The Fenwick & Pike Winter Gala is the one job on my calendar that I have not been able to cancel, and I have not wanted to.
It’s Tuesday the twenty-third of December, 6:10 p.m., the lobby of a restored shoe factory in Portland that now rents out its brick for weddings and mergers. I have two hundred and forty guests arriving in fifty minutes, a string quartet that has lost its violist, and a head caterer named Lucho who is weeping quietly over a tray of crab cakes that the walk-in freezer decided to turn into soup.
“I can make forty more,” says Lucho. “In twenty minutes. If nobody talks to me.”
“Nobody will talk to you.”
“And if the client talks to me?”
“I’ll stand in front of you,” I say, and I do, because the client has just come through the door, in a long black coat and pearls, and she is looking straight at me.
---
Eloise Fenwick is seventy-one and has run a law firm in Maine for forty-four years without once, to my knowledge, being surprised. She has hair the color of steel wool and a voice that makes junior associates check their ties.
“Ms. Delgado,” she says.
“Mrs. Fenwick.”
“I read the Courier.” She unbuttons the coat. “I read the part where you said, under oath, that you invented a boyfriend. I read the part where you said you had a real one. I want to say that I’ve been waiting eleven years for a vendor to tell me the truth before I had to ask.”
“I told you on the fifteenth,” I say. “By phone, from the car, an hour before it posted. I thought you’d want to hear it first.”
“I did.” She hands me the coat without looking at it. “That’s why I’m here. Three other vendors this month have called me to say how *distressed* they were about their own errors, and every one of them was distressed about something I’d already found out. You were the only one who called with the thing I didn’t know.” She looks around the lobby, at the quartet, at the soup. “Is that crab?”
“It was.”
“Good. I hate crab. Serve the lamb and tell the quartet to play slower than they want to. Is he coming?”
“Who?”
“The boyfriend,” says Eloise Fenwick. “I should like to see what a headline looks like in person.”
---
He comes at 8:15, in a dark suit and a tie I’ve never seen, and he stands at the back of the room with a glass of seltzer, trying to be a piece of furniture.
It does not work. The quartet, down to three players, has chosen exactly that minute to play something slow and tender, and the effect is of a man being scored. He is six-foot-three and rumpled in the particular way that expensive wool becomes after a long day. Every head in the room turns to look, and then turns away, as though it’s been caught. A woman in sequins whispers something. A man in a bow tie takes a very obvious photograph with his phone.
I cross the floor at 8:20 with a clipboard in one hand and a tray of crab cakes in the other, because there is nothing in the world I will not carry across a room to prove to myself I’m working.
“You’re doing the thing,” I say quietly.
“Which?”
“Standing like a man who’s afraid he’ll be asked to speak.”
“I am a man who’s afraid he’ll be asked to speak.” He takes a crab cake, eats it, and closes his eyes briefly. “Marnie. May I tell you something and not have it count as a speech?”
“Please.”
“I’m proud of you,” says Beckett, in a voice so low I have to lean in, “in a way that has no strategic value whatsoever.”
I look at the tray for a long time. “That’s the nicest thing anyone’s said to me in front of a quartet,” I say, and go back to work, because the soup is on fire.
---
The last guest leaves at 10:35. Lucho is asleep on a flour sack in the kitchen with his apron over his face, the quartet’s cellist is eating the last crab cake out of the bin with great dignity, and Eloise Fenwick is signing something on the back of a menu with a pen she took out of her own hair.
“Same date next year,” she says. “Same room, same vendor. The lamb was acceptable.”
“Mrs. Fenwick, you don’t have to—”
“I know what I don’t have to do. I’ve been practicing it for forty-four years.” She slides the menu across. “One condition. Whatever happens in January, you telephone me before the newspaper does.”
“I’ll telephone you second,” I say. “My cousin Tomas is first. I promised.”
“Good answer,” says Eloise Fenwick, and puts her coat on without looking at it, the way she took it off.
---
Christmas Eve is a Wednesday, and Charles Whitfield spends all of it at Rosa’s kitchen table, with a fountain pen and sixty-one sheets of cream paper, writing.
He started at six in the morning. I know because I came by at six-thirty with a casserole and found him in the borrowed cardigan, with a pot of coffee and a pair of reading glasses balanced low on his nose, writing the first line. Beside him sits a ledger open to the register: *Knox County Registry of Deeds, Book 14872, Page 203.*
“Ambrose wrote Christmas letters every year,” he says, without looking up. “Sixty-one households. They’re the reason you’re all in this mess.”
“I know.”
“Each one said, in a good hand, *Merry Christmas. Your lease will be renewed for the coming term.* *The coming term.* He’d type the greeting. He’d sign it himself. He’d seal them with the green wax.” He blots a line. “Nobody ever wrote down how long a term was. He thought he’d tell them later.”
“And you?”
“I thought I would be the person who got to write the number.” He turns the page toward me, and I read it upside down.
