Iven was good at one kind of speech, and it was the kind nobody applauds.
He could read a notice aloud to a crowded hall so that the back row understood it on the first hearing. He could draft a clause so that a tired reeve and a frightened widow would arrive at the same meaning.
What he could not do, and had never done, was be looked at while he did it. In the market hall at Marren Ford the paper had stood between him and three hundred faces. In the Harbor Court of Leases there was no paper. There was a brass rail, a Justice, a gallery, and a long lean man walking slowly toward him with his hands folded.
“Mr. Sayer,” said Rennick. “You are an engineer.”
“I am a surveyor and an adviser. I have never sat the engineer’s examination.”
“Why not?”
“Because I learned the work on other people’s levees, and by the time I had the fee for the paper I had the arm to explain.”
The Justice looked up. It was quick, and then it was gone. Rennick nodded, as if he had been given something he could use, and did not use it yet.
He began, instead, in the same soft voice, with the notices.
---
“This is your hand.”
“It is.”
“A notice of alteration, addressed to the Marren Ford town and receiver and read in the market hall on the fifty-second day. You wrote it, and you read it, and you signed it as adviser to the cooperative.”
“As adviser to the town.”
“As adviser to the town, on behalf of the cooperative. I have the paper. It says that the cooperative will alter, not remove, certain fittings listed on Dunmore’s Schedule C.” He held the sheet up between thumb and forefinger. “Alter. A pleasant word. Does it have a meaning in your trade?”
“It has the meaning I gave it in the first sentence. We don’t remove what we have no leave to remove. We change how it sits, so that it does less harm, and we write down exactly how, so that anyone can put it back.”
“Anyone.”
“Anyone with a key. We leave the key.”
There was a small restless sound in the gallery. Iven did not turn. He kept his eyes on Rennick’s second button and his hand flat on the rail, because the left one, beneath the coat, had begun its slow beat, a clock in another room.
“A key,” said Rennick. “A stone block, I understand. At Bellwether you wedged a float latch with a block of stone, and you put a padlock on the block, and you gave the padlock to the receiver. Is that right?”
“Two padlocks. The receiver’s and the yard board’s.”
“And the cooperative holds the liability.”
“For the keying. Yes.”
“So if the float opens, and the marsh is drained, and a child is drowned, the court may look to your cooperative for the cause.”
“It may look to anyone it likes,” said Iven. “I’d look to the man who set the float to open at a mark in a flood, and told no one. But yes. We hold liability for what our hands do. I would not ask a harbor to trust us otherwise.”
He knew, as he said it, that it was a good answer. He also knew that it was a gift. It was the thing Rennick wanted, handed over in a clean wrapper: the cooperative had taken liability for Dunmore’s equipment, and an engineer had said so aloud under oath. The Justice’s pencil moved. In the corner of his eye he saw Hale’s shoulders settle, very slightly, like a woman bracing for a wave she has seen coming.
“Thank you,” said Rennick. “You were most candid.”
“It’s the only way I’ve found to be believed.”
“I wonder,” said Rennick. And then, with no change of voice at all, “How is your arm, Mr. Sayer?”
---
It was a hit, and it was a good one. It went in under the ribs.
“It’s mended in the way that matters.”
“I am sorry to press. I have a document.” He held up a page Iven knew: a clean sheet in Dr. Lorne’s upright hand, with the date and the seal of the Saltwake surgeon. “A letter, produced by the cooperative in discovery. It states that you are to take no rope work for forty days from the thirty-seventh, and thirty more from the fiftieth, which carries you to the eightieth day, and that a failure of the left arm could occur without warning under load. Is that your surgeon’s opinion?”
“It is.”
“And you have advised, at Bellwether and at Marren Ford, on levees on which people’s lives depended.”
“I have.”
“Standing on a plank walk, with a lever twelve feet long.”
“Directing it. Not holding it.”
“Directing it,” said Rennick, “with a failing arm. Is it fair to say, Mr. Sayer, that the cooperative’s chief adviser on these matters is a man his own physician has forbidden to lift?”
The silence in the room was very thick. Out of the second row of the gallery a small cough came, and was smothered.
He had been asked, he thought, the one question that was not a question at all. It was an invitation to defend himself. He could say that he had stood where he stood and not lifted. He could say that Marren Ford had been held by eight hands at a time with a caller, a book and a rota, and that no one hand had mattered. He could say that this was the point of the whole business.
He found that none of it was what he wanted to say.
“Yes,” he said. “It’s fair.”
Rennick blinked.
“I can’t lift. I might fail on any given night. It’s why I don’t.” He took a breath, and it came out with a little shake, which he permitted.
“In the last three months I have fallen asleep on my feet twice and written a nonsense line in a log. I’ve had good people take the weight I couldn’t. It is the best thing that has happened to the work. I’d be sorry for a harbor that depended on a single adviser with two good arms, because I’ve seen what it does to the arms.”
