said. He looked at the scribe, at the chain, at Ardent, who stood with his palms folded and his eyes politely on the middle distance, as a man looks away from a stranger’s quarrel.
“I’ll write it up as *released to the custody of the Table for the duration,*” he said, to no one in particular. He fished in his belt for the key. “I’ve never written that before. I don’t think it’s a thing.”
“It is now,” said Verna.
The key clicked. The cuffs came off, and my mother set them on the counter, beside her saucer, with the same neat unemphatic movement she had always used to set down a thing she was done with. She rubbed her wrists. Red marks lay across them like a bracelet.
“Thank you, Sheriff,” said June. “You’re a decent man.”
“I’m a tired one.”
“The one doesn’t preclude the other.”
---
They gave her room.
I will never forget it. Maude moved first, without a word; she took her steno pad off the counter, and stepped to the side, and the two stools next to nine emptied. Kane stood from eight and took his coffee to the end. The wolves along the wall drew back. Ruth came out of the kitchen with her flour on her arms and set a clean towel on the zinc, unasked, and smoothed it out with the flat of her hand.
My mother stood. She took the scribe from its handkerchief.
She did not look at it. She held it as one holds a thing one has held a thousand times: low in the fist, the wooden handle against the pad of the palm, the brass tip between the first two fingers, the way a girl holds a pencil when she has been taught by someone who did it for love and not for school. Her hand was perfectly steady. It was not a hand I knew.
“I need a blank,” she said.
Ardent opened the black bag again. He drew out another flannel, small, gray, and unfolded it. It was another brass plate, new, mill-backed, the same size as the first. It was blank. It was as clean as a coin before it is struck.
“It will take the name,” he said. “Once the seal is broken.”
“I know what it’ll take.” She put the plate on the towel. “Where’s the envelope?”
He handed it to her. He gave it to her in both hands, as one hands over a book to a priest. And for the first time that morning, I saw my mother hesitate. She looked at the green wax disc for perhaps three seconds, and her thumb moved on it, across the little clover-bow, once.
“The cutter reads it first,” she said, to the room. “That’s the form. The one who cuts the plate breaks the seal, and reads the name, and sets it in brass. No one else sees it until the plate is hung.” She glanced at me. “I’d like it to be understood that I haven’t read it. That I don’t know what it says.”
“Nor do I,” said Ardent. “I wrote only the one word, on a card, on Tuesday. I sealed it myself, and I did not look at it again.”
“Then it’s a stranger’s name to both of us,” said June.
“If you say so.”
“Why do I feel you’ve told me a very great deal, Julian, and none of it is the thing?”
“Because I do not lie,” said Ardent. “It is a considerable limitation.”
She slid her thumb under the wax. It cracked with a small dry sound, like a knuckle. The envelope opened. She drew out a card of heavy stock, folded once, and bent her head over it, and read.
---
I was watching her face. Everyone in the room was watching her face. And so I saw what it did.
It did nothing.
It was the stillest I have ever seen a human face. She read the name, whatever it was, and the lines did not move, and the eyes did not flicker, and the mouth did not tighten. Only the color went, very slowly, from her cheeks, as the tide goes out of a flat; and I knew from that alone that it was not a name she had expected. And it was not a name she had not.
She folded the card once and put it in the pocket of her coat. She did not show it to anyone.
“I’ll need the room quiet,” said June. “I’ll need twenty minutes, and a lamp, and for nobody to talk to me.”
“Of course,” said Ardent.
“I don’t mean you.”
“I know.”
Ruth fetched the pie-case lamp on its long cord and set it on the counter, so that its pool of yellow fell on the towel and the brass. My mother sat on stool nine. She laid the blank plate in the light. She put her left thumb to the back of it, in the lower middle, and pressed, with a slow, even force, till the brass took the mark, and she lifted her thumb off, and a dimple stayed.
*A hand,* I thought. *It has a hand.*
Then she bent over it, and set the point of the scribe, and began.
