An alibi is a strange thing to need in your own kitchen.
“I was in the walk-in,” I said. “Wednesday. Twenty to five.”
“Doing what?” said the Judge.
“Counting eggs.” It sounded ridiculous, said aloud, in front of ninety people. “The Thursday order goes in at five. Ruth reads me the shelf and I write it on the pad. Tilly holds the flashlight because the bulb in the back corner’s gone.”
“I read the shelf,” said Ruth at once, from stool three. She had her cardigan buttoned wrong and her face was swollen with crying, but her voice was steady. “Four cases large, two medium, one flat of duck eggs for the Elks. I remember because Holly gave me the wrong total and I said so, and she said she hadn’t slept.”
“And the child?”
“I had the flashlight,” said Tilly. She had come up beside the stool and was standing very straight. “It was a green one. It had a lanyard. You said I wasn’t to put it in my mouth.”
“Did she leave?”
“No. We were in there a hundred years.” Tilly considered. “It was cold. Holly said a word.”
“Which word?”
“I’m not allowed to say.”
“Thank you,” said Tate. “I think the court will accept that she did not leave.” He sat down on stool one again, heavily, like a man who has been on his feet since dawn. “I do not need three witnesses to a woman in a freezer, Ms. Brandt. I merely find that I enjoy the process.”
---
I should have gone and sat down. I had been standing for something like twelve hours. But I had an unfamiliar feeling, in my knees and in my stomach, that if I sat on nine I would not be able to get up again, and that there was a person in the room I had not looked at since the notary’s voice came out of the speaker.
My mother was on stool eleven.
She had been there since the Judge moved the hearing. She had come to the counter with Dunmore’s hand under her elbow at half past nine, and eaten her eggs, and been told she was a guest and could not be moved, and sat.
For eight hours she had said almost nothing. She sat with her right hand in her lap, in its plain gray glove, and her left on a cup, and her hair pinned up as it had been when she was twenty, with the wide silver streak that she had never colored.
She was looking at the envelope of thumbs, which the Judge had set on the counter.
“June,” I said.
“Yes.”
“They’re yours.”
“Yes,” said my mother. “They’re mine.”
---
I do not know how to put down what she said next. I have tried it a number of ways. I have written it out and torn it up. In the end I think the only honest thing is to give it as she gave it, quietly and plainly, in a room where it was so still that I could hear the grill tick as it cooled.
“In October of 2021,” said June, “your grandmother rang me in Salem. She had not rung me in eleven years without a reason, and she did not say the reason. She said, *Come on Sunday. Bring ink.* I thought it was a joke. We’d always had a joke, she and I, about ink. When I was a girl I’d press my thumb in the blotter for the fun of it and she’d say I was learning to sign a deed.
“I came. We sat in the office. She had a stack of the fourteen-line checks and a green stamp pad, and she took my right thumb in her hand, as you would a child’s, and pressed it on a pad, and then on the corner of a check. And then another. And another. She did sixty.”
“Why?” said Maude.
“She said it was for a door that would open to a thumb.” June turned her gloved hand over on her knee. “I said, *Mother, we have no door like that.* She said, *We might.* She said there would come a day when I could not be in the room, and she should like the Table to know me anyway. She said, *There’ll be a second pair of hands to carry it. You’re not to look for them.*”
“A second pair of hands,” said Judge Tate.
“Yes.”
“Did she say whose?”
“No,” said my mother. She looked up at last, down the counter, across Dane and Kane and the empty stool between, and I saw that her eyes were wet and quite steady. “I thought she meant you, Hollis.”
---
It went through me like a draught.
“Me?”
“I thought, who else is there? You were the Keeper. You’d had her hand since you were nine. I had spent twenty years being a person who was not wanted, and I thought she’d found something for you to carry that was not for me.” She drew a breath.
“She died in the January. I put the sixty thumbs in the glove box of the sedan, with the second original of page seven, because it was the one place I was sure nobody went. I thought, *Hollis will find them when she needs to.* And in the spring the letters changed, and Strand, who had been my eyes on you, said you were doing everything your grandmother’s hand told you to do, and I thought, *She knows. She’s playing it exactly right.*”
“I never wrote a letter,” I said. “I never had a letter. I read Ardent’s tin this *afternoon.*”
“I know that now.” She shut her eyes. “I think I have known since the clock. It stopped at three-twelve and I wrote my slip and I thought, *If Hollis is the second pair of hands she’ll understand it.* And you didn’t. You came in and asked the Table what it was for, in front of everybody, and I thought, *Oh, Mother. Not her. Somebody else.*”
“Somebody who could do my signature.”
