At 7:20 on Thursday morning, Hattie Bray takes a jurat from Margaret Aldous at the Pemberton post office counter, with her new seal, her old glasses and a face so rigid with joy that it could be mistaken for grief.
“Raise your right hand,” Hattie says. “Not that one. Margaret, you’ve been to a courthouse.”
“I’ve been to a board meeting,” says Margaret. “It’s not the same hand.”
It is not a long statement. Ines wrote it at midnight and Margaret rewrote it at six, with a pen, in her kitchen, and Ines, to her credit, let her. It says that Margaret Aldous signed a two-page affidavit on the twenty-ninth of October, that she did not sign, read or authorize a third page, and that the paragraph on that page, concerning any beneficial interest of the Company in the unclaimed property, was not in her copy of what she swore.
It says all of it in forty-one lines, in the plain Maine voice of a woman who has been the chairman of something for eleven years and would like to be done.
“Do you swear,” Hattie says, “that this is true, so help you God?”
“I do.”
Hattie stamps. She stamps with a smack. For a moment the little room is quiet, apart from the radiator and the ferry horn, and I notice that Margaret’s hand, which was perfectly steady on the Bible, has gone to the counter and is holding it.
“I’d like it noted,” she says, “that I haven’t changed my mind about the block.”
“Noted,” says Ines.
“I’m still selling. To whomever the right of first refusal permits.” She picks up her gloves. “I’m helping you because someone pasted a paragraph into a paper with my name on it. That’s a different thing from being on your side.”
“Understood,” I say.
“You’ve got your grandmother’s way of saying it.” Margaret looks at me for a moment too long. “It’s very annoying.”
She leaves. At the door she nearly collides with Charles, who has been standing on the step in the cold, without a coat, for what Mr. Bray later tells me was forty minutes. They look at one another. Neither speaks. And then Margaret, in a voice I wouldn’t have thought she owned, says, “Charlie,” and walks around him to her car.
He does not follow. He stands very still on the post office step, his white head bare, and I understand that he has just been spoken to, for the first time in sixteen years, by the one other person who was in the corridor in 2009.
---
At 11:34 the Office of the Treasurer has the same ficus and, today, no Dalton Pruitt, which makes the waiting room feel like a church after the sermon.
Gail Pell takes us into a conference room with a long table. She is a small precise woman in a gray blazer, with reading glasses on a chain, and she has the look of someone who would be a pleasure to be audited by. She has brought the file herself, in a red folder, and she sets it in front of us without a word.
Next to Ines sits a woman I haven’t met. Dr. Priya Nand is a document examiner from Boston, forty, with cropped hair, an enormous canvas bag and a loupe on a lanyard like a medal. Ines retained her yesterday at four in the afternoon. She drove up through the night, and she’s holding a cup of Pell’s coffee as if it were a controlled substance.
“I’d like to be clear that this is a preliminary look,” Dr. Nand says. “I’m not rendering an opinion. I’m looking at paper.”
“Look,” says Pell.
There are two documents in the red folder. The first is the original affidavit, filed on the twenty-ninth of October: two pages, stapled once at the upper left corner, with a received stamp and Margaret’s signature on page two. The second is the supplemental version, filed Thursday last, the day Mr. Pruitt argued forgery: three pages: the same two pages with a third added behind them. It has been stapled twice.
Dr. Nand lays them side by side under a lamp and does not speak for four minutes. I count. The radiator ticks.
“Here,” she says at last.
She turns the original over and lifts it by one corner. At the upper left, a pair of small holes in the paper, a quarter-inch apart, with a faint rust ring around each. She turns the supplemental version over. At the same corner, the same pair of holes. And a second pair, a centimeter lower, still sharp, the paper around them white.
“The pages of the original have been pulled from their staple and re-stapled,” she says. “You can see it. The first set of holes is old. The second set is a week old at most. Somebody pulled pages one and two from the filed copy, set a new page behind them, and bound all three again. In a hurry. They’ve used a heavier stapler.”
“A heavier stapler,” says Pell, mildly.
“A different instrument. The leg length’s different. And look at the third page.” She slides it from under the others. “It’s a slightly brighter stock. Ninety-two bright. Pages one and two are an eighty-eight. They were printed on a laser printer and this was, I’d guess, output from a different device. The signature page, page two, hasn’t been altered. It’s Ms. Aldous’s real signature. It’s the pages around it that moved.”
“And this?” says Ines, pointing to a thin line of type along the top margin of the third page.
Dr. Nand tilts the lamp. In very small gray type, at the edge, the kind of line a fax machine prints without being asked, are a sender’s name and a time.
