The Pemberton Mercantile opens at 7:00 on weekdays, and by 7:55 on the Monday after the Grange vote it has sold eleven coffees, a bag of rock salt, and a box of the extra-long matches Mrs. Hendry buys when she is worried.
Hattie Bray runs the register. She is in her middle seventies, a notary with a renewed commission and an ironed cardigan, and since the night we found out what her grandnephew did with Charles’s old laptop she has been quiet in a way that fills a room.
She hands me my coffee without charging for it. I put the dollar on the counter. She pushes it back. I put it down again. We do this twice, and then she lets it lie there, and neither of us says what it’s for.
Tomas is at the end of the counter with a blueberry muffin the size of a fist and the look of a man who has been told he’s a witness and is trying to behave like furniture.
“Don’t talk,” I say.
“I’m not talking.”
“Don’t make faces.”
“This is my face,” says my cousin, with his mouth full.
At 7:59 the bell over the door rings, and a woman in a green wool coat comes in out of the cold.
---
I’d built her in my head into someone tall. She is five foot four. She has dark hair going gray in a single stripe at the left temple, which she hasn’t colored, and a long tired face, and she holds her gloves in one hand and a paper folder in the other, in a way that tells me she’s rehearsed the whole walk from the ferry and forgotten all of it in the doorway.
“Ms. Delgado.”
“Ms. Lomax.”
“Thea.” She looks at Tomas. “Is that your witness?”
“I’m Tomas,” says my cousin, standing up and brushing crumbs off his chest. “I’m her cousin. I’m also, as of this morning, a very large piece of furniture. You can talk to me like I’m a lamp.”
Something happens at the corner of Thea Lomax’s mouth, and is gone. She lets Hattie pour her a coffee, pays for it, and takes the stool across the end of the counter from mine, with the folder between us, closed, her hand flat on top of it like a person keeping down a lid.
“I’ve been on the island since Saturday night,” she says. “I rented a room at the Pemberton Arms under my own name. I want that known. I wasn’t hiding.”
“You were in a green coat in a hotel at the Jetport on Friday.”
“I was in a green coat at the Jetport Residence Inn from Wednesday to Friday at noon.” She says it to her hands. “I checked out at twelve. I left a keycard at the desk for a colleague who asked me for one. I didn’t ask why.”
“Kevin Dunne.”
“Yes.”
“And you didn’t ask.”
“I didn’t ask,” says Thea, “because for about eighteen months I’ve been very good at not asking. It’s the skill I’m best at. I’m told it’s a gift.”
---
I ask her the thing I asked Simone. I do it plainly, because I’ve learned that if I wait for the right moment, it turns into a wrong one.
“What’s your price?”
She actually flinches, and sits back.
“I’m sorry,” I say. “I didn’t phrase it kindly. I just find it’s better if I say it aloud. Somebody I trust told me to. What do you want in exchange for what you’re about to tell me?”
“Nothing.”
“Nobody wants nothing.”
“Fine.” She laughs without any humor. “I want my name kept off a forgery, which I had no part in and can prove. I want not to be named as the person who booked the room. I want to be able to say I came here first and not with a lawyer, because if I’d had a lawyer I’d have been told to stay home. And I want,” she says, and stops.
The coffee machine hisses. Hattie, at the register, has put down her pencil.
“I want to not be the person in the car,” says Thea Lomax. “That’s all. There are two kinds of people in this, and one of them sits in a car outside a house with a clipboard and a smile and a phone call to make.
I’ve been that one. Yesterday I called a woman in Lewiston and offered her sixty thousand dollars for her dead mother’s house, and she cried, and I said *take your time,* and I hung up and sat in my rental and couldn’t turn the key.”
“Linda.”
“I didn’t give you her name.”
“She’s a friend.”
Thea nods, slowly, as though that was what she’d expected, and had hoped, perhaps, to be wrong about. “Then I’d like you to have this,” she says, and opens the folder.
---
It’s a single sheet, printed in a small gray font, with nine rows.
LOT. HOLDER. OFFER. SIGNED. At the top, in the corner, in letters so small I have to tilt the page: *Kittiwake Harbor Homes LLC. Landings Transition Credit.*
“The credit is the offer,” she says. “Fifty-two thousand on average. It’s called a credit because it sounds like a refund. The people get cash for the house and the assignment of the lease. Kittiwake becomes the lessee on the ground, and the owner of the building, and a member of the Leaseholders’ Association with a vote.” She taps the sheet. “One vote per household. Nine households signed between last Monday and yesterday. Thirty-eight is the tenth, if she takes it.”
“Why?”
“Why what?”
“Why would a company that wants the ground buy houses? You’d have the ground *and* the roof, and nobody on it.”
“You’d have a vote.” She sits back, and for the first time she looks at me directly, with eyes that are dark and exact. “I wrote the first version of this on a whiteboard in Boston. The Association’s bylaws were amended in 2019 by your uncle.
