Skip to content
Zodygo

Chapter 66

A Rule Against Advising

The order was four paragraphs long, and Hale read the third one aloud in the room over the net store at seven the next morning with the particular flat voice she kept for documents that had been written to hurt.

“No member or servant of the cooperative is to approach Berth Nine, by land or by water, to inspect, to dive, to alter, or to advise.” She put the paper down on the table among the bread and the cold tea. “Advise. I told her it would be the word that did the damage.”

Iven was sitting with his back against the wall and his left arm laid along a folded blanket, the way Ro had taught him to rest it after a bad day. He had not slept much. He had listened to Leda breathing in the next bed, and heard her tell him in the dark, in a low even voice, about the Exchange and the damp room and the watch.

He had said very little. He had wanted to say a great deal, and had found that none of it was any use to her, and in the end he had put his hand across the gap between the beds and she had taken it.

“It means,” he said now, “that if the harbor wardens ask what we think, we cannot answer.”

“It means that if anyone in this city asks you what the root is going to do on the seventy-eighth, you must look at your boots.” Hale turned to the window. “I spent an hour in chambers yesterday after the hearing. I spent two last night. Justice Aldane is not a woman who changes her order because she has been asked nicely. But she is a woman who hates to be made a fool of by her own wording.”

Ro, who had come in from the stair with a loaf under her good arm, put it down. “She’d back off?”

“She’d amend. In writing, at nine, in open court. I won’t know the exact words until she says them.” Hale gave a short, tired, wolfish smile. “But I think she has found a door.”

---

The door was a single sentence, and the Justice read it from her bench with every sign of disliking it.

“The court has considered the proper meaning of the word *advise*. The court has formed the view that it does not extend to evidence given on oath, in open session, in answer to a question put by an officer of this port.” She turned a page. “The Act makes the harbor warden responsible for the condition of Berth Nine.

“The Act makes this court responsible for the safety of the quay it sits on. It follows that this court may, if it chooses, sit as an inquiry into that safety, and may call any person it likes.”

A murmur ran along the gallery. She waited for it to die.

“Mr. Thale will attend.”

A man rose from the harbors’ bench and came forward. He was about forty-five, heavily built and slow-moving, in the blue coat of a harbor sergeant with a new warden’s armband pinned on above the elbow and not yet quite square. He had a square brown face and a big, quiet, patient jaw, and he held his cap in both hands as if it might get away.

“Corbin Thale, my lady. Acting warden, since the suspension of Miss Orne.”

“You have the berth in your charge.”

“I have, my lady.” He glanced at the gallery, toward the bench where Orne sat in her good coat with her plait pinned up, and Orne lifted two fingers at him without a smile. “I’ll say plainly that I don’t understand the matter. I’ve been a sergeant twenty years.

“I know ropes and drunks and the tide table. I’m told there’s a thing in the root of the third pile that wants to open on the seventy-eighth, and I’m told that if it does, I’m standing on the end of a very old wall.”

“You are being told accurately.”

“Then I’d like to put some questions, my lady, to the people who know, and I’d like to put them in the open. And I’d like it written.”

“It will be written,” said the Justice. “Mr. Sayer, please come forward.”

He stood. His arm gave a long, dull throb as the blood moved, and he let it. He walked the length of the aisle to the witness rail in the silence of three hundred people trying not to look at his sleeve.

---

Thale was a good questioner. It was not the slick kind that Rennick had been. He asked what he did not understand, in the order that he did not understand it, and he did not mind sounding slow.

“What is a root?”

“A living thing under the quay, sir. It is old. It has been there as long as the wall. It holds water in it the way a sponge does, and it presses on what is around it. At high tide the harbor leans on it, and it leans back.”

“And the thing in the third pile?”

“A seat. A cut in the wood for a device the size of a bread loaf. We saw the device itself yesterday, on the clerk’s table. It is a trap scale.” He kept his voice level. “It’s set so that when the pressure on that part of the root reaches a given height, it lets something go.”

“At what height?”

“Five feet and two inches. That’s the gauge on the Court’s steps.”

“Which the tide will reach.”

“Which the almanac says it will reach on the seventy-eighth, sir. Not before. It’s a foot over the common spring.”

Thale looked down at his cap. “And if we did nothing at all.”

“I can’t tell the court what would happen.” Iven stopped, and thought, and said it honestly. “I can tell you what I should fear. A root that has been shaped for years toward a single hollow, and is then opened at the one hour when the harbor is pressing hardest, is a root that loses its head all at once.

“It would be like pulling a plug from a full barrel. The water in the wall would go out through the third pile into the harbor. Whatever is built on that water would sit down.”

