There was nobody in the kitchen.
I say it flatly because I looked in every place a person could be. Dane went first, low and silent, with his good hand out in front of him like a man feeling for a step. I went behind.
We went down the line: the flat-top, cooling; the pass, with its steel rack of order slips; the six-burner range; the dish pit, with its stack of cups that Tilly had been ordered to leave alone and had not. We looked under the prep table. We looked in the walk-in, in the cold corner, behind the lard. We looked in the broom closet, which has a mop and a very old calendar from a feed store.
“There’s no one,” said Dane.
“There’s a pen.”
“Is there?”
“I heard it.”
“I heard it too.” He had his head tilted, as he does on the porch. “I heard something scratching. It’s stopped.”
It had stopped. The kitchen was quiet except for the compressor and the small tick of metal cooling. There was a smell, I was told, of lemon and green ink, so faint that it might have been a thing left from an hour before. And on the swing door that leads to the pantry, set precisely at the height of my eyes, someone had tacked up a guest check with a brass thumbtack.
It had fourteen lines. Three of them were written on, in wet green.
---
*Hollis. I am sorry about your coat. It was the only one in the building that would not make a noise. I have always thought it was a kind coat.*
*I cannot be seen yet. You were right about that, in the pantry, though you did not say it: a table is a place where somebody has put something warm in front of you, and I have not been fed. I may not be known until I am.*
*Set a plate. You know the rule. A plate for the one who is not here. Eat first. Then give it away.*
There was a dash. There was a small green thumb.
I read it standing in the kitchen doorway with my hand on the frame. I read it twice. Then I turned it over, and on the back, in a different green, a faded one, as though the ink were old and the check had been in a drawer for years, was a line in Granny’s own hand, plain and square and slanting like a roof. I would have known it in the dark.
*For the one I could not feed. H. B., 1991.*
“Dane,” I said. “I need you to tell me what that means.”
“I don’t know.”
“I do,” I said. “I just don’t want to.”
---
It is a rule of the kitchen, and one of the oldest. I had not thought of it in years. You can find it in the third drawer of the office, on an index card, in Granny’s pencil: *At the end of the night set one plate more than the room. Do not say who for.*
She did it every Christmas Eve, and every Easter, and on the anniversary of Eli’s death, a single plate set at the last stool at the end of the counter, with a fork and a napkin, and a cup of coffee turned face down on its saucer. At closing it would be gone.
I had thought for thirty years that she gave it to Mrs. Whitcomb’s cat.
It was the first thing she had taught me. I had put it so far back in my head, with all the other small rules, that I had not known it was there until a stranger’s ink pulled it out. And I thought: *She was feeding somebody.* Every Christmas Eve for thirty years, with a coffee cup turned over, so that the one who came would know it was not a trick.
“Hollis,” said Judge Tate.
He had followed us to the kitchen door, with his stick and his pocket watch and Verna’s arm in his, and he had read the check over my shoulder.
“I should like,” said the Judge, “to propose a recess. It’s six o’clock. These people have been in this room since five this morning. There are ninety of them and three of them are over eighty, and one is seven. I believe we should have supper.”
---
I want to put down what that supper was, because it was the strangest of my life, and the best I have ever eaten.
Ruth took the grill back. She did it without a word, with a flourish of her wrist, like a woman who had been away to a war. She said, *Out,* to everyone in the kitchen, and when I came forward she said, *Not you, either. You’re a guest. You’ll sit.* I sat on stool nine, in front of the grill, and watched her cook.
I had not watched anyone cook, from the stool side, since I was a child.
It is a different thing from the outside. It looks like a dance. She took forty pounds of ground beef out of the walk-in in a single armful, and a sack of onions, and the Elks’ flat of duck eggs, and she did not seem to hurry; she simply moved, and things were done. The flat-top roared.
The onions went down in a long slow hiss. She had Dane on the potatoes and two of the Marlowe pack on the fryer and Maude’s husband, Emmett, white-faced and silent, on the dish pit, and Tilly on a milk crate at the pass, putting the plates out in rows with the grim exactness of a general.
“It’s meatloaf,” said Ruth, to the room. “Meatloaf and mashed potatoes and green beans from a can. It’s not Granny’s. Nobody’s going to say it is. It’s what I make when somebody has died.”
Nobody had died. But nobody said so.
---
Kane washed the cups.
I do not know who asked him. I think no one did. He had been sitting on stool eight with his coat on his knees for three hours, and at half past six he stood up, very slowly, hung the coat on the end hook, rolled his sleeves to the elbow, and went round the end of the counter into the dish pit, and Emmett Haskell looked at him in terror and moved over.