“Somebody who could do all of us,” said June.
“And you let me go on.”
“I let you go on,” said my mother, “because for four years I believed I had given my daughter a thing to carry, and that she carried it better than I could. It is not an easy thing to be wrong about.” Her mouth did something I will not describe. “I was wrong about it from the first letter. I am sorry, Hollis.”
I looked at her for a long time. I could not smell her. I did not need to. She was sitting there with her ruined hand in her lap and her small proud ruined face, and she had been wrong for four years in the one direction that could not have hurt me, because it was a direction that had thought well of me.
I did not say that it was all right. It was not. But I put out my left hand along the counter, past the pie and the saucer and Dane’s wrist, and she put her left in it, and we sat like that.
---
“Miss Brandt,” said the Judge.
“Yes, Your Honor.”
“I shall have to ask you some questions that are not kind.”
“I would expect nothing else.”
“How many of the sixty did you use?”
“Four,” said June. “The slip in the key well. A card in the Westclox parcel, because I knew Hollis would not take the word of a stranger. A note I clipped to the cashier’s check. And one for Dane, in an envelope, on the Fourth of January, that he has not yet opened.”
Dane made a small noise.
“It’s in my coat,” he said. “I didn’t want to...”
“I know you didn’t.” Her mouth moved. “It says *Be good to her.* It’s a very bad letter.”
“Then you used four,” said Tate, “and there are fifty-three in this envelope. That makes fifty-seven. Three are unaccounted for.”
“There are thumbs on the pantry slip, on the lid of the box in the oven, and on the Dec. eleventh letter in Ardent’s tin,” said Okonkwo, consulting his notebook. “I counted them this afternoon. Three, sir. Not one of them June’s own doing.”
“Then we have our three,” said the Judge, and he did not sound pleased.
---
So of sixty thumbs, four were June’s, fifty-three lay in the envelope, and three had gone out into the world on a slip, a lid and a letter, all of them, I thought, to the same hand.
“And the sedan?” said Dunmore.
“Was impounded on the fourth,” said Okonkwo. “By Lyle Gorman, as part of Sheriff Dunmore’s order. The glove box was inventoried on the fifth. I have a note.” He went to the telephone. He was on it for eight minutes with the evidence clerk at the county annex, a woman called Bev Aldana, who had gone home and was cooking something that, from the sound, was on fire.
“The glove box,” Okonkwo said. “The sedan. Item eleven.”
A tinny voice, a long pause, the clatter of a pot lid.
“Released,” said Okonkwo, when he came back. His face was thoughtful. “Released on the fifth. At ten past three. To the owner’s authorized representative. For a manila envelope and a roll of motel stamps. She signed the book.”
“Who did?”
“Ms. Brandt,” said Okonkwo.
---
I did not say anything. I had said it twice already, and there was a limit to the number of times a person could stand up in her own diner and say *I was not there.*
“Three-ten on Monday,” said Maude.
Everyone turned. She was standing by the pie rack, with her green coat on and her gloves in her hand, and she had the look she gets on the first day of a school board meeting, quiet and polite and entirely unbudging.
“On Monday afternoon at three-ten,” said Maude Haskell, “Hollis and I were on our hands and knees in the warm room with a flashlight. We counted jars from one o’clock until the tape went up at four. We did not leave the room. I have the jar-book, and I wrote the times in the margin, and I can show you the page. We had a sandwich at half past two that Ruth sent down.”
“That’s what I’d hoped you’d say,” said the Judge.
“I’m not in the habit of saying what people hope,” said Maude. “I’m saying what happened.”
“Who signed for the sedan?” said Dunmore, to Okonkwo.
“The clerk says it was Hollis Brandt. Green coat. She asked for a pen because she’d forgotten hers.” Okonkwo turned the page. “And a witness signed, as the form requires. It’s in a very fine, slanting, old-fashioned hand. The clerk remembers because the sheriff’s office hasn’t had a doctor sign anything in years.”
“A doctor,” said the Judge.
“Ness,” said Okonkwo.
---
The doctor had been on stool five all day. I think we had all forgotten him. He had come in at nine and stayed, with his black bag between his feet and his thermos on the counter and a book of crosswords. He had looked at my nosebleed at noon. He had told me, in his soft voice, that I should stay out of loud rooms.
He put his pencil in the book and shut it.
“I did sign that,” he said.
“Dr. Ness,” said Tate.