I have a copy. To enter into a purchase of the ground, the Association needs two-thirds of the households. Forty-one of sixty-one. If twenty-one households vote no, the Association can’t buy the ground, and the Trust is left to sell it to whoever is paying.”
I do the sum before she finishes. Tomas does it faster, and I hear him put down the muffin.
“Twenty-one,” I say.
“Nine are signed.” She holds up the page. “Twelve more, and a land trust is dead before it’s born. They don’t need to buy the whole island. They need a third of the leaseholders, as a bloc, voting no.”
“And a third of the leaseholders is all Halvorsen has to buy.”
“Kittiwake rents nothing. Kittiwake owns the houses and lets the families stay on, rent-free, for a year, as a courtesy.” She shuts her eyes briefly. “It’s called a *transition period.* I wrote the term. I’ve never liked it.”
---
I wish I could say I took the news calmly. I took it the way I take most things, which is to say I reached for a pen and found I was holding a paper cup.
“There’s one more thing,” says Thea. “And I’d like to get through it before you’re angry, because afterward you won’t hear it.”
“Go on.”
“Delphine Rourke authorized me on Thursday to make you an offer. I wasn’t to make it unless you asked what Halvorsen would pay for peace. You didn’t ask, but I’m going to say it anyway, because I think you ought to know the size of it, so that when you say no you say no to the real number.”
She slides a second page across, a plain white sheet with a single line typed on it. “Delgado & Company, Events, retained as the Pemberton Island Transition Partner for twenty-four months. Two hundred and forty thousand dollars a year. You’d run community liaison. You’d have an office.
Your cousin could have the kayak concession, rent-free. Your grandmother would have a lease, I’m told, in writing, for life.”
I don’t look at it. I look at Tomas.
He has gone very still. He’s wearing the expression he wore at nine, the day his mother told him the dog had gone to live on a farm. He knows what two hundred and forty thousand dollars means to a person with a Friday payroll. He is the one I owe eight thousand nine hundred.
“Tomas,” I say. “Before I say a word. It’s two hundred and forty thousand a year for two years. It’d cover your salary, and the hole, and everything I owe Beckett, and I’d be able to hire someone. It’d make the company safe. I want you to hear that I thought about it. For about four seconds, I wanted it very much.”
“Okay,” says Tomas.
“I’m going to say no.”
“I know.” His voice is thick. “I know you are. I’m saying okay because you told me first. I’d rather you told me you wanted it and said no than said no like it was nothing.” He wipes his hands on his jeans. “You know what I’d do if you said yes?”
“What?”
“I’d be mad for about a week. And then I’d work for you anyway.” He grins, wetly. “That’s the kind of idiot you’ve got.”
I turn back to Thea Lomax. I push the page across the counter, face down, with one finger, exactly as I’d return a plate.
“No,” I say. “Thank you for telling me the number.”
“I thought you might.”
“Did Rourke?”
“Ms. Rourke thought it was a lovely offer. She believes everyone has a number.” Thea picks up the page, folds it once, twice, and puts it in her coat. “She’s been right about nine households. I wouldn’t tell her I think she’s wrong about you. It isn’t kind to disappoint her in the first week.”
---
My phone buzzes on the counter, at 9:12. It’s a photograph, taken at an angle, of a white counter and a blue rubber stamp.
*RECORDED. Knox County Registry of Deeds. Book 14872, Page 203. 9:12 a.m. Notice fixing term, Pemberton Island Trust to Lessees, 25 years from Jan 1, with minutes of Dec 7 attached. Ms. Tibbetts says it’s the first notice of its kind since 1981 and she’d like to frame the receipt. $38. B.*
I show it to Tomas. He reads it twice, silently, with his lips, and he’s still holding the phone when Thea Lomax stands up.
“Is that what I think it is?” she says.
“It’s a term. For sixty-one families. It was filed at 9:12 this morning, with minutes, in the open.”
Her face does something I can’t read. “Good,” she says, and means it. “It won’t stop the nine. It’ll stop a termination.” She buttons the green coat. “Ms. Delgado, I’d like to say one more thing, and then I’m going to take the next boat off the island and sit in a car in Tern Harbor until I’ve decided whether to quit.”
“All right.”
“Friday at five,” says Thea. “That’s the closing. All nine at once, at the Knox County title office in Rockland, so that they all happen on the same afternoon and nobody has time to say anything to the others. There’s a tenth on the schedule, an eleventh, a twelfth. The ones I’ve called this weekend who haven’t said yes yet. I wrote the call list. It’s at the bottom of the page.”
I turn the sheet over. Below the nine rows, in smaller type, there are twelve more.
“Your grandmother is not on it,” says Thea. “I’d have refused. I think Rourke knew I’d refuse. Nobody else is spared.”
She goes out. The bell rings after her. Hattie Bray, behind the register, picks up her pencil, puts it down again, and says, to nobody, “Well. That was a long minute.”
---
I find Rafa on the Grange steps at 10:05, splitting kindling that nobody needs with a hatchet that has been in his family since the Coolidge administration.