*Dear Mrs. Hendry. The term of your lease runs for twenty-five years from the first of January, as recorded in the registry at the book and page below. You may read it at the Mercantile. It will also be read aloud in the Grange on the first Sunday of each year, for as long as there is a Grange. With respect and apology, Charles A. Whitfield, Trustee.*
“Beckett co-signs,” says Charles. “Both of us, in blue ink. It seemed the proper way.”
---
We deliver them at 1:30, by hand, house to house.
It is my favorite kind of logistics, a route. I have it drawn on the back of a restaurant menu: sixty doors on the island proper and one on the mainland, which belongs to the man whose boat shed Tomas rents. Beckett carries the sack. Charles walks beside him. Behind us, half a step back, with her hands in her coat pockets, Vivian follows. She asked, last night, if she could carry nothing.
It is a gray, still afternoon with a low ceiling and a faint flat smell of snow. At the first door Mrs. Hendry opens, in a green cardigan and her glasses on a chain, and takes the letter without comment, and reads it standing on her own porch.
“Twenty-five years,” she says.
“From the first of January.”
“I am seventy-seven,” says Dot Hendry. She looks at Charles and a long moment goes by. “I intend to be a very difficult woman until 2051.” She folds the letter and puts it in her cardigan pocket. “Merry Christmas, Charles. Thank you for finally writing it down.”
“I’m sorry it took so long.”
“So am I,” says Mrs. Hendry, and shuts the door gently.
---
It takes four hours. I will tell you about two of the doors.
At the fourteenth, Walt Prouty comes out onto his porch in a flannel shirt with a screwdriver in his hand, and does not take the letter. He stands with his arms folded. He’s the man who challenged Beckett in the Grange. He has a long jaw and a reputation as the most honest person on Pemberton.
“I’m not saying I trust it,” he says.
“I’d think less of you if you did,” says Beckett.
“Ink dries.”
“So does a recording. It’s at the registry. You can read it any day you like. I’d like you to.” Beckett holds out the envelope. “You don’t have to take the letter. You can take the book and page.”
Walt looks at him. At Charles. At the paper. Then, with great reluctance, he takes it, and tucks the screwdriver under his arm so he can read.
“Your grandfather,” he says, not looking up, “never once wrote a number.”
“No.”
“You put one in.” He lifts his eyes. His face doesn’t soften, exactly, but it relaxes, the way a clenched hand does. “Merry Christmas, I suppose.”
---
The thirty-eighth door is Linda Szabo’s.
It’s her mother’s house, the small white one on Lot 38 with the blue shutters, and the Comeaus who rent it have gone to their daughter’s for the holiday. Linda has driven down from Lewiston, and she’s on the front step with a broom. She sees us come up the path, the four of us and the sack, and doesn’t put it down.
“I haven’t signed,” she says, before anyone speaks.
“We didn’t ask,” says Beckett.
“You were going to.” She looks at the envelope. “Everybody else did. Delphine Rourke called me three times before the judge told her to stop. She said sixty thousand and then sixty-five and then she said *I’m sorry, I’m just doing my job,* and I thought, *That’s the saddest sentence I’ve ever heard.*”
“Linda—”
“I’m not selling.” She puts the broom against the rail. “I was never going to. I wanted someone to want me to. Do you understand? My mother sorted fish for your grandfather for thirteen years, Mr. Whitfield, and then she rented a house she couldn’t afford. I wanted somebody to say she *mattered.*”
Charles takes off his hat. It’s the first time I’ve seen him do it. “She did,” he says. “Dolores Szabo. Sorter, 1978 to 1991. Her name is on the list. It’s number two hundred and eight.”
“I know,” says Linda. She takes the letter. Her hand is shaking. “I was there when it was read.”
---
At 6:15 the whole house is full.
Rosa’s Christmas Eve is the one dinner of the year that cannot be improved. There are pasteles, forty of them, wrapped in banana leaf and string; there’s a roast pork shoulder, arroz con gandules, and a pot of coquito that Rafa has been guarding with his body since noon.
The Long Table is the long table again, with the door and the card tables beneath a white cloth. There are twenty-two places, and I’ve done the seating, and I would like to note that at no point was a Whitfield placed within reach of a knife.
Charles sits at the wobbly end. Vivian sits at the other, by Beckett, with a plate she’s barely touched. Margaret is not here. She went back to Portland on Monday, after the AG’s office asked her to come in. She left a tin of shortbread by the door.
Carmen has her list. It’s a new list. It begins, I notice, with *Joyce at the title office, widowed, kind,* and ends with Rafa’s name crossed out, and she presses it into my hand like a communion wafer and says, “I’m just asking.”
“Tía,” I say, “I’m taken.”
“I know. It’s for your cousin.”
“Tomas?”
“No. Your *other* cousin. The one who hasn’t been born yet.”
---
At 8:30, between the pasteles and the flan, Vivian catches Beckett in the hall by the coats.
