Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 50

The Fourth Name

Judge Tate heard the cellar motion over a slice of apple pie, with his galoshes crossed at the ankle, to the sound of my mother engraving.

I will say for him that he did it properly. He had Mr. Penn state the motion, and he had Deputy Okonkwo state the sheriff’s seal, and he asked three questions in a mild dry voice that made the fair young man go pink to the ears. Had the county’s tape been disturbed? (No.) Was the Notice of Four a pleading before the court? (Mr. Penn thought it was in the nature of a courtesy.) Had anyone proposed an actual inspection of any actual jar? (Not yet.)

“Then I’ll say what I said Monday,” said Tate, with his mouth full. “The cellar stays shut. The seal stands. I won’t open a room in which someone has already been twice by a back way, and I won’t have it opened by either side until I know who has the key.” He swallowed. “The Keeper, I take it, has no counsel.”

“I’m representing myself, Your Honor.”

“God help you.” He did not say it unkindly. “I’ll hear the rest at noon, back at the courthouse, if I can be spared this. I don’t, as a rule, adjourn for a Council of anything. But I’m told this one is quicker than a trial, and I confess I’d like to see how.”

“It is a very short ceremony,” said Ardent.

“I’m sure it is. They always are.” He pulled the thermos toward him. “Go on. Don’t mind me. I’m eating.”

---

My mother laid down the scribe.

She did it with a small, ordinary, careful motion, and then she sat very still, with her right hand held out over the towel as if it belonged to someone else. The fingers were curled. The thumb, the one she had pressed into the brass, had gone white at the tip. When she tried to open the hand, it did not open, and she looked at it with mild interest, as one looks at a glove that has shrunk.

“It’s cramped,” she said, to me. “It’ll pass. It did, as a girl, after a long cut.” She flexed it once, twice. It stayed curled. “I don’t think I’ll cut another. It’s quite all right. I only had the one in me.”

“Mom.”

“It’s the price, my dear. I told you there’d be one. It’s only that this one is mine.” She lifted the plate in her left hand and held it out to me. “Take it. Hold it in the light. It wants to be seen before it’s hung.”

I took it.

It was warm from the lamp. It had the weight of a thing that has been made. On the back, in the lower middle, just below the center, there was a shallow oval dent: the print of a whorled thumb, curving to the left like a river from the air. It was a smaller thumb than Eli’s. It was perfectly clear.

I turned the plate over.

The letters were small and square. They were beautifully cut, with the clean, even, rather severe elegance of a hand that had learned from a locksmith. They did not look like a name. They looked like a tool. They said:

*KANE.*

---

I have thought a good deal about the next three seconds, and about how I ought to have known. I had every piece.

A man who ate fourteen breakfasts at a counter; a man paid for eleven years by an employer he had never seen; a man whose father was owed, and whose mother was paid, and who had been given a brass key at seventeen and told *Not yet.* I had stood in my own cellar and read *P.K. 1990,* and not once had I asked what a man who is owed so much is *worth* to the man who owes it.

I looked up.

He had not moved. Kane stood at the end of the counter, beside Maude, with his waistcoat buttoned and his hat in his hand and the cup of black coffee at his elbow, still steaming. His face was perfectly smooth. It had gone the color of tallow, and it showed no more than a plaster mask would, and in his eyes, for just the length of a held breath, was something that I recognized from the mirror.

It was the look of a person who has been told, out loud, in front of a crowd, that the thing she thought she was doing for herself had been done to her.

“Pruett,” said Maude, very quietly.

“I heard.”

“Did you know?”

“No.” He did not look at her. “I did not.”

“I never said it was Mr. Kane,” said Ardent.

His voice had not changed. It was very level. He stood by the black bag with his gloved hands clasped, and not one muscle of his face asked for pity, or for anything else.

“It says *Kane.* It says nothing more. I wrote it on the sixth, on a card, as the Instrument requires. I did not write a Christian name. I wrote the name that a Table cannot refuse, because it has fed it.” He glanced at the plate in my hands. “The Table does not ask which. It never has.”

He went on in the same level tone. “Mr. Kane has eaten fourteen breakfasts at this counter. It has fed him a plate every morning for fourteen days. In the matter of the name *Kane,* there is, as of this hour, one person it has served.”

“Ellen Kane,” I said.

“Died three years ago, in Salem, and never once sat at this counter. She was never fed here.” He did not blink. “I have inquired.”

“You’ve been waiting for this.”

“I have been waiting,” said Ardent, “for thirty-four years.”

---

It was then that he opened the ledger.

He did not hurry. He took up the green book, No. 2, from the row on the counter, and thumbed it to a place near the middle, where a satin ribbon lay. He turned it round on the zinc so that its face looked toward me, and set his forefinger on the page.

“I’d like the Keeper to read it,” he said. “Aloud, if she can. I think she is entitled.”

It was a ruled page, in a small severe hand. A column of dates down the left; names in the middle; at the right, under a ruled heading, a column of sums. I knew the hand. It was the fountain-pen hand that had struck through *13* and *14* in my grandmother’s ledger.