They stood side by side at the sink, the man who had come to buy my diner and the man who had sold the Table’s secrets for a feed-store note, up to their wrists in gray water. They did not speak. Kane washed. Emmett dried. Between them they put up two hundred and six cups in forty minutes.
“You hold them by the bottom,” said Kane, once, mildly, to the other man. “If you hold them by the handle, they slip.”
“Thank you,” said Emmett.
“I used to wash dishes. In Salem. At the care home.” He rinsed a saucer. “My mother liked a clean cup.”
It was the longest thing he had said since morning. Maude heard it from the pie rack, and put her hand to her mouth, and then turned very deliberately away and cut ten wedges of pie with a steady hand.
I watched them. I cannot tell you how much I wanted to smell that room.
---
They ate.
That is all I can say. Ninety people sat on stools and in the booths and on the long bench along the wall, with their coats on or off, and ate Ruth’s meatloaf off Granny’s heavy white plates, and for forty minutes it was quiet in a way I had not heard in the building since the week of the funeral.
They did not talk about the cellar. They did not talk about the Judge. A farmer from the Fenwick road told the man on his left about a heifer.
Two old women argued gently about a recipe for sour cream coffee cake. The Marlowe pack, in a row along the wall, passed a basket of rolls from hand to hand, the big hands like shovels, taking one each and passing it on. The Judge ate with a napkin tucked under his chin, and said it was the best meatloaf in the county, and Ruth said that was a lie, and he said that he was a magistrate and would be happy to prove it.
Ardent ate.
I watched for that. I had put a plate in front of him myself, because Ruth was busy and the pass was crowded, and I had taken the tray from Tilly’s hands and carried it down the counter. I could do that. A guest can carry a plate for someone else. It is the *cooking* she cannot do. I set it on stool twelve. He looked at it, and at me.
“Thank you, Miss Brandt,” said Julian Ardent.
“Eat.”
“I have.” He picked up his fork. “I should like to say it is the first meal in thirty-four years that I have eaten sitting at the same counter as someone who was not afraid of me.”
“I’m afraid of you.”
“I know,” said Ardent. “But you’ve brought me gravy.”
I do not think he was joking. I had not known he could.
---
At ten to seven Dane sat down beside me with two plates.
“I made it,” he said. “The potatoes. I’m told I’ve put in too much butter.”
“Ruth said so?”
“Ruth said I’d ruined them and ought to be proud.” He set one in front of me. “I didn’t ask you for anything yet. I’d like to say that, in case you were worried. I haven’t asked. I’m not going to ask for something you don’t want to give.”
“I’m not worried.”
“You were. For about a quarter of an hour.” He picked up a fork and turned it, tines down, in his burned hand, and I realized that he was going to feed me again, in front of everybody, and I was going to let him. “I used it for the stair. I’m sorry. I’m sorry I did, and I would again.”
“You’d *again*?”
“I’d do it if it was the end of the world, Holly.” He put a bite of potato on the fork. It was an odd, naked, serious thing to say, in a diner, over meatloaf. “I’d do it. It’s not a thing I’m proud of. I’d just rather you were angry with me than up a ladder with no one.”
I ate the potato. It had too much butter. It was salty and hot and rich, and I tasted it, all of it, and I thought that I was a woman of thirty-odd years who had cooked for a living since she was fifteen and had never once been told by a man that she was worth being afraid for.
“I’m not angry,” I said.
“You said a word.”
“I said a *different* word.” I swallowed. “It’s not for repeating in front of Tilly.”
---
Tate rapped the counter with a spoon at ten past seven.
“I should like to resume at half past eight,” he said. “Not before. I should like it understood that every person in this room will be fed first, and that no one will be asked a question by this court until his plate is empty.” He consulted the paper in his hand. “I have a note from Deputy Okonkwo, which I’d like to read into the record. It concerns the count.”
“The Deputy has been in the cellar,” said the Judge. “He reports that the tally wheel on the cellar door reads seven, and that it has not moved since twenty to five. He also reports that the dumbwaiter car is at the top of the alley bulkhead, with its door open, and that the one set of small footprints in the slush has been covered, in the last hour, by snow.”
“It’s snowing?” said Maude.
“Lightly. It began at six.”
“Then there’ll be nothing to follow,” said Dunmore.
“No, Sheriff. There will not.” Tate laid the paper down. “I draw attention to it for this reason. Somebody went up that shaft at five o’clock and did not come back, and somebody hung a coat on a hook in a hall within the hour, and somebody pinned a note to a door before six.”