FROM: PRUITT, D. 11/13 08:12 AM PG 3 OF 3.
“That’s a fax header,” says Dr. Nand. “A transmission line. Page three was sent by fax, from the office of Mr. Pruitt, at twelve minutes past eight on the morning of the thirteenth. If you look at the received stamp on this version, it’s 8:20.”
“Eight twenty,” I say.
“A claim cannot be supplemented by a paragraph that didn’t exist when the affidavit was sworn,” says Ines. She is speaking very slowly. “It was sworn on the twenty-ninth. Page three came by fax two weeks later. It’s not that Mr. Pruitt paraphrased his client. He wrote a paragraph his client never read and pasted it into a sworn document.”
Gail Pell has taken off her glasses. She has been taking notes in a tiny hand, and she stops, and puts the pen down at a perfect right angle to the pad.
“I was concerned last Thursday that the matter had been approached too quickly,” she says. “I noted it, for the file. I’d like to say, on the record, that I have never in nineteen years been handed a document of this kind and been pleased about the cleanliness of the staples.” She folds the glasses.
“This is not for me to decide. The hearing officer will decide whether to take evidence on it. If it’s what it appears to be, it also isn’t a civil matter. I’ll be sending a note to the Attorney General’s office, with copies of the pages, and with Dr. Nand’s name.”
“Is that a threat to Mr. Pruitt?” I ask.
“It’s a reference,” says Pell. “A threat has to be more interesting.”
---
At 3:02, in the passenger seat of Ines’s rental car on the road to the ferry, Ines tells me to put on my seat belt, close my eyes and say who Greg is.
“I’m sorry?”
“The hearing officer will ask you under oath. Mr. Pruitt’s lawyer, or Mr. Pruitt’s replacement, will ask it after her. Someone will ask it in a good light and a bad one, and it won’t be Cass Dunleavy’s kind question.” She doesn’t take her eyes off the road. “Who is Greg?”
“He’s not here.”
“That’s not an answer.”
“Greg Binder was an invention,” I say. “I hired a man who was an actor. I told my family and my town the man was my boyfriend, and then I let it ride for a weekend, and then for a longer one. I lied to a hundred people who loved me, for reasons that seemed sound at the time, and which I’d now describe as fear. His name was never Greg. It was Beckett’s idea to stop being Greg, and mine to start.”
“That’s a speech.”
“Is it wrong?”
“It’s not wrong. It’s beautiful.” Ines indicates left. “It’s two hundred words long, and it begins with ‘I’ and ends with a story. Cross-examination doesn’t take speeches. It takes yes and no. They’ll say you’ve admitted deceiving this island. They’ll say the man financing the claimants is the man you deceived with. They’ll say you’re a party with an interest.”
“I am a party with an interest.”
“Say that.”
“I’m a party with an interest,” I say. “I’m in love with him.”
I hadn’t planned on that. The words sit between us in the car like a third passenger. Ines does not move her head, but I’d swear her mouth gives way by a degree.
“That, Ms. Delgado,” she says, “is a very good answer. Say it first, in one sentence, before they can use it.”
“It would’ve been nice if you’d warned me you were going to make me say it.”
“I find that people only say true things when they’re tricked into it.” She changes lanes. “Which is an unattractive trait in a lawyer, and I’ve built a career on it. Again. Who is Greg?”
I say it nine times before the ferry. By the ninth, I’ve stopped being embarrassed, and started being accurate, which is, I suspect, the point.
---
At 4:25, on the ferry landing bench with the wind taking the corners of my notes, I give Tomás the news about Charles’s travel profile, and he takes it the way he takes everything, which is to say he opens a laptop.
“Holdings still pays for his phone,” he says after a minute. “And his email. And the travel portal, and the car service in Portland. He’s the company’s removed president and he’s on every system like a ghost who pays rent.”
“Dalton reads the itineraries.”
“Dalton’s office is the administrator. It’s in the portal’s footer.” Tomás scrolls. “Marnie, if I’m reading this right, that profile has been forwarding a copy of every booking to the same address since April. Not Dalton’s own. A shared inbox called special-projects.”
“What else goes to it?”
“Everything with Charles’s name on it. Prescriptions at the pharmacy he charged to the company card. A cello repair in Portland in August. The ticket on the Eleanor W.” He stops. “He’s been followed for seven months by a mailbox.”
“Tell Charles,” I say. “Not so he changes it. So he decides.”
“Decides what?”
“Whether he wants it to keep going while we find out who else reads it.” I think of Margaret’s dark window. “Somebody wrote a letter to Providence that was accurate about a note on my own desk. I’d like to know how many other doors have a slot in them.”