“Sit down.”

“Settle. By inches, or by feet. I don’t know. A quay that has stood six hundred years does not fall over. It slumps. And it slumps wherever it was weakest.”

Someone near the back of the gallery coughed, and the cough went round the room and died.

“My lady,” said Thale, turning to the bench, “is it within the inquiry for me to ask the witness what he’d do?”

The Justice let the pause go on for exactly as long as it took to be a pause. “The court,” she said, “would regard that as a question.”

---

He had been working on it since three that morning.

It had come to him in the dark as an ache and then as an idea, the two so tangled that he could not afterward say which had arrived first. He had lain awake with his arm throbbing and the sound of the crate in his head, and he had thought about the stone sill at Bellwether and the sleeve at Orra and the coffer at Marren Ford, and about how every one of them had been a way of *giving water somewhere to go*.

“A root’s strength,” he said, “is its head. That is the height of water standing in it above the level it is held at. If the harbor is at five feet two, and the root is full to five feet two, the pressure at the third pile is the whole of five feet two.”

“Yes.”

“Then lower the root. Not the harbor, sir. We can’t touch the harbor. The root.” He took the chalk from the clerk’s tray, in his right hand, and drew on the slate that Thale held out: a long line, a short line, a rough curve. “The old city has a tidal drain, under Cooper’s Row.

“I walked it last night with Mr. Tibb. It was built before the quay was repaired, and the quay was repaired over it, and it was shut with a wooden shutter in the time of Justice Aldane’s grandfather.”

“I know it,” said Thale slowly. “We call it the Dead Drain.”

“It runs from the root bed under the Row to the old moat at the back of the market, which is low and has not held water in forty years. If the shutter were drawn, the root would bleed down it, slowly, as the tide rose. Not enough to weaken it. Enough to keep its head under what the trap is set for.”

“By how much?”

“I think six inches. I can’t promise it. I’d want an hour with the slate and a man who knew the levels.”

“I know the levels,” said Thale.

“Then I’d say six inches. Possibly seven. It would put the head at the third pile at four feet eight or four feet six, on the seventy-eighth. The trap sits at five two. It would not move.”

There was silence.

“And the price?” said Justice Aldane.

Iven had been waiting for it, and he found he was grateful. “It floods the cellars of Cooper’s Row, my lady. All eleven houses on the north side. The water goes into the moat, and the moat is low, and it will come up through the cellar drains before it finds the market’s old sump. They will be wet to the second step for a night and a day.”

“By design.”

“By design.”

“Whose liability?”

He said, “Mine.”

He heard Hale draw breath beside the rail, and he did not look at her.

---

It was not the speech of a brave man. He was clear about that, afterward. It was simply the only sentence that could be made true.

“The cooperative has no funds for it. The cooperative has lost forty crowns to this court and a month of fees to a flood. I would have the drain opened under my own name, and every cellar owner can bring a claim to me. If I’m wrong the cost is mine. If the quay stands, I should like the court to remember that the water went where I said.”

“You are aware,” said the Justice, “that your own arm is not what it was. That you have testified that you cannot hold a rod.”

“I’m aware, my lady. I’m not proposing to hold a rod. I’m proposing to hold a pen.”

It was the thing he said best, he thought, with Leda behind him in the gallery like a drawn breath. A thing a man can do with one good hand.

Aldane looked at him for a long while. Then she looked past him, to the third row of the gallery, where a mild red-eyed man in a rumpled coat had half risen, and was waving a nervous hand.

“Mr. Tibb,” she said. “You have something to add?”

“My lady.” The clerk of the Court was very pale. “It is my row. I mean to say, I live there, over the tobacconist’s. My cellar is the third from the end, and it has a well. Mr. Sayer asked me last night if the cellar might be flooded for the public safety, and I said I would have to ask my wife.” He swallowed. “I asked her. She said that if the Court sat down on us, she would rather have wet stockings.”

A great, relieved, unseemly laugh went up from the gallery. It was the first since the crate. The Justice let it run and did not smile, but one corner of her mouth moved.

“The record will show,” she said gravely, “that the clerk’s wife consents.”

---

They spent the rest of the morning with the slate.

Thale knew the levels. He had walked the tidal drain as a boy for a dare and again as a sergeant for a drowned cat, and he laid out the fall of it in a kind of slow, careful shorthand on the back of a harbor chart while Iven watched him and corrected two figures. By noon they had a plan on a single sheet: the shutter, the sluice, the mud-gate at the moat’s end, who would draw what and when.