I’m not meant to hear. I have gone to find the extra cups and I stop, with my hand on the pantry door, because the hall is narrow and sound travels in it.
“I’m leaving on the twenty-seventh,” she says. “I’ve changed my flight twice. I won’t do it a third time.”
“Okay.”
“I’d like to come back. If you’ll have me. In February, say, when the cold’s done the worst of it.” Her voice is careful. “Not to stay. Not yet. I’d like to be somebody who comes for the first Sunday of the month, and doesn’t leave early.”
There’s a pause that has the shape of a man thinking about it for real.
“Can I ask you something first?” says Beckett.
“Of course.”
“Will you tell me when you’re scared? Not after. During.”
“I’ll try.”
“Then yes,” says Beckett, in a low voice. “February. Bring a coat.”
I back away from the pantry door very quietly, and I take four cups I don’t need to the sink.
---
We exchange presents at 8:50, at the bottom of the back stairs, in the little hall off the kitchen where the coats hang and the radio can’t reach.
I’ve wrapped mine in the tissue from a bridal client, which seems right. It’s flat and square. He takes it as if it might be a document.
It’s my first run of show, the one from the reunion, printed on the cheap paper I use for drafts. *Friday 4:10 p.m. Ferry. 4:25 Ramp. 4:30 Greg arrives.* I’ve had it framed in plain pine. The last line, where I had always put *Sunday 8:00 p.m. Tent strike,* is blank. I’ve left a space the width of a finger and written nothing.
“It’s the schedule,” he says.
“It’s the one that didn’t work.”
“The end’s missing.”
“That’s the point,” I say. “I don’t know what goes there. I thought you might.”
He doesn’t say anything for a long time. Then he reaches into his jacket, which I’ve always thought of as the place where he keeps his money, and takes out a small blue notebook, the sort you buy at the Mercantile for a dollar-fifty, with a rubber band.
“I’d like to be a man who asks,” he says. “I’m not good at it yet. I wrote down a list.”
I open it. The first page has one line, in his square slanted hand.
*May I?*
The second page has a date, and under it: *Dec. 12. Asked Marnie if she wanted me in the room for the thing with my mother. She said yes. I would not have known.* The third page is blank. And the fourth. And so on, all the way to the back, perhaps fifty empty pages, waiting for the next fifty times.
I kiss him in the coat closet, in the smell of wet wool and wood smoke, with a boot against my ankle and Tomas’s voice coming from the kitchen asking where the corkscrew is. It is short and warm and a little ridiculous. When we come out Rosa is standing at the end of the hall with a dish towel on her shoulder, and she doesn’t say anything at all, and it’s the loudest thing she’s said all night.
---
At 9:52 Priscilla comes in, in her coat, with snow in her hair and her phone in her hand, and the look of a woman who has been told to bring good news and has brought news.
“I’m sorry,” she says. “I wouldn’t, on the twenty-fourth. But you should hear it tonight.” She sets down a tin of cookies, ceremonially, as an apology. “Mr. Tamura at the AG’s office. He sent me a summary of Kevin Dunne’s statement. I’m not allowed to share it. I can tell you what it doesn’t say, which is that Dunne acted alone.”
The room has gone quiet. Vivian sets down her fork.
“He says he was engaged by a vendor,” says Priscilla. “Who was engaged by another vendor, who was engaged, in September, by a person at Halvorsen’s *outside counsel.* A firm. A named one. He gave the name. I’m not going to say it here.” She meets my eyes. “But it’s one that Delphine Rourke is partner in. Mr. Tamura’s office sent the same notice to Halvorsen’s counsel at nine tonight.”
Nobody moves. Rafa, at the stove, puts the spoon down.
“She’s—” says Beckett.
“She’s never said she’d known. And I don’t think she did. The partner in question is, as I understand it, in another city.” Priscilla breathes out. “But she’s going to find out tomorrow, or the day after, and she’s going to have to decide what she’s willing to be.”
Her phone buzzes. She looks at it. She goes entirely still.
“Priscilla?”
“It’s an email,” she says. “It’s from Delphine Rourke. It’s dated nine-forty-seven.” She turns the screen toward me. There are four lines.
*Counsel, I am withdrawing my limited appearance for Halvorsen Coastal Partners in all Pemberton matters, effective tonight. I told Mr. Whitfield I would lose well. I did not say I would lose for someone who let me speak for them without telling me. Merry Christmas. D.R.*
I read it twice. Then, across the table, at the long white cloth, I look at Beckett, and he looks at me, and Rosa, at the head of the table, puts down her wooden spoon.
Nobody eats right away. Tomas looks at Ines, who has come for the pasteles and stayed for the flan, and Ines looks at the ceiling, and I understand that she is already drafting the motion to subpoena a partner in another city. Charles has gone the color of the tablecloth. Vivian reaches under the table and takes Beckett’s hand, and he lets her.
“Eat,” says my grandmother. “It is Christmas. Whoever they send next, they will have to send him hungry.”


Chapter comments
No comments yet. Be the first!