Tomás closes the lid very gently. “I’ll tell him tonight. He’ll want to take it out at the root.” He looks at the water. “And then I’ll ask him to leave it.”
“You’re getting good at this.”
“I’m learning what it costs to ask,” says Tomás, “from a man who’s asking me to ask him.”
---
At 6:12 the Courier’s newsroom calls the Mercantile’s landline, because Cass Dunleavy still doesn’t have my cell number and is, apparently, too proud to ask Tomás.
“Marnie,” she says. “I’m calling to tell you before it runs.”
“Before what runs?”
“A story. Tomorrow, ten a.m. online. The headline’s Wedding Planner’s Firm Kept Afloat by Billionaire Boyfriend as Island Fund Fight Nears Hearing. It has your promissory note. It has the Providence letter. It has a quote from a Fenwick & Pike attorney who calls it ‘a conflict I’d have expected to see disclosed.’”
“Where did you get the note?”
“It was in an email to me at 4:40 this afternoon. I don’t give up a source.” There’s a pause. “But I’ll say it’s a better-typed email than the usual.”
“Dalton.”
“I didn’t say that.” Another pause, a smaller one. “Marnie, I’ve run the numbers. The note’s real and it’s 4 percent, and there’s an Ines clause that’s more generous than any bank I’ve ever dealt with. It isn’t a scandal. It would look like one at ten o’clock on a Friday morning to a person who stopped at the headline.”
“What are you asking me?”
“I’m asking if you want to put it in your own words. Before ten.” Cass clears her throat. “That’s the whole offer. I don’t do it for everyone.”
I look at the Mercantile’s cash register, at Tomás at his laptop, at Rosa in the kitchen doorway with her spoon, listening, as she has been listening to everything for sixty years.
“Yes,” I say. “I’ll tell you. On the record. All of it. The note, the twelve contracts, Greg, the date I started loving him and the date I realized. If you’d like to print the part about Providence, print it.”
“You’d like me to print that you love him?”
“No. I’d like you to print that I’d say it under oath.” I press my palm flat on the counter. “I’m done being the person who finds out what’s in the newspaper.”
“I’ll take the interview at 7:30,” says Cass. “Don’t make me regret it.”
“You won’t.”
“Everybody says that,” says Cass Dunleavy. “In my experience it’s what a person says right before I do.”
---
At 11:04 that night, Beckett Whitfield sits on the third step of the Mercantile porch in a coat I haven’t seen before, with a laptop closed on his knee and the look of a man who has been rehearsing a sentence for hours.
“I read the story,” he says. “The advance one. Cass sent it to Ines. It’s accurate. I wish it weren’t.”
“I’m going to say it in my own words in the morning.”
“You don’t have to.”
“I know. That’s why.” I sit next to him. It is, I think, the first time we’ve touched in three days. His shoulder leans, and mine accepts it. “Tell me about the money.”
“Not tonight.”
“Beckett.”
“It’s fine. It’s a pledge schedule.” He opens one hand. “It’s thirty-eight point six. I have twenty-nine point two available between the trust, the freight line’s receivables and what I can lien against my house in Boston, which as you know isn’t mine to lien alone. Dennis Orr’s bank is bridging the remaining nine point four. He’s confirmed. I’m to sign at nine tomorrow morning.”
“Then why do you look like that?”
“Like what?”
“Like you’ve sat on a tack.”
He laughs and doesn’t laugh. “Because I’ve been told for four days that I’m a fool, a savior and a man with a conflict. I’ve been told it by people who like me. And I find that the only person who hasn’t said any of it to my face tonight is the one I’d most like to hear it from.”
I put my hand on the back of his neck. I don’t plan to. It is warm, and a little damp from the cold.
“You’re a fool,” I say. “And a savior, and you have a conflict. And you asked. I’d like it written on a plaque. In the Mercantile. Next to the toilet.”
“The staff toilet.”
“The public toilet. I want visibility.”
He leans in. His forehead rests on mine, briefly, the way a man rests it on a door he’s decided not to knock on tonight. “I want to keep you out of the story,” he says. “I’d like to be able to promise that.”
“You can’t.”
“No.”
“Then say the other thing.”
“I’ll ask first,” says Beckett, softly. “Every time. I’d like that on the plaque as well.”
His phone buzzes against his knee. It buzzes again. He says “Sorry,” automatically, and then, because he’s learned something this week, he turns it over and shows me the screen. It says DENNIS ORR, and the clock on the screen says 11:10.
The preview beneath the name says: Beckett. I need you to call me back right now. The bank has pulled the commitment.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!