“I do not follow.”
“You will not,” said Iven, “have to depend on me. That’s all. That’s what the rota is for.”
He looked, then, at the bench. The Justice had put her pencil down. She was looking at him over her spectacles with a small flat expression he could not read, and he thought: *I have not helped. I have said exactly what I think.* It was a clean strange feeling, like putting down a bag he had been carrying for a very long time.
“I have no more questions on that,” said Rennick, a little slowly.
“You’ve had your three hours,” said the Justice drily. “Mr. Sayer, you may sit.”
He sat. It was only then that he understood how long he had stood. His left arm had turned to a bar of hot iron from shoulder to wrist, and when Hale, passing, slid a folded handkerchief into his good hand without a word, he found his knuckles were white.
---
Dunmore’s own man was called after the noon recess.
Iven had not expected it, and neither, plainly, had anyone but the man himself. Tobias Wren came up the aisle in a gray assessor’s coat with a canvas bag over his shoulder, and when he had been sworn he laid the bag at his feet like a dog told to stay. He was a stooped, soft-middled, bookish man of fifty with a tea-stained mustache, ink on his cuff and a nose that went pink when he was frightened. It was very pink.
Rennick’s questions were gentle and meant to be short. Did Mr. Wren hold a field assessor’s post under Dunmore? He did. Had he visited the cooperative’s works at Bellwether and Marren Ford? He had. Had he reported that the cooperative had *interfered* with Dunmore assets?
“I reported that they had altered them,” said Wren. “In writing. With notices.”
“Interfered, Mr. Wren.”
“I did not use the word, sir. I do not think it was fair.”
A pause. Rennick set down his paper. “My lady, I wonder whether this witness has been, ah, coached.”
“By whom?” said the Justice. “I’d like to meet him. Let the witness proceed.”
Wren took a breath that rattled. “I was asked to report on the condition of nine assets at Marren Ford, numbered 0301 to 0309. I went. I was the only person from Dunmore ever to go. In eleven years of the lease, sir, I was the only one. The levee root was in good order. The gate at 0302 was a relief vent that had been opened beyond its design, and not by the cooperative. The cooperative closed it, to three fingers. I saw it myself. I made a note.”
“A note. For whom?”
“For my office.”
“And what did your office say?”
“Nothing, sir.” Wren swallowed. “I wrote to ask whether the Committee on Lease Condition, Western Range, which had passed Resolution Fourteen, was on our roster. I looked in the register and I could not find it. I asked the secretary. I asked my superior. I asked three times.”
He lifted his eyes, and for the first time they were quite round and steady. “Nobody at Dunmore Marine Holdings has ever met a member of that committee. Nobody has seen its minutes. Resolution Fourteen of the board is about stationery. I have the board’s own book.”
Hale made a small sound. It might have been a cough.
“The committee is a name, my lady,” said Wren, to the bench. “It is a name on a paper that I was told to serve. I served it. I am sorry I did, now.”
It took Rennick two minutes to put him down, and he did it very kindly. When Wren stepped out of the box his hands shook, and he picked up his canvas bag with both of them as if it were a child.
Iven saw him in the corridor ten minutes later. A porter was carrying out a cardboard box. It held a brass inkwell, a pair of spectacles, an assessor’s seal and a bundle of letters. A grave junior in a black coat had handed Wren a paper, and Wren was standing against the wall with it in both hands, reading it, with his pink nose.
“They’ve terminated my engagement,” he said, when Iven stopped. He did not seem to be asking for sympathy. “With effect from the end of today’s session. It’s quite in order. It says I’ve shown insufficient loyalty to the respondents’ counsel.” He gave a small cracked laugh. “I have never in my life been told I was disloyal. I rather liked it.”
“I’m sorry.”
“I’m not.” He folded the paper in four. “I’m a clerk, Mr. Sayer. I’ve never done a brave thing. I think that was one. It is very strange. I want to be sick.”
“Come and have some tea,” said Iven. “The Court has a canteen.”
“Is it a good one?”
“No.”
“Then I’ll come,” said Wren, with something like happiness. “I’m not hungry for good things today.”
---
The trouble came at four, and it was a sort of mercy that it came in the shape of a motion.
Rennick stood up when the last witness had stepped down. His long hands were folded. He had been perfectly decent all afternoon, and now, in the slant of gold light from the high windows, he looked tired and sad and years older than he had that morning.
“My lady, I wish to make an application. It concerns a crate.” He gave a small bow, as if to an old friend. “It has been mentioned in the evidence. It is lodged in the bond store of this court, sealed by the cooperative’s own witnesses. I do not know what is in it. Neither, I believe, does the cooperative. Miss Vale said as much on her oath.”
“Ms. Hale?” said the Justice.
Hale was on her feet. “It’s not been tested, my lady. It is the cooperative’s evidence.”