“Yes, Frederick. It was Monday. I had gone down to the annex to look at the dog bite on the night clerk, and a young woman came to the window in a hurry, and the clerk said she’d need a second signature.” He took off his half-glasses.
His eyes, without them, were pale and small and very kind. “I signed. She said she was the Brandt girl, and I thought, *Well, she looks tired.* I’ve looked at Hollis Brandt since she was in a pram. I did not look very hard.”
“Did she speak?”
“She said she couldn’t smell,” said Dr. Ness. “I remember, because I thought, *Another one.* I have had a great many cooks this past week who couldn’t smell. It’s the cold, and the stress.” He paused. “She said the word *Doctor* as though she’d been practicing it.”
“And her height?”
“Her height.” He put the glasses back on. “I did think she was wearing flat shoes. She was shorter than I had expected, Frederick. An inch, perhaps. Two. I put it down to the hurry.” He looked at me with real distress. “My dear. I am so sorry. I should have known you.”
“It’s all right,” I said.
“It is not all right,” said Dr. Ness. “But it is what happened.”
I was sorry for him. I will say that. I was sorrier than I could say, in that half-second. And at the same time, from a place in my skull as cold and quiet as the cellar, a different thought stood up, clear as a bell, and said: *She was shorter. Two inches. She wore flat shoes. And he has sat at your counter since nine, through all the talk of the sedan, and said nothing until his own name was read out.*
I did not say it. I put it away.
---
It was Dane who found the coat.
I am not sure why he thought of it. I think it came to him in the way that these things come to a man who smells for a living, from some thread at the back of his mind that had been tugging all afternoon. He had been standing by the swing door, with the bandage black and his jaw set, saying nothing. He turned and pushed it open with the flat of his good hand.
“Holly,” he said. “Where’s your coat?”
“On the hook. By the back door.”
“Is it?”
“It’s where it’s always...” I stopped.
I had gone in at four that morning in the dark. I had hung it on the third hook from the left, between Ruth’s brown one and Tilly’s red. I had not touched it since. I had not thought of it once all day. It had hung there, I thought, quietly, through the whole of the hearing, as a coat does.
I went through the kitchen at a half-run, with Dane at my back and the Judge’s *Ms. Brandt* following like a thread, and I came to the back hall.
It was on the hook.
It was a long green wool coat with a belt, an old one, that I had bought at a church sale in Tamarack, and I knew every thread of it. It hung with its sleeves folded, and its collar up, as I always leave it.
But it was wet.
I put my hand on it. The hem was dark with slush, a good six inches up, and the lining had that damp and faintly warm feel that cloth has when it has been worn indoors from the cold and hung up by someone in a hurry. There were drops on the floor under it. There was a smear on the wall where the sleeve had brushed.
“It was dry at four,” I said.
“I know,” said Dane. He had not touched it. He had put his face down close to the collar, and his eyes were shut. “I said, earlier, *not her coat.* I was wrong.” His voice was very low. “It’s been out in the alley, Hollis. It was worn through that bulkhead an hour ago. And whoever wore it hung it back on this hook, in this hall, with the whole of this building sitting forty feet away, eating pie.”
“How?”
“I don’t know.” He opened his eyes. “I can smell shoe polish, and violets, and wet wool. And under those a thing I cannot place at all. It’s very faint. I would say it is a *wolf.*”
---
I put my hand in the right pocket. It was where I keep a pencil. There was a pencil.
In the left there was a slip of paper, folded in four, and it was not a guest check. It was a small square receipt, yellow and torn at one edge where it had come out of a carbon pad. It said *TAMARACK VALLEY SAVINGS: NOTARY FEE.* It had a date, 1/7, a time, 4:40 p.m., and a sum, $7.00. In the space for *Received from* somebody had written, in a small neat forward-leaning hand that crossed no sevens, the words *H. M. Brandt.*
Under it, in green, a thumbprint.
And under that, as though she had added it in a hurry, on the lower margin, in four words that were smaller and closer than the rest:
*She is in the kitchen.*
I read it three times. Then I looked up. I looked down the long, bright, empty back hall, with its mop and its bucket and its door to the alley and its door to the pantry, and the open gap of the swing door at the end, through which I could see the backs of ninety people at my counter, eating pie.
Nobody was behind me. Nobody was in front.
But somewhere in the kitchen, in the clean warm air above the flat-top, something was ticking that was not the register clock, and was not the Seth Thomas, and was not the wall.
It was the sound of a pen, writing.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!