*1974. Haskell, E. One chair kept warm. Paid: a loan never called.*

My eye went down.

*1990. Kane, R. Death. Paid: nothing owed. Quiet.*

*1991. Kane, P. (17). Key 4417. Paid: the rent of the box, in perpetuity, so that the seat shall be there when he comes.*

“When he comes,” I said. My voice sounded very strange. “He’s been paying rent on a *seat.*”

“I have been paying it,” said Ardent, “on his behalf. It is a small sum.”

He lifted his chin. “It was agreed in the winter of 1991 by the man you have been calling my principal, who understood, perhaps before the rest of us, that there are two kinds of debtor.”

He lifted one finger. “There is the one who is made to pay. And there is the one who is made to be *owed.* I shall not say which is more useful. A man to whom a great deal is owed will not ask what the debtor wants. He will assume that it is justice.”

I looked at Kane.

I could not help it. I looked at him, and I found him looking at the plate.

“The Table can’t refuse the name,” said Ardent. “Nor can the Keeper. I have no quarrel with you, Ms. Brandt. I propose only that the Council seat the fourth, as the Instrument permits. And that the fourth, as the Instrument says, *sit.*”

“And then?” said Dane.

He had not moved from the mat. He stood just inside the door, with the cold on him and the burnt hand against his chest, and the pack at his back, silent at the sill.

“Then the Table does as that person says. For so long as he sits.”

“As Pruett Kane says.”

“As the seat says. Mr. Kane is merely the one in it.” He was almost gentle. “It is the oldest of the forms. The man in the pewter coat in 1974 asked for it, and was refused. It has taken my principal fifty years to find a name the Table would not refuse. I should like it understood that I did not choose it for any malice. I chose it because Mr. Kane has been *kind.*”

---

“What do I do?” said Kane.

It was a very ordinary question. He asked it of nobody, and the whole room heard it. I had not known he could sound uncertain. He had been a force in this town for thirty-four years. He had owned its mortgages. He had sat on stool eight in his waistcoat like a stone in a stream. And now he stood at the end of my counter, a stooped gray man of fifty-two, in a room full of faces, and asked the floor what to do.

“You needn’t sit,” I said.

“Can I refuse?”

“I don’t know.”

“I do,” said Verna.

Her voice cracked across the diner like a dropped tray. She had risen to her feet, which she did not often do now, and she stood with both hands on the knob of her stick and her scarf slipping, and looked at no one but him.

“You can refuse the seat, Pruett Kane. A named man may decline. It’s been done. It was done in 1962, by a Halvorsen, and in 1988 by a Marlowe who preferred his orchard.” She drew breath. “But you cannot decline a *plate.* Once it’s cut, with a hand, in front of the Table, and hung, the name is on the stool whether you sit or not. And the Table will go on doing, till it’s unhung, whatever the person it’s named for says in his sleep.”

“Unhung by whom?”

“By the one who hung it.”

“Who hangs it?”

“The Keeper,” said June, from nine, in a small clear voice. “It’s always been the Keeper. It’s the one task she can’t be told to refuse. She sets the plate in its place with her own hands.” She did not look at the plate. She looked at me.

“That’s what the slip was for, Hollis. You’d have been made to hang it whether you asked for it or not. This way it has a hand on it. It has my hand. It has the whole Table’s attention, and not a counterfeit’s.”

“You *cut* it.”

“I cut what he gave me. I cut a name. I did not choose it.” She lifted her curled right hand an inch from the zinc. “I could have broken the seal in the lobby of the courthouse. I could have let him find another. But he would have found one. And it would have been a better liar than I am. At least this way, I know what it says, and so do you, and so does he.”

“Does he?” I said. I turned. “Mr. Ardent. Do you know what it’ll do?”

“I know what it is meant to do.”

“And what will it do?”

“I should like very much,” said Julian Ardent, “to find out.”

---

I did not decide it in the way one decides in a book. There was no bell. I had no plan.

I had a brass plate in my hand, with a thumbprint on the back and a man’s name on the front, and a roomful of the people I fed standing along the walls like ushers at a funeral, and a judge at the far end of the counter eating pie. I had my mother’s right hand curled and white on the zinc. I had Dane at the door.

I had the slip in my pocket, which said *It is not the name you think,* and that was true. It had been quite true.

I thought of the two blank lines in Granny’s ledger, held open for fifty years, *for the one who sits.* I had always thought she was keeping a seat from a villain.

I thought: *She was not afraid of a villain. She was afraid it would be somebody kind.*

“Mr. Kane,” I said.

“Ms. Brandt.”

“Come here, please.”

He came. He walked the length of the counter, past the stools, past eight, past ten, past the place where I had once stood with a skillet and watched him eat a boy’s breakfast in a man’s suit. He stopped in front of me. We were of a height. His eyes were bloodshot.