It was more than he could do himself. Mercer had come in from the quay at eleven with Pike, both in the thick brown coats of men who had been up all night on someone else’s business. Pike took the sheet from Iven’s hand, read it with his lips moving, said, “Aye,” and went to find his foreman. Mercer stood a moment with his hands in his pockets.

“You’ll want somebody who can swing a mallet and hold his tongue,” he said.

“I’d want you,” said Iven.

“I know you would.” Mercer looked at the floor. “I never thought I’d be asked.”

The afternoon went on the cellars. Thale came with a warden’s lantern and Tibb with a ledger, and between them they went down the north side of Cooper’s Row, the eleven houses in the order of their numbers, to say in plain words what would happen and when.

Iven wrote each name and each cellar’s contents in the ledger himself, with the pen in his right hand, because he had told the Court the claims would come to him and he meant to be able to read every one.

Most of it was coal, preserves and broken furniture. The tobacconist kept his stock on the first floor and shrugged.

A widow at number nine had a harp in hers under a sheet, and stood at the head of the steps with her arms crossed and said that nobody was carrying a harp anywhere. The old woman at number four, in the shawl, had her husband’s clock and a sack of seed potatoes, and asked only whether the water would come up as far as the second step or the third.

“The second,” said Iven. “I think. I’ll put it down as the third, and carry the potatoes myself if it comes to it.”

“You’ve one arm.”

“Then I’ll carry fewer.”

She considered him for some while. “Put me down for the third,” she said. “And I’ll hold you to the potatoes.”

They drew the shutter at dusk. It took eleven men, with a baulk and a block and a great deal of language, and when it came free the Dead Drain breathed out a long cold smell of old stone and a hiss of water that had waited forty years for an excuse. Iven stood at the mouth of it with the lamp in his good hand and listened.

Under his feet, very far down, the root moved. It was not a sound. It was a slackening, a letting of breath, like a held muscle easing in sleep. He felt Leda come to stand at his shoulder in the dark, and she did not speak, and neither did he. He had given his word to the Court and could not advise. He found, to his surprise, that she did not need to be told.

“Down,” she said at last, very softly. “It’s coming down.”

---

Hale found them there at ten, and she did not come to say well done.

She had a paper in her hand, held away from her body between finger and thumb as a person holds a thing that has fallen in a gutter. Her cheeks were pink with cold, and her eyes were hard and bright.

“The Registry,” she said. “A late order. It came in by a clerk’s boy at half past four and was entered on the Court’s docket at five, which is half an hour after the Justice rose. I’ve had Tibb read it to me twice.”

She gave it to Iven. He held the lamp up.

It was a half-sheet, neatly written, headed in a copperplate hand *In the matter of Berth Nine, Ashlen Quay. Order as to the safe custody of the lessee’s property.*

The text was short. *Whereas the lessee of Berth Nine has by its servant Gill a lawful interest in the said berth, and whereas the Court has in its wisdom barred certain parties from approaching, it is ordered, for the avoidance of doubt, that the said servant may remain at Berth Nine during the seventy-eighth day, and during the slack of the great tide, to protect the lessee’s property.*

Below, a signature: *J. Sutter, Registrar.*

And beside the signature, pressed deep and sharp into the wax, a stamp.

It was violet.

He read it twice. Then he laid it on the stone coping of the drain and looked down at the black water going away under the Row, slow and obedient, toward the old moat.

“The Registrar may sign an order on his own authority,” said Hale, “if it is ancillary, and does not alter the Justice’s judgment. It is, as the document says, for the avoidance of doubt.” Her voice had gone very quiet. “It is perfectly regular. It is entirely within the Registry’s power.”

“It puts Gill on the quay,” said Leda.

“It puts Gill on the quay on the one day we cannot touch it.” Hale took the paper back. “By the Court’s own paper. Whoever it was, Mr. Sayer, has read the same Act that I have, and has read it better.”

Beyond the drain, under the dim lamps of Cooper’s Row, someone was already carrying chairs up out of a cellar. Iven watched an old woman in a shawl hand a clock to a boy at the top of the steps, with great care, as if it might spill. Then he looked at the stamp again, and found that his hand, the good one, had closed on the lamp so hard the brass had marked his palm.

“Gill,” he said. “He was sent off the quay once already. He’ll be glad of the chair.”

“He’ll be glad of the order,” said Hale.

“No.” Iven turned the lamp. “He will be glad of whoever it is that gave him one.”

Support the author

Enjoyed this chapter? A few coins keep the story going.

Sign in to support

Chapter comments

Sign in to comment

No comments yet. Be the first!