---
It is a very quiet sound, an engraving. I had not known. It is like a mouse in a wall: a thin, faint, patient scratching, with little pauses. The scribe went in at an angle, and a curl of brass rose up in front of it and fell off, glittering, and was swept away by the side of her hand. I could not see what she was cutting. She had her back half turned to me and the card in her coat.
Nobody spoke. Somebody’s chair creaked. Tilly stood by the urn with a cup of coffee in each hand and didn’t know where to put them. Kane watched with his head tilted, like a man listening to a tune he half remembers.
I stood in the middle of my own diner with two brass plates in my hand and the slip in my apron, and I watched my mother do the thing she had apparently done at ten years old, at her father’s elbow, in the workshop on Alder Street, and had not done since. Her shoulders loosened a little as she worked. It was an extraordinary thing to see. She looked, for the first time since she came home, like someone who was where she belonged.
“Hollis,” said Ardent, quietly, at my elbow.
I had not heard him come. He stood a pace away, with his hat, and his eyes on the scribe.
“Granny’s plate,” he said. “Yours. I wonder if I might ask for it.”
“No.”
“It is an exhibit. It may be needed at ten, before Judge Tate, to show the difference between the two. Mr. Penn here will hold it in chain of custody.” He nodded to the fair young man with the cold. “He has a bag. It will be returned to you intact before noon.”
“It’s my grandmother’s.”
“It is the only plate in the building with a hand on it.” He said it with the faintest edge of apology. “You said so yourself. It would be a pity if it were lost, or dropped, or mistaken for something else, in a crowded room.”
“Is that a threat?”
“I have never made one. I only observe that you are carrying it, and that you do not seem to have anywhere to put it.”
That was true. I looked at my hands. I looked at the counter, which was full of the Table’s property, the Westclox and the pin and the loaf and the book, and at the one thing in the whole building that was not for sale, and I thought, *If I don’t give it, he’ll say I hid evidence. If I give it, he’ll own the only proof.*
*Both,* I thought. *They both want her here.*
I held out the plate.
Mr. Penn took it in a white handkerchief, as if it were hot. He slid it into a clear plastic sleeve. It was done in four seconds. And I felt, as it left my palm, a little *give* in the room, a thinning. The thing on the counter, my grandmother’s plain brass, with a thumb in its back, had been the single fixed point in a place full of moving ones. It was gone.
“Thank you,” said Ardent.
“Don’t.”
“As you like.”
---
The bell rang at 9:58.
It was a brisk, businesslike, slightly impatient ring. I had never been so glad of a bell. It was the first sound all morning that had not been somebody’s cue.
The door opened, and a gust of cold air came in with a short, stout, white-haired man in a brown overcoat, a tweed hat, and a pair of enormous rubber galoshes. He had a briefcase in one hand and a thermos in the other.
He stood on the mat and surveyed the room, the ninety people, the pack in the doorway, the sheriff, the loaf, the clock, with the unhurried gaze of a man who has seen a great many unlikely things in his life and expects to see a great many more.
“Good morning,” said Magistrate Frederick Tate. “I’m told there’s a plate.”
Nobody answered. My mother’s scribe went on, scratch, scratch, scratch, with a little pause between.
“I am also told,” said the judge, shutting the door behind him with his heel, “that there’s pie.”
“There’s pie,” said Ruth.
“Good. I shall have mine at the bench.” He walked up the length of the aisle between the stools, unbuttoning his coat, and put his briefcase on the end of the counter, beside Maude’s steno pad, and unscrewed the lid of his thermos. “Now. Which of you is the Keeper?”
I put my hand up. It trembled.
“Ah.” He peered at me over his glasses. “You look as if you’ve been up since yesterday. Sit down, young lady, before you fall down.” He sat himself on stool one, at the far end, with a small grunt. “Sheriff. Mr. Ardent. I gather we have a matter before the court. I shall hear it at ten. In the meantime, would somebody tell me why a woman is carving brass in the middle of my hearing?”
“She’s not carving,” said Verna. “She’s finishing a sentence.”
“Whose?”
“It’s the Table’s,” said my mother, without turning round, and cut the last letter.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!