“I’m not going to ask you what you want,” I said. “I’m going to tell you what I know. I know you’ve eaten here fourteen mornings. I know you have been tipping twenty percent on a plate of eggs.

“I know that you were owed a great deal, and that you let it ride, not because you were weak, but because you were afraid of what would happen to the owing if it were paid.” I held out the plate. “I know you sat down on stool eight on the twenty-fifth of December and did not once ask for anything.”

“I asked for toast.”

“You asked for toast. That’s all.”

“Hollis—”

“I’d like to ask you something,” I said. “And I’d like you to answer before I decide what to do with this. It isn’t the Keeper’s question. It’s mine. What do you *want?*”

He did not say anything.

For a long time. I counted nine ticks of the Seth Thomas. Beside me, Old Betsy hissed and settled. Down the length of the counter, my mother held her breath. And Kane stood in front of me, with his white face and his folded hands, and looked at the plate, and then at the zinc, and then, slowly, as if it were the hardest thing he had ever done in his life, at the stool.

At *fourteen.*

“I want to eat,” said Pruett Kane.

“Is that all?”

“It’s the only thing I’ve wanted in thirty-four years that I was ever sure of.” His mouth twisted. “I’ve wanted a good many others. I was never sure they were mine.”

---

I hung the plate.

I did it myself. I did not wait for the form to carry me. I took the brass, with its thumbprint and its name, and I knelt, a second time, on the black-and-white linoleum in front of stool fourteen.

Ardent’s counterfeit, *STOOL 14. RESERVED,* lay loose on the zinc where I had set it down, and I did not touch it. I set my mother’s plate in its place, and put in the two screws, and turned them, one and then the other, with the little yellow screwdriver I had carried since I was fifteen.

The room made no sound.

When it was done, I stood. There were two plates in front of stool fourteen: the one with no hand and no name, lying loose, and the one with a hand and a name, screwed down. It looked, for all the world, like a small brass sign in a lawyer’s window.

“Now,” said Ardent. “He sits.”

“He may,” I said.

“He *shall.* It is in the form.”

“The form says the *Keeper* seats the fourth.” I looked at Kane. I looked at no one else. “It does not say how. It does not say I must say *yes.* My grandmother answered twelve oaths, and I answered two more, and not one of them said what I thought it said when I opened my mouth. So I’ll put it in a plain sentence.”

“Hollis,” said Verna, warningly.

“Mr. Kane,” I said. “Will you sit?”

He stood for a moment. Then he put his hat on the counter, very carefully, brim up, beside the cup of coffee. He put one hand on the back of stool fourteen, and with the other he took hold of the edge of the counter. His knuckles whitened.

“I will,” said Pruett Kane. “But allow me a moment on my feet first. It seems the sort of thing a man should come to standing.”

“As you please.”

He stood a moment longer, and nobody breathed.

He sat.

---

It was a very small thing.

I had expected a great deal. Thunder. A hole in the floor. I had braced myself for the cold of stool fourteen, the lake-cold, the middle-of-the-water cold, and instead there was only a slight settling, as of a very old house taking a breath. The stool turned an inch under his weight. A little dust rose from the cushion and hung in the light of the pie case.

Behind me, Old Betsy’s pilot went out.

It did not flicker. It did not gutter. It went out like a candle snuffed between two fingers: a short bright blue, and then not. I could not smell the cold iron that came off the grill, but I *saw* it, a pale ring in the air like a stranger’s breath in winter. The whole kitchen went dim.

And all along the counter, from one end to the other, on every stool, in every booth, in every man and woman who had ever been fed in that room, I saw the same thing happen. Their heads turned. Not much. Not as if they had been told. They turned as plants turn, an inch, a hair, toward a light that was not there. Toward the man in the waistcoat, on the stool at the end.

“Mr. Kane,” said Ardent, very softly.

“Yes.”

“The Table is yours. It will do as you say. You have only to say it.”

“Anything?”

“Within the form. It is a very old form. I should not like to promise you the moon.” The long face was quite grave. “But the Table is in your keeping, and its whole company, for so long as you sit, and it will not refuse you. I regret that I cannot tell you more. I never lie, and I do not know what you will say.”

Kane closed his eyes.

He sat there, on the cold stool, with the plate in front of him, and the whole diner leaning toward him, and the clock ticking. I saw his hand on the zinc. It was shaking, a little: the neat, clean, heavy hand of a man who had spent his life counting other people’s money. And in the silence I heard my mother, on stool nine, draw one slow breath.

She was not afraid. I saw that, in the end. She was not afraid at all. She was *waiting.* She had the look of a woman who had put a coin down on a table, a long time ago, and has been watching it spin.

“Hollis,” said Kane.

He had opened his eyes. He was looking at me. And I could not read his face at all.

“Yes, Mr. Kane?”

“I find that I do have an order.” He folded his hands. “I should like you to close the diner.”

For a moment I heard nothing at all, not even the clock.

“Close it,” said Kane, quite gently, “now. And lock the door. And everyone is to stay exactly where they are.”

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!