“It is Dunmore’s property,” said Rennick, “by its own stencil. I am not asking for it back. I am asking only that it be opened. Here. In open court, in front of every party, tomorrow morning, before the judge.” He turned his face to the gallery, one quick faintly puzzled glance, as one looks to see whether a visitor has arrived. “I say that if the cooperative is acting in good faith, it will not object.”
It was a very neat trap, and Iven could see no way out of it. If the harbors’ side fought the opening, they had something to hide. If they agreed, then whatever was in the crate would be opened by a clerk, in the dry, in a public room, with a gallery.
He looked at Leda. She was white, and entirely still, with her good ear turned a little toward the door that led down to the bond store. She gave the smallest shake of her head. He knew what it meant: *it hums.* He knew what she was afraid of, because he was afraid of it too.
“No objection,” said Hale.
She had said it very softly, and Iven understood that she had no choice, and that she knew it.
“Then it is ordered,” said the Justice. She was looking at neither side. She was looking up at the empty second row of the gallery with her mouth gone very small.
“The crate will be opened here, at ten o’clock tomorrow, before the court, in the presence of the clerk and every party. No one will touch it before. No one will tilt it. It will be carried up by the clerk and by two porters of this court’s own choosing.” She laid her pencil down. “I do not like orders that come from nowhere, Mr. Rennick. I like even less the feeling that I have given one.”
“I am obliged to the court.”
“I was not complimenting you.”
---
They signed Dray’s statement at the infirmary at half past five, in a long ward that smelled of carbolic and boiled barley, with the last of the daylight going gray across the sheets.
He was awake. He was thin as a wire and bright-eyed, with a sister’s hand under his heel to keep it raised, and he did not want to be moved. Hale had brought a clerk of the court as a witness, a young man who looked embarrassed to be present at a sickbed, and he held the pen while Dray signed.
“I’d like it in the record that I’m not innocent,” said Dray.
“It will be there,” said Hale.
“That I initialed the Orra card after the fact.”
“It will be there.”
“And this.” He fumbled at the sheet with a hand like a bundle of sticks, and Leda drew out of her coat the blue paper folder with its soft corners and *Corvey School* written on the front. She laid it on his knee.
He did not open it. He rested two fingers on the cover as one rests them on a sleeping child’s hair. “My girl’s receipts. Four years of fees. They’re in a violet ink, all of them, the same hand. I always thought it was the school’s clerk.” He closed his eyes. “I turned one over, last night. In the fever. I don’t know why.”
Hale opened the folder. She read the top sheet, then the next. The early ones were printed for a bursary, a *Friends of the Western Range*, and signed with a scrawl. She did not say a word. She laid the latest on the blanket, face up, so that Iven could see.
*Received of Vesper Salvage Co., Berth 9, Ashlen Quay, for the account of Miss E. Dray, autumn term, 22 crowns.*
It was signed, in a clerkly hand, *for the manager*.
“Thank you, Mr. Dray,” said Hale, in a very steady voice. “That will do very well.”
“Is it bad?”
“It is exactly what we needed,” said Hale. “I think.” She turned over another receipt. “It means the bursary that has been paying for your daughter became, last spring, the company that leases the berth.”
“Then he’s been kind to me for four years,” said Dray, “and he’s been planning to drown the levee of my own town.”
“I don’t know what he’s been planning.”
“No.” He lay back on the pillow. “That’s what makes it so fine a thing.”
---
Leda came out of the infirmary a few minutes behind him, with the cap in her fist.
He was waiting on the steps in the snow, with his arm in its sling and a day of other people’s words in his head. It was nearly dark. Down the long hill the harbor was lighting itself lamp by lamp, and Berth Nine lay at the end of the quay in a little pool of gold, quite quiet.
“Ten o’clock,” he said. “In front of a room. Whatever it is.”
“Yes.”
“I’d like to know what it’s for, before we open it. Not what it is. What it’s *for*.” He heard how he sounded. “I don’t mean the hum. I mean the place. The stencil says Berth Nine. Someone has done something at Berth Nine. I think it’s a thing made to fit a seat.”
“I know,” said Leda.
“What do you mean?”
“I mean I’ve been thinking it since the stairs this morning.” She looked down the hill at the little pool of lamplight, and her face in the dusk was perfectly calm. “I’m going to dive it tonight. At the night slack. Before it’s opened, and before anyone’s had time to arrange the water.”
“You can’t. The berth is leased. You’d be trespassing in the middle of a hearing.”
“Yes.”
“They would tear the whole case up.”
“Yes.”
“Leda.”
“It’s my ear,” she said, “and it’s my reserve, and it’s my name in the log.” She took his good hand and turned it palm up and put the stub of her log chalk into it. “If I’m not back by the slack, write it down for me. You’ve paid for Dray. This one is mine.”