He listens to the whole thing without looking up. He sets a log on the stump, splits it, sets the halves aside, and picks up another. When I get to the number, twenty-one, the hatchet stops in the air.
“Two-thirds,” he says.
“You wrote it.”
“I wrote it in 2019. After a man from Connecticut came with a briefcase and a good voice and wanted to buy four houses on Ledge Road for a retreat.” He lowers the hatchet. “I thought, *a man could buy four, then eight, then wake up one morning and own the vote.* So I said, to buy the ground, two-thirds.
Nobody ever argued. It seemed a safe thing to ask for.” He looks at his hands. “I built the wall, Marnie. I built it to keep strangers out. I didn’t think about what would happen if somebody started buying the bricks.”
“Nobody thought of it.”
“The Halvorsen girl thought of it,” he says, meaning Thea, with no heat at all. “A person who knows how a wall is built is the person you want standing next to it with a crowbar.”
“Do you want to stop them?”
“Of course I want to stop them.” He puts the hatchet in the stump. “I don’t know how. A man’s house is his house. I can’t tell Ada Courtney she can’t sell, when she’s alone, and her husband’s a box on the shelf, and somebody’s offering her fifty thousand dollars to go live near her daughter.”
“Then we don’t tell anyone they can’t.”
“Then what?”
“We find out why every one of them said yes. And we ask what it would take for them to say it a different way.”
He looks at me for a long moment, with his mother’s eyes under a Whitfield-hating brow. Then he picks up the hatchet and splits a log so cleanly that both halves fall away in the same instant, one on each side of the stump.
“Mira,” says my uncle. “That’s what your grandmother does. She finds out why, and then she cooks.”
“I can’t cook.”
“No,” says Rafa. “You can count. It’s the same trade.”
---
By eleven, the sheet is pinned to the corkboard in the Grange kitchen, between a flyer for a 2019 bake sale and a notice about the stove.
Mrs. Hendry has brought the ledger. It’s an actual ledger, bound in green cloth, a record of the Pemberton Leaseholders’ Association that she has kept in a spidery, beautiful hand for twenty-one years, and it contains the lot number, the names, and the rent paid, for every household on the island.
“Four,” she reads off the sheet. “Ada Courtney. She sits in the next row at church. She lost her husband in March.” She puts a pencil mark beside it. “Nine. The Faucher brothers. Twelve. Mrs. Doyle.”
“Nineteen,” I read. “Twenty-seven. Thirty-one.”
“Lyle’s cousin,” says Mrs. Hendry. “Forty. The Perrys. Fifty-two.”
“That’s Mr. Bray’s boat shed.” I look at the corner of the page. “The one he rents to the kayak people.”
“It was Mr. Bray’s.” She makes a mark. “It’s been Tomas’s since June. He pays Mr. Bray eight hundred a month, and he’s never got round to taking the assignment.”
At the end of the counter, standing with his back to the stove, Tomas goes red from the collar up. “I didn’t sign,” he says. “I want that said.”
“Nobody’s saying you did, dear.”
“Mr. Bray sold the boat shed to somebody, though, didn’t he? Last week. He said he had a *buyer.*” His voice wobbles. “He said he was tired, Marnie. He’s eighty-one. He was going to give me the keys and I said let me think, and I thought for six months. It’s my fault.”
“It isn’t.”
“It’s not nobody’s fault,” says Tomas. “I was *thinking.*”
“Tomas.” I put a hand on his arm. “It’s lot fifty-two. It’s not the only lot. We’re going to find out who sold and why, and we’re going to do it without anybody feeling like a thief. Give me a pencil.”
Mrs. Hendry has been running her pencil down the margin of the ledger while we talked, and now she clears her throat.
“I notice something,” she says. “I want it on the table before it’s lost. Of the eight I’ve read so far, all eight are over sixty-five. Four of them have a medical debt I know about, because I was in the room when their husbands or wives died.
None of them was approached by a stranger. They were approached by a nice woman who telephoned and said *take your time.*” She taps the ledger. “Nobody here is a fool. Somebody studied us, and then called when we were tired.”
“That’s the whole business model,” I say.
“Then I don’t like the business.” She turns the page. “Where was I? Yes.”
I go back to the sheet, and Mrs. Hendry reads on, in her clear flat voice, with the ledger in her hands.
“Twenty-three,” she says. “Quarry Lane. The little gray cabin with the green door.”
I stop. I’d been writing. The pencil makes a long gray line across the corner of the sheet.
“Who’s on twenty-three?” says Tomas.
Mrs. Hendry looks at the ledger. She looks at the sheet. She looks, with great gentleness, at me.
“Ortiz,” she says. “Carmen M. Ortiz, of Worcester, Massachusetts. Bought in 1998, the year she was married. Her signature is the one in the box, Marnie. She signed on Friday.”
Behind me, I hear my cousin sit down on the floor of the kitchen. He doesn’t fall. He folds, slowly, with his back against the stove, the way a tent comes down when the poles are taken out.
“That’s my mom,” says Tomas.


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!