“The first person was in the alley. The second was in the back hall. The third was in the kitchen, with Miss Brandt’s mother on a stool in plain sight and every other pair of hands in this building accounted for.”
“Three people,” said Dunmore.
“Or one who is able to be in three places.” The Judge folded his hands. “I find I’m not at all in favor of that.”
---
I did it at half past seven.
I will not say that I thought about it. I had a plate, because Dane had cleared it and Ruth had handed me another, and on the plate was a slice of meatloaf and a spoonful of potato and a pile of green beans. I was a guest and could not cook. I could not serve. But I could carry a plate that someone else had filled, and there was a rule on an index card in the third drawer of the office.
*At the end of the night set one plate more than the room. Do not say who for.*
I carried it to the end of the counter.
It is a very long counter. It runs forty-one feet along the window, from stool one to stool fourteen, and then it stops. Past fourteen there is the swing door and the wall. That is where the end of the counter is, in the corner by the pie rack. There is no stool there. There never has been. There is a small, plain, round-topped step stool with its legs folded, that Granny used to reach the top shelf.
I unfolded it. I set the plate in front of it. I laid a fork, and a napkin, and I poured a cup of coffee from the urn, and turned it face down on its saucer.
Nobody said anything. I think half the room had gone quiet without knowing why.
“Hollis,” said Verna, softly, from her bench by the door.
“I know.”
“That was your grandmother’s.”
“I know.”
“She never told me who it was for,” said the old woman. “In thirty years, I never asked. I thought it was a thing a person was owed.”
“I think it was,” I said.
I went back to my stool. I sat. I could not eat. I held the fork, and looked down the long counter at that one plate, in the corner by the pie rack, with its napkin folded and its cup face down, and I thought: *Come. Come, if you’re coming. I’ve done it as she did.*
---
It was Tilly who found it, at eight.
She had been told to clear. She had a gray plastic bus tub and a wet cloth, and she moved down the counter in the way of a child who is trying to be inconspicuous, stacking plates with a faint scrape, the fork on the top, one by one. She came to the end. She stopped. I saw her stand there with the tub on her hip and her head tilted, looking at the plate in front of the step stool.
“Holly,” she said.
“Yes?”
“It’s gone.”
I got up. I do not remember crossing the room. The plate was empty. It was the cleanest plate I had ever seen. Not a smear of gravy, not a crumb of potato. The fork lay across the rim with its tines down, set precisely at four o’clock. The napkin had been folded again into a triangle, and tucked under the saucer. And the coffee cup stood upright on its saucer, with its handle turned to the right, and it was still warm.
I had been looking at that corner for half an hour. So had a hundred other people. Nobody had gone near it. Nobody had gone near it, and the plate was clean.
“Nobody ate that,” said Dunmore.
“No.”
“I was watching.”
“So was I,” said Okonkwo, who had come up behind, and he did not sound like a man with a notebook.
“Somebody did,” I said. I lifted the napkin, and under it, on the white of the saucer, pressed flat, was a small folded check. The ink was wet.
---
I opened it with a hand that did not feel like mine.
*Thank you, Hollis. It was very good. It tasted like her kitchen. I have not eaten in this room since 1991 and I was afraid I had forgotten how.*
*Now I have been fed, and I may be known. But it must be done in the proper order. The cellar opens a fourth time at nine.*
*Come down. Bring one with you. Not the Alpha, who has fed you. Not the mother, who has asked you. Not the old men, not the clerk, not the sheriff, not the child.*
*Bring the one you have not fed.*
*It is the only person in this room who has never taken a plate from this Table in all the time it has stood. You will know them. They have brought their own.*
I read the last line twice.
Then I raised my head and looked down the length of my diner, over ninety fed and drowsy faces, over the heifer-man and the sour-cream women and the long sleepy pack in a row against the wall. I looked past Maude, and Emmett, and Kane at the sink with his sleeves rolled to the elbow, and the Judge with his napkin still tucked in his collar.
I looked at stool five.
He was sitting where he had been since nine in the morning, with his black bag between his shoes. He had a crossword book open on the counter, and a pencil, and a plain steel thermos at his elbow. In the eleven hours he had sat at my counter I had carried plates past him fifty times.
I had put coffee in front of him that he had turned down with a courtly little wave. He had told me, in his kind soft voice, that he had a delicate stomach, that he never ate between meals, and that he had brought his own tea.
There was no plate in front of Dr. Ness.
He looked up. He took off his half-glasses, slowly, and folded them, and laid them on the crossword.
“Ah,” he said. “I’m afraid I rather thought it would be me.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!