Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 61

Under Oath

The Harbor Court of Leases sat in a building that had been built to impress sea captains, and it still did.

It stood at the head of the Ashlen quay behind a row of stone pillars, with a clock in its pediment and a brass tide gauge set into the steps, so that every litigant climbed past the water level on the way to be judged.

Leda counted the marks as she went up. The harbor stood well below the top line. Nobody else seemed to notice. The clerks and the lawyers and the gallery regulars went up the steps in their good coats with their eyes on the doors, as people do who have never needed to read a river.

She had slept for three hours, in a rented room over a net store, with the green cap under her cheek. Her ear had stopped humming in the night and begun again at dawn, a thin sweet wire in the dark of her head. It was the same note. She had not told Iven. She had decided, on the stairs, that she was entitled to one small private worry before nine o’clock.

“Stand when she comes in,” murmured Hale at her shoulder. “Sit when she sits. Answer the question that is asked, and not the one you wish had been. If you do not know, say so. If you are sure, say that, and say how.”

“Is that all?”

“It is the whole of the craft. Most people cannot do it.” Hale’s mouth went wry. “They want to be understood. A witness who wants to be understood is a witness who gets taken apart.”

“I do want to be understood.”

“Then be understood slowly,” said Hale, “and one sentence at a time.”

---

The courtroom was long and high and smelled of wet wool, beeswax and fear.

There were benches for the parties on the floor and a gallery above for anyone with a card. Leda found Iven on the harbors’ side, in his one good coat, with the sling hidden under it so that only the slight lean of his shoulder gave it away. He looked up when she came in. His face was perfectly composed and perfectly gray. Hale had told him he would be the first called, and he counted the minutes by the clock the way he counted the load on a lever.

Across the aisle sat Dunmore’s side. She knew it by the size of the table. There were four lawyers, a man with a ledger on his knee, the receiver’s seat with Corva Lisle perched on the edge like a bird on a wire, and a gap at the far end of the bench where a chair stood empty.

Above them, at the rail of the gallery, in the second row, a man in a gray coat sat with his hat on his knee. His scarf was folded in his lap. It was violet. He nodded at her, courteously, when she looked up.

She nodded back. It cost her nothing. She had already decided that the only possible answer to that man’s manners was to have better ones.

“Be upstanding,” said the usher.

Justice Marguerite Aldane was a short, broad, silver-haired woman with a face like a well-kept ledger, and she came in at a brisk walk, as if the court had kept her waiting. She sat. She looked at the room over the tops of her spectacles, once, slowly, the way a woman looks at a pantry she suspects of mice.

“This is the matter of the Marren Ford, Bellwether and Orra Landing harbor boards, against Dunmore Marine Holdings and others,” she said. “I am told the order of witnesses has been changed overnight, and not by me. I should like to hear by whom.”

A tall man at the other table rose. He had a lean, well-bred, faintly weary face, and a way of folding his hands that suggested he was lending them out. “Mr. Rennick, my lady, for the respondents. It was an application of convenience. Two of our witnesses are traveling.”

“Convenience is an excellent word,” said the Justice. “I have found it covers a great deal. Sit down, Mr. Rennick. Ms. Hale, call your first.”

Hale half rose, and the clerk, who had a sheet in his hand, called out before she could speak. “Leda Vale.”

She had been put on the list second, as a witness of fact, to follow Iven. In the second before Hale’s hand closed on her wrist she understood that the order had changed again.

“They’ve swapped,” said Hale, under her breath. “Their counsel asked for you before Iven, so that you cannot hear his evidence first. It’s a standard dodge. Stand up.”

She stood up.

---

The witness stand was a wooden box with a rail, and a small brass gauge on the wall at the height of her eyes. She put her hand on the book. She swore. Her voice came out clean and dry and quite steady, and she was extremely proud of it.

Rennick took his time. He walked slowly round the end of his table with a paper in his hand and looked at it as if it were slightly disappointing. “Miss Vale,” he said at last. “You are a diver.”

“I’m a tide-keeper.”

“A distinction without a difference, surely. You go under water for money.”

“I go under water for fees,” said Leda. “Some of which I have never been paid.”

There was a ripple in the gallery. She heard it and did not look. Rennick smiled kindly.

“You have been paid a good many fees. Over the last three months you have been engaged at Bellwether Reach, at Orra Landing and at Marren Ford. You earned, by my reckoning, three hundred and forty crowns.”

“I don’t know the sum.”

“It is in the cooperative’s own ledger, which my learned friend has kindly supplied.” He glanced at Hale. “I wonder whether you would agree it is a good living.”

“It is a living.”

“A better living when there are floods.”

“It is a living when there are requests,” said Leda. “A request is a flood, mostly. Or a thing that will be one.”

“Quite so. Then I put it to you plainly.” He turned to the bench with the air of a man laying a great weight down. “The cooperative is paid by the harbor boards to prevent catastrophe. The more catastrophes it can be shown to have prevented, the more its services are valued. Is that not so?”

She felt the trap close, softly, like a lid.

It was not even a lie. That was the cleverness of it. She thought of Marren Ford, of the almshouse widow on the rope, of Hettie standing on her own step in gum boots. She thought of what Hale had said. *One sentence at a time.*

“Yes,” she said.

Rennick paused. He had plainly expected a struggle.

“We are paid when things go wrong,” said Leda. “That is a flaw in the trade. We have a rule against it. Every request we answer, we log what it would have cost us to leave undone. The cooperative’s accounts are open to anyone who wishes to read them. I would rather be a tide-keeper who is not needed. But I did not go to Marren Ford to be needed. I went because a warden wrote to ask.”

“You went because Mr. Sayer was already there.”

“Mr. Sayer was at Bellwether. He came after.”

“Ah.” He consulted his paper. “Let us turn to Marren Ford. On the fiftieth day you dived on a Dunmore asset, number 0302, in the dark, without leave, and altered its position.”

“I closed a gate that had been opened to a hand and a half. I left it at three fingers.”

“On a lessee’s property.”

“On a levee,” said Leda, “that three thousand eight hundred people lived behind.”

“That is an answer to a question I did not ask.”

“Then I’m sorry. Yes. It was Dunmore’s asset, by the schedule. I altered it. We gave notice of the alteration, in writing, to the town and the receiver. It is in the court’s papers.”

“In a notice written by Mr. Sayer.”

“In a notice written by Mr. Sayer, which was read aloud in the market hall and signed by the warden and the reeve.”

Rennick gave a thin, pleasant nod, as if she had passed a small examination, and set his paper down. It was a pause that she would remember. For the first time he looked directly at her, and his weary face was quite free of malice. It occurred to her that he did not hate her. He was simply making a table, and she was an item on it.

“Let us go on to the crate,” he said.

---

She had expected the crate. She had not expected the kind way he said it.

“You removed a crate from the sump at Tanner’s Lock.”

“I did.”

“Which was stenciled with the number of a Dunmore asset, and the name of a berth in this port.”

“It was.”

“And you did not open it.”

“No.”

“Why not?”

“Because it was sealed. I thought it should be opened in front of someone.” She heard Hale shift. She did not stop. “I didn’t know what was in it. I still don’t. I heard it, though, and I think that’s why you ask.”

The gallery went quite quiet.

“You heard it,” said Rennick.

“It hums. It has hummed since I first laid a hand on it. It is a very small sound and I have a damaged ear, so I want to be careful about what I say.” She turned, a little, to the bench.

“I think it is a device, and I think it was cast to answer something, and I think the something is a root. I can’t prove that. I can show you the lid and the seals and the receipt, which has five signatures. I can tell you what I observed.”

“You *think* it was cast to answer a root.”

“I think so.”

“On what grounds?”

“On the grounds,” said Leda, “that Mabry Sloane, aged eight, of Marren Ford, told us the levee root had said *I heard.* And that it did. In front of three hundred people. I was not there, but I know it, because—”

“Objection,” said Rennick, quite gently. He did not even rise. “My lady, I regret the interruption. The witness is about to give evidence of what a child of eight reported that a pipe said.”

“Sustained,” said the Justice, in a voice like a closing drawer. “Miss Vale, the court cannot receive what you were told. It may receive what you saw and did. Ms. Hale will tell you the same.”

“I do,” murmured Hale, from far away.

“Then I’m sorry,” said Leda. “I strike it. Please.”

“It is struck.” The Justice wrote briefly, and did not look up. “The record will not include the child’s remark. The clerk will note that it was offered and withdrawn.”

It was not much. It was a line in a book. But Leda stood in the box with her hands closed on the rail and felt it go, the one small piece of true thing she had carried for two hundred miles. Mabry had said *one more*, and *I heard*. Now it had been officially unheard.

In the gallery, above and behind, she did not look. She knew what was there. A gentleman with a violet scarf, who had not stirred, sitting very straight with an expression of profound and gentle regret.

---

“One more matter,” said Rennick.

He had grown quieter. He crossed the floor in no hurry and picked up a document from the corner of the table, and for a moment she saw he was holding it carefully, by the edges, as if it were hot.

“You are aware,” he said, “that the cooperative has, under its charter, no powers over a lessee’s property.”

“We ask. We do not take.”

“And yet in three months at four sites, you have, if I may reckon it, wedged one plate, keyed one float, closed one gate, removed four fittings, and carried off a crate.”

“We—”

“I do not say it was wrong. I say it was a very great deal to do without a license.” His voice softened. “I have only one question left, Miss Vale, and I will ask you to answer it carefully. If a harbor, any harbor, told you tomorrow to leave a Dunmore fitting alone, because it was lawful and sound, would you leave it alone?”

She thought of Orra. She thought of the vent under the east steps and Arlo’s low house. She thought, steadily, of every careful, painful hour of the last three months.

“I would ask the root,” she said.

“And if it could not answer?”

“Then I would ask the people who live on it.”

“And if they were wrong?”

It was a clean question. It was the best he had asked. She took her time.

“Then I would be wrong with them,” she said, “and I would write it down. We have been wrong. The log says so. Orra’s plates stayed in a month too long because I trusted a table.”

She drew breath. “We do not claim to be right. We claim to be present, and to say what we saw, and to be told by anyone with a better eye. That is the only license I know how to carry. I would give a good deal for another.”

There was a short, curious, shifting silence. It was not applause. It was nothing like it. But in the front of the gallery a woman in a darned shawl blew her nose, and the Justice, without looking up, made a small mark with her pencil in the margin of her notes.

Rennick looked at her for a moment. He was about to speak. Leda saw it in the set of his mouth: another question, shaped, ready, perhaps worse than the last. He drew breath.

And then a boy in a clerk’s gray apron came up the side aisle with a folded paper in his hand.

---

He did not hurry. He passed along the bench with a duck of the head and set the paper, very neatly, on the corner of Rennick’s table. It was small and cream-colored. Leda knew the paper. She had seen its twin on Wil Tanner’s kitchen table by a lantern.

Rennick opened it. It took him less than three seconds. His face did not change at all, except that it seemed to become, quite suddenly, a face she could not see into. He read the note once. Then he folded it very small and put it inside his coat.

“My lady,” he said. “I have no further questions of this witness.”

The Justice’s eyebrows rose. “You had a moment ago.”

“I find I do not.” He bowed. “The court will forgive an old man’s economy.”

“You are fifty-one,” said the Justice drily, “and you have never economized in your life. Very well. Ms. Hale, do you wish to re-examine?”

Hale rose. She looked quite as surprised as the bench, though only a fool would have seen it. “A few things, my lady. May I begin with the lessee of Berth Nine?”

“You may.”

“I have a copy of the berth register, which the court has had since the week began. Berth Nine on the Ashlen quay is leased on a one-year term, running from the first of last spring, to a company called Vesper Salvage.” She held up a paper. “I have the lease. The signature is a manager’s, and the manager has no name. It is simply *the manager*. The seal is in violet wax.”

“Is that a question?” said the Justice.

“It is an observation, my lady, for the record. I should like to ask Miss Vale whether she has ever heard of Vesper Salvage.”

“No,” said Leda.

“Whether it holds any other lease in the port?”

“I don’t know.”

“Whether it has any other address than the quay?”

“I don’t know, Ms. Hale.” Leda found, to her surprise, that she was smiling a little. “I am a diver. It’s not my trade to know.”

“Thank you.” Hale folded the lease. “Nor mine, until recently. I should be glad to know it before the hearing is done.”

The Justice looked at the clock. She looked at the gallery, and her glance traveled along the second row and did not stop. She turned her pencil over, once, in her fingers.

“Miss Vale, you may step down,” she said. “You have been a better witness than any of us expected, and I include yourself. The court will take ten minutes. Mr. Sayer will be called on its return.”

Leda stepped down. Her knees, she discovered, were made of damp rope. She got three paces along the aisle before a hand fell on her shoulder, and it was not Hale’s.

It was Iven’s. He was already on his feet. His eyes were extremely bright and quite steady, and his lips were tight with a kind of fury that she had seen in him only twice before.

“They’ve heard you,” he said very quietly. “But he stopped. Why did he stop?”

“The note.”

“Yes. What did it say?”

“I don’t know.” She looked, then, up at the rail of the gallery. The second row was empty, and the seat where the man had sat was cold. On the bench lay a folded scarf the color of a bruise. It was not left behind. It was set down, quite carefully, like a card turned face up on a table. “But I think he’s decided,” she said, “that Mr. Rennick has done enough, and that he would rather do the rest